4th Edition Review

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Rotipher of the FoS
Thieving Crow
Thieving Crow
Posts: 4683
Joined: Sat Dec 06, 2003 4:18 pm

Post by Rotipher of the FoS »

Re: Loss of variability within classes

What seems to be happening, here, is that the pendulum of character customization is swinging back again. In both OD&D and 1E, there was really very little mechanical difference between characters of a given class; your ability scores and hit points differed, and wizards' spell choice, but that was all. 2E put a few more choices into players' hands, at first with specialty priests and rogues' assignment of % points to their thieving skills, and later with character kits. Nevertheless, even with kits, virtually everything that made a PC unique came from how they were role-played, not from what was written on their character sheet.

Late in 2E's era, the Player's Option books tested the waters of customization, and the resulting fine control over PC abilities proved highly popular among players. It also, unfortunately, stirred up a lot of issues of game balance, which kits had already brought to light; an awful lot of Option-built PCs were unstoppable in that narrow strategic niche for which they were designed, yet crippled in any other context. Therefore, when 3E -- the most customization-friendly incarnation of the game, by far -- a big selling-point for its system was that it was so hard to "break the game" if you min/maxed characters ... or at least, it was pretty hard to do, before splatbook-proliferation set in.

Now, with 4E, it appears that WotC has drawn much sharper boundaries on what is or isn't reasonable for particular levels of characters to do. The use of the three tiers, and the way both magic items and monsters are scalable in synch with PC levels, suggest that controling character advancement and keeping everything in step with it had been given a very high priority, as they re-engineered the system. Unfortunately, something had to give way, in tradeoff for that greater control, and that something was customization: leveling the playing field for all characters of a given level meant that, while each class has its perks, they all have to meet a narrow set of standards as to what is level-appropriate. Extreme class-benefits had to be axed, nerfed, and/or postponed to higher levels at the expense of those higher levels' abilities.

So now, gamers accustomed to maximum variability are seeing a level of customization that's less than they're used to, and are upset by that loss of variety. The irony is that, compared to early editions, 4E will still be vastly more customization-friendly than anything gamers had seen, prior to the Player's Option series: up until then, "using the exact same ability over and over" is how every non-spellcaster in the game fought! It's only in contrast to 3E/3.5 that it seems restrictive.
"Who [u]cares[/u] what the Dark Powers are? They're [i]bastards![/i] That's all I need to know of them." -- Crow
User avatar
Lord Soth
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 264
Joined: Fri Apr 09, 2004 11:59 pm
Location: Nedragaard Keep, Sithicus

Post by Lord Soth »

Yeah, but is there ever a time you wouldn't want to do this?


When fighting Brutes, which're apparently low AC but high hit points. Against them, the to hit bonus won't really matter and you'll want the higher damage.
But most of the time, especially against solo monsters, you find your best chance of hitting and spam, spam, spam.


In other words, it plays just like 3E? Well, at least things aren't worse. ;) Still, there's more to the game then just Solo monsters. There're Brutes, Soldiers, Lurkers, etc. Some of them are easier to hit, some harder, etc. And if people spam the same attack? Well, isn't it better to spam a different attack in different combats then to spam the same attack in every single combat?
"using the exact same ability over and over" is how every non-spellcaster in the game fought! It's only in contrast to 3E/3.5 that it seems restrictive.


That was true in 3E, too. Whenever I played a Fighter or a Paladin, I tended to just make a basic attack and that was it. I got a Cleave off every once in a while, Smite Evil on occasion, and maybe used Power Attack. But beyond that? Not a whole lot. Hell, sometimes I'd do crazy stuff just to mix things up every once in a while, like doing a Bulls Rush even when the situation didn't call for it, that sort of thing.

I demoed the Cleric a while back and I used all three of his At-Will Powers throughout the course of the game. It was great. And of course, I had my Encounter Power. Not to mention my Daily. And as you level you gain more Encounter Powers, more Daily Powers, and Utility Powers. I'm looking forward to it.
Man lives in the sunlit world
Of what he believes to be reality.
But, there is, unseen by most, an underworld,
A place that is just as real,
But not as brightly lit.....
A DARKSIDE.
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Rotipher of the FoS wrote:The irony is that, compared to early editions, 4E will still be vastly more customization-friendly than anything gamers had seen, prior to the Player's Option series: up until then, "using the exact same ability over and over" is how every non-spellcaster in the game fought! It's only in contrast to 3E/3.5 that it seems restrictive.
Part of my problem is that a design goal for 4e was to give classes a choice in each round of combat, an option of something interesting to do.
"Should I use eyebite or drop and action point and use it twice?" is not enough...

And weapons and in-character design also quickly restrict your abilities. Want to play a bow-ranger or dagger-rogue, well your possible abilities have just been halved. Want to play a warlord that directs the battle from the edge and uses a bow, or a fighter who is a master archer? Get ready for disappointment because both are melee-only.

I'm also irritated by the dev team's ignorance. They have the wizard acting as a "controller" with that role, apparently, being damaging lots of enemies. That's not a controller, that's a blaster/nuker. Crowd control involves terrain manipulation and keeping the enemies where you want them to be.
Despite claims that 4e is nothing but a MMORPG the authors haven't played many.
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Oh right, alignment. Because people will want to know.
It's already been leaked so it wasn't new to me, but I don't think that discussion made its way here.

Down to five: good, lawful good, evil, chaotic evil, unaligned.
Or as I call them: Batman, Superman, Luthor, Joker, and bystander.

Good seems to be a combination of chaotic good and neutral good while evil is lawful evil, which seems odd as a generic evil alignment would be more NE. Honorable evil is unussual so having it be the default doesn't fit for me.
User avatar
Sorti
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 255
Joined: Sat Nov 26, 2005 9:56 am
Location: Ethereal Border

Post by Sorti »

Goooood, Jester, gooood... Join us in the Dark Side... :twisted:

BTW, I _tried_ to read 4e manuals, but I had to close them, disgusted. Most of them are _worse_ than I had imagined, and I wasn't exactly a 4e fan.

And yeah, the "if we gave you rules to make your own X you wouldn't buy the Complete X book" is so blatant I'm gonna puke (with due respect).
Coltiviamo per tutti un rancore
che ha l'odore del sangue rappreso
ciò che allora chiamammo dolore
è soltanto un discorso sospeso
User avatar
A G Thing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1216
Joined: Tue Mar 25, 2008 5:41 pm
Gender: Female
Location: Currently the Frozen Wastes of Mount Pleasant Michigan

Post by A G Thing »

Since my group is going to try it I will experience the first adventure but this just makes me feel better that I have not wasted my time revamping 3.5 with varient rules.

I don't like all of what I am hearing and the way things seem to be going I may be awhile in being able to afford this edition even if I do find I want to invest in it...

I am going to have to wait and reserve judgement after I have played and examined the books (With a fine tooth comb!) though and I will most definitely respond then, one way or the other on how I view this so called 4th edition.
"There is only one true answer to any and every question. The rest are just vagaries and obfuscations."
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Something else came to me recently. No NPC stats/classes. Any NPCs would be monsters. So if you're aided by some NPC they're going to have PC classes or be a soldier or lurker or such.
Makes it hard to play an evil party and attack commoners. I suppose they'd just be minions...
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

Lord Soth: A 1st level fighter had to pick 2 feats from a laaaarge list of feats. Now a fighter has to pick 50% or even 75% of the available choices.
If only four at will powers are presented and you pick two or three, there's no room for customization. As Roti said, that keeps the powergamers in check, but really sucks.

Also from what I have seen most powers are:

Charisma/strength/intelligence/... vs Will/AC/reflex/...
Hit: Deals X fire/thunder/slashing/... damage

OK, they may be area attacks or single attacks but more or less they seem ... hollow.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Lord Soth
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 264
Joined: Fri Apr 09, 2004 11:59 pm
Location: Nedragaard Keep, Sithicus

Post by Lord Soth »

alhoon wrote:Lord Soth: A 1st level fighter had to pick 2 feats from a laaaarge list of feats. Now a fighter has to pick 50% or even 75% of the available choices. If only four at will powers are presented and you pick two or three, there's no room for customization. As Roti said, that keeps the powergamers in check, but really sucks.


That's in addition to the Feat selection, though. Not to mention that At-Wills are the be-all and end-all of available options. The Fighter has 77 available powers. He can get 17, which is a little over 20%. That's a far cry from 50% or 75% of the available choices. Is there a real lack of choices when you can have three Fighters in the same party and have each and every one of them have wholly different abilities, save for approximately 3-4 duplicated abilities?
Charisma/strength/intelligence/... vs Will/AC/reflex/...
Hit: Deals X fire/thunder/slashing/... damage

OK, they may be area attacks or single attacks but more or less they seem ... hollow.


To each their own. Personally, I was reading through several of them, and they seemed damn fun. Like the one where the Rogue uses some poor schlub as a human shield with a blade to his throat. Or when the Fighter makes the equivalent of a Whirlwind Attack which also knocks back all his opponents. Or the Wizard casts Elemental Maw which pulls everyone around into it.

Incidentally, I was reading over the Warlock, again, and you can actually mix and match the Encounter, Daily, and Utility Powers. So a Feypact Warlock can take Infernal Pacts powers, Star Pact power, and so on. There're bonuses sometimes when sticking to powers from your own pact, though.
Man lives in the sunlit world
Of what he believes to be reality.
But, there is, unseen by most, an underworld,
A place that is just as real,
But not as brightly lit.....
A DARKSIDE.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

Lord Soth wrote: The Fighter has 77 available powers. He can get 17, which is a little over 20%.
Compared to the 3rd edition fighter and rogue they are enough. After all, the guy playing the fighter was doing less in 3rd edition. (But look bellow)

Now, 100-150 powers for clerics that had 300 spells to pick from is few. Do you know what we said about the cleric and the druid when we played the 3rd edition for sometime? "Gee... they need more options. 300 spells to pick from are few"

However: I have spell compedium, the book of eldrich might and a eldrich sorcery. I have and use the Book of nine swords.
So, my players and my characters have to pick from about 3000 spells and the warriors from about 100-200 powers + feats.
I demand that player wanting to play fighters take at least some levels as warblades because I find fighters as they are bland.

I didn't expect a starting book to contain as many options as I have build up in the years that I played 3rd. But to contain less options than the PHB?! :evil: :x

I respectfully disagree with you Lord Soth. They have improved the nonspellcasters by giving them more options than Powerattack/Disarm/trip/combat expertise/spring attack.
However, after playing a fighter/rogue for 2 or 3 times and watching 2-3 other players playing fighters you have explored the class completely.
Now on the spellcasters: The 150 choices Jester mentions are far, far less than I was used to. You said it was bad for spellcasting classes to have all the choices. They could give the fighters the choices they did without cutting down the spellcaster choices. Also in 3rd edition high level spellcasters could do a lot more than 17 different things.

ON THE OTHER HAND: I like the new combat/ritual magic system. While the warrior classes could have more powers it is a good step forward to make them interesting.
I Still have the book of nine swords to steal powers from. I Still have the spell compedium to copy spells from. I Still have a productive mind so I can create spells and powers of my own. I still have a disdain for balance so I can experiment with my creations without too much fear of the consequences.

WotC gave us the following rule: A monster should go down with 4-6 attacks of characters of it's level.

Jester: Do you want an archer fighter?
I'll make an per encounter power for 3rd level.

Level 3 monster usually has 32+ con= 47 hp. So our power should do about 47/5= 9.5 hp. Since it's per encounter it should do something more than that. Let's assume that the bow deals 1d8 damage (Average 4.5) and that the archer has dex about 16-17.

All the following are per encounter
Power 1: Leg hit (standard, ranged weapon, reliable): dex vs AC.
Hit: Deals 2xW+dex mod damage (12 average damage) and the target has -2 speed until he/she/it takes a move action to remove the arrow. Creatures immune to pain (like undead) are immune to this effect.
Miss: No effect looser! (but you keep the power. Try again)

Power 2: Precision blow (standard, ranged weapon): Dex vs AC
Hit: deals 2xW+dex mod damage and the target if marked is pushed 1 square backwards.
Miss: W+dex mod damage.

Power 3: vicious arrow (standard, ranged weapon): Dex vs AC
Hit: Deals W+dex mod damage. If the target is living, bleeds for your dex modifier each turn (save ends). (Average damage of this power is 12.75 damage)
Miss: No effect again, and this time you don't try again.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Lord Soth wrote:
alhoon wrote:Lord Soth: A 1st level fighter had to pick 2 feats from a laaaarge list of feats. Now a fighter has to pick 50% or even 75% of the available choices. If only four at will powers are presented and you pick two or three, there's no room for customization. As Roti said, that keeps the powergamers in check, but really sucks.


That's in addition to the Feat selection, though. Not to mention that At-Wills are the be-all and end-all of available options. The Fighter has 77 available powers. He can get 17, which is a little over 20%. That's a far cry from 50% or 75% of the available choices. Is there a real lack of choices when you can have three Fighters in the same party and have each and every one of them have wholly different abilities, save for approximately 3-4 duplicated abilities?
Keep in mind many of the later ones are apparently restricted by weapon. So if you're a long-sword fighter each level you may get a choice from three or two or only one power.
This would also be limited by the weapons in the PHB as there's only so many flails and hammers and spears.

This kind of limitation affects most of the powers. Bow-only ranger? Your powers are halved (and Lord help you if you want to do something with a ranger other than bow or two-weapons). Dagger-only rogue, that also cuts down your choices.
Then you get your choice of the four mandatory paragon paths (unless you're a multi-classer or something) so one better fit your ideal of your character.
Then there are the four epic destinies. Again mandatory unless you don't want extra powers.
A choice of four options seems to run throughout the book. There's probably an average of 4 feats per race as well.

This is just the impression I get.
The books felt complete and yet as bare-bones as possible. They put enough so you have close to a choice but not enough so that you don't eventually run out of options.
Two human fighters with the same weapon will likely have 2/3rds of the same powers (or more) and probably a very similar choice of feats. This does make race stand out though, as a dwarf fighter will be different from a human fighter as they'll take different racial feats just to have a choice...

To be fair though, the PHB did have a very, very limited number of feats, especially for fighter. But the number of possible characters was opened-up by multi-classing which isn't as much of an option here.
And while the PHB was limited in feats, everything else seemed more complete. But in 4e there seems to be a limit to everything. Limited number of powers, paths, destinies, feats, weapons, magic items, equipment, rituals, monsters, traps, poisons, diseases, etc.
In fact, there's very little I would say that feels complete or comprehensive. Maybe races, as there's a good 12+ in the MM so you have a good 20+ choices for race including Ebberon-specifics like doppelgangers (replacing changelings), a couple shifters and warforged. And gnomes, orcs, drow, minotaurs (yay), kobolds, etc.

I've seen this in other RPGs, where something is almost complete but they're missing some rule or element or choices and few and far between. But that always felt related to space restrictions. 3e was one of the few games where something wasn't missing. But 4e has three hardcover books and one one is a decent size. Given the almost 100 page difference between the PHB and the DMG there is NO reason why anything should feel limited. And unlike other RPGs I've read, this is the first one that felt needless.
I've seen omitted information before. Revised Vampire had limited abilities, restricting them to those usable by high-generations. But this made sense as lower-gen vampires were designed more as NPCs. It was a case of player vs possible storyteller information. And the 3e Ravenloft core book omitted darklords, but that made sense in retrospect. And the Eberron Campaign setting had mysteries and omissions galore; which was done for similar reasons: sell more accessories and novels, but the main book was comprehensive and complete, it gave you everything you needed to play and more, it just left you wanting more to satisfy your curiosity.
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

alhoon wrote:Jester: Do you want an archer fighter?
I'll make an per encounter power for 3rd level.

Level 3 monster usually has 32+ con= 47 hp. So our power should do about 47/5= 9.5 hp. Since it's per encounter it should do something more than that. Let's assume that the bow deals 1d8 damage (Average 4.5) and that the archer has dex about 16-17.

All the following are per encounter
Power 1: Leg hit (standard, ranged weapon, reliable): dex vs AC.
Hit: Deals 2xW+dex mod damage (12 average damage) and the target has -2 speed until he/she/it takes a move action to remove the arrow. Creatures immune to pain (like undead) are immune to this effect.
Miss: No effect looser! (but you keep the power. Try again)

Power 2: Precision blow (standard, ranged weapon): Dex vs AC
Hit: deals 2xW+dex mod damage and the target if marked is pushed 1 square backwards.
Miss: W+dex mod damage.

Power 3: vicious arrow (standard, ranged weapon): Dex vs AC
Hit: Deals W+dex mod damage. If the target is living, bleeds for your dex modifier each turn (save ends). (Average damage of this power is 12.75 damage)
Miss: No effect again, and this time you don't try again.
Yeah, it's probably not that hard to make new powers remotely balanced, as the damage limits are very apparent. It's making fighter powers that don't step on the ranger or rogue's toes that's the problem.

And I won't have to wait long... Martial powers come out in the fall and likely has new powers for four classes.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

As I said... I don't mind if the fighter step on the ranger's toes. For my archer PCs and NPCs I'll probably steal many of the ranger's powers. That daily power with the two arrows for example seems archer-like. Why only rangers should have that option?

And that Jester brings us to a better solution to the fighter problems. I believe many of the exploits would work as good in more than one class so the list increases. OK, healing others like the warlord does is out, but the leaf of the wind from the warlord or the Nimble strike from the ranger seems good enough for all martial classes.

Out of topic: I never imagined that I would be defending the 4th edition from Jester. I was sure he was in a secret payroll from the WotC. :)
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
HuManBing
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3748
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2005 9:13 am
Contact:

Post by HuManBing »

Did a playtest of 4E with the hobby store owner DMing. It was rather brief. (2 hours, most of which was acclimatization.)

There are some improvements:
Skill tree tightened up.
Spells and powers are divided into categories of use frequency.
Dynamic saving throws.
Combat is more varied than it was before

There are some changes that are indifferent:
Hit points are crazy high.
Healing is no longer solely one class' power.
Combat is more survivable.
Combat is more important.

So if you're after something that still looks and feels a lot like the old game then this could be a good progression. This system still has the arbitrary say-so of the WotC designers in the classes, which I personally was getting to outgrow even back in 3.5.

It looks like my gaming group may spin off a 4E game, but I will definitely not be DMing that. I am undecided whether to keep the 3.5 game going at all with the FtF group, which is not Ravenloft. The FtF group has not voiced a preference for GURPS.

For my Ravenloft group, the players have all opted to end and resume in GURPS. Not a few of them even pointedly asked me what had taken me so long, to which my main response was "nostalgia".
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

:shock: NOT DMing 4th edition? But it's so much easier for the DM! Not the player BTW, the DM.

Also I believe I'll play 3rd along with 4th edition for some more time. Probably I'll just uprgrade some things from 3rd edition, breaking the 4th edition balance in the process but hey! Life's not fair, why should a game be?
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Post Reply