4th Edition Review

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

alhoon wrote:A real pitty Jester, I hoped to play 4th in Ravenloft with you as a DM in the D&Dinsider. :cry:
I'd really have to see how customizable D&DI is. Most of Insider is still missing.
Plus I'm already involved in multiple games and poor, so Mrs. Jester wouldn't like me spending $15/month and more time gaming.
User avatar
Mortavius
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 630
Joined: Wed Dec 17, 2003 11:21 am
Location: BC, Canada

Post by Mortavius »

It's funny Alhoon, I thought the solution about the ooze being knocked prone was wonderful! After all, it's a compromise between storytelling and game mechanics. The DM doesn't simply tell the player "You can't do that." and thus makes one of the player's abilities useless because of a technicality that an ooze doesn't have legs. The feeling of the move is there, the game mechanics still reflect it, and the game "reality" (if I may use such a term) is still preserved.

As to the Phasing and Insubstantial qualities, from what I can tell, it's assumed in 4E that creatures with these types still have somewhat solid mass, but due to their natures, are resistant to full effects on the material plane. Phasing in particular is simply a creatures ability to avoid difficult terrain; in effect, it phases out everytime there's a small rock in it's way and actually has no effect on combat damage. If you really want to keep consistency, you could say that creatures with these qualities are resistant to push, pull, and slide effects the same way Dwarves are, just for a different reason.

I have to say, I like the new rules on Insubstantialty better than 3E's take on them. Having a player have a purely random chance that he has no control over of his attacks missing, despite his best efforts is disheartening. My players hated fighting ghosts because of that. It may have been better if the players could have influenced the percentile roll, but as it was in 3E, without house ruling it, it was either there, or not; an on-off switch. Some attacks were fully affected by it, and others fully bypassed it (transubstantial spell, for example).
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

IMPORTANT CORRECTION: I just noticed:
The ranger can fight effectively with 2 weapons. Actually he's the only class to fight with two melee weapons in a reasonable maner.
Fighters with two melee weapons just get a ... +1 bonus to their attacks, whatever the off hand weapon is. :?
However: The ranger attacks at will with his two weapons doing... two attacks. The catch? No strength or dex bonus. That's all.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Nikolas of the Mists
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 183
Joined: Wed Jun 04, 2008 3:04 pm

Post by Nikolas of the Mists »

alhoon wrote:The catch? No strength or dex bonus. That's all.
Not on his at will power, but he does receive it on both attacks on encounter and daily abilities (Two-Fanged Strike 2w+str, Jaws of the Wolf 2W+str).

The at wills for all classes are just meant to be a step above a normal base attack, in this case getting two normal 1w attacks instead of one 1w+str/dex. Most at wills are 1w with either +hit bonuses or other minor effects like a shift.

Two weapon fighting became a finesse fighting style and translated into melee rangers in 4e. (Dwarven dual wielding melee axe rangers coming to a campaign near you hehe)

Sidenote: if you open the ranger up to having access to firearms (however you choose to do firearms), it becomes a lot more interesting and feasible as a class for Ravenloft I think :P
User avatar
Dion of the Fraternity
Lurker Maximus
Lurker Maximus
Posts: 1092
Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 4:20 am
Location: Baguio City, Philippines
Contact:

Post by Dion of the Fraternity »

I've finally decided that 3.5 will remain my system of choice for the time being, especially in my Ravenloft campaigns. I'll most probably cannibalize the valuable nuggets in Pathfinder's 3.75. At the moment, 4e holds no appeal for me. I do agree that there are more people digging in their heals over the change from 3e to 4e as opposed to 2e to 3e, but I personally believe that the release of 4e has a different motive.

Read this:
http://jediwiker.livejournal.com/57390.html

I believe in the write, for the most part.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

So 39% say they will convert gladly and 39% say they won't convert. I'm at the 22% of the middle.

Why I agree with some parts from the blog you mentioned and disagree with other parts my answer is:

It is a different game. I'll play both as I play both WoD and 3rd edition. Now I'll include 4th edition in my games of choice. As for the 39% of non-converters, in a year it will be 15% :)

As the author of the Blog says, I have given 4th a chance. It is a nice game. A different game than 3rd but a nice game. Feels more like old D&D than 3rd edition.

