Page 9 of 9

Re: The City of Ravenloft

Posted: Sun Jan 22, 2012 2:09 pm
by BedrockBrendan
I think their power should be less directly political in most cases. They could wield a lot of influence, be masters of the criminal underworld, or head a major trade guild. Their conflicts and goals should also be the major shaping forces of the city.

Re: The City of Ravenloft

Posted: Sun Jan 22, 2012 3:08 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
True, there should be other power-brokers and players in the city; I just figure that Council status would be a good demarcation between the ones who are actually darklords, and the ones who are conventional NPCs. Sometimes a territory's darklord might be an acknowledged member of the Council, much like how many darklords in canon Ravenloft are open rulers, but in other cases their participation on the Council might be covert (e.g. Malken might bribe Councilor Bolshnik's assistant to alter his boss's ballots on the sly), or exerted through a proxy (e.g. Lamordia District might have a Councilor Von Aubrecker who always votes as Lamordia's lord instructs).

Re: The City of Ravenloft

Posted: Sun Jan 22, 2012 6:30 pm
by Manofevil
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:I agree that restricting the darklords to their own territories seems inappropriate for this variant of the setting. Possibly they could be confined to the city itself, but they ought to be able to leave their neighborhoods.

Rather than physical confinement, perhaps there should be some other occult mechanism in place to stop the big-league lords from simply killing all the minor ones off. Perhaps there's some kind of DP-enforced voting system in effect at the City Council, that forces the powerful darklords to cut deals with the lesser ones for support in decision-making? There could be an arcane tally-keeping device -- maybe a huge accursed hourglass, reminiscent of the ones in the Grim Harvest modules -- that measures how each darklord votes, in proportion to how much territory and/or how many citizens they control. Even Azalin wouldn't rule enough of the city to dictate the outcome of a vote, so there'd be lots of political maneuvering to recruit lesser lords' support whenever the major darklords disagree about something.

Hence, no mass slaughter of pipsqueaks like Baron Evensong or D'Polarno: so long as their territories are secure enough to make a land-grab politically costly, they're more useful as swing votes than as corpses. Takeovers would still be possible, given enough brute force or economic/political coercion, but would have to be undertaken with discretion so the other lords don't find out and vote to punish the aggressor.

Rather than the DPs simply slapping the "darklord" label on someone, they might have to actively complete a ritual to become a Council member. If the tally-glass is full of blood, like from the modules, the would-be Councilor might have to contribute some of their own blood (ichor, venom, whatever) to the mix. Villains who don't do this could still have some influence in the city, but wouldn't have a vote in Council ... or a darklord's supernatural connection to a territory. New darklords would be inducted into the Council by a sponsor who believes they'll support them in future votes; the newbies wouldn't be told that doing so incurs a curse until after-the-fact.
Well, most of the points you've raised here have already been addressed within the parameters of the original definition and my expansion of it. There are, however, certain things which are implied by what you have here. Based on my model, which is admittedly optional, we have every single Darklord of Ravenloft within the confines of a few dozen square miles. There are already circumstances which allow them to leave their territory, HOWEVER, that does NOT make regular confrontations between them a good idea. Let's examine the concept of a council of Darklords

The bell tolls and all the Darklords gather at city hall. How is the God-Brain supposed to make it all the way down from Madness Mountain to attend?
Won't the whole city notice that?
Won't they also notice a very large crocodile crawling up out of the river to get to city hall?
How's the Nightmare Court supposed to attend?
Do we really expect Azalin and Strahd to sit in the same room for any length of time? Or Mordenheim and Adam? Or the four sons of the Shujin?
Who's going to willingly sit in the same room as Drakov for any length of time? Or Soth?
Who's going to be willing to do it more than a few times?
What's it like sitting in the same room as Tristessa or Tristan Aplanc?
Drakov is a raging mysoginist. What's going to happen when he meets Ivana Boritsi? Or Jaqueline Renier?
Does he know that Gabrielle Aderre is his daughter? What if he comes on to her?
Do you wanna see the city burn? What else would happen when Drakov meets Elena Faithhold? And that's just Drakov. What would happen between these women and Bluebeard? or Ivan Dilisnya? Or Harkon Lucas?
What happens when Davion shows up? Or Eason the Mad?

The council of Darklords, as it is, probably really isn't a good idea. At least not as a regular thing. Maybe once every ten years it could happen. It probably would be best to include only the Darklords in the city proper. That would exclude most of the inhumanoid Darklords and ...

WAIT A MINUTE!! I just thought of something that may solve every point I just raised here! The clocktower is the realm of Vecna, right? So why can't city hall be the equivalent of the Shadow Rift. The Fey rule there. The tower clock tolls, and Darklords within the city are called to the council. Every one of them comes under magical compulsion that NONE of them can fight, then when they get there and take their seats, they suddenly look up and think 'Oh God, We're HERE again.' There isn't really a lot of business done at these meetings. These people aren't in the practice of doing business with each other. Mostly there's just a lot of curses and threats exchanged across the table, Largely because no one can get out of their seats or use their attack magic or projectile weapons. This is all to the delight of the fey who are just twisted mischievous enough to keep doing it. Every once in a while though, when the bell rings, they'll just lower the barriers that keep the Darklords imprisoned in their territories. The Darklords immediately know that if there's anything they want to do outside their territories, that's the time to do it.

The trouble is, we still need a mechanism to keep the Darklords from killing each other. Maybe the fey could take a hand there, too.

Re: The City of Ravenloft

Posted: Mon Jan 23, 2012 12:12 am
by ewancummins
My original notion had been that the Clock Tower simply signaled conjunctions (the mysterious work of the Dark Powers, causes or purposes unknown). This released the darklords to wreak havoc, fight duels, spy on one another, etc. They couldn't leave the city, but they could leave their domains within the city. Perhaps when it strikes the thirteenth hour, then the Grand Conjunction occurs, and the neighborhoods and houses of the city become coterminous with real estate in a dozen or more cities on various prime plane worlds.


City Hall would be a neutral zone, in which any and all Darklords could meet. I imagined the Mists as transporting them there. A darklord killed there would be returned to his domain and raised. Or perhaps any darklord offering violence in the hall would simply be expelled by the Mists?


That said, I do rather like Roti's ideas. The council of darklords seems cool. The only thing I see wrong with his 'add to the tally glass, join the council ' idea is this: Evil is not a club. Why would the older darklords even want to add new councilors? Isn't that just setting themselves up for trouble? Sure, some of them might see it as a way to gain an ally- but an evil ally who soon finds out you tricked him into cursing himself is probably not a good friend to have.

Re: The City of Ravenloft

Posted: Mon Jan 23, 2012 12:41 am
by ewancummins
If you guys think darklords bound to the city, with lairs/power centers (sort of like the lairs from Masque of the Red Death, perhaps?) is a better idea than a patchwork of discrete domains with a clock tower to signal conjunctions- go for it. :azalin:


Here's an alternate set up that combines ideas from several of you:


  • Darklords have domains that are basically lairs (like the ones in Masque of the Red Death). Within these power centers, which might be a single room or an entire huge building, the darklord who owns the lair is stronger. It is always tied to the owner/darklord in some way- never just some place he picked for convenience. Darklords often feel drawn back to these locations.

    Most darklords can leave their domains- only a few, like Lord Godefory, are bound to a particular house or other site.

    None of the darklords can leave the city limits, unless some sort of conjunction has occurred by the will of the Dark Powers.
City Hall is Vecna's domain. This makes sense for a number of reasons:
  • He's really powerful, so sitting at the center of power seems fitting.

    Kas is trapped with him, in an adjacent domain (the painting). This fits with their backstory, and mirrors the domains they were given in Canon-loft. :azalin:
    Vecna cannot destroy the painting, no matter how he tries. Sometimes Kas sends minions from it to trash the hall, and Vecna's slaves fight them back into the painting-world.

    It's just one building, so there's some irony that Vecna is confined in it (he's one of the lords who cannot leave his lair) while 'wimps' like Ivan Dilsinya roam the city at will.

