Page 2 of 3

Posted: Fri Mar 30, 2007 5:05 pm
by Mangrum
Vlad wrote:Take 'Neither man nor beast'. One of the nice things about this module is exploring the island. What's the fun if one of the PCs flies up, draws a map and says: okay, there's a monastry on top of that rock. I'll check it out.
I have to say, I find it less than shocking that an adventure designed for a 1st- to 4th-level party doesn't taking flying PCs into account.
Vlad wrote:Or in Forlorn, if the PCs are contemplating if they want to enter Tristenoira, that one of the PCs makes 'reconnaissance-flights' over the castle. It takes awat the gothic mood of walking up the decripit Barbican, etc. Perhaps that's my most strong objection: it takes away the mood.
In this instance, it sounds a lot less like "takes away the mood" and more like "derails my railroad."

When I ran that adventure, back in the day, my PCs couldn't fly -- and they never went anywhere near the barbican.

Posted: Fri Mar 30, 2007 5:11 pm
by Vlad
Mangrum wrote:
Vlad wrote:Take 'Neither man nor beast'. One of the nice things about this module is exploring the island. What's the fun if one of the PCs flies up, draws a map and says: okay, there's a monastry on top of that rock. I'll check it out.
I have to say, I find it less than shocking that an adventure designed for a 1st- to 4th-level party doesn't taking flying PCs into account.
No, in this case, no. But in many other modules, some spells seem just to be too disruptive to the story.

In this instance, it sounds a lot less like "takes away the mood" and more like "derails my railroad."
Uh, railroad.. how strange is it to enter a castle through the front gate?

Posted: Fri Mar 30, 2007 5:21 pm
by Mangrum
Vlad wrote:Uh, railroad.. how strange is it to enter a castle through the front gate?
When the people in question are adventurers looking to slip inside, you mean? Why would it be strange not to? After all, that's the root of your complaint -- that the PCs may want to try an option other than the One Correct Option you have in your head.

If the PCs don't want to use the front gate, and the DM has a problem with that because it denies him the ability to describe a scene from the precise angle he wants it, then the DM might as well just announce to the PCs that they need to put down their dice and pencils while he narrates a cut scene. The players would find just as much freedom of choice in a CRPG.

Posted: Fri Mar 30, 2007 6:41 pm
by Lost Heretic
Vlad wrote:Well, it's not only escaping but also getting into places that should be hard to reach, like the top of Castle Ravenlofts tower for instance. Or entering it's dungeon through the lookout in the cliff. (In my campaign one tried to do that, with a rope. The last thing he saw was a dark shape under the overhang slicing his rope in two.. Much more fun than a PC flying to the window and Strahd casting dispel magic.
Well then, I can whole-heartedly say that if I was in your campaign I'd be casting spells left and right to get an edge in the future, since trying something as mundane as climbing a rope it's far too risky.

I mean, in the campaign I'm currently playing in, all the fun of being a mage is trying to find a slick way to handle a situation. In the case of Castle Ravenloft, just flying around and checking things out really isn't too bad of an idea in my opinion. As a DM, you need to reward the players for their good thinking, but as a Ravenloft DM you need to keep the players confused and on their toes. Just think about it a little. The player can fly up and get a good look, but I'd bet that Strahd has quite the magical security system. If the player lingers too long or gets too close, then have some arrows shot at him from the dark windows or possibly have his flight dispelled if he cannot be detered. Still, he'll have some good information for the rest of his party, but he won't want to try something like that again.

Re: Magic screwing up modules...

Posted: Fri Mar 30, 2007 9:51 pm
by Jason of the Fraternity
Lost Heretic wrote:I mean, in the campaign I'm currently playing in, all the fun of being a mage is trying to find a slick way to handle a situation.
I would tend to agree. A wizard only has a limited number of spells memorized per day, and they certainly cannot plan for every conceivable obsticle that will arise. A lot of the fun of playing a wizard is trying to prepare for the dangers ahead and then using their selected spells to their best benefit. How often is your average wizard going to be able to cast fly during the course of the adventure (at least without spending numerous days rememorizing the spell or creating several scrolls in advance)?