On monsters as races:
For those wanting more variety in races, the Monstrous Manual races are very easy to implement. There's nothing missing there except of racial feats.

The best wizard? Probably gnome! They have crazy powers! One of the best races I have seen so far. Invisibility without need to sustain it :shock: Also if they start an encounter with cover they may "escape notice" with a stealth check. +2 arcana, +2 stealth.

The best warrior? Definetely... the orc. Trumps the dwarf and the dragonborn over the head. +2 str +2 con and ... an extra free healing surge once per encounter! :shock: :? Speaking of balance in races.

I didn't like the bugbear, the kobold, the minotaur and some of the other races. They seem either too weak or too powerful. I understand that there can't be a level equivalent but minotaurs with just +2 strength and kobolds without a strength penalty? That's the difference between minotaur and kobold? 2 strength?
I believe they could have done something similar with the 2nd edition approach: say if you're minotaur you can't have natural strength below 15 (i.e all minotaurs have str 17+) and if you're kobold you can't have natural strength above 14 (i.e all starting kobolds have str below 14)
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Ail
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3429
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 7:33 am
Location: Egham, UK

Post by Ail »

Hi Pam,

I was glad to read your post, so let me answer as I can. Well, our party was two fighters, a cleric and a rogue. I don't know what other characters remained in the box, safe that one was a wizard. That might have been helpful, but I have been itching to play a dwarven fighter for ages now, and I didn't even blink when I heard that was available.

So, with no wizard, things got difficult for us. I'm surprised to hear that the spirit helped you. I had some hopes it would do that, but at one point the rogue asked it for help and it could do was vaguely point in the elf's necromancer direction. So, no help there. But now, with Holy Word only usable twice per combat, it really isn't much. Each PC can use a free healing surge once per fight, and with two more uses only to divide among the party in each encounter, that really is nothing. With the statues, we needed to be healed every round, as the skeletons were, and we couldn't of course get that. So, really, fighting is much harder now, even with a cleric.

But let me ask you, how did you kill the elf wizard? Our DM told us it was a DC20 to climb, and even though I had +8 in Athletic, my dward was really the only one scheduled to oppose the statues, and they seemed to be the biggest threat. I may have had a killer DM: he did say he brought the statues in when we failed to hit the elf on the first round, otherwise he would probably have kept them at bay.

As for the Dwarf powers, I did have Reliable on the Daily Power (and I shudder to think of Daily Powers without Reliable) but not on the encounter power. And while encounter powers are, well, available on the next encounter, I guess people shouldn't think of them as minor or something: in the DL campaign I'm playing, we've had mostly one encounter a day, making an encouter power a daily power. To lose it so easily (no Reliable) is frustrating. As for the preselected choice, I haven't read anything in the books, so I don't know what other choices I had.

But in all, I'm glad I tried it, and I liked experiencing the new rules. I'm not adamantly against or for it, I'm not going to switch now merely for economic reasons. It would be a huge investment, both in money AND TIME, to learn a new edition and forget about all I the work I have had meanwhile, and all the books I have read.

Alex
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
Nikolas of the Mists
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 183
Joined: Wed Jun 04, 2008 3:04 pm

Post by Nikolas of the Mists »

alhoon wrote:The best wizard? Probably gnome! They have crazy powers! One of the best races I have seen so far. Invisibility without need to sustain it :shock: Also if they start an encounter with cover they may "escape notice" with a stealth check. +2 arcana, +2 stealth.

The best warrior? Definetely... the orc. Trumps the dwarf and the dragonborn over the head. +2 str +2 con and ... an extra free healing surge once per encounter! :shock: :? Speaking of balance in races.
Eh Gnome is pretty awesome, but it's for the stat and skill blocks.
Reactive Stealth is interesting, but the changes to cover and concealment make it harder to get away with.
Fade Away made me soil my trousers when I saw it at first, until I realized a couple things.
i) It's an encounter power
ii) It's reactive upon you taking damage
iii) It only lasts for one turn.

