cure wrote:sticky floor spells (no resistance) and web spells (no resistance) knock down reflex saves and increase the susceptibility to area effect spells,
You are free to house rule this as you like, but I have searched all throughout the PHB and DMG for anything to do with being Grappled and your Reflex save, and there is nothing on the subject. (For what it's worth, I was researching combat tactics using Azalin's spellbook, in the thread of that name.)
My house rule is if a caster is able to grapple an enemy with a magical effect, usually Black Tentacles, it will remove all Dex bonuses to Reflex saves. It is very similar to the official canon rules on AC and Grappling, which state that you lose your Dex bonuses to AC when Grappled. Some of my players think even that is too lenient and they would actually start assigning penalties to Reflex saves while grappled.
You are of course right that there is no penalty to reflex saves. A slip of the pen so to speak.
Knocking a mere 1 off the AC of an entangled Talon (DX 12) by ridding him of his bonus to AC is a bit distressing. And not effecting his reflex saves is even more distressing. But simply pinning them and their mounts in place and nicely lined up for a series of lightning bolts, while slow burning alchemical fire is eating them alive, is really not that bad from a kobold's perspective.
Last edited by cure on Mon Jul 09, 2007 2:53 pm, edited 1 time in total.
I have to echo Brandi and Tucker's Kobolds. I don't know the whole story, but I do know they were the only critters left in the dungeon, because the adventurers decided they were too costly to fight.
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."
Isabella wrote:I have to echo Brandi and Tucker's Kobolds. I don't know the whole story, but I do know they were the only critters left in the dungeon, because the adventurers decided they were too costly to fight.
Don't know it, but I think that I can imagine it.
On their home ground, with years to create traps, no need at all to create tunnels scaled to human size, and no need for light, they can and should be unholy terrors.
But the Basilisk is winning a reputation for himself not simply by repulsing anyone who looks him up. He is on the offensive. He is taking the fight to the enemy. And he has very limited ability to exploit the size and the trap making skills of the species. No Talon in his right mind is going to ride down a road that narrows to path 2.5' wide surrounded by thick undergrowth. Equally kobolds who spend weeks building a trap on the road are likely to be discovered and eaten by something arguably worse than the Talons. The rules as written basically elminate traps as useful ambush techniques save for at the heart of your home terriotory. The spell Create Trap spell helps a little but only at a low level.
True, but I think Tucker's Kobolds also used guerrilla warfare to push on the offensive as well - one example I recall (fuzzily) was hiding behind burning barricades while pushing them forward with elongated poles.
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."
Isabella wrote:True, but I think Tucker's Kobolds also used guerrilla warfare to push on the offensive as well - one example I recall (fuzzily) was hiding behind burning barricades while pushing them forward with elongated poles.
Interesting. Very interesting.
I am currently toying with a sleet storm spell and dire weasels (which have the scent ability) and perhaps riders with blind-fighting.
From Wiki:
"Tucker's kobolds were a fictional tribe of kobolds made famous by Roger E. Moore's editorial in Dragon magazine issue 127.[1] The editorial described a dungeon crawl adventure designed and run by a Game Master in Fort Bragg, North Carolina named Tucker in which a party of high-level adventurers entered a dungeon whose first level was inhabited by kobolds.
While normally kobolds are considered extremely weak monsters of no significant threat, Tucker's kobolds were intimately familiar with their home territory and were well prepared to repel invaders using devious traps and ambushes. Tactics described in the editorial included trapping the party in a corridor filled with flammable materials that they then set on fire, shooting crossbows at the party through murder holes or from sniper positions with prepared escape routes, and hurling Molotov cocktails at the party from behind the cover of flaming barricades that groups of kobolds pushed ahead of them with metal poles. The party's hirelings and henchmen were all killed and they had to abandon their donkeys and many of their supplies in their hurry to get through the kobolds' territory. The party ultimately "escaped" down an air shaft that led to a very deep level of the dungeon inhabited by demons.
