Your opinion on undying soul?
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
- The Giamarga
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2313
- Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
- Location: wandering
Btw in Tales of Ravenloft: Nocturne the (Pied) Piper of Hamelyn (Hamelin/Hameln) dies in Richemulot at Jacqueline Renier's hands, his magic pipe is lost/discarded...
Last edited by The Giamarga on Mon Nov 12, 2007 11:38 am, edited 1 time in total.
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
Harkon Lukas invented a new bardic song/spell as a cruel joke, which he teaches to passing human bards. It attracts dire wolves to the singer's location ... but it doesn't place the ravenous creatures under control in any way whatsoever.
For Lukas, this is just a handy way to draw in some muscle; for the bards he suckers, it's a way to unwittingly get themselves killed. But if just one of them survives the initial encounter with uncontrolled dire wolves, and goes on to teach the spell to others for the purpose of leading wolves into traps....
Again, shot himself in the paw.
For Lukas, this is just a handy way to draw in some muscle; for the bards he suckers, it's a way to unwittingly get themselves killed. But if just one of them survives the initial encounter with uncontrolled dire wolves, and goes on to teach the spell to others for the purpose of leading wolves into traps....
Again, shot himself in the paw.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
- The Giamarga
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2313
- Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
- Location: wandering
Thanks Roti, now I remember that one. I think a magical song is more appropriate than a flute.
Or if fate would have it that he casts the spell while in a position/company to defeat them.. ...the Ancestral Choir moves in mysterious ways.Rotipher of the FoS wrote: For the bards he suckers, it's a way to unwittingly get themselves killed. But if just one of them survives the initial encounter with uncontrolled dire wolves ...
- Nathan of the FoS
- Fiendish Enforcer

- Posts: 5247
- Joined: Fri Nov 28, 2003 3:39 pm
- Location: San Francisco CA
Domains of Dread has one, though (perhaps in response to the lack in IoT?); in Diamabel's case, he's not vulnerable to a "what", but to a "who"--the "black-eyed rascal" prophesied to destroy him. Which makes the whole thing a very different kettle of fish; now the PCs are dealing with "fulfilling a prophecy" and not "figuring out the puzzle" to undo his Undying Soul.Sylaire wrote:I don't really see the tension between "Undying Soul" and the rejuvenation power of a ghost (or similar creature), honestly. Ghosts, after all, are dead. And unlike corporeal undead such as zombies and vampires, which essentially have their "life force" tying body to soul replaced with necromantic magic, Negative Plane energy, or what have you, they don't have a physical tie to this reality. So it makes sense that just applying overwhelming physical force to them won't kill them permanently--the physical manifestation you're throwing the damage at isn't even real, but merely a projection of its magical power.
(Though if you want to talk about absurd "normal" monsters, I present to you the 2E odem, right out of the Black Box: a literally unkillable monster. Come to think of it, Diambel in "Islands of Terror" had the same issue--there was never any way, not even an absurd, next-to-impossible way, to actually kill him permanently.)
Whoa, now. Just because they're darklords? You mean, the most central and iconic characters? The ones who Ravenloft is built around, both in-game and metagame? Why would you not give a darklord a lot of extra firepower?What I don't like are the Draga Salt-Biters and Harkon Lukases of Ravenloft, which are purely corporeal creatures that the Dark Powers give a cheap out essentially just because they're darklords.
But Harkon Lukas et al. are Godefroy's peers as darklords--why give Godefroy the easy out but deny it to the "mortal" darklords? Keep in mind that before the VRGs, undead were just as "mortal" as any other foe--destroy them once and they stay gone. So why not give equal opportunities for undead and living darklords to return?Godefroy is a ghost, thus you'd expect to have to go to great lengths to lay him to rest.
Sure.I do agree with UC and DeepShadow in that a good Undying Soul effect should be domain-specific. A good Undying Soul is tied to the story of the domain and of the darklord...
(snip)
It seems to me that what this demands is a better tie between darklord and domain (take it away, DeepShadow!)What gets me is what DeepShadow said about US being a response to munchkin players. Ever notice how the US darklords that get on peoples' cases are the ones where the story and the domain don't make any sense together or are just generally lacking?
Some examples:
Saragoss: The worst of the offenders, IMHO. Saragoss is a classic example of a strong idea for a domain with a darklord tacked on as an afterthought. Adrift at sea, with the lack of resources and bitter harshness of nature against them at every turn, the folk of the Sargasso Sea are reduced to elemental savagery by their desperation to survive. Draga is a sideshow, a purely physical threat in a setting where the horror comes from the human psychological reactions to the various different threats. It's the Donner Party at sea, and getting eaten by a wereshark is nowhere near the top horror in the domain. Saragoss would work much better if it wasn't a domain, but a phantasmoragia like the House of Lament.
The Wildlands: The Wildlands is another example of a domain in which the concept (nonhuman, sentient-animal perspective, with animals expressing facets, as metaphor, of human personality traits--on one level, walking into the Wildlands is like walking into the inside of a human brain and finding out that the very worst aspects are in charge, as expressed by King Crocodile...) dominates the individual. But you can kill King Crocodile. Instead of him coming back, another crocodile king will eventually develop. Mechanically, it's the same as Draga or Lukas, but it works much better because the domain really is dominant--it's not the individual King Crocodile that's important, but the idea that there always will be a King Crocodile so long as the nature of the Wildlands remains intact.
Kartakass: Lukas is a strong character with a good backstory which is properly expressed in his domain. Here's an example of the worst kind of Undying Soul: it compensates not for the weakness of his story or the weakness of the character, but for the crappiness of base wolfwere statistics. To the average PC, Lukas is a simple enemy: once you've identified him as a target, you lug out the silver
A party that brings the silver to a fight with Harkon Lukas is in for a short and unpleasant experience.
I dunno. It's definitely true that Harkon Lukas has to have the Undying Soul to make him viable against PCs, or against his own lieutenants--Haldrake Moonbaum, as a greater wolfwere, could probably take Lukas apart--or his enemies--Mother Fury, a mountain loup-garou, could probably also beat him one-on-one.and render him down to dogmeat. He can't have a big enough support staff to keep the PCs out of his hair, because if he did he wouldn't be Harkon Lukas (his lack of an effective army/land to rule is part of his curse--in essence, he's the opposite of Vlad Drakov; Drakov has all the resources anyone could want and can't do anything with them, while Lukas is a genuine strategical/political genius and hasn't got any resources to apply that genius with--or anything significant to apply it to), so instead he gets a cheesy Undying Soul to bail him out if the PCs outthink him so they can get close enough with the Big Damage.
But Undying Soul levels the playing field and makes him viable against his existing threats.
IMC his Undying Soul is also an expression of his "original sin"--the thing that made him a darklord candidate to begin with. IMC wolfweres respect and protect wolves, but Harkon Lukas hates and despises them because they can never build him the empire he wants. His ability to displace and destroy a wolf's life, without its knowledge or consent, to further his own is the ultimate expression of his disdain and devaluing of the creatures to whom he should be most closely tied.
[b]FEAR JUSTICE.[/b] :elena:
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
I missed this the first time around. "Just because they are Darklords"? Did you really just say that?Sylaire wrote:What I don't like are the Draga Salt-Biters and Harkon Lukases of Ravenloft, which are purely corporeal creatures that the Dark Powers give a cheap out essentially just because they're darklords.
If think you are getting too hung up in the metaphysics of fantasy. Metaphysics moves at the speed of plot, which is to say, if it's good for the story, the metaphysics can make it work. If the DP's can really bring out a land that reflects a person's innermost self, why cannot that land regenerate the person tied to it? If Strahd is in every rock and tree of Barovia, I see no reason why those rocks and trees cannot bring him back.
That's one way to handle it. The other, as Nathan said, is to tie the DL to the domain better. I think I did all right, if I say so myself.Saragoss: The worst of the offenders, IMHO. Saragoss is a classic example of a strong idea for a domain with a darklord tacked on as an afterthought. Adrift at sea, with the lack of resources and bitter harshness of nature against them at every turn, the folk of the Sargasso Sea are reduced to elemental savagery by their desperation to survive. Draga is a sideshow, a purely physical threat in a setting where the horror comes from the human psychological reactions to the various different threats. It's the Donner Party at sea, and getting eaten by a wereshark is nowhere near the top horror in the domain. Saragoss would work much better if it wasn't a domain, but a phantasmoragia like the House of Lament.
I strongly disagree. If they beefed up so many other DL's beyond the original creature, they could have beefed up Harkon. He's supposed to be a quick kill that keeps coming back. Everything points to it: his berserking sword, his undying soul and his wolfsong all work off this theme. With his berserking sword, every fight is to the death, so if he didn't have undying soul, his lifespan could be clocked with an egg timer. If the undying soul was to compensate for crappy stats, why give him that sword?Kartakass: Lukas is a strong character with a good backstory which is properly expressed in his domain. Here's an example of the worst kind of Undying Soul: it compensates not for the weakness of his story or the weakness of the character, but for the crappiness of base wolfwere statistics.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
Nathan of the FoS wrote:Whoa, now. Just because they're darklords? You mean, the most central and iconic characters? The ones who Ravenloft is built around, both in-game and metagame? Why would you not give a darklord a lot of extra firepower?Sylaire wrote:What I don't like are the Draga Salt-Biters and Harkon Lukases of Ravenloft, which are purely corporeal creatures that the Dark Powers give a cheap out essentially just because they're darklords.
Yep. I really did just say that.DeepShadow wrote:I missed this the first time around. "Just because they are Darklords"? Did you really just say that?
Here's what I mean, and Nathan pretty much explained what my point is without noticing it: the darklords are whom Ravenloft is built around. They're the "dark souls" who reflect the very essence of horror and give us a chance to game it out--and the geography, the culture, and so on of the demiplane each are a reflection of their dark lord. In a way, the dark domains are human sins made into terrain, a way to plunge the players into an exploration of the darkness within us.
The darklords are the ne plus ultra of Ravenloft, the baddest of the bad, not just in terms of game statistics or sheer body count, but because they resonate with the players on an emotional level, whether because of the nature of their own actions/story or because that story itself resonates with past literary experiences.
Draga Salt-Biter (as written in IoT) couldn't resonate with me with a frequency scanner and a drum set.
Darklordship is something you earn. I'm not sure if other people see it this way, but what it seems to me is that with the darklords whose Undying Soul or other attributes annoy me is that the power feels "tacked on," a munchkin-gaming solution by the designers to counter munchkin-gaming by potential darklord-killing PCs. Tie the non-standard power to the darklord's story and it does two things at once: it makes the power palatable and it simultaneously fleshes out the story (Nathan, for example, just cited a perfect example--the Domains of Dread Diambel fixes his problem by making his Undying Soul into part of a prophecy, and hence part of Diambel's story--which then itself can be fleshed out).
A similar example is the consistent problem of when the domain is a good idea but the darklord is just somebody tossed in because the Ravenloft setting rules require that there be a darklord. To wit...hell, there's Draga again! Bluetspur is similar (as written, not with the BoS fix to the God-Brain), since Lovecraftian Unknowable Cosmic Horror by its very nature doesn't feature the same kind of single-individual, dark-side-of-humanity evil that Gothic horror does. Similarly, 2E Arak--the idea of a drow kingdom simply doesn't resonate with the idea of a particular Gothic horror darklord because what's scary about drow is the Evil Nonhuman Culture (in a weird kind of way, dark elves are to generic D&D what the Yellow Peril was to early 20th century pulp fiction, which is also, I suspect, why latter-day drow have started to become more of a fully-fleshed civilization, with the Liriel Baenres and their ilk, becuase of the realization of how shallow the previous portrayal of drow was in light of their intelligence and inherent "humanity"), not a particular individual's perversions (It's kind of like why I don't find 2E Hazlik particularly...relevant. He's a Red Wizard of Thay; evil wizards are a dime a dozen in his homeland and he's not even particularly special as an evil wizard; Azalin and Meredoth both do his "evil wizard" schtick better than he did). The Black Box's Jack Karn read like "Hey, here's another classic D&D monster that doesn't have a darklord yet, so here we go!"
(You can see some of the same kind of thinking in the post-Grand Conjunction realignment: Gundarak went away because there was nothing about Duke Gundar and Gundarak that Strahd and Barovia didn't do better. Likewise, Ladislav Mircea and Sanguinea were removed, but were then brought back but with original aspects to his character that helped to define him.)
Sheesh, this is getting long enough that I almost need to go back and outline and edit it as an essay on the Nature of Darklordship.
So let me conclude: when I say, "just because he's a darklord," I don't mean that darklords aren't somehow key and special, I mean that the particular character has nothing special about him/her except that he's been given the label "darklord"--as if, I don't know...like "darklord" was a prestige class that he/she bought his way into with enough experience points, rather than being a feature of the character's background of compelling drama, tragedy, and evil. When a character's powers as a darklord feel like a function of game mechanics instead of character background, I believe that they fail.
(And if you can rewrite Draga so that he becomes a compelling, interesting character, that he becomes the dominant element within Saragoss and yet the nature and character of the domain remain intact, then you've earned my intense and sincere admiration, and I do mean that without any trace of sarcasm.)
Wow. Excellent idea. (And I was never impressed by Draga either.)Sylaire wrote: Saragoss would work much better if it wasn't a domain, but a phantasmoragia like the House of Lament.
ETA: To expand on Sylaire's essay-like post above (my comment was simply in reply to the later one), I wonder if the concepts of phantasmagorias and mist oubliettes were an attempt to work around the standard domain definition? Some Bad Places don't need a lord embodying them, and some Bad People don't need a land to rule-- just their personal hell/holding pen.
- NeoTiamat
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 4119
- Joined: Tue Sep 12, 2006 5:00 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Boston, Massachusetts, USA
As a side note, I withdraw all objections to Harkon Lukas on the basis of his Undying Soul. Now to figure out where I can get a bard in Tarlyn's game.....
We now return to your regularly scheduled thread.
We now return to your regularly scheduled thread.
Ravenloft GM: Eye of Anubis, Shattered City, and Prof. Lupescu's Traveling Ghost Show
Lead Writer & Editor: VRS Files: Doppelgangers; Contributor: QtR #20, #21, #22, #23, #24
Freelance Writer for Paizo Publishing
Lead Writer & Editor: VRS Files: Doppelgangers; Contributor: QtR #20, #21, #22, #23, #24
Freelance Writer for Paizo Publishing
- Scarycount
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 244
- Joined: Sat Aug 26, 2006 2:13 am
- Location: Castle Ravenloft
The Giamarga wrote:I have no problem with Undying soul or unkillable darklords. It is Ravenloft after all. A land cerated from Mists to eternally torment the darklords. If you can stomach a whole country with populations being made on the spot by the DPs, why not rebuilding a destroyed darklord? The whole every NPC ought to be killable by PCs notion is very foreign to me. By that logic the DPs should be killable too.
If darklords shouldn't be killable, why have them in the game. I don't mean to say a darklord ought to be nothing more than someone for the PC's to fight, but the darklord becomes useless to the game unless there's some way for the PC's to interact with them. Sure fighting a darklord isn't the only way to interact with them, but in other campaign settings you don't take the hint that you should interact in a different way when you kill them and they come back to life somehow. Also, the players will not get that the land exists to torment the darklords, or at least their characters won't (excepting knowladge Ravenloft of course). To them, it will look like the DM is arbitrarily deciding that the villian is not dead. Finally, if undying soul is a manifestation of the fact that RL exists to torment darklords, why doesn't every darklord have undying soul?
Hail Strahd!
- The Giamarga
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2313
- Joined: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:11 pm
- Location: wandering
I'm counting on Deepshadow doing just that in the Sea of Sorrows Gazetteer.Sylaire wrote:(And if you can rewrite Draga so that he becomes a compelling, interesting character, that he becomes the dominant element within Saragoss and yet the nature and character of the domain remain intact, then you've earned my intense and sincere admiration, and I do mean that without any trace of sarcasm.)
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
The Giamarga wrote:I'm counting on Deepshadow doing just that in the Sea of Sorrows Gazetteer.Sylaire wrote:(And if you can rewrite Draga so that he becomes a compelling, interesting character, that he becomes the dominant element within Saragoss and yet the nature and character of the domain remain intact, then you've earned my intense and sincere admiration, and I do mean that without any trace of sarcasm.)
Thank you, Giamarga, but wouldn't that be the Verdurous Lands Gazetteer?
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7108
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
Sometimes, the point of the game is to defeat darklords, since eliminating them completely is out of the question.
Joël
Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
- JinnTolser
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 523
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 10:43 am
- Location: Franklin Park, IL
I have no objection to Undying Soul itself, provided that it ties into the darklord's story somehow, and actually makes sense, rather than just seeming "tacked on" as Sylvaire said. If there's a clear reason why they shouldn't die, above and beyond simple darklordship, then it's fine.
Adam and Mordenheim are the perfect example. I'm on the fence about Harkon Lukas, and I don't know enough about Draga Salt-Biter to render judgment there either, but from what's being said here he sounds like he's in bad need of some fleshing out.
As was also said before, darklords are what the setting is about. But, that alone does not seem to me a good enough reason to be unkillable, else why aren't they all that way?
I think Undying Soul should be reserved for two or three special cases at max. I'm not sure how many darklord possess the quality now, but I think it's too many.
Adam and Mordenheim are the perfect example. I'm on the fence about Harkon Lukas, and I don't know enough about Draga Salt-Biter to render judgment there either, but from what's being said here he sounds like he's in bad need of some fleshing out.
As was also said before, darklords are what the setting is about. But, that alone does not seem to me a good enough reason to be unkillable, else why aren't they all that way?
I think Undying Soul should be reserved for two or three special cases at max. I'm not sure how many darklord possess the quality now, but I think it's too many.
- Rotipher of the FoS
- Thieving Crow

- Posts: 4683
- Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm
The way I interpret Undying Soul is that it's not an "ability" per se: rather, it's the Dark Powers' way of saying "Hang on, we're not done with you just yet..." to a slain darklord whom they still find useful, for their own mysterious reasons. Rather than intervene to save such darklords, which would be even more of a blatant deus ex machina, they see that a slain villain they want to keep is restored to his or her domain, preferably in a way that villain will find chastizing.
This means that darklords can't always count on Undying Soul to bring them back from death, as it's the whim of the Land that imprisons them which is responsible for such revivifications, not anything inherent in themselves. If a darklord loses the DPs' interest and support, or some more intriguing villain kills an incumbant darklord, they might very well hang the old one out to dry, withdrawing the effects of Undying Soul and letting the previous lord get killed out of the setting.
Bhakholis might very well have had Undying Soul at one time; indeed, the manner of his death (letting Gabby walk right up and stab him) implies he was grossly overconfident. Perhaps the Dark Powers had gotten tired of him, as they grew tired of Lord Soth, and withheld the ability to return from death -- which he'd doubtless learned about the hard way -- right when he needed it the most.
This means that darklords can't always count on Undying Soul to bring them back from death, as it's the whim of the Land that imprisons them which is responsible for such revivifications, not anything inherent in themselves. If a darklord loses the DPs' interest and support, or some more intriguing villain kills an incumbant darklord, they might very well hang the old one out to dry, withdrawing the effects of Undying Soul and letting the previous lord get killed out of the setting.
Bhakholis might very well have had Undying Soul at one time; indeed, the manner of his death (letting Gabby walk right up and stab him) implies he was grossly overconfident. Perhaps the Dark Powers had gotten tired of him, as they grew tired of Lord Soth, and withheld the ability to return from death -- which he'd doubtless learned about the hard way -- right when he needed it the most.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
