HuManBing wrote:
As a single individual myself, I'd say in any given week I do things that could fulfill six or seven of the alignment squares myself.
...and of course
married individuals probably do all nine alignment squares in the course of a week.
And I would agree with you, Sylaire, about the difficulties of incorporating alignment as a hard-and-fast separator for things like magical items and spell effects, etc.
The Girdle of Sex Change (or possibly "Femininity/Masculinity") is actually in my opinion slightly LESS artificial and clumsy sounding than the Helm of Opposite alignment. Sex is, at least, tangible and visible. (And if you're like me and you live next door to a noisy couple, it's clearly audible too. The swine.) Alignment? Ehhh... not so much, as Jon Stewart might say.
I kind of view alignment as a diamond, with LG at the top, and then LN and NG a step below, then LE, TN, and CG a step below that.
Then on the nether side you have NE and CN, and finally the most corrupt and unpredictable alignment is CE at the bottom.
LE people are those who are constrained by law from reaching their full potential to be destructive. NE strikes me as the ultimate in selfishness and "take care of number one". CE strikes me as being one step even further in depravity than NE - a CE person might actually take calculated risks to his own safety just to throw a spanner in the works of a social order.
To use a slightly controversial example, say somebody sneaks a clockwork bomb into Martira Bay and detonates it.
The act is clearly evil. It's killing a load of people he doesn't know for no particular justification.
If he's doing it because he's part of a church that has a clear edict that justifies this act, then it's still evil, but if the individual genuinely lives by the church's code, then he's lawful. This is even more strongly shown if he would never do something that would actually benefit him if the church forbids it (e.g. sleep with an unmarried woman or steal money he didn't earn).
If he's doing it because he wants to stop Martira Bay's trade entirely and thus profit handsomely from his own trading company, then that's Neutral Evil. The act itself is outside of the law, so it can't be lawful, and it's destructive and there is no justification on a personal level as to killing those people, so it's evil. However, the benefits to this person are clear. So the fact that he does it makes sense from a cost-benefit utilitarian viewpoint, even if the morality and axiomatic axes do not support it.
Somebody who does it for no personal gain, with no legal code (internal or otherwise) to justify it, and who does it merely to sow chaos and destruction, is clearly chaotic evil.
I'd argue that CE is a very hard alignment to consistently follow, in the same way (and for much the same reasons) as LG is a hard alignment to consistently follow. In fact, I'd argue it is at a basic level contrary to social intercourse itself, and so the concept of a CE society is something of a contradiction in terms.
You can see the game designers getting their panties in a twist when they try to create an "order" or "society" for supposedly CE creatures like drow and Tanar'ri. These creatures are so evil and antisocial that to me their societies seem under great stress and likely to splinter at any given time.
A LE society can exist fairly smoothly - everybody is out for themselves but will observe laws, so there is an objective norm of behavior that is at least reasonably expected.
A NE society no longer has the exterior laws to follow, but there is the law of the selfish preservation to guide others. The norm of behavior is more subjective than in a LE society, but it's still there and if everybody is out looking out for themselves and not extending anything further than that, there's a good chance you can figure out a niche of your own and fight to defend it ferociously, to the point that it's not worth it for others to try to transgress on your turf.
A CE society doesn't even have that. Any standard of behavior is shifting and intangible. When individuals don't display objectively observable behavior patterns, or even go out of their way to betray their previous patterns of behavior, a neighbor has no idea what the other person will do. Under these stresses and strains, a CE society struggles to grow beyond a level where each person knows each other person by face. Once you have to deal with people you've never met before and you have no behavioral yardstick to measure it by, society falls apart and splinters into small groups who know each other on an individual level.
You can see even Ravenloft's designers had trouble with this. In his earlier incarnations, Strahd was Chaotic Evil - but that doesn't make for a very sympathetic villain at all. This is especially true for Ravenloft, where each major villain needs something about them that the PCs can look at and identify with.
And of course once the "noble general" backstory came into being, CE didn't work at all.