    Vecna can keep the lesser lords in check while they visit him.
Now, why would they come? Why doesn't he ever destroy any of them? These things may be related to his curse/s- which should be modified. This idea could be combined with some sort 'tally cup' and 'council of lords' idea, as per Rotipher. i wouldn't require all darklords to join, but I would consider using some of the more politically minded lords.


Here are some other ideas-

Lord Godefroy communicates at civic meetings via a mirror, a Ouija board, a spiritualist medium, or some other indirect means. He doesn't actually come to City Hall when Vecna summons a conclave.




The shadow fay could be worked in as creatures infesting a certain gorge, the last truly wild spot in the city. Unlike the overgrown vacant lots or the parks frequented by the werewolves and other feral monsters, this area really is true wilderness- but it's small. Small on the outside, that is. On the inside, it's large. It's a hole that leads to the time before the city existed or the first dawn broke, when the world was locked in eternal twilight and faeries ruled. To preserve ManOfEvil's idea of fay tormenting the darklords, perhaps the fay have a custom of luring mortals into the 'rift' for 'fun and games.' Darklords are in no away immune to this, unless the lord in question is bound tightly to his home (like a ghost in a haunted house).

Re: The City of Ravenloft

Posted: Mon Jan 23, 2012 7:17 am
by Sorti
It seems it would take a really, really huge injection of magic and/or Omnipotent Force Meddling to keep all the Darklords in a room for even one minute; is it really worth it? What would we gain by it? In the Canon many Darklords don't know they are different from normal people, and this logically goes against the fact that they have land-influencing power like closing borders. We risk falling in the same problem: Mordenheim thinks of himself as a scientist and rationalist trying to cure his wife, not like a murderer who would fill a hourglass with blood to gain power over the city, or be kept in a room full of undead and monsters by a demigod lich.

Someone said that we want to distinguish Darklords from evil NPCs, but basically Darklords are evil NPCs with the difference that the land is shaped to reflect their horrible crime and curse; in 2nd ed. I'm quite certain that by failing Power Checks you could become a Darklord, so I don't see why we can't say that evil NPCs who commit enough atrocities slowly begin shifting their lair and servants to reflect it; much like Joker's underlings are crazy and dress like clowns while Two-Face's have masks with one side normal and the other horrible.

We don't need to enforce an in-game set of arcane rules to obtain a good atmosphere. Since we like a Council it makes sense that its members are the noble ruling class; this includes aristocratic politics-oriented Darklords like Strahd, Ivana and d'Honaire and non-Darklords like von Aubrecker and lord Weathermay. Also I suppose we want the church of Ezra in the city; I'm not convinced that its Lawful Good branch or any good organization would not go crazy at the thought of a lich gathering evil people in the City Hall. All in all it would cost a lot of immersion and suspension of disbelief.

So I propose to not overcomplicate things. Azalin doesn't kill d'Polarno because he can include him in his genial master plan, Strahd because he's busy looking for Tatyana and squabbling with Azalin, Drakov is actually trying to kill Jacqueline because she's a criminal leader but when he sends falks in her territory they die horribly, Bluebeard likes Ivana but his instinct tells him she's best left alone, and so on. Every non-enforced Darklord-to-Darklord relationship is open space for the DM to work on and an awesome source of adventure ideas.

