Page 2 of 3
Posted: Tue Jun 03, 2008 11:08 pm
by Zettaijin
Very valid points, although in my case I was more concerned with potential island domains taken from prime material worlds that include so little land as to be but a mere city surrounded by mists. A problem solved by adding a little bit of meat around the bone so to speak and putting in more land around the city - enough at least to avoid suspicions.
Of course, the whole cloned with altered memories theory is perfectly serviceable and would help explain quite a bit, so long as the darklord doesn't have a significant number of friends in the city who suddenly refuse to acknowledge that anything has changed. Not that this couldn't be used for some interesting stories.
But where's the fun in that? I rather enjoy the idea of doomsday cults and mass chaos following the arrival of a new domain. Sure, some folks will accept it as normal - more or less like some folks figure it's normal for cities to sink into the ocean were Elminster to sneeze too hard (just how cool would that be?) - but those who don't...
Still, I concur that for the average DM running a, you know, real life campaign as opposed to posting on a message board about an hypothetic campaign (like say, myself), it's all pure conjecture. Only the most detail-hungry player will start asking those uncomfortable questions.
Although that reminds me of a funny anecdote from way back when as a relative newbie to all things role playing. An anecdote from a Dark Sun game involving desert survival techniques that were quickly denied by my DM ("too disgusting for your character - seriously" and possibly too disgusting for this board but still considered perfectly legitimate) while the idea of fairly normal, balanced folks running around with an oversized bug that eats people and a pint sized elf-eating savage was just dandy. "Remember, Athasians have a different notion of good and bad than you do. It's not the real world!"
Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2008 1:07 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Strahdsbuddy wrote:Naylor is making great observations about the state of the average inhabitants' view of the world around him. But PCs are not average folk. They are just the type of people, like us, who would WANT to know the nature of things going on around them. The very nature of the Arcanist class is to seek out precicely the things we are trying to figure out!
True, there would be people who try to puzzle out patterns to the Mists' activities. Some might even come close to the truth; heck, that's what the
in-game Fraternity of Shadows is all about! But for the majority of Ravenloft natives, there's no real need to explain the Mists; even to the atheistic Lamordians, they're bound to seem much like bad weather or earthquakes, i.e. an unpleasant natural phenomenon.
Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2008 12:50 pm
by A G Thing
Quick question! Are the Darklords aware of False Histories or are they also memory altered in such instances?
Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2008 2:02 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Outlander darklords generally do remember their origins, although some may forget specific details (e.g. the Lady of Ravens' lost name) as a part of their punishment. Native-born darklords' memories aren't altered, and they evidently retain memories of "false history" from their natal domains (e.g. Dominic d'Honaire would recall Mordentish false history, even after his move to Dementlieu).
Those darklords who have been around a long time, and/or have ranks in Knowledge (Ravenloft), are probably aware of the "false history" effect. Certainly, those whose own memories contradict those of their domains' population would notice the discrepancy, although some will have come up with their own (bogus) rationale for it (e.g. Elena Faith-Hold assumes Nidalans welcomed her to "her" kingdom because Belenus had sent her there, and prepared them for her coming).
Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2008 4:14 pm
by A G Thing
Thanks Rotipher!!! Just a few more questions then!
1: Also how far back does the general false history go?
2: Does each go back to the begining of Ravenloft or is it variable for each domain?
3: If so how far does it go back basically?
Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2008 4:15 pm
by Jester of the FoS
Strahdsbuddy wrote:I've sat down and tried mapping at least THREE seperate Cores, forming slowly, a domain or two at a time. The idea of four major Conjunctions before the Black Box still makes a lot of sense to me. The first COnjunction: the formation of Barovia, THe second: the introduction of Mordent and its surrounding land, THe creation of Darkon with lands either made by the DP or stolen from another world, and A Torilian COnjunction that introduced the land that would make up Nova Vaasa and Hazlan. IMC, after the "Grand Conjunction" the Deminplane began to congeal in a way that had not been seen in its history. Shadowborn Cluster appeared ont he north of Darkon, Souragne replaced Sithicus, Vorostokov's mountains showed up along the southern Core, Sanguinia filled int he lower half of the Shadow Rift (Thanks Gomez!), and the eastern border of Vechor gave way to the Amber Wastes and the Steaming lands (My "new Core")
I've always kicked about the idea of a map circa 715, prior to Sithicus and Verbrek. Generally twenty years prior to the state of affairs in the Black Box (which gives campaigns a good 40 or 50 years before they get close to the current date). There'd just be a "Misted Wood" where those domains would be.
