Page 2 of 3

Posted: Fri Aug 01, 2008 9:58 am
by Nathan of the FoS
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:Assuming these resourceful yougn women work it out so that the capture the doppelganger, milk Horstmann for glowing support and then kill him without being implicated, what are their powers checks?
Murderous betrayal is a Betrayal Atrocity or Abomination (5 or 6), evil subject is -3, so they're looking at a Trespass or Sin (2 or 3) for a 2 or 4% chance of failure.

Capturing an intelligent creature to be tortured, so as to get personal gain thereby, would probably be a Violent Enormity or Atrocity (3 or 4), again against an evil subject for -3, so zero or 1% chance of a check there.

Posted: Fri Aug 01, 2008 10:33 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
Thank you, Nathan! These characters seem so heroic by Falkovnian standards that I sometimes worry that I'm not being vigilant with the powers checks. This is probably their worst gambit so far, so it's good to know I haven't been lax.

Posted: Fri Aug 01, 2008 8:28 pm
by Manofevil
gonzoron wrote:K, here we go:
Anakin Skywalker:
1) Somewhat accidentally destroys the doid control ship, no doubt conatining some semi-innocent Niemoidians.(sp?)
2) Slaughters an encampment of sandpeople (men, women, and children) in revenge for his mother's death
3) At Palpatine's urging, cuts off the arm of Mace Windu (Jedi Master, one of the leaders of Anakin's own Order) allowing Palpatine to get the advantage and kill him.
4) Betrays his Order completely, allies with the Evil Palpatine and slaughters (Good) Jedi by the dozens, including "younglings" (Innocent children)
5) Thinking she's betrayed him, force-chokes his own pregnant wife, Padme.
6) Assists Palpatine in creating a brutal, oppressive regime (the Empire)
{darklord yet?}
7) continues to hunt down and destroy remaining Jedi
8) Tortures his daughter, though he doesn't know it's her
9) Kills his mentor and friend Obi-wan in battle
10) Routinely force-chokes subordinates, sometimes to death.
11) Cuts off the arm of his own son.

(Did I miss anything?)
I would add
12) His attempts to corrupt his own son and his facilitation of Palpatine's attempts to corrupt his son. These attempts include his threats to his own daughter which were briefly successful in corupting his son. Would the Dark Powers recognise his betrayal of Palpatine or his failure to show mercy to Darth Tyrannus at Palpatine's urging?

Also thanks guys. I hadn't thought of this as the way it would go initially but having thought of this in a flash, I'm glad all of you were willing to embrace this. I really like where we're going with this. :D

Posted: Fri Aug 01, 2008 9:20 pm
by Lord Soth
gonzoron wrote:1) Somewhat accidentally destroys the doid control ship, no doubt conatining some semi-innocent Niemoidians.(sp?)


That wouldn't lead to a Powers Check, as it was still the ship of an opposing military force, and its destruction was essential to saving the people of Naboo. And I doubt there were any innocent or semi-innocent Trade Federation types aboard. Aside from it being a military vessel, it seemed to only be crewed by those necessary to operate the ship and their droid army, plus high ranking officials. So not like Anakin nailed any civilians. And even if there were any, Kevin Smith has something to say about that. :P

Posted: Mon Aug 04, 2008 10:31 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Okay, how about the stepfather in Pan's Labyrinth?


SPOILER SPACE











He viciously kills two men he knows are innocent of their crimes because one of them mouthed off to him. He shoots the local doctor to death for helping revolutionaries, thereby causing his own wife to die in childbirth at the hands of a vastly underqualified military field medic. Finally, he kills his own stepdaughter after she restores his infant son to him.

Posted: Tue Aug 05, 2008 12:16 am
by HuManBing
He also executes injured men by taunting them first with the pistol at finger's distance. Additionally, he taunts torture victims beforehand by promising them their freedom if they can complete an impossible task (like a stammering man count to three without stammering). His torture methods leave the person alive, often over a period of days, for execution by firing squad later.

He's really not a very nice man at all.

Posted: Sun Aug 17, 2008 3:51 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
The Lesser of Many Evils, an adventure from CotN: Created, gives the PC's options to cope with Azenwrath's approach. To force the people of Canondale to give up their beloved icons warrants a 5% powers check for destroying another's faith, while abandoning them to Azenwrath warrants a 20% powers check. How would all of you calculate these checks?

Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 2:24 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
While DeepShadow's example is still on the table, I'd like to add this one:

Summon Undead I-V are a group of spells from Magic of Faerun, reprinted in Heroes of Horror and Libris Mortis. They pretty much do what you'd expect. Does casting this spell merit a powers check, and if so, how high?

My spiritualist argues that he's not creating undead, only summoning existing undead from elsewhere and turning them to a good cause. If some of the undead get killed in the process, so much the better, he's ridding the world of a few horrible creatures. And if the spell lasts longer than the battle, rather than dismissing them, he turns them on each other, again hoping to rid the world of some undead, and put their souls to rest.

Of course, he's still got to be "meddling in things man was not meant to know" (TM), but is it enough to matter in the DP's eyes?

Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 2:35 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Using Evil methods for a good cause should never be a sufficient excuse in Ravenloft, IME. Diamabel and Elena both honestly believe that they're doing what's right, but believing that isn't enough. Plus, summoned creatures don't die permanently if killed, they just go back where they came from.

I'd definitely impose a check, but lower the % slightly because the PC's intentions aren't bad. In fact, I'd probably just say that the DPs consider that series of spells to be Necromancy, even if they're technically classed as Conjuration by the rulebooks.

Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 2:39 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:The Lesser of Many Evils, an adventure from CotN: Created, gives the PC's options to cope with Azenwrath's approach. To force the people of Canondale to give up their beloved icons warrants a 5% powers check for destroying another's faith, while abandoning them to Azenwrath warrants a 20% powers check. How would all of you calculate these checks?
H'm...what would happen to the villagers if they don't give up the icons? Azenwrath appears and starts killing people? How strong is the PCs' evidence that Azerwrath can a) kill all the villagers, b) kill the PCs? How strong is the evidence that the PCs can prevent the villagers from being killed?
Summon Undead I-V are a group of spells from Magic of Faerun, reprinted in Heroes of Horror and Libris Mortis. They pretty much do what you'd expect. Does casting this spell merit a powers check, and if so, how high?

My spiritualist argues that he's not creating undead, only summoning existing undead from elsewhere and turning them to a good cause. If some of the undead get killed in the process, so much the better, he's ridding the world of a few horrible creatures. And if the spell lasts longer than the battle, rather than dismissing them, he turns them on each other, again hoping to rid the world of some undead, and put their souls to rest.

Of course, he's still got to be "meddling in things man was not meant to know" (TM), but is it enough to matter in the DP's eyes?
So...he uses the Black Arts to demand the service of the unquiet dead, turns them on his enemies, and then forces them to fight each other if there's anything left over?...:misori:

I'd give points for chutzpah, but I think this is a straight Black Magic check. IIRC the UTPC would give Summon Undead I-III a 2% chance of failure and Summon Undead IV a 4% chance of failure.

Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 2:53 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Using Evil methods for a good cause should never be a sufficient excuse in Ravenloft, IME.
Agreed, but are the methods actually evil?
Plus, summoned creatures don't die permanently if killed, they just go back where they came from.
That's the major question we had. Couldn't find any rules text to support it, though. Where is it said in the books? One big draw of choosing this spell was the collateral damage to the undead. If it's not permanent, it's much less appealing. (Although just try finding a good 5th level necromancy spell for a non-evil spiritualist necromancer)

Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 3:23 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Check out the PHB's original description of the Conjuration (summoning) subschool (p. 173). There's nothing in the RLPHB or the Summon Undead spells' descriptions to contradict its statement that summoned creatures, if killed, aren't really dead, so the default rules for Summoning-descriptor spells apply.

Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 3:35 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Check out the PHB's original description of the Conjuration (summoning) subschool (p. 173). There's nothing in the RLPHB or the Summon Undead spells' descriptions to contradict its statement that summoned creatures, if killed, aren't really dead, so the default rules for Summoning-descriptor spells apply.
D'oh, there it is, right there in the SRD. thanks. So oddly enough, he may be willing to risk the 4% check, but probably won't be as interested in the spell anymore...

Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 5:03 pm
by Archedius
also what's to stop the undead he summons from twisting the spirit of his commands or creating collateral damage while summoned? It IS Ravenloft so that would seem plausable.

Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2008 5:21 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Using Evil methods for a good cause should never be a sufficient excuse in Ravenloft, IME. Diamabel and Elena both honestly believe that they're doing what's right, but believing that isn't enough.
Yeah, IIRC this sounds a LOT like Elena's justification for summoning evil creatures in another thread. Might be funny to take note of how the PC justifies his actions, and use her as a dark mirror.