Re: The City of Ravenloft

Posted: Mon Jan 23, 2012 10:08 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Really, either option (forced Council sessions engineered by the DPs/fey, vs. voluntary attendance by ostensibly-cordial backstabbers) offers opportunities for plot development and character conflict. Personally, I'd been picturing a more "civilized" Council, to go along with the urbanization this variant of Ravenloft embodies -- something like the Parliament of Princes in Glantri (Mystara setting), where all the nobles smile politely to their bitterest enemies and cut each other down with backhanded compliments in place of fireballs -- but if having the lot of them tied to their chairs, howling vituperations at each other and the powers-that-be, is more to your liking, that's fine too.
Manofevil wrote:The bell tolls and all the Darklords gather at city hall. How is the God-Brain supposed to make it all the way down from Madness Mountain to attend?
What God-Brain? The Madness Mountain representative is perfectly human, everyone sees that. What? That funny scar on the back of his skull, and that glazed look in his eyes? Never mind that, everyone knows the poor man bumped his head in a carriage crash years ago; he's still a good delegate. :wink:
How's the Nightmare Court supposed to attend?
What's the Nightmare Court? That's Councilor Trasker sitting in that chair, everybody knows him.
Do we really expect Azalin and Strahd to sit in the same room for any length of time? Or Mordenheim and Adam? Or the four sons of the Shujin?
Imagine the filibusters, the half-veiled insults, the votes of no confidence! Mordenheim would sit for Lamordia, BTW, probably worrying about how Adam is home trashing his lab the whole time.
Who's going to willingly sit in the same room as Drakov for any length of time? Or Soth? Who's going to be willing to do it more than a few times?
Drakov can be the hothead who can never muster enough support to achieve his agenda, and is always getting censured for not ceding the floor. (His can't-win-respect curse at work.) Soth can send a proxy if he bothers to involve himself at all, and isn't in his navel-gazing phase at the time we're discussing.
What's it like sitting in the same room as Tristessa or Tristan Aplanc?
If we're going back to a drow-inhabited Arak, as a previous post implied, Tristessa might've been on the Council (disguised as a normal elf) before she was executed. Death needn't deny her her seat, even if she never comes to meetings. As for ApBlanc, why would he be a problem? In daylight, he looks human enough to pass, and we know he was politically-savvy back in Forfar.
Drakov is a raging mysoginist. What's going to happen when he meets Ivana Boritsi? Or Jaqueline Renier? Does he know that Gabrielle Aderre is his daughter? What if he comes on to her?
Heck, they're probably part of the reason why he can't get his agenda through a session: he ticked them off with his bad attitude, and have been blocking his every move since. As for coming on to Gabrielle, the guy's been molesting Falkovnia's women in canon-Ravenloft for decades, it's not like it'd be the first time he'd have unwittingly done something like that.
What would happen between these women and Bluebeard? or Ivan Dilisnya? Or Harkon Lucas?
You make it sound like the women would be passive targets in these confrontations. Maybe they'd be the ones eating the guys alive in Council sessions. Imagine Ivana, Jackie, Gabrielle and the Hags as a voting bloc... :twisted:
What happens when Davion shows up? Or Eason the Mad?
Ever heard of the Official Monster Raving Loony Party? Crackpots and wild cards like them can be marginalized, in the event they actually happen to attend a session. With their reality-altering powers nullified outside their territories, it's no problem if they want to rave off in a corner somewhere.
Won't they also notice a very large crocodile crawling up out of the river to get to city hall?
Heh heh. Who says that King Croc needs to have ever attended a Council meeting? Maybe a previous darklord once ruled the Wildlands -- probably a big-game hunter a la ''The Most Dangerous Game", who imported all those dangerous animals for sport -- until he slipped up while in pursuit of an unusually-large crocodile. The croc ate the former darklord, absorbed his power, and thus attained both sentience and darklord status secondhand. The ideal demonstration of the Wildlands' predatory ethos: ascension by om nom nom! :lol:


Really, every darklord's story of how they attained Council status, and the tenor of their appearances or no-shows at the sessions, can be tailored to his/her/its quirks. But in any case, it's really just an excuse to actually do something that canon-Ravenloft makes utterly impossible: to get all of these fascinating NPCs into the same room, bound by a veneer of civility that forbids outright slaughter, and then watch the fur fly as they slander, betray, deceive and talk smack to one another. Having them pinned there by a common enemy would only inhibit them from playing out their various personality-conflicts, IMO: after all, the Grand Conjunction finale proved that even Strahd and Azalin are capable of working together if they have someone else to despise.

Re: The City of Ravenloft

Posted: Mon Jan 23, 2012 10:59 am
by Manofevil
Image Roti, You CAN slay me.

