Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2007 11:20 am
Yep. And that song/spell of Lukas's dates back to some of the earliest Ravenloft products too, so the TSR designers most likely planned it that way. 
Welcome, friends, to our establishment.
https://fraternityofshadows.com/forum/
Or if fate would have it that he casts the spell while in a position/company to defeat them.. ...the Ancestral Choir moves in mysterious ways.Rotipher of the FoS wrote: For the bards he suckers, it's a way to unwittingly get themselves killed. But if just one of them survives the initial encounter with uncontrolled dire wolves ...
Domains of Dread has one, though (perhaps in response to the lack in IoT?); in Diamabel's case, he's not vulnerable to a "what", but to a "who"--the "black-eyed rascal" prophesied to destroy him. Which makes the whole thing a very different kettle of fish; now the PCs are dealing with "fulfilling a prophecy" and not "figuring out the puzzle" to undo his Undying Soul.Sylaire wrote:I don't really see the tension between "Undying Soul" and the rejuvenation power of a ghost (or similar creature), honestly. Ghosts, after all, are dead. And unlike corporeal undead such as zombies and vampires, which essentially have their "life force" tying body to soul replaced with necromantic magic, Negative Plane energy, or what have you, they don't have a physical tie to this reality. So it makes sense that just applying overwhelming physical force to them won't kill them permanently--the physical manifestation you're throwing the damage at isn't even real, but merely a projection of its magical power.
(Though if you want to talk about absurd "normal" monsters, I present to you the 2E odem, right out of the Black Box: a literally unkillable monster. Come to think of it, Diambel in "Islands of Terror" had the same issue--there was never any way, not even an absurd, next-to-impossible way, to actually kill him permanently.)
Whoa, now. Just because they're darklords? You mean, the most central and iconic characters? The ones who Ravenloft is built around, both in-game and metagame? Why would you not give a darklord a lot of extra firepower?What I don't like are the Draga Salt-Biters and Harkon Lukases of Ravenloft, which are purely corporeal creatures that the Dark Powers give a cheap out essentially just because they're darklords.
But Harkon Lukas et al. are Godefroy's peers as darklords--why give Godefroy the easy out but deny it to the "mortal" darklords? Keep in mind that before the VRGs, undead were just as "mortal" as any other foe--destroy them once and they stay gone. So why not give equal opportunities for undead and living darklords to return?Godefroy is a ghost, thus you'd expect to have to go to great lengths to lay him to rest.
Sure.I do agree with UC and DeepShadow in that a good Undying Soul effect should be domain-specific. A good Undying Soul is tied to the story of the domain and of the darklord...
(snip)
It seems to me that what this demands is a better tie between darklord and domain (take it away, DeepShadow!)What gets me is what DeepShadow said about US being a response to munchkin players. Ever notice how the US darklords that get on peoples' cases are the ones where the story and the domain don't make any sense together or are just generally lacking?
Some examples:
Saragoss: The worst of the offenders, IMHO. Saragoss is a classic example of a strong idea for a domain with a darklord tacked on as an afterthought. Adrift at sea, with the lack of resources and bitter harshness of nature against them at every turn, the folk of the Sargasso Sea are reduced to elemental savagery by their desperation to survive. Draga is a sideshow, a purely physical threat in a setting where the horror comes from the human psychological reactions to the various different threats. It's the Donner Party at sea, and getting eaten by a wereshark is nowhere near the top horror in the domain. Saragoss would work much better if it wasn't a domain, but a phantasmoragia like the House of Lament.
The Wildlands: The Wildlands is another example of a domain in which the concept (nonhuman, sentient-animal perspective, with animals expressing facets, as metaphor, of human personality traits--on one level, walking into the Wildlands is like walking into the inside of a human brain and finding out that the very worst aspects are in charge, as expressed by King Crocodile...) dominates the individual. But you can kill King Crocodile. Instead of him coming back, another crocodile king will eventually develop. Mechanically, it's the same as Draga or Lukas, but it works much better because the domain really is dominant--it's not the individual King Crocodile that's important, but the idea that there always will be a King Crocodile so long as the nature of the Wildlands remains intact.
Kartakass: Lukas is a strong character with a good backstory which is properly expressed in his domain. Here's an example of the worst kind of Undying Soul: it compensates not for the weakness of his story or the weakness of the character, but for the crappiness of base wolfwere statistics. To the average PC, Lukas is a simple enemy: once you've identified him as a target, you lug out the silver
I dunno. It's definitely true that Harkon Lukas has to have the Undying Soul to make him viable against PCs, or against his own lieutenants--Haldrake Moonbaum, as a greater wolfwere, could probably take Lukas apart--or his enemies--Mother Fury, a mountain loup-garou, could probably also beat him one-on-one.and render him down to dogmeat. He can't have a big enough support staff to keep the PCs out of his hair, because if he did he wouldn't be Harkon Lukas (his lack of an effective army/land to rule is part of his curse--in essence, he's the opposite of Vlad Drakov; Drakov has all the resources anyone could want and can't do anything with them, while Lukas is a genuine strategical/political genius and hasn't got any resources to apply that genius with--or anything significant to apply it to), so instead he gets a cheesy Undying Soul to bail him out if the PCs outthink him so they can get close enough with the Big Damage.
I missed this the first time around. "Just because they are Darklords"? Did you really just say that?Sylaire wrote:What I don't like are the Draga Salt-Biters and Harkon Lukases of Ravenloft, which are purely corporeal creatures that the Dark Powers give a cheap out essentially just because they're darklords.
That's one way to handle it. The other, as Nathan said, is to tie the DL to the domain better. I think I did all right, if I say so myself.Saragoss: The worst of the offenders, IMHO. Saragoss is a classic example of a strong idea for a domain with a darklord tacked on as an afterthought. Adrift at sea, with the lack of resources and bitter harshness of nature against them at every turn, the folk of the Sargasso Sea are reduced to elemental savagery by their desperation to survive. Draga is a sideshow, a purely physical threat in a setting where the horror comes from the human psychological reactions to the various different threats. It's the Donner Party at sea, and getting eaten by a wereshark is nowhere near the top horror in the domain. Saragoss would work much better if it wasn't a domain, but a phantasmoragia like the House of Lament.
I strongly disagree. If they beefed up so many other DL's beyond the original creature, they could have beefed up Harkon. He's supposed to be a quick kill that keeps coming back. Everything points to it: his berserking sword, his undying soul and his wolfsong all work off this theme. With his berserking sword, every fight is to the death, so if he didn't have undying soul, his lifespan could be clocked with an egg timer. If the undying soul was to compensate for crappy stats, why give him that sword?Kartakass: Lukas is a strong character with a good backstory which is properly expressed in his domain. Here's an example of the worst kind of Undying Soul: it compensates not for the weakness of his story or the weakness of the character, but for the crappiness of base wolfwere statistics.
Nathan of the FoS wrote:Whoa, now. Just because they're darklords? You mean, the most central and iconic characters? The ones who Ravenloft is built around, both in-game and metagame? Why would you not give a darklord a lot of extra firepower?Sylaire wrote:What I don't like are the Draga Salt-Biters and Harkon Lukases of Ravenloft, which are purely corporeal creatures that the Dark Powers give a cheap out essentially just because they're darklords.
Yep. I really did just say that.DeepShadow wrote:I missed this the first time around. "Just because they are Darklords"? Did you really just say that?
Wow. Excellent idea. (And I was never impressed by Draga either.)Sylaire wrote: Saragoss would work much better if it wasn't a domain, but a phantasmoragia like the House of Lament.
The Giamarga wrote:I have no problem with Undying soul or unkillable darklords. It is Ravenloft after all. A land cerated from Mists to eternally torment the darklords. If you can stomach a whole country with populations being made on the spot by the DPs, why not rebuilding a destroyed darklord? The whole every NPC ought to be killable by PCs notion is very foreign to me. By that logic the DPs should be killable too.
I'm counting on Deepshadow doing just that in the Sea of Sorrows Gazetteer.Sylaire wrote:(And if you can rewrite Draga so that he becomes a compelling, interesting character, that he becomes the dominant element within Saragoss and yet the nature and character of the domain remain intact, then you've earned my intense and sincere admiration, and I do mean that without any trace of sarcasm.)
The Giamarga wrote:I'm counting on Deepshadow doing just that in the Sea of Sorrows Gazetteer.Sylaire wrote:(And if you can rewrite Draga so that he becomes a compelling, interesting character, that he becomes the dominant element within Saragoss and yet the nature and character of the domain remain intact, then you've earned my intense and sincere admiration, and I do mean that without any trace of sarcasm.)