Lost Heretic wrote:As a DM, you need to reward the players for their good thinking, but as a Ravenloft DM you need to keep the players confused and on their toes. Just think about it a little. The player can fly up and get a good look, but I'd bet that Strahd has quite the magical security system.
Barring magical wards (such as Lost Heretic's examples of arrows or dispelling magic), I don't think that it would be out of line to have swarms of bats (or even crows/ravens) attack adventurers that spend too much time flying around the castle. This would prevent your wizard from being able to do a lot of reconnaissance work without putting himself/herself into danger. However, it does allow them to use their spell(s) without being immediately punished.

Posted: Fri Mar 30, 2007 10:08 pm
by Jason of the Fraternity
Vlad wrote:As a DM I'm quite restrictive as of which magic and spells I give to my PCs. For instance, fly and teleportspells won't be in their spellbooks, as is phantom steed. The reason for this is that I hate those spells, because they tend to screw up my modules and adventures. "Oh, Strahd is lowering the portcullis, well no problem, we'll just fly out of his castle!"
I can certainly sympathize with the frustrations that arise when a plyer uses a spell or magical item to easily overcome an encounter. It can be especially in a Ravenloft adventure when you are trying to create a scary mood or horrorific event. However, I don't know if I would be so restrictive with the spells that I allow.

Borrowing from my message in the post above, how often can a wizard cast a spell (such as fly) each day without devoting a great deal of time creating scrolls or a specific magic item? Just because the wizard can cast fly to escape from the castle that doesn't mean the rest of the party will get past the lowering portcullis... Likewise, Strahd might dispatch some flying monsters (perhaps gargoyle) to deal with adventurers that try to fly away.

Lost Heretic wrote:If they can keep getting away with the same trick over and over again, then your villains are idiots. No offense.
And Strahd, for example, wouldn't fall for the same trick even if the adventurers did escape. He would definitely have improved his defenses should the 'heroes' decide to come back to his castle again.

Posted: Sat Mar 31, 2007 8:08 am
by Vlad
I can certainly sympathize with the frustrations that arise when a plyer uses a spell or magical item to easily overcome an encounter. It can be especially in a Ravenloft adventure when you are trying to create a scary mood or horrorific event. However, I don't know if I would be so restrictive with the spells that I allow.
Well, that's exactly what I mean. I don't wanna railroad my PCs through every adventure that way I see it, but those spells tend to be disruptive in some modules. I am not that restrictive (perhaps that view arises from my posts above), but I want them to use their brains instead of their (standard) spells.

Borrowing from my message in the post above, how often can a wizard cast a spell (such as fly) each day without devoting a great deal of time creating scrolls or a specific magic item? Just because the wizard can cast fly to escape from the castle that doesn't mean the rest of the party will get past the lowering portcullis... Likewise, Strahd might dispatch some flying monsters (perhaps gargoyle) to deal with adventurers that try to fly away.
Ofcourse, and I know perfect ways to play Strahd :twisted: .. Perhaps I find those spells, like fly or teleport, too fantasy. Never saw a hero in a gothic horror movie do something like that. That's my point.

Posted: Sat Mar 31, 2007 10:47 am
by Sylaire
Vlad wrote:
Ofcourse, and I know perfect ways to play Strahd :twisted: .. Perhaps I find those spells, like fly or teleport, too fantasy. Never saw a hero in a gothic horror movie do something like that. That's my point.
Well, the original Ravenloft module and its various reincarnations isn't particularly gothic horror. Good ol' I6 was at its heart a big ol' dungeon crawl, albeit with a particularly well-designed dungeon and exceptionally atmospheric window dressing (funny how all my favorite TSR adventures from that era were by Tracy and/or Laura Hickman--both Ravenlofts, the "Desert of Desolation" series (I3, I4, and I5), and the "original" D&D adventure "Rahasia" (B7) ), but a dungeon crawl all the same and it played out in the same way.

