HuManBing wrote:
I have the 1995 version and was irritated at the writing style, which explained very little and assumed that the reader had already read all there was to read in the 1990 version.
That's one of the annoying things about the classic "updated reissue" of products (what's Ravenloft on now, four versions?). On the one hand, there's an established fanbase for Dark Sun products, and those are the people who are most likely to fast-draw their wallets for something new Dark Sun-related. On the other hand, if it's just a new campaign set, well, the
established fanbase probably has that already, else how did they become the established fanbase?
So they have to include new material to interest the established customers. In this case, they seem to have gone way overboard in that direction, because after all, campaign sets are also supposed to be starting points for new customers. That's the major reason for re-releases of successful campaign settings, to expand the market for the gaming company by drawing in new customers who would otherwise hesitate to "jump aboard" with the original sourcebooks 5-10 years out of print (a problem which Ravenloft as a setting is having now with no product support).
Yet it's really easy to go too far in that direction, too. That's why, for example, I bailed out of reading American comic books around five years ago. All the comic companies got so wrapped up in attracting new readers that they got into their kick of "anyone can pick up this book with any issue and start reading immediately!" that years of continuity became essentially irrelevant. The characters became utterly frozen without any meaningful development at all, because
development has to be done with reference to
past events for it to be meaningful, and essentially books were not allowed to refer to past events because new readers wouldn't have the background necessary to understand them. Result: I stopped reading.
It's definitely not an easy line to walk, when dealing with an established product line. Personally, I'd like to see about 25-50% new content each time there's a restart of the line. Of course, that means that after a few rereleases they start to become unwieldy...but hey, that's the price of success.