As for Orcs, it's not that they receive a free healing surge, rather that they can expend one of their own during the action if it successfully hits. An encounter power that is straight Str vs AC which gives you a chance at expending one of your healing surges isn't so great. I think I would still stick with a Dragonborn or Dwarf for their Healing Surge related abilities.
"I wouldn't worry too much about the Vistana with the pistols --
If he wanted to kill you, he'd have done it already."
User avatar
Pamela
Sorority Shadow
Sorority Shadow
Posts: 931
Joined: Tue Sep 13, 2005 3:48 am
Location: Have gun, will travel
Contact:

Post by Pamela »

Hey Alex!

I think the reason that the spirit helped us was because we took care of the bones in the room with the trapped sarcophagi. He also gave our party a hidden healing potion for doing so (we never did get to use it). As the cleric of Pelor, I also warned everybody not to raid the tombs. I read somewhere online that the spirit actually somehow possessed one of the statues (?!) for a round, so it seems to have been written into the game.

Beyond the Healing Word, Evon also had Healing Strike. I never used it myself, but I also would have had to succeed in hitting my opponent in order to get that extra healing surge for someone. I was holding off on those powers because the dice were not on my side in combat. The skeletons, necromancer and statue combo was a killer though, no matter what.

I think your DM was being a bit heavy-handed; the statues did come after us but not until the third round, I think. Our rogue focused on the necromancer with her bow and our human fighter jumped on to the platform to go one-on-one against him; they both had excellent rolls. I was playing medic for the human while the remaining fighters dealt with the skeletons and statues.

My cleric’s daily power was Avenging Flame (by the way, the only reason I know his and the dwarvish fighter’s stuff is ‘cause we brought home the PC sheets – our DM seemed to have at least 20 on hand for any extra games/gamers). It’s cool because it’ll still do damage even if I miss.

As you said, encounter powers are far from minor, and it is frustrating to lose them in battle. On the other hand, the at-will powers are there; admittedly weaker, but still better than just swinging a sword.

The books here only cost £40 for the entire set on Amazon (and they complain about how expensive things are in Britain?!). Time-wise, well, I detested 3e and couldn’t wait to see the back of it. I’ll keep the fluff from the earlier books and anything else that might appeal. Otherwise, no skin off my nose.

I will say that this is the first time that I can recall enjoying playing a first level character in my adult life. It was wonderful not to have the wizard (or anybody) die with one blow. The fighters were able to say more than “I swing my sword.” It was fantastic to have the cleric and mage move into the next room without having to rest eight hours to get their spells back.

Pam
His only real danger is if stupidity is contagious and lethal. In which case, we’re all dead…-Gertrude
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

Nikolas of the Mists wrote: Eh Gnome is pretty awesome, but it's for the stat and skill blocks.
Reactive Stealth is interesting, but the changes to cover and concealment make it harder to get away with.
Fade Away made me soil my trousers when I saw it at first, until I realized a couple things.
i) It's an encounter power
ii) It's reactive upon you taking damage
iii) It only lasts for one turn.

As for Orcs, it's not that they receive a free healing surge, rather that they can expend one of their own during the action if it successfully hits. An encounter power that is straight Str vs AC which gives you a chance at expending one of your healing surges isn't so great. I think I would still stick with a Dragonborn or Dwarf for their Healing Surge related abilities.
Gnome: Enemy hits gnome: Gnome disappears. Next turn it passes through the enemies without problem. Reaches good spot with cover etc. Then attacks. That simple and it costed the gnome nothing.

It's far better than having nothing to do when you're hit. It's an immediate encounter power so it doesn't cost even a minor action and it's available in each encounter. The wizard that picks invisibility at 16th level drops fly or stoneskin to get it! Sure he can use a minor action to sustain the spell... but once he attacks it breaks! That means that a 16th level daily utility power is a bit better than this power.

As you said also it has very good stats and skills bonuses for a wizard with a racial on stealth.

Orc: The orc has the chance to heal twice as much as the other classes in combat. The chance to hit a creature of his level is about 60% so there's a solid chance the orc will be healed.
The ability to heal twice in combat instead of once is very important IMO. Better to heal now in the combat rather than after the combat hoping you'll survive.
Penalty: You don't use another encounter power that probably deals more damage.
Still, that encounter power is very useful IMO.

The orc has +2 strength +2 con the best stats for warriors :)
and a useful per encounter.
The Dwarf's ability to heal as a minor action isn't as useful IMO. Sure you hit and heal in the same round, but the orc has a 60% to do that too. If it doesn't work, then he spends a round for healing surge.
The Dragonborn's ability of +con mod is good for low levels since you heal a bit more, but on higher levels isn't useful. level 15 dragonborn fighter with 19 con (16+3 from levels) has 118 hp. So with each surge he heals 33 hp instead of 29. Not so important. In the long term, in a day he would heal more than the orc but that "more" is 429hp instead of 377 hp. And frankly, do you really think the fighter will usually need all 13 healing surges in a day? I believe he will need 2 healing surges in a fight more often after all.
Pamela wrote:I will say that this is the first time that I can recall enjoying playing a first level character in my adult life. It was wonderful not to have the wizard (or anybody) die with one blow. The fighters were able to say more than “I swing my sword.” It was fantastic to have the cleric and mage move into the next room without having to rest eight hours to get their spells back.
Pam
Yeap, the 1st level char is the equivalent of the old 4th level char or something similar. And I agree that not having to rest 8 hours to get your spells back at 1st level after an encounter or two is an improvement.

Still, I prefer to implement that in 3rd edition so far.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Nikolas of the Mists
Arch-villain
Arch-villain
Posts: 183
Joined: Wed Jun 04, 2008 3:04 pm

Post by Nikolas of the Mists »

alhoon wrote:do you really think the fighter will usually need all 13 healing surges in a day? I believe he will need 2 healing surges in a fight more often after all.
Except that most cleric (and other healing abilities including healing potions) allow or require you to expend a healing surge.
"I wouldn't worry too much about the Vistana with the pistols --
If he wanted to kill you, he'd have done it already."
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

Except that potions heal 10 hp and cost money. :) And healing by the cleric costs the cleric an action.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Mortavius
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 630
Joined: Wed Dec 17, 2003 11:21 am
Location: BC, Canada

Post by Mortavius »

I dunno Alhoon, I'm still not convinced of the Orc superiority. His power is an encounter power. If he hits, he does normal damage and can spend a healing surge. If he misses, he's screwed. He's wasted an encounter power and a standard action all in one round.

Whereas the Dwarf can make the same attack (a basic attack, at that) and use his Second Wind. And there's no chance of him failing in using that Second Wind. Even if he misses with the Basic attack, he still gets the healing and defense bonus; the Orc, even if he hits, only gets the healing. Add to that the fact the Dwarf is almost certainly not going to use a simple basic attack, but instead a stronger at-will attack power or even more, and I think they balance out.

Don't get me wrong; I'm not crapping on the Orc's ability, I think it's dandy. I just don't think it's so much better than the Dwarf's Second Wind ability.

And I also don't see how the Gnome's power is so great. (Useful, yes. Overpowering? Not sure.) The Gnome's is an encounter power, and happens after it takes damage. It gives him a turn's worth of actions to perform invisibly, but if he attacks, the invisibility ends (thus, he would get Combat Advantage of +2 to hit, but that's it without any other bonuses). If he doesn't attack, it ends at the end of his turn.

The Wizard on the other hand, has it as a daily power. It can affect the wizard or someone else. It also only lasts 1 round, unless the Wizard spends his standard action to sustain it, which allows him to keep it going indefinately, although it ends if the affected character attacks (giving the character Combat Advantage as above).

So the Gnome can do it more often, but he can't just do it whenever he wants; he has to take damage. And he only gets a single turn to do something. The Wizard can do it less often, but he can choose when and how to use the power, in addition to affecting others (like the party Rogue), and he can keep it up as long as it needs to be until the attack is ready, instead of just having one round to do something in.
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

However, the dwarf only gets the one second wind per encounter, even though it can use if quicker. Once that's gone, they have to rely on clerics/warlords/paladins for any and all healing.

The orc, once it's used the second wind, still has the racial power to fall back on when it *needs* healing. That's the difference.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

Jester, my point exactly + the orc has strength bonus instead of wisdom.
Mortavious:
- I don't try to convince you, I'm just saying what I think; It's not a competition here :) . Each to his own opinion.
- I didn't say the gnome's power is overpowered. I said it's a very good power for a wizard. :wink:
- It's "alhoon" not Alhoon.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Post Reply