Tucker's kobolds became a famous part of Dungeons & Dragons lore, often referred to as an example of how cunning and local knowledge can be used by physically weak opponents to overcome much more powerful adversaries."
Actually there is a webpage too. Though I wonder about the copyright . . .
It may well be that for all the terrible rumors, the Basilisk is actually just an ordinary kobold-- with exceptionally good tactical skills. And wouldn't that p*ss off Drakov most of all-- that the little runts' "dishonorable" tactics are kicking the collective butt of his finest warriors?
Or maybe the whole notion that there's a "Basilisk" leading the kobolds at all is pure political propaganda, to cover up the fact that Drakov's troops *are* getting their collective butt kicked by independent guerilla-squads of sneaky little runts?
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Or maybe the whole notion that there's a "Basilisk" leading the kobolds is pure political propaganda, to cover up the fact that Drakov's troops *are* getting their collective butt kicked by sneaky little runts?
This I like. Think especially of terrorists in the real world. Organizations that are more structured will look at them and think "If I cut off the head, the body stops kicking". So they call in a missile strike, or they storm a bedroom at night, or they pepper a car with bullets one sudden moment along a road.
The head of the terror group is dead, clearly. But then just a few weeks later, they strike again, and somebody else among the unending ranks of ambitious underlings has risen to fill the space...
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Or maybe the whole notion that there's a "Basilisk" leading the kobolds at all is pure political propaganda, to cover up the fact that Drakov's troops *are* getting their collective butt kicked by independent guerilla-squads of sneaky little runts?
As much as this idea appeals to me in its sheer elegance, I wonder if we are not overestimating the degree to which there is public opinion in Falkovnia in need of manipulation by propaganda. What the overwelming majority of Falkovnians know of the eastern front is exactly what Drakov wants them to know. That is to say the Basilisk would be the public excuse for problems that Drakov would not permit the public to know of in the first place. True, soldiers and merchants might repeat what they have seen, but that would be high treason and colaboration with the enemy, although other reasons would be invented for their executions. Short of spectacular raids into the cities, the only real proof that would be available would be the sons who did not return, assuming that where they were stationed and died is not also a state secret, which it ought to be.
I wonder if the propaganda is not rather for the consumption of Drakov and his generals. As previously suggested by someone earlier in this thread, a company commander who admits losing his men to a pint sized enemy is not long for the world. So it is the lowly men in the field who have dreamt up the Basilisk and to some extent have come to believe in him too . . . suggesting even the possibility that he is or will become a bogey man.
A little to much magic for my taste, but if it works for you that's fine.
Here's what I did with the Falknovian Kobolds IMC:
Head on confrontations are suicide for the kobolds against plated Talons; it might be possible against regular troops but risky. The kobolds must focus their attacks on only certain factors
1. Overwhelming numbers; i.e. swarming lone or small groups
2. prepared ambushes in advantageous terrain
3. Negation of armor, mounts and polearm advantage
-I had several kobolds to a bill-hook (a polearm useful for hooking into armor chinks and dismounting the rider or at least limiting movement) with several of them in use assault plate wearers- keeping them at a distance with the assistance of pikes
-At the same time the horses legs and stomach would be cut by another hook or a daring kobold with a dagger (humans did this in our own medieval history)
-Hails of arrows at the non-plate wearers as well as slings/alchemist's fire/acid etc
-Crossbows used on Talons (yes they could pierce plate at close range, longbows could to at VERY close range but kobolds cannot use those)
- If talon is knocked prone, several kobolds with clubs and daggers rush up and beat him to death
Other ways I had the kobolds fight were to sneak into camps and assassinate the soldiers, or apply poisons to food/water/people; dumping of rotting flesh into wells; I played them up as using every 'dirty' trick in the book- In other words they waged war to the best of their ability. To me the basilisk is nothing more than a brilliant kobold tactitian and leader.
Could be, the "Basilisk" started out as an excuse the regional garrison's commanders cooked up, to avoid being staked for losing troops to puny little kobolds. OTOH, S found out about the Basilisk somehow, and I doubt if she managed to read those commanders' secret battle-reports to Drakov.
