Gnome Racial Statistics
Posted: Thu Jan 11, 2007 11:08 pm
This is perhaps my biggest pet peeve with the PHG 3.0, if only because I fancy myself as a gnome player.
Why the hell don't Gnomes get a bonus to Intelligence? The idea behind a gnome is that it is generally better than humans at tasks that are associated with Intelligence (memory, creativity, knowledge, etc). Baldurs Gate gave them a bonus to intelligence and a penalty to wisdom. The ancient Advanced D&D Monster Manual by Gary Gygax (don't ask how I actually have a copy) listed their Intelligence as 'Very'. I'd argue Intelligence is what defines gnomes as a race. BG also threw in the fact that they had a lower wisdom (which makes sense). I also understand them getting a -2 to strength due to their size.
But instead, they get a +2 to Con because of their relation to dwarves, making them a very obtuse race to use. Never mind how apparently they make good bards in 3.5.
Can someone suggest a legitimate reason why Gnomes were done this way in 3.0? And before anybody says it wouldn't be balanced to have a Wizard favoring race with a bonus to Intelligence, consider that the barbarian favoring race gets a +2 to strength, and the rogue favoring race a +2 to dexterity.
Why the hell don't Gnomes get a bonus to Intelligence? The idea behind a gnome is that it is generally better than humans at tasks that are associated with Intelligence (memory, creativity, knowledge, etc). Baldurs Gate gave them a bonus to intelligence and a penalty to wisdom. The ancient Advanced D&D Monster Manual by Gary Gygax (don't ask how I actually have a copy) listed their Intelligence as 'Very'. I'd argue Intelligence is what defines gnomes as a race. BG also threw in the fact that they had a lower wisdom (which makes sense). I also understand them getting a -2 to strength due to their size.
But instead, they get a +2 to Con because of their relation to dwarves, making them a very obtuse race to use. Never mind how apparently they make good bards in 3.5.
Can someone suggest a legitimate reason why Gnomes were done this way in 3.0? And before anybody says it wouldn't be balanced to have a Wizard favoring race with a bonus to Intelligence, consider that the barbarian favoring race gets a +2 to strength, and the rogue favoring race a +2 to dexterity.