I always paired that idea with a netbook "Ages of the Mists" detailing the old Core and the lost lords of Richemulot, Invidia, Gundarak, and Borca.
Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2008 4:22 pm
by cure
A G Thing wrote:1: Also how far back does the general false history go?
Nova Vaassan false history goes back centuries perhaps even approaching a millenium. Richemulot, as written, hardly goes back at all and attempts to root into the matter yields explosions of rats and what not. (I kid you not.) So it varies.
Posted: Thu Jun 05, 2008 6:49 pm
by Wiccy of the Fraternity
Strahd, of course I rememebr you mate, long time no see
Of course, False History, The Mists and other devices are merely tools we wield to keep things from becoming obvious, managing to help them retain their mystery. The common man (or woman) in the demiplane would rarely have travelled more than a few miles from his/her home unless their occupation defines that they would, even then they would be a wary, superstitious bunch if their locale dictates so. Travel and distance in Ravenloft is also not set, it has been mentioned that distances alter. What could be a mile one day may well be 10 the following, or maybe less than it's "normal" distance as a scaled map would state. The Ravenloft maps have no scale, so we're fit to redeem whatever distances and dimensions we require for our own games. A useful tool and a small one at that.
I see the lands that are taken up as domains as empty areas shrouded in mist and secrecy. People can wander out into them, but most would not out of fear of the unknown. I certainly wouldn't see anyone from Barovia wandering off into the mists before the other lands around them formed. Maybe a foolhardy few would have at first, but when many didn't return and those that did were overcome but some unknown terror, it would surely would have halted future endeavours.
Everyone has their own vision on how the world formed and what it was like before that "hole between those 3 or 4 domains was filled in". So we think of what our own preferred method for that instance is.
PC's are pretty much average folk when they atsrt out, even though they're sense of adventure makes them somewhat unusual when people call them mad for wanting to see what's beyond the next village(lol). As they progress they learn a few little secrets here and there, they uncover that most of those Old Wives Tales have alot of truth to them, but they never come close to the biggest truths. Though a run in with a couple of DL's may make them wonder whether they are descendents of the original baron or whatever, or are they that same man/woman/thingy?
Posted: Sun Jun 08, 2008 3:14 am
by Lord Cyclohexane
Hey, Strahdsbuddy, I've thought a lot about this issue as well, but not in dealing with a Chronomancy campaign. My concern was about what Darkonian elves should know, considering that elves start adventuring at around 120 years of age, meaning they were born in 635 BC (Ravenloft 3E being set in 755 BC).
In 635, none of Darkon's current neighbors, save Arak and Keening, had come into existence. So what should that elf's opinion of the world be, considering she could have seen Lamordia, Falkovnia, Nova Vaasa, Markovia and G'Henna all come into existence during her own lifetime?
Anyway, I've not worked on it for a while, as I realized that I hate drawing and so mapmaking may not be suggested for me. But I had a few ideas that may help your own creations.
1) Altered Physics - Upheavals
As Mr. Naylor mentioned, Ravenloft works on a different set of physics from the real world. Here in the real world, when we feel an earthquake come on, we know that it's due to tectonic plates rubbing against each other and that, in several thousand years, this will eventually cause the earth to rise up into a new mountain range in that area.
Additionally, in our world, new land only comes into existence when volcanoes spew sufficient magma to either increase the landmass of an existing island or, due to the presence of underwater volcanoes, cause a brand new island to come into existence by finally throwing up enough magma to build a spire that reaches above sea level.
However, those are due to the unique physical composition of our planet. In Ravenloft, which may or may not have tectonic plates miles below the surface, an earthquake may instead signal the formation of a new landmass, not by causing a mountain range to rise up between point A and B, but by instead adding miles and miles of new plains and forests and rivers to come into existence between that point A and point B.
Hence, you could have Barovia and Darkon originally border each other, as made canon in I, Strahd: The War Against Azalin and strengthened by the Darkonian History section in Gaz II which proposes the idea of a "Barovian Cluster." Then, at some point later on, a known physical event (as recorded by many "natural philosophers" as the field was called before "science" was invented) occurred that signaled the emergence of new landmasses and, upon investigation, the new landmasses of Markovia and G'Henna were cartographed.
I propose calling such lesser events, which create/destroy only a small landmass at a time, "Upheavals", so as to differentiate them from the "Great Upheaval" which is only distinguished by the fact that so much land was created and destroyed in such a small span of time, as compared to normal.
To especially note the seeming normalcy of Upheavals, note the effect of the Great Upheaval of 740 BC. Or, actually, note the *lack* of effect. Other than inspiring Wyan of Viktal to being his Inquisition in Tepest, did anyone even care? Outside of Ivan Dilisnya, that is, who was inspired to build a wonderful bridge off of his mansion to give a splendid view into the Rift.
But seriously, four domains completely disappeared (Markovia, G'Henna, Bluetspur, and the Nightmare Lands) and the vast, vast majority of people simply shrugged. To my mind, this indicates that Upheavals (associated with minor Conjunctions) are relatively normal to the natives of Ravenloft and are a catalogued natural occurrence in the Land of Mists.
2) Altered Physics - Mistlands
As also proposed by others above, there's the idea of holes of Misty land in the middle of the Core, where there'd be solid land all around where that Core domain will eventually go, but for the moment it's just Mists in the middle. That does help to fit in extra space, like when lands start appearing between Barovia, Darkon and Mordent but which don't fill the entirety of the space.
However, to fill that space in a way that I find more satisfying, there can also be:
3) Lost Domains.
In Neither Beast Nor Man, in Uncle Fran's library there is a book detailing three domains that have never appeared on any canon map nor appeared in any other Ravenloft accessory, and even in NBNM they're only mentioned by name. They are, however, listed as having been Core domains in the past. So, what happened to them?
As above, I propose that Markovia, G'Henna, Bluetspur and the Nightmare Lands were not the first domains to have disappeared from the Core. Rather, they're only special because all four of them disappeared simultaneously.
To fill in additional spaces when expanding the Core, sometimes new domains should be added that will disappear later. For example, when Gundarak forms in 593 and pushes apart Barovia and Mordent, a previously unnamed domain may go north of Gundarak to fill in the hole created in the Barovian Cluster so that the Barovian Cluster's overall shape remains relatively balanced, and this domain may later disappear in another event or be absorbed into the landmass of other domains.
4) Evolving domain size
Modern-day Barovia and Invidia are much larger than they used to be, due to absorbing the landmass of the older domain, Gundarak. How many other domain were relatively small in their original form and then became larger as they annexed land from failed lost domains?
5) Time delays before joining Core
In Gaz II, in the Falkovnian History section, Vlad Drakov retreats from Darkon into the Mists and finds himself in Falkovnia. However, there appears to be a six month or so delay between when Vlad becomes Darklord of Falkovnia and when Falkovnia joins the Core.
As such, when the Timeline lists Falkovnia appearing in 690, is that when Falkovnia appeared as part of the Core or as an Island in the Mists? Could Falkovnia have waited before becoming part of the Core until a few other domains were ready to join as well?
I find this idea to work relatively well, of certain Clusters forming before they pop up in the middle of the Core. I like the idea of Falkovnia and Richemulot becoming Core domains at the same time, of Drakov leaving Darkon in 689, Falkovnia forming as an Island in 690 and having certain problems, Claude Renier leaving Falkovnia to make Richemulot in 694 and thus making the Falkov Cluster, and only then do the two domains become part of the Core, both admitted at the same time although the domains formed seperately.
6) Dissolution of the Barovian Cluster
But what I found would be easiest is for the Barovian Cluster to break up somewhere before 593 BC, when Gundarak would form. Then, three seperate Clusters would form, following the dominant cultural trends:
Balok Cluster, started with just Barovia and Forlorn after the breakup, would then spawn Gundarak (593), Invidia (603), Kartakass (613), Borca (684), Markovia (698) and Dorvinia (715). This being the strong center of Balok culture, it then becomes part of the Core later on.
Seaside Cluster, a transient cluster, would start with Darkon, Mordent, Arak and Keening after the break with the Balok Cluster. It would then spawn the Sea of Sorrows (630) and have a odd number of islands appear and disappear before its break up around the 670s.
Darkonian Cluster would take Darkon and Arak and Keening after the breakup and then spawn Nova Vaasa (682), Falkovnia (690), Tepest (691), Richemulot (694), G'Henna (702), and Hazlan (714).
Mordentish Cluster would take Mordent and the Sea of Sorrows along with a random number of islands and then spawn Lamordia (683), Dementlieu (707) and Arkandale (708).
Then, some time between 715 BC (Dorvinia forming) and 720 BC (Sithicus forming, which is the first entry on the Timeline to mention "the Core"), the Core forms properly, with the three major Clusters sliding together to form one huge landmass.
Summary
This is what I see as the best creation of the Core, anyway, of having three major Clusters be the main originators of the Core. Play with a bit to see if you can find a better overall conjunction, though!
Posted: Sun Jun 08, 2008 4:52 am
by Lord Cyclohexane
Actually, looking at the map again and examining the order that domains appear, there's actually no problems at all until Nova Vaasa appears in 682. With Arak bordering on Barovia prior to that point (as Azalin goes into the Mists from Arak to form Darkon, but doesn't hit the Mists before that, Arak and Barovia must share a border at some point), Nova Vaasa has to squeeze between Barovia and Arak, pushing apart those two as well as seperating Barovia from everything else at that point.
Before that, you can make a Barovian Cluster of Darkon as the North Core and Mordent, Barovia, Forlorn and Arak as the South Core as proposed in Gaz II. All future lands can be added on from there (have Mordent be where Borca is now, in relation to Barovia, as they're the same size, and you can add Gundarak south of it just fine) without any problems.
As such, it now seems like it'd be best to keep a pre-Core for longer than I originally suggested. Then, due to some event between 630 BC (Sea of Sorrows forms) and 682 BC (Nova Vaasa forms), then break it into the three main Clusters that I propose above.
-------------
So, to put it all in one space again, it'll start with the Barovian Cluster.
Barovian Cluster notes:
Darkon goes across the entire North of the Barovian Cluster.
Mordent will have its western coastline as a continuation of Darkon's western coastline, making one long coast, and the Arden River of Mordent will have an additional tributary from due east, coming from the northwestern most of Barovia's lakes, which currently forms a minor tributary of the Luna River.
The Old Svalich Road does not continue into Mordent as it stops at Krezk, but the eastern side of the Old Svalich Road, which currently goes into Nova Vaasa, will instead become part of the Rawboned Road through Arak, the same Rawboned Road that Azalin in 755 BC is trying to reopen as the Via Strigos.
Because of the shape of Arak, there is a small border between Arak and Barovia but a larger empty triangle of Mistland between Arak, Barovia and Darkon. It has a horizontal northern border that follows Darkon's southern border, which from its western point goes south-east along Barovia's east side, then comes north-east after hitting the border with Arak. Part of this Mistland will eventually be taken up by Keening.
Alternately, in that small crook, it may be more fulfilling to have a Lost Domain appear. It would certainly be interesting to see Mt. Lament be torn from an existing domain (Arak) and then steal lands from some other existing domain (which time later forgets as it disappears to make way for Tepest later on).
Evolution of the Barovian Cluster into the Core:
From the Barovian Cluster, the following domains are added on as normal: Gundarak (593), Invidia (603), Kartakass (613) and the Sea of Sorrows (630).
Between 630 and 680, some event occurs (likely another bid of Azalin's to escape the Mists) that breaks the Core into three main pieces:
New Barovian Cluster: Starts with Barovia, Forlorn, Gundarak, Invidia and Kartakass, then spawns Borca (684), Markovia (698) and Dorvinia (715).
Darkonian Cluster: Starts with Darkon, Arak and Keening, then spawns Nova Vaasa (682), Falkovnia (690), Tepest (691), Richemulot (694), G'Henna (702), and Hazlan (714).
Mordentish Cluster: Starts with Mordent and the Sea of Sorrows with its myriad islands, then spawns Lamordia (683), Dementlieu (707) and Arkandale (708).
And then, somewhere between 715 BC (Dorvinia forms) and 720 (Sithicus joins the Core), the Core is formed by the three Clusters reforming as one whole, then Sithicus forms in 720 BC, Valachan joins the Core after waiting 100 years since its formation, and Verbrek finally forms in 730, finishing the Core as it appears in 740 BC for the Black Box set.
----------
Only concerns: No idea when Bluetspur should join up with the Core but I don't think the Barovian Cluster had sufficient resources to keep from being overrun by Bluetspur when Bluetspur originally formed in 581.
Also, I'd have to check the dates of the Falkovnian Campaigns to see how that affects things.
Errata: Ravenloft Campaign Setting's Timeline does not mention the date of formation for the Nightmare Lands, so I couldn't add that into the above plan.
----------
Oh, and to reiterate on the above: All of the above are simply my ideas, and there is absolutely no reason for you to use them unless you happen to like them. I am not an authority, none of the above is canon, and potentially all of the above is silly and should not be used by anybody.
Posted: Sun Jun 08, 2008 10:29 pm
by Ryan Naylor
I really, really like what you've said, especially about the effects of Upheavals and forgotten Core domains (so forgotten, in fact, that I'd forgotten about them).
If it helps, I think I read somewhere that the Nightmare Lands joined the Core after Nova Vaasa. They were an Island, then joined the Core beside Nova Vaasa, then became an Island again. I think it was the Nightmare Lands, but i'm not sure. It may just have been when we were planning the Gazetteers. I'm not sure.
Posted: Mon Jun 09, 2008 7:27 am
by Strahdsbuddy
Wow! Thanks for turning this whole thing on its ear! Excellent observation that the word "Core" doesn't appear int he official timeline until Sithicus. Could the whole thing really have been in flux right up until the Black Box? Puts a new spin on things. Not only would a 120 year old 1st level Elf have a long memory of what happened, even someone like Jules Weathermay would have seen a great deal of change in his lifetime. Even if the whole Core had formed as one piece, older NPCs would have seen a lot of domains show up (I don't use a lot of demihumans IMC)
A little expansion on my own ideas of the Greater Mordent. Including all the land of the southwertern Core along with it shows a bit of the sloppiness with which the land was introduced and the fact that it may not have exactly been part of the Dark Powers' plans. Godefroy is the ultimate lame-duck darklord, a big part of the reason so many campaigns have started in Mordent; it has that feel of a "1st level" domain, fairly or not. But Godefroy's focus on Gryphon Hill could weaken his hold on, say, the Arkendale forest, if he even realized he was lording over that realm at all!
The strong bloodlines that already existed in Mordent (Godefroy, Weathermay, Timothy, Renier, and d'Honaire) really spread out through the demiplane. Was it a coincidence, though? COuld the purpose of the Mordent Conjunction not been the snagging of one darklord, but the collection of a number of strong familes with the potential for both great evil, and great heroism? (Yeah i know the designers took the names from I-10, but let's try to think in-game here) I like the idea of Madame Eva being a foil to the DP, and i think she fed Strahd info that would have sent him in the particular direction of Mordent during his upcoming ritual. But was she trying to bring in the heroes or the villains?
Posted: Mon Jun 09, 2008 10:00 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Lord Cyclohexane wrote:
5) Time delays before joining Core
In Gaz II, in the Falkovnian History section, Vlad Drakov retreats from Darkon into the Mists and finds himself in Falkovnia. However, there appears to be a six month or so delay between when Vlad becomes Darklord of Falkovnia and when Falkovnia joins the Core.