Sounds to me like Masque of the Red Death might be more to your taste. The restrictions on magic use there in are definitely more setting-appropriate and lead to a more cerebral, story-based playing style. At its core, Ravenloft is about slipping horror motifs and atmosphere into your fantasy gaming, while MotRD is essentially a horror RPG that happens to use d20/AD&D-based rules.

Posted: Sat Mar 31, 2007 2:53 pm
by Ronia Sun
This is just my two cents, but I get the feeling that Vlad's gripe arises more from uncreative, rather lazy players than from real issues with the spells/rules/whatever themselves. Players who use the same dumb tricks over and over instead of using their brains are rather missing the point of tabletop gaming, I think. You want brainless, go do a demon-slog on Diablo or something. :D If you play tabletop, though, I don't think it's unfair of a DM to expect his/her players to actually use their imaginations.

Perhaps, rather than simply outlawing certain spells, you might try being upfront with your players? Tell them your concerns, remind them that you spent a great deal of time and effort in planning this, and you'd just love a bit of cooperation and a bit less laziness. In my experience (admittedly a little limited, since I've only been doing tabletop for a few years) a good player is more than willing to extend their cooperation. After all, they want to enjoy it too, and an intelligent player usually gets the idea that, sometimes, you just gotta help the DM out a little. Cooperation, rather than the DM having to fight the players every step of the way. :)

I admit, I'm a little spoiled with my RL party. They're fantastic. (And that's the sort of "Fantastic!" you'd hear from The Doctor, they're that good.) Very creative, cooperative, etc etc. Still, their creativity makes them a bit unpredictable at times, and that can be a little nerve-wracking for the DM. So, last week, I reminded them that I was working on an adventure set at a masked ball and asked for a bit of assistance. I told 'em I was thrilled they were so creative and unpredictable, and that while I didn't want to change that a bit I *would* need a little willingness to go along with the story, just for the ball. They all said they were more than willing, and that was that. :D

I suppose the point is, perhaps you'd have a bit more success asking the players themselves to help you out a bit. I always make sure my players understand that I, as a DM, am mostly interested in telling a fun story they are involved deeply in, and that I'm not so interested in killing them off unless they do something really, really stupid. Maybe it removes some of the "fear" but I find it more enjoyable overall and I can then focus on scaring the pants off them in other ways. They seem less likely to fight me on things if they at least know I'm not going out of my way to try and actually *kill* them.

If, when all is said and done, the players *still* don't want to use their imaginations, then maybe it's time to find another group. :roll:

Posted: Sat Mar 31, 2007 9:57 pm
by Jonathan Winters
Hey everybody,

The more I think about this, the more I have to side with JWM on this one.

Why should the PCs try something else if a Fly spell will fix everything?
You can't really blame the PCs for using their class abilities, can you?

If you start restricting allowed spells from PC's spell list, you start unbalancing Core Classes from the Player's Handbook. Will you start restricting Fighter's feats too? A Rogue's Sneak Attack? etc.

If your players fool you once! Shame on them! :)
If your players fool you twice... Well...

Just my two cents!

Patrick

Posted: Sat Mar 31, 2007 10:59 pm
by alhoon
Actually playing a Campaign with a 13th level wizard and a 11th level mage I have to say that I agree with those that say "Let them use the spells! That's why they are there for!"

Do you really want wizards that are just fireball throwers?

Yes, flying over the castle walls is an easy, safe solution. Why would someone not take it? If it works, then why wouldn't he/she use that trick again and again?
The way you described the uses of portable hole shows that your players have imagination. :) Why would someone restrict them to the choice: "Should I prepare to deal electricity or cold damage today?"