Heh. Maybe the garrisons' "excuse" has grown out of control? Drakov's regular troops could've picked up on the idea (not knowing it was fake) and spread it all over Falkovnia as they were rotated to new postings. From them, it would spread to the civilian population -- yes, technically it's a military secret, but stopping every hard-bitten soldier in a country from boasting and/or complaining is probably about as effective as stopping them all from carousing -- from whom S heard the tale.
For that matter, the kobolds might've picked up on the idea themselves, and run with a rumor the humans started. Anyone read that Batman mini-graphic "The Killing Joke"? In it, the so-called 'Red Hood Gang' weren't really led by a supervillain named the Red Hood: they just took turns wearing a red mask, to confuse the cops and intimidate their victims.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
"Head on confrontations are suicide for the kobolds against plated Talons; it might be possible against regular troops but risky. The kobolds must focus their attacks on only certain factors".
I agree heartily . . . but figuring out how to take down five mounted Talons with no, or at least very minimal, losses is an interesting challenge. And the answer would make the kobolds a first rate menace for a moderately powerful party.
"1. Overwhelming numbers; i.e. swarming lone or small groups"
If he is wereing the armour and is mounted on a heavy warhorse even a single Talon, possessed of the cleave feat and until you get him off that warhorse, is a lethal threat for kobolds.
"2. prepared ambushes in advantageous terrain"
Nothing less and with routes of flight prepared that mounted Talons cannot follow.
"3. Negation of armor, mounts and polearm advantage"
If you run the numbers on tripping (forcible dismounting) and disarming, they are depressing, unless the spell steal size is brought into play, and it is far from assured against the magically protected Talons. Kobolds with their lack of size and lack of strength are dismissal at this kind of work and aid another does not ultimately help.
Now mounted, changing, flanking, dire weasels aren't half bad at grappling, in effect, Talons seated in their saddle and then the blood/constitution draining beginnings. But a Talon is likely to pummel two or three of them to death before going peacefully to the grave. Which make it a rather stressful proposition for the local ecology. 'Get me more dire weasels, more dire weasels damn it!'
"-I had several kobolds to a bill-hook (a polearm useful for hooking into armor chinks and dismounting the rider or at least limiting movement) with several of them in use assault plate wearers- keeping them at a distance with the assistance of pikes
-At the same time the horses legs and stomach would be cut by another hook or a daring kobold with a dagger (humans did this in our own medieval history)"
Cutting down the horses must be the first priority of the average kobold making melee attacks, closely seconded by cutting bow strings. For afterward they have an absolute speed advantage and if balance checks can be brought into the equatation the Talon is in massive trouble thanx to his armour.
"-Hails of arrows at the non-plate wearers as well as slings/alchemist's fire/acid etc
-Crossbows used on Talons (yes they could pierce plate at close range, longbows could to at VERY close range but kobolds cannot use those)"
Ranged touched attacks, alchemical fire, acid and tanglefoot bags, against AC 11 rather than ranged attacks against AC 21 is the unique sweet spot available to the kobolds and they must exploit it massively.
Large quantities of caltrops are a must too.
"- If talon is knocked prone, several kobolds with clubs and daggers rush up and beat him to death"
Well, with flanking, aid another, the Talon prone, attacks of opportunity when he tries to get up, this might eventually yield results. Then again, a successful cleave or two quickly messes up the equation. Better work frankly for the dire weasels, although assisting them would be nice, and would help to limit losses.
"Other ways I had the kobolds fight were to sneak into camps and assassinate the soldiers, or apply poisons to food/water/people; dumping of rotting flesh into wells; I played them up as using every 'dirty' trick in the book- In other words they waged war to the best of their ability. To me the basilisk is nothing more than a brilliant kobold tactitian and leader."
This is the other place where kobold would need to focus. And indeed thieves kobolds should be in high demand for this priority work.
