Page 2 of 3

Posted: Thu Sep 20, 2007 8:57 am
by Jester of the FoS
Jakob wrote:
JinnTolser wrote:I proposed the idea of different statistics for different nationalities of humans once on the Kargatane board years ago, and it was almost universally rejected. I still think it's a good one, especially with demihumans playing such a small part in canon RL. I wouldn't go as far as to have different ability score adjustments, nor would I want humans' extra bonus feat to be automatic for a given nationality. But perhaps an additional benefit/drawback for each nationality would add some variety.
I really do not like the idea. Difference in nationality can be exploited trough skills, feats and good old roleplay, with no need to have "nationality modifiers".
Even in Greyhawk's Player's Guide the different stats for human "races" were absolutely optional.
Seconded. All it does it take away humanity's vaulted flexibility.
Jakob wrote:I do not agree. Gnomes are really different from dwarves. They have a natural spellcasting tradition, with even small children being taught to use cantrips (they CAN use them spontaneously, after all), and the 3.5 minor change (with bard as their favored class) make them repository of knowledge, after all... Quite different from dwarves. Theirs, for example, is not a culture obsessed with leaving traces of their passage on earth.
Well, look at the folklore of gnomes.
They're shot little people who live in caves, mine, turn to stone when exposed to sunlight and horde magnificent treasures. Books on gnomes could almost be written verbatim about dwarves.
The only differences seem to be the legends that gnomes are tricksters and more goblin-ish than dwarves and that gnomes are typically a foot tall.

Now look at D&D. In 2nd Edition gnomes were almost identical with most of the same racial abilities but a desire for gems and fondness for illusions.
Ravenloft tried to make them different by making dwarves more like Vikings and gnomes like Greeks.
Dragonlance made them tinkerers.
3E made them bards while taking bits and pieces from Dragonlance.

But, at their core, they're a short subterranean people that lives in caves and has a good constitution. Like dwarves. Only they're a magical people with natural arcane talents. Like elves.

Posted: Fri Sep 21, 2007 5:49 pm
by Adam
Yes, my thoughts on humans were not to add any kind of ability score modification, merely something like the WoT setting offered, namely regional bonus feats, class skills associated with each region, and bonus starting equipment that reflected the person's background in some way.

Posted: Sat Sep 22, 2007 4:27 am
by Jakob
Well, look at the folklore of gnomes.
They're shot little people who live in caves, mine, turn to stone when exposed to sunlight and horde magnificent treasures. Books on gnomes could almost be written verbatim about dwarves.
The only differences seem to be the legends that gnomes are tricksters and more goblin-ish than dwarves and that gnomes are typically a foot tall.

Now look at D&D. In 2nd Edition gnomes were almost identical with most of the same racial abilities but a desire for gems and fondness for illusions.
Ravenloft tried to make them different by making dwarves more like Vikings and gnomes like Greeks.
Dragonlance made them tinkerers.
3E made them bards while taking bits and pieces from Dragonlance.
Hm...
When I think about folkloric gnomes I think about The world of David Gnome and Huygens' paintings, so I'm not an expert. :D
But, at their core, they're a short subterranean people that lives in caves and has a good constitution. Like dwarves. Only they're a magical people with natural arcane talents. Like elves.
Well, you'll agree that "gnome" is much better than "elwaves" or "dwelves". :P

Anyway, there was a good article on gnomes in an old Dragon that set the "standard gnome culture" for 3.X...

Posted: Sat Sep 22, 2007 11:42 am
by Jester of the FoS
Don't get me wrong, I love gnomes. But their cantrip powers are fairly useless in-game, the ability to speak to burrowing mammals seldom comes up, and their remaining racial abilities are low strength and high con, which are hardly unique.
If they were the one Core race that had a boost to Cha or Int or even Wis it might make them more interesting but game-wise they're not that interesting.
All the other races are very, very different. Elves, dwarves, halflings and humans are night and day apart. Half-elves are close to both humans and elves, but that is their role as a half-breed so it's the one possible exception.
Gnomes are just dwarves with the strength of halflings and the magical aptitude of elves.

They also lack the clear role, folkloric archetype or famous character from fantasy books. There's no Gimli or Legolas as there are with dwarves and elves. No Flint or Laurana.

It's no real surprise that gnomes are not likely going to make it into the 4E PHB.

Posted: Sat Sep 22, 2007 7:12 pm
by cure
The whole problem with gnomes (well part of it at least) is that they do not have the Scent special quality. What is the point of having a big nose without that? Without dark vision, what is their edge underground? Why of course it should be their nose.

Posted: Sun Sep 23, 2007 5:00 am
by Isabella
cure wrote:The whole problem with gnomes (well part of it at least) is that they do not have the Scent special quality. What is the point of having a big nose without that? Without dark vision, what is their edge underground? Why of course it should be their nose.
I was certain I read somewhere the +2 bonus to alchemy gnomes got was because of their keen smell. I guess it's not keen enough to get them anything neat.

Their stat bonuses aren't much to look at either. If they had +2 int -2 wis it would match up better to how they are commonly portrayed. I can see why gnomes and kobolds have a rivalry; kobolds got more attention and popularity than gnomes ever did. Pretty good, considering kobolds were originally just... German gnomes.

I looked on Wikipedia for unique gnomish traits, but there's not much - just the garden gnomes craze and this:
"In Sydney, Australia, Gnomes are known not only for their garden based oppression, but for their cricketing prowess. A famous Sydney-based institution is The Gnomes Cricket Club. Operating within the North Shore Comp, this band of 'cricketers' have for years now closely followed many Gnomish traits - such as indulging in ale and card games, whilst simultaneously attempting to play the popular Australian game of cricket. These Gnomes are commonly known as Crisps."
That's pretty original.

I half think that gnomes would be better off if they were no longer a subterranean race. Everything that's unique about them involves either gardening or alchemy - maybe they should have been druids instead. Especially since they don't have darkvision.

Posted: Sun Sep 23, 2007 12:43 pm
by Jakob
The point of 3E base races was not having one with bonus to mental scores, in order to avoid the "XXX make the best wizard/cleric/sorcerer". ;)

Posted: Sun Sep 23, 2007 3:46 pm
by Isabella
Didn't do the gnomes much good, did it. =P

I'd also have suggested +2 dex -2 wis, except I know WotC would disapprove of that kind of stat arrangement. And it would also make gnomes better rogues than alchemists or wizards. And too much like halflings. Bah!

Posted: Mon Sep 24, 2007 3:03 am
by Jakob
...
I like gnomes. One of my favourite PCs was a gnome. And though they are not "combat friendly, their cantrips ARE useful. :(
I found them one of the less stereotypical race. And not having THE gnome (like we have THE dwarf or THE elf or THE halfling) in one of the annoyingly vast number of Dragonlance books... Well, it is a PLUS, for me. :?

Posted: Mon Sep 24, 2007 8:18 am
by Jester of the FoS
Jakob wrote:The point of 3E base races was not having one with bonus to mental scores, in order to avoid the "XXX make the best wizard/cleric/sorcerer". ;)
But there's still a "XXX make the best wizard/cleric/sorcerer" as dwarves/half-orcs make bad sorcerers, half-orcs make poor clerics, etc

Posted: Mon Sep 24, 2007 9:47 am
by WolfKook
Jakob wrote:...I found them one of the less stereotypical race. And not having THE gnome (like we have THE dwarf or THE elf or THE halfling) in one of the annoyingly vast number of Dragonlance books... Well, it is a PLUS, for me. :?
We don't have THE gnome??? WHAT ABOUT DAVID????? :lol:

Indeed, I agree with gnomes having to have a good wisdom score. I like the DL tinker gnomes (Which, IMO, are better implemented in WoW:tRPG), and I would go through that line to create a 4E version of the gnome. In Ravenloft, that would make them very interesting creatures, engineering the steampunk era which permeates some advanced domains...

Posted: Mon Sep 24, 2007 7:08 pm
by LouisVendredi
Interesting you should mention it. I'm about to introduce a new Gnome NPC who works as a Master Gunsmith in Lamordia. The party is going to see him. Unfortunately, he's gone a bit too far and has been making Mechanical Golems.

Posted: Mon Sep 24, 2007 10:55 pm
by Dion of the Fraternity
And this thread explains why I only have humans in my campaigns. :)

Posted: Wed Sep 26, 2007 12:52 am
by Isabella
Jester of the FoS wrote: Now look at D&D. In 2nd Edition gnomes were almost identical with most of the same racial abilities but a desire for gems and fondness for illusions.
Ravenloft tried to make them different by making dwarves more like Vikings and gnomes like Greeks.
Dragonlance made them tinkerers.
3E made them bards while taking bits and pieces from Dragonlance.

But, at their core, they're a short subterranean people that lives in caves and has a good constitution. Like dwarves. Only they're a magical people with natural arcane talents. Like elves.
If D&D alchemy actually did anything useful (without heavy GM fiat) then maybe the gnomes' penchant for alchemy could've given them a better niche. As it is, alchemist's fire quickly loses it's usefulness against foes, but still makes you a walking firebomb waiting to happen.

Well, Ravenloft happens to have some extended alchemy rules... do you think it would improve on the gnomes if their fervor for acid and fire was extended to homunculi and emotional purgatives?

Posted: Wed Sep 26, 2007 8:27 am
by Jester of the FoS
Complete Adventurer has some nice alchemical weapon options and tanglefoot bags from the PHB are the most awesome thing ever.