Terminator 2 is a great gothic work?Gonzoron of the FoS wrote: After all, as a character in a great gothic work once said, "There is no fate but what we make"
kidding

Terminator 2 is a great gothic work?Gonzoron of the FoS wrote: After all, as a character in a great gothic work once said, "There is no fate but what we make"


There are Greek tragedies that didn't involve divine caprice or fate and in which the villain was solely responsible for his actions, however. Tantalus didn't wind up damned in Hades for nothing, and he wasn't the only one.Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Just an observation: It's sad but true that a "classical" darklord would be very, very hard to do. Not just because it's an odd fit for Ravenloft, but because many Greek tragedies choose to depict their protagonists as the powerless victims of fate and/or divine caprice. That's certainly true of King Aischos -- in fact, judged purely as an homage to Greek tragedy, it's one of the most moving facets of his story -- but unfortunