Paladins of the Wolf God

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

I hear you, whalejudge, On the one hand, alternate Paladins are a symptom of a problem that often bothers me about 3.x. There are many options out there (which I normally like), but so many that there's almost no tradeoffs anymore. I call it the "Skill Focus problem." Back in 3.0, with just the PH, the only Feat that gave +2 to two different skills was Alertness (Spot/Listen). With that in mind, the 3.0 Skill Focus (+2 any skill) seemed like not such a bad idea.

But then the splatbooks proliferated and more Alertness-like feats came out, eventually getting folded into the 3.5 PH, which has:
Acrobatic (Jump/Tumble)
Agile (Balance/Escape Artist)
Animal Affinity (Handle Animal/Ride)
Athletic (Climb/Swim)
Deceitful (Disguise/Forgery)
Deft Hands (slight of hand/use rope)
Diligent (appraise/decipher script)
Investigator (GI/Search)
Magical Aptitude (Spellcraft/UMD)
Negotiator (Diplo/SM)
Nimble Fingers (DD/OL)
Persuasive (Bluff/Intimidate)
Self-Sufficient (Heal/Survival)
Stealthy (Hide/MS)

(And that's just in the PH! There are more in other books, WotC or otherwise)

They are "theorectically" balanced with skill focus because you give up flexibility for more bonuses. But in practice, almost no matter what skill you were going to put your +2 skill focus on, there's a +2/+2 feat that will give you +2 on that skill and +2 on another as a bonus. So to make up for it, they had to up Skill Focus to +3 for 3.5, and even then, it rarely seems worth it.

Anyway, the point I'm making is, the more specific choices that are out there that claim to balance out because their increased power forces a specific path, the less balance overall because you can just choose any path and find an option that boosts that path. (See also prestige classes, and how Pathfinder had to boost the core classes to compete with them.)

So the alternate paladins do seem to hand out "paladin goodies" without limiting you to LG, which can rub the wrong way.

But then on the other hand, why would LG deities be the only ones who would choose a champion? Why should those champions just be fighters? or some wacky prestige class? In that sense, the alternate paladins work, and it's just enought logic for me to accept them.


Though I do love Rotipher's idea too....
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
Pale
Criminal Mastermind
Criminal Mastermind
Posts: 102
Joined: Sat Jul 19, 2008 10:01 pm

Post by Pale »

I like the idea that each faith has champions. Figures that embody the faith's values and heed their god's whims.

I think that they should be formidable, but I do not necessarily believe that they ought to get a cookie-cutter copy of the Paladin class with a whisper of cosmetic changes.

I think it's possible to have a Wolf God Champion. A lawful good Wolf God Champion is a bit of a bigger challenge, but not insurmountable. I think Rotipher's idea with Sabak is also an excellent opportunity. Generally, I'd be surprised if the Dark Powers didn't find some aspect of Timothy's religion to use to twist the knife.
Post Reply