Another bit of "canon or not?" trivia:
While it was never officially declared non-canon -- probably due to both the product lines it'd pertained to (RL and PS) being discontinued -- a great portion of "Die, Vecna, Die" seems to have simply been left by the wayside. Initially, it was hinted that Vecna's escape from Ravenloft into Sigil had extremely drastic consequences, possibly accounting for the metaphysical (i.e. game-rule) changes of the 2E-to-3E transition. However, when 3E eventually got around to describing the Great Wheel, much of what D.V.D. had stated was never even mentioned, leaving it very much in doubt what "really" happened.
This is currently under discussion on the WotC boards, in the "Deities and the Planes" forum. Planescapers have evidently been debating the issue on and off for years, to the point where it's attained "dead cow" status on their fan-sites.
Non Canon list
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7107
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
This has hitched me for a while too. But after thinking about it, if you consider only the Ravenloft part of the story, it's easy to consider it canon (or say it's consistent with the continuity if you prefer) - Vecna escaped, Cavitius/Tovag was destroyed (or let's say lost in the mist if you prefer) in the process.
But for PS, I agree, DVD can having another status, as it messed with many things. The Greyhawk part seems OK too (if you forget the concentration of Vecna relics into one place
)
Joël
But for PS, I agree, DVD can having another status, as it messed with many things. The Greyhawk part seems OK too (if you forget the concentration of Vecna relics into one place
Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
- Undead Cabbage
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 623
- Joined: Wed Oct 19, 2005 7:39 pm
- Location: In one of Neil Gaiman's books, or at least I wish I was.
- Contact:
I'd like to jump on board the antipathy-towards-canon boat. Of course, I'm a GM that goes so far as the change some of the rules of gameplay, let alone the petty details of a campaign setting.I completely agree. Canon? They used to say something in one product, totally contradict it in the next product, and then change the "canon" to fit with the second product. They did that all the time. S&S did a bit of revisioning this way too. In that light, Ravenloft's "demise" as a commercial product line isn't a bad thing, as you don't have to worry about some game desinger coming along and revisioning the setting while you still have things the way they were.
The way I feel is that I'm the DM and it's our campaign. Our version of Ravenloft is different in some ways, the same in others. Canon? Who cares?
Now, in no way do I mean this as a shot to the published material; it is very well written, and even if I wasn't GMing I'd probably still read it all just for the sake of a great story. But in the end, my campaign is my campaign, Coan's campaign is Coan's campaign, etc. etc.
Besides, imagine if there were no creativity in role playing? Imagine if nobody dared do something against the canon material? Roleplaying game progress as we know it simply wouldn't exist. We all do role playing because we are all intelligent and creative enough people to not need a screen did dictate a game for us.
And there's my rant for today
- ChrisNichols
- Arch-villain

- Posts: 174
- Joined: Sun Nov 06, 2005 10:45 pm
- Location: Shawnee, OK
I've often thought of posting a "What I Would Change If a 4th Edition of Ravenloft Were Published" thread, discussing things I would "fix" from previous editions. This "fixes" fall into four broad catagories - Stuff That We Never Got Around To, Stuff That Needs To Be Removed or Fixed, New Stuff, and, yes, Stuff I Would Have Done Differently.Mangrum wrote:Oh, I think I've gone down that road too often as it is. Basically my personal apocrypha falls into two categories: "Stuff I think is plain awful" and "Stuff I would have done differently." I've made enough noise over the years about the former (it's no mystery what would appear high on this list), and the latter would just be me being a bad sport.
Stuff That We Never Got Around To would be fleshing out thing left vague by previous editions, like Liffe, Farelle, and other under developed domains. Also rules that never got good conversions - nightmares and pocket domains, for instance.
Stuff That Needs To Be Removed or Fixed would be things that broke the tenets of Ravenloft, ignored continuity, was poorly designed, or were bad ideas from the start. Sheriff Von Zarovich, I'm looking at you.
New Stuff would be, obviously, new stuff - particularly designs from my notebooks. New domains and darklords, new types of magic, new character classes and prestige classes, and so on are all possibilities.
Stuff I Would Have Done Differently is a touchy category. This is stuff that isn't objectively a Remove Or Fix item - it's just... I already had ideas and the published material wasn't it. Removing these things would be a major disservice to the authors, but... I like my ideas better on these items. That makes this a touchy and kinda selfish category, but it *is* there.
The big reasons I haven't written said thread are A) I'm bound to offend *someone,* and B) it would take a fair bit of time and effort to collect my thoughts and notes, and actually type the darn thing up, something I'm not ready to devote resources to at the moment.
Maybe over this winter's break.
Chris Nichols
- Nathan of the FoS
- Fiendish Enforcer

- Posts: 5247
- Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 3:39 pm
- Location: San Francisco CA
"Canon" is a concept for the writers, really. For DMs and players it's just a scaffold for their own work.
The writers are actually adding something to the "common world", so they need to agree on where they're starting from so they can produce interlocking, rather than mutually contradictory, information.
Of course, if the right hand doesn't know what the left is doing (see Champions of Darkness vs. Gazetteer 1) then you arrive quickly at "mutually contradictory" anyway. That is where the "canon vs. non-canon" debate comes into play, and what a messy argument it always turns out to be, to be sure.
The writers are actually adding something to the "common world", so they need to agree on where they're starting from so they can produce interlocking, rather than mutually contradictory, information.
Of course, if the right hand doesn't know what the left is doing (see Champions of Darkness vs. Gazetteer 1) then you arrive quickly at "mutually contradictory" anyway. That is where the "canon vs. non-canon" debate comes into play, and what a messy argument it always turns out to be, to be sure.
[b]FEAR JUSTICE.[/b] :elena:
