Posted: Fri Mar 24, 2006 8:37 am
I wouldn't necessarily say the shadow cloaker has to be Evil, jundging by the description; it's not as if it chose to be parasitic in its biology. I'd be more inclined to call it an "Often evil" than a "Usually" or "Always", as that makes it a bit more useful as a monster: most shadow cloakers would be antagonists for PCs, but occasionally a Neutral one might crop up working for the same side as the heroes.
Note that a lack of true compassion need not rule out Good alignments, altogether. A shadow cloaker wouldn't adhere to Good standards out of sympathy for its host, but it might make the intellectual decision to adopt a moral code, acting upon reason rather than emotion. Extremely unlikely, but it's at least possible: not all Good creatures are governed by empathy.
Note that a lack of true compassion need not rule out Good alignments, altogether. A shadow cloaker wouldn't adhere to Good standards out of sympathy for its host, but it might make the intellectual decision to adopt a moral code, acting upon reason rather than emotion. Extremely unlikely, but it's at least possible: not all Good creatures are governed by empathy.