Seriously though, this DOES allow us to pursue some rather interesting possibilities. In addition to confrontations, you've already pointed out alliances. It could even go so far as couplings. Could you imagine Soth and Tristessa as an item? Harkon and Jackie might be a good one. Bluebeard and Gabby. These things don't have to last, just make for interesting interludes. :diamabel:

Re: The City of Ravenloft

Posted: Tue Jan 24, 2012 8:22 pm
by Five
Manofevil - When you were designing the city did you envision a similar architecture throughout the city (as in the city is the city no matter who the current landlord is), a difference between the boroughs, per 'domain'...?

Just curious.

I see pretty much the same throughout the city (almost as if it was there before the first dark lord arrived) but with cultural trimmings, in an almost squatter way, that reflect the dark lord's people/servants/victims. Outside of the obvious differences that separate one social class from the others. Of course.

Anybody else?

Would it be too weird to have a city with vastly different CL neighbourhoods? Or should there be some common theme throughout?

Some really great ideas floating out there about the power structure of the city by the way. And I second Sorti's advice that we shouldn't overcomplicate things. The more ideas to bombard the reader with then the more this city can adapt to their game/whatever. Triple-up the Dread Possibilities, it can't hurt. I'm with the council idea personally, and I care as much about spit-shining that idea as I do explaining exactly how the Dark Powers work. Some details are fine, but the specifics certainly can be fudged some.

DM: "Why was (the dark lord) drawn to Ravenloft and imprisoned in (their domain)?"

Book: "Because they're cursed."

Book explains the evil(s) that they committed.

DM: "Oh. Ok."

- 2E in a nutshell, and I say that as a big fan of the setting.

Re: The City of Ravenloft

Posted: Tue Jan 24, 2012 9:29 pm
by Manofevil
Re: Archtecture and CLs. The model I was building on was New York from the movie "Gangs of new York'. In this movie, we have The Five Points, a high crime neighborhood with dirt streets and wooden sidewalks and buildings, and uptown with cobbled streets, stone buildings, and horse-drawn, rail-based, streetcars. It's all very irregular. Perhaps poverty levels should be a factor more than cultural levels. Also in a far more localized environment like this, government is far more informal. It really all depends on who's in charge, thus you can have an iron fisted dictator like Drakov running every aspect of his area, while Strahd sits in his manor, allowing his area to run itself so long as the taxes get paid and no one interferes with his business. Oh, he can intervene if he HAS to, but he doesn't often have to.

We really would have to better define each area in relation to it's Darklord. I would submit that we'd want to keep the basic fundamentals of each Darklord and a lot of the same issues are still there. Drakov and Harkon Lucas still have all the same reasons to feel inferior, for example. There are all kinds of ways to include pieces of actual RavenLoft in Ravenloft city. It's all just a question of how slick we wanna be.

Re: The City of Ravenloft

Posted: Wed Jan 25, 2012 11:40 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Some aspects of the city's architecture will need to be dictated by geography and resources, such as the local availability of stone, brick, and lumber for construction. If bricks are cheap and stone is expensive, that right there is a way to distinguish working-class neighborhoods from upscale ones. Styles that aren't appropriate to the region and climate ought to be left out, even if they'd fit the cultural motif of one of the darklords (e.g. no tents in Pharazia district if the weather's too cold/wet for them).

I'd presume the baseline climate is on the warmer side of temperate, if we're including Souragne and the Wildlands? Colder locales like Sanguinia would need to be at a much higher altitude, if that's the case. Perhaps the arctic domains are atop a high plateau that catches the worst of the cold winds over the mountains, while the harbor islands and the peninsula where Markovia and the Wildlands are located can jut out into warm currents moving up the coast. Humidity can be highest in the lowlands, while Nova Vaasa is dry enough to remain grassland because it's more sheltered by the mountains' rain shadow.

Re: The City of Ravenloft

Posted: Sat Mar 24, 2012 5:11 pm
by Manofevil
I just finished rereading this. We did a good job. Good point on the climate there at the end Roti.