I agree that spells like detect thoughts, legend lore, fly, teleport etc tend to give the PCs quick, clean solutions. I agree that this may throw an adventure out of the window... I don't find that necessarily bad.

Many people do however: So I would just advise you the following:
Restrict your players from the beginning of the campaign to non-spellcasting classes.
To be sincere, I would feel completely cheated if I decided to play a wizard and then, when after pains and adventures I reached 3rd level heard a "nope, you cannot have invisibility or detect thoughts. And later you cannot have gaseous form or fly in your spells!"

Posted: Sat Mar 31, 2007 11:12 pm
by alhoon
Examples of how spells can kick an adventure hard:

Yesterday night: Big bad monster. All the chars had been ready for the big fight. Haste, mass aid, circle protection from evil, stoneskins etc. (and they are LOT).
(short version)
Mage: I have locate creature active, do I sense the monster approaching?
Me: yes
Mage: I ready prismatic spray
Me: It comes in the corridor... (etc. etc)
Mage: I hit it with the spell. (Rolls 1d8---> Ray that sends it to another domain).
Me(rolling save): It lost the save.
*Poof* The big bad monster has been sent to Vorostok. (Yeap, I rolled to see, and they used scry to check where it ended).

It gave us a good laugh, and we went on with the campaign.

Another time, they scried where a vamp hid his coffin, teleported in invisible, casted web to keep at bay the numerous dominated thralls, got the coffin while the vamp was sleeping for the day and teleported in a river... at midday. Bye bye villain. :) One of the most creative uses of teleport I have ever seen.

Another time: Sithicus, Big bad Hydra, 16 HD, 8 heads, diseased bite, was infecting the nearby water with the disease, the locals couldn't deal with it.
Mage flying, throwing empowered cone of cold, mordenkainen's sword, empowered fireball and a couple more spells. The Hydra even dived in the water of a nearby lake, but still, the flying mage got her with sonic spells that can work under the water.

That's how it is. When someone is one of the most powerful mages of the core, compaired to Hazlik in power, he gets to be tough. :) That's the fun of evolving to a high level character.

Yeah, sometimes it is not so fun when they find a loophole around an adventure you worked on for 4-5 hours, and they finish it in 5 mins. But I'm creative, so I keep the game going, having them do other things and learning to avoid loopholes.

Posted: Sun Apr 01, 2007 5:39 am
by Vlad
Ronia Sun wrote:This is just my two cents, but I get the feeling that Vlad's gripe arises more from uncreative, rather lazy players than from real issues with the spells/rules/whatever themselves. Players who use the same dumb tricks over and over instead of using their brains are rather missing the point of tabletop gaming, I think. :
Well. the strange thing with my PCs is, they don't care for magic at all. (seems like a paradox with regard to what I stated earlier, but I'll explain). I used to have 2 clerics and 1 mage. The clerics (one is still left) don't care what kinda spells they have, almost exclusively using cures. The mage only used the standard fireball/magic missile spells. Not much else. The fighters in the group complained about this, saying they would do better. The spellcasters focused more on roleplaying than bothering to read the spells they had. I did like those players approach, but sometimes they just underused the magic (well, just like I like, but sometimes you just need more). Right now, we've got a new mage and a fighter turning into a priest, and those two players are much more dedicated to casting spells. So much, that they outwit me with their spell knowledge. Okay to me, but they tend to use it too much. In my ideal world, they would only use it as a last resort (and then they can use all the knowledge they have). With all respects, but the quote from alhoon above reminds me of a SWAT team, not of a party of horror-adventurers.
On the other hand, perhaps I should let them go. Perhaps there is a fear in me that they will destroy everything I plan, but hey, otherwise I should be writing books.. I used to allow very much (like the bag of holding, teleport, etc) and it quickly derailed (in my point of view ofcourse).