* * *
If kobolds are seen as teeming masses, reproducing like rabbits, and never in short supply, then putting many in the way of near certain death is not a problem.
If the supply is rather limited and the successful leader is he who rigourly avoids wasteful tactics, then sleath, alchemy, dire weasels (used with care), and ultimately magic strike me as being essential parts of the puzzle, not in the least because Talons have so many hit points to eat through.
Last edited by cure on Tue Jul 10, 2007 2:32 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Do kobolds like bugs? A swarm of bees would throw any mounted Falkovnian unit way off balance. Horses panic and throw their riders, and armored enemies are helpless as the bees crawl in between plates and under rivets and start stinging.
A waterpit trap, laid across a road or an encampment, could work. This would take some time to finish, but given the right conditions you have a deep pit of marshy mud or quicksand and the top layer bakes in the sun so it looks like normal sand or dirt. Even light creatures like kobolds or perhaps (if you leave it long enough) even a human could walk on it, but once a horse tries the same, it cracks the thin top layer and falls in.
Kobolds could lure mounted or armored enemies into dry brush and then start a brushfire behind them and launch arrows and bolts from in front.
Kobolds are not good at doing damage, so they should smear poisons and other nasty things on their missile weapons to do the damage for them.
Combining tactics
Or the cunning little buggers could use all these tactics. Have a kobold tribe drive all the humans out of a distant village, either by poisoning or otherwise besting them in non-face-to-face combat. The villagers tell the local Talons where the kobolds are. Talons assemble a force to retake the village.
Meanwhile, the kobolds prepare waterpit traps at every exit to the village save one. They also pile dry brush into all the huts and hovels, and likewise place lit lanterns at strategically spaced locations in the surrounding brush.
As the soldiers ride up there, the kobolds strike from the cover of the longgrass. They do minimal damage, instead infuriating the soldiers, who give chase.
At regular intervals along the path, the kobolds have stationed a group of three or four archers. The group retreats towards a preordained point, where a waiting relief group of kobold archers awaits. When the previous group retreats back to the waiting group, the waiting group pops up out of the longgrass, giving the illusion of a tenacious band of kobolds who can run and shoot unusually well. Then the waiting group retreats, and so forth, all the way until they get to the village.
Three exits to the village have been trapped with waterpit traps to snare horses. The fourth exit is the one the kobolds run in through, drawing the horsemen in. Once that's done, the kobolds throw a beehive or an earthen jug of bees into the middle of the soldiers and then retreats. The final team of kobolds sets fire to all the buildings and then the surrounding brush. As the soldiers on horseback try to escape, their mounts plunge into the waterpit traps. Soldiers on foot fare somewhat better but still have to get out of the village, amidst a rain of poisoned kobold arrows and bolts, before the fire engulfs the entire fields and village itself.
In one fell swoop the kobolds will have inflicted a fairly humiliating defeat on the enemy, encircling and destroying an entire guard's worth of soldiers.
And of course the village will probably not be habitable for a long time afterwards, if indeed ever again.
A bee swarm is interesting. Are there official stats for one anywhere?
I actually think that a simple skunk, or at least the illusion of one, has great potential in getting an ambush going.
I suppose on your take, Gondegel and the human resistance to Drakov generally is being tarred by the false allegation that it works with those fiendish pint-sized (like the accursed demi-humans) terrorist kobolds.
In regards to the Falkovnian armored Talons, I recall one game where we held off a "siege" with common items as makeshift ammo. We had buckets of boiling water, hot oil, hot sand (OW!), boiling lye, pitch, bleach, and other nasty things that we tossed at the attackers. All of those ran through chinks in the armor and couldn't be gotten out out of the armor once it was in - so the attackers had to pick between excruciating, crippling pain or taking their armor off. For extra nastiness we added hot honey to some of it to make it stick. We also found out that boiling lye plus even more heat is about the same as napalm (or at least our GM thought it did).
The kobolds could have portable traps with that stuff, or depending on their level of technology they could use them as catapult and ballista projectiles.
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."