As such, when the Timeline lists Falkovnia appearing in 690, is that when Falkovnia appeared as part of the Core or as an Island in the Mists? Could Falkovnia have waited before becoming part of the Core until a few other domains were ready to join as well?
Just as a thought: could Falkovnia's hypothetical "time delay" account for the discrepancy in Ivan Dragonov's alleged age? The fact that he was supposedly born in Falkovnia, but generations before that domain was known to have existed, has always been a nagging flaw in an otherwise-intriguing NPC.
What if Falkovnia wasn't just out of touch with the Core for a while, but out of
chronological synch with it, too? Perhaps Vlad Drakov was actually given his domain (then an Island) decades before the established timeline claims, but the DPs opted to place all of Falkovnia in suspended animation until there were enough rival rulers in the Core to treat the Kingfuhrer with the condescention he deserves. From the Falkovnians' POV, their king would have appeared in 690 BC, but in reality they'd have been kept on ice for a long time before that.
Dragonov could have appeared when the Island-Falkovnia did, wandered into the Mists immediately thereafter, and thus been left out of the time-stopping effect. Thus, he'd arrive in the Core long before Falkovnia's "official" emergence -- just in time to make his appearance in the novel
Mordenheim, in fact -- and be effectively stranded outside his homeland, until the DPs brought it out of cold storage. Until his native land did emerge at last, he'd have been mistaken for just another outlander by Core residents.
Posted: Mon Jun 09, 2008 11:27 am
by HuManBing
Your idea of a much larger original Barovia has merit. Remember that Strahd's father, Barov von Zarovich, was actually a king in his own right. For Strahd to be a mere count implies that the governable lands under his dominion must be greatly reduced from his father's time.
It's possible that Barov lived to see his son's victory in uniting the nation, and then Strahd dutifully returned the crown position to his father to act as king. Strahd himself may have been heavily influential, but nominally held a smaller title with direct authority over a county.
This also solves the problem in Roots of Evil where Prime Material Barovia is somewhat larger than the Ravenloft realm was.
Posted: Wed Jun 11, 2008 9:10 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
It's correct that Old Borjia -- not yet "Barovia", as Strahd re-named those highlands he'd liberated in his own lifetime -- was a somewhat larger nation than the domain Strahd rules today. Both I, Strahd and the history of Borca (which was largely inspired by that novel) make it clear that the Tergs hadn't entirely ousted the Von Zarovich royals, but only chased them from their former seat of power -- not Castle Ravenloft, but presumably someplace near Lake Zarovich -- and into the lowlands of Borjia, where the Dilisnyas, Wachters, Buchvolds, and other nominally-subordinate families held authority.
Technically, Barov I died before Strahd ever got the chance to reinstate his father's kingship over the highlands/Barovia, but I, Strahd implies that Strahd had generally assumed he'd be restoring his father's crown, not seizing power for himself. At the time of his parents' deaths (347 BC), Strahd was still engaged in military operations, so he never really had the chance to mourn them or come to terms with being heir to the kingdom. Retaining the title of "Count", which he'd long expected to hold as his father's vassal, presumably helped him avoid having to face up to their deaths when he (and Barovia's military forces) couldn't afford the distractions of his grief.
In a sense, Strahd only really had to admit his parents were gone when Sergei arrived, and forced him to face the truth: that he'd missed out on the last thirty years with his family, and could never get that facet of his life back. The fact that Sergei was the unintentional bearer of such bitter tidings would've only added to the repressed resentments and envy which Strahd felt for his younger brother, even before Tatyana entered the picture. Thus, Strahd never did get to pay his respects to his parents' graves, which he would surely have felt duty-bound to do, before he could assume the title of king.
Even if Barovia is or was larger in your campaign, it wouldn't be a bad idea if its borders still fell short of where Barov and Ravenia were really buried. That way, Strahd's regrets for not honoring their graves can remain intact, as he's left with nothing but a false, DP-crafted version of their crypt to mock him under Castle Ravenloft.