Another example: phantom steed. My PCs had that spell and used it always, in stead of horses. I hated it, not because it screwed up my modules, but because they used to race through my campaignworld. Even as I am writing this, I find it hard to explain what I didn't like, but I think it's just the idea.. magic should be something mysterious and wonderful. Not something you use in your everyday life. What's the fun of Gandalf giving the hobbits a permament flying spell so they could drop the ring in mount doom without trouble?

Posted: Sun Apr 01, 2007 6:08 am
by The Giamarga
I think it's very important to let the PCs have access to (almost) all the spells that they want. I had a DM who didn't give PCs the fly spell or teleport or even invisibility. I hated it. It does make the PCs go with fireball-magic-missile-grease etc. While this leaves less disruptions for the DM i find it does perhaps cause even more problems for a Ravenloft campaign. Such a battlecaster does fit even less into the Ravenloft atmosphere than say a charm-casting enchanter. (Charm is another one of those supposedly disrupting spells)

When i decided to run a short Dungeon adventure I consciously allowed free spell selection (but you had to roll if you understood the spell, those were 2E rules). The player who had played all those dum-boring fireball throwing wizards, selected not a single of the cheesy standard spells. (Well he tried invisibility but rolles 100 on all 3 variations of it! ) Instead he made a very athmospheric wizard with a spell selection that was powerful and still quite tightly themed. I'll never forget the encounter that had his very first use of the dreaded teleport spell: It was a nightly random encounter and their watch had fallen asleep. I told him he woke up encased in webbing and saw a huge spider directly above him. He teleported a few feet away out of the webbing, cast some damaging spell and then ghost touch and vampiric touch in rapid succession.

Long story short, i think you should let the players have access to all spells. If you know what spells they have you can on the other hand stop pulling the punches with NPCs and monsters and have them use their spells and powers creatively too.

If you want to somewhat restrict or control what spells are available, I suggest using a system like path magic, where you have to know spell x to be able to learn spell y (i.e burning hands before you can learn fireball etc.) I know this system from an old 2e dragon article, but i think a similar one has been published for d20. (SKR might have one on his site.) This allows for themed very atmospheric wizards. I.e. a Battlecaster or a cursing witch vs a conjurer. It allows some control and you know what to expect and it enhances the overall athmosphere.

Posted: Sun Apr 01, 2007 8:56 am
by alhoon
Vlad wrote:
In my ideal world, they would only use it as a last resort (and then they can use all the knowledge they have). With all respects, but the quote from alhoon above reminds me of a SWAT team, not of a party of horror-adventurers.
:wink: I don't use Ravenloft for Horror adventures as much as the rest of the people here. I use it as a managable, low on magic items small plane with a horror background. The forests are beautiful but dark, the mountains are looming, there is mist everywhere etc.
When I use it for more Gothic games (and they are short!) I just don't allow high levels. I mean a short adventure of 3-4 sessions with a party of 3rd-4th level.

Vlad wrote:
magic should be something mysterious and wonderful. Not something you use in your everyday life. What's the fun of Gandalf giving the hobbits a permament flying spell so they could drop the ring in mount doom without trouble?
You can be sure that if Gandalf could do that, he would. :wink: He didn't want the Hobbits to have a nice adventure, he wanted them to succeed. Also in that case... how would the flying hobbits defeat the ringwraiths? Or whatever flying monstrocity was in their way?
And when in the Lord of Rings Gandalf was showering every enemy with fireballs?
IMO Don't be afraid of the spells. Find ways to counter them, so your PCs will find ways to counter them again etc.

OR: in your case, from what I have seen from your posts here I would suggest the following: Don't allow wizard PCs.
Let's face it: Wizard PCs (not NPCs) don't merge well with the gothic horror games you want to run. In that regard, not even clerics mesh in well.
Try the Archivist class from the Heroes of horror for clerics and tell the other PCs to take rangers, barbarians, fighters, rogues or for spellcasters Archivists or bards.
Remember to drop in a wizard ally every once a while to give them a couple of potions of fly for the one time they need it. If they have a one-shot fly, they wouldn'y waste it. :wink: