Page 2 of 4
Posted: Mon Mar 16, 2009 12:12 pm
by DocBeard
Wow, some of these are very cool. Your spelljammer domain definately beats the vague idea I had for one(An asteroid-city run by a paranoid administrator who could never get the security she craves.)
And I'm sorry, Wolf, I misread the nature of the contest. I can say that I'd probably do the three canon domains a little differently; I'Cath seems a perfect place to recreate rural, fairy tale China, complete with a wicked witch who's core flaw is an inability to understand the daughters she's invested so much of her life into, for example, or Nossos not being the same old story of civilization versus nature, but nature versus nature, with Marcus as the high shaman of the virus god and his court of bacteria spirits.
Anyway, good luck.
Posted: Mon Mar 16, 2009 2:52 pm
by WolfKook
DocBeard wrote:And I'm sorry, Wolf, I misread the nature of the contest...
No problem, Doc. I just hope neither you nor anyone else was left with a great domain idea that didn't make it to the open call's deadline.
Any suggestions for the contestants? Anything you want to see in any of those domains? Remember that they'll be fleshed up as we go...
Posted: Mon Mar 16, 2009 3:01 pm
by MadStepDad
http://madstepdad.proboards24.com/index ... 442&page=1
My Darklord rankings are up. I demand to know who submitted Principato delle Grazie! This was the only submission to earn a perfect 5-star rating!
Good job to everybody and good luck on future rounds!
peace,
MSD
*EDITED*
PS, while you're there check out my ongoing PbP adventure of THE EVIL EYE - remixed for MASQUE of the RED DEATH MILLENIUM VERSION.
http://madstepdad.proboards24.com/index.cgi?board=weed
Featuring some well known RAVENLOFT board members and fans!
[/end shameless plug]
Posted: Mon Mar 16, 2009 3:25 pm
by Igor the Henchman
A word of explanation regarding the domains of Ast, Forest of Memory and Zumbera. These 3 domains (by me) got lost in WolfKook's mailbox and so, didn't make it for round 0. I contacted Wolf about it, and he retroactively put them back - having first shown them to the judges, of course.
I find it strange MadStepDad doesn't remember these submissions - I received his comments of them two weeks ago, forwarded by Wolf:
Forest of Memory
MadStepDad: "Sounds like more faeries".
Tec-Goblin: "It might be interesting to realize that some known NPCs are dead in fact, and they will fade away, or they temporarily fade away in the moonlight."
Zumbera
MadStepDad: "I like it, different twist, unique creature in RAVENLOFT."
Tec-Goblin: "Another name that's very funny in Greek (like Barovia = the girl who spends all her life in bars). Classic idea, how this absorption would take place though? What are its signs?"
Ast
MadStepDad: "I like it, interesting to see how they can incorporate the bane of all RAVENLOFT purists into the setting without compromising its integrity."
Tec-Goblin: "An idea: drabonborn PCs might make occasional pilgrimages back to this domain, in order to sacrifice precious items to appease these gods, and protect their people. How the guilt for the actions performed to appease these gods reflects on the proud and honest psyche of a dragonborn? Will they try to rationalise it?"
Posted: Mon Mar 16, 2009 3:29 pm
by MadStepDad
Oh yes, now I remember! Those came through my inbox at the last minute. Good stuff! I have no idea where any of these submission came from so I was forced to remain fair and impartial!
peace,
MSD
Posted: Mon Mar 16, 2009 8:32 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
Are we revealing who did what at this point, then?
Posted: Mon Mar 16, 2009 8:51 pm
by Sorti
By the way, it could be great if we had a less strict word limit on the next rounds... Pretty please?

Posted: Mon Mar 16, 2009 9:13 pm
by Igor the Henchman
Nathan of the FoS wrote:Are we revealing who did what at this point, then?
I just thought people might be incredulous at why 3 all-new proposals suddenly popped out of the blue, that's all. As to whether or not I might have other submissions afloat, I'm not telling yet. Oh, this is fun
Other things I'm noticing:
There's suddenly quite a lot of italian domains. I've counted ten (out of 38 ) that used italian-sounding names in some way. I suspect Sorti's malign influence to be at work.
The overall submission quality is increasing. No more 1/5 ratings. The number of 2/5 ratings has decreased, too. Will 4/5 be the average in the next round?
Some domains with very high ratings sport a cool darklord, but reveal next to nothing about the actual realm. The undead pregnant woman seems firmly in the lead, but no info on the actual domain, as of yet - and the expectations are high.
I feel my familiarity with the domains grow from round to round. Back in round 0, it seemed like just a list of weird names. Now, when I think "Felsinea", it actually evokes something meaningful.
Posted: Mon Mar 16, 2009 9:24 pm
by Igor the Henchman
Sorti wrote:By the way, it could be great if we had a less strict word limit on the next rounds... Pretty please?

Nope! 30 words it was, 30 words it will be! Up to the final write-up, I say!

Posted: Mon Mar 16, 2009 10:27 pm
by DasSoviet
Well... that could be a little tricky, as according to Wolf's original schedule, the next one is the domain's stat block, consisting of, if I do recall correctly:
Cultural Level:
Ecology:
Climate/Terrain:
Population
Main Settlements:
Races:
Languages:
Religion:
Government:
Ruler:
Darklord:
Currency:
plus a summary of the domain... which will likely need to be a bit more in depth than the 30 words we've already thrown out

Posted: Mon Mar 16, 2009 11:52 pm
by WolfKook
Nathan of the FoS wrote:Are we revealing who did what at this point, then?
Not yet... You'll have to wait to round three, just like everyone else
Sorti wrote:By the way, it could be great if we had a less strict word limit on the next rounds... Pretty please?

Mmmmmm... I'll think about it... (See below)
Igor the Henchman wrote:There's suddenly quite a lot of italian domains. I've counted ten (out of 38 ) that used italian-sounding names in some way. I suspect Sorti's malign influence to be at work.
And you're quite right on that one...
The overall submission quality is increasing. No more 1/5 ratings. The number of 2/5 ratings has decreased, too. Will 4/5 be the average in the next round?
I guess the stakes are getting higher each round; and that's great, cause that was the whole point. In this round-to-round basis, everyone will have to outdo themselves each round to keep their domains in the competition.
I feel my familiarity with the domains grow from round to round. Back in round 0, it seemed like just a list of weird names. Now, when I think "Felsinea", it actually evokes something meaningful.
Well, that's an unexpected, but totally welcome, side-effect
DasSoviet wrote:Well... that could be a little tricky, as according to Wolf's original schedule, the next one is the domain's stat block (...) plus a summary of the domain... which will likely need to be a bit more in depth than the 30 words we've already thrown out.
Well, we're getting ahead of things, but you're totally right, DasSoviet... And the statblock is also quite right (Though the populations would probably change, because of the nature of the RLR project). About the summary, the word count will extend to 300 words. For inspiration, look at Jöel's
Fan Made Domain list.
But don't start writing right now... There are still three days for the judges to give their results, and a couple of them who haven't said anything yet. Right now, there are 10 domains that will not get to round two, but anything could happen in the next couple of days.

Posted: Tue Mar 17, 2009 12:41 am
by Yaoi Huntress Earth
I guess I should've reworded my entry for Demise's Darklord to better explain the whole curse. That she is unable to enjoy her new fame due to becoming a monster (representation of her own inner ugliness and pride.) Oh well, what's done is done.
Posted: Tue Mar 17, 2009 1:15 am
by Igor the Henchman
I know what you mean, Huntress. I too had one or two submissions cut from the get go over nothing more than a poor choice of words.
On the other hand, its only one judge out of four, so nothing's decided yet.
Posted: Tue Mar 17, 2009 1:21 am
by Nathan of the FoS
Well, some concepts are easier to convey in 30 words than others are.

The way the cookie crumbles, I suppose.
Posted: Tue Mar 17, 2009 1:33 am
by DasSoviet
Igor the Henchman wrote:I know what you mean, Huntress. I too had one or two submissions cut from the get go over nothing more than a poor choice of words.
Oh, agreed. After I looked over Newumberland again, after the judges' reviews, I saw several errors which I really shouldn't caught the first run through... particularly the 'electrical lines' part. Newumberland is supposed to be New England with a touch of Lovecraft and Stephen King... really doesn't read that way does it?
Ahh well... we still have our home games, and that's what counts
