I guess it depends on how much you consider Vampirism to be a curse. I guess I see it more as a biological (or necrological) state. A more scientific and less magical view, I suppose. I understand that most powers of vampires are physically impossible, and need magic to be explained, but in my low-magic view, their weaknesses are based on biological fact, not magic.alhoon wrote:Its how you treat sunlight. If the curse actually is "when the sunlight touches the vampire's flesh" then the clothing protects it. If the curse is "When the vampire is exposed to sunlight" then the clothing shouldn't protect it.
It would be different if an NPC was cursed by a vistani to be hurt by the sun. In that case, there's a magic effect following the NPC around and interpreting the curse. In the case of the vampire, if we assume something within his skin is disturbed by the pure sunlight, disrupting his powers, and we further assume that a diffuse reflection changes the light in a way that a direct reflection does not, then if no photons travel directly from the sun (or via a direct reflection) and hit his skin, how can he be hurt by it?
This is why I see thick clothing as a similar effect to buildings, coffins, and earth. If some magic aura surrounded the vampire's clothing, why not his coffin, or castle? It's Occam's razor, I suppose. It seems more simple to me that the light only affects the vampire himself. And we're not talking a t-shirt and shorts. It would be excessive bundling up for a cold-weather expedition, including a hooded cloak, scarves, goggles, furs. (since the vampire's "cover" is a bumbling young monk, the comical effect of his excessive preperation should deflect suspicion.)
A good question, and my answer is this: Few nosferatu would find a reason to do so. There is very little that a vampire cannot accomplish at night. Why risk the discomfort or death a possilbe tear in the suit would give? What could a vampire be doing in the day that would not be hindered by the bizarreness of such a suit? The only thing out in the daylight that isn't there at night are other people, and they would be scared off by the freakish suit. A vampire might long to go out in the sun as he did as a mortal, just to feel and see the sunshine again, but the suit won't help there. Also, for most Nosferatu, losing their powers temporarily isn't such a big deal, since they can retreat to their coffin and get them back.But why doesn't every nosferatu have a head-to-toe leather suit that covers its body completely, along with a mask with smoked glasses for eyes or something similar to be completely immune to sunlight?
And here's where I say that it's personal preference. Clothes seem to fit more in the gothic tradition to me than a magic ring. Think of the Invisible Man wrapped in his bandages, or Frankenstein in the blind man's hut. Being hidden by mundane means seems more fitting to me.But yes, as a player I would prefer to be outsmarted than finding out that he used magic to cover its weakness. However, using clothes would seem far worse to me.
Agreed, magic is inherently reality-bending, but in this case, I see it as rules-bending for three reasons.On another topic:Why you believe the ring is rule-bending? You said personal preference, but I am interested to know. (Really, not just backing my opionion).
My opinion is that magic is reality bending, so doing something with magic isn't rule-bending (just difficult).
1) Such a ring doesn't exist in any published product. I know, I can make up whatever I want, and I often do. But in this case it seems like I made up EXACTLY what I needed, which is too convenient. It's such a niche use of magic that I find it hard to believe the character would just happen to have it. If I had a problem that could be solved with a ring of invisibility, or a ring of levitation, sure, I might use it. But a ring of protection from sunlight for Nosferatus? It's a bit contrived feeling.
2) If such a ring did exist, I would expect it to be a one-of-a-kind legendary object for vampires (compare with the Ring of Amara from Buffy/Angel), much sought after by those angsty vampires who just wanna sunbathe again. It should be the focus of an adventure, not a side element added to make part of another adventure work.
3) My Ravenloft is supposed to be low-magic, so the ring seems out of place, for all the reasons Stygian Inquirer gave.
PS Rotipher, I like your idea with the "healing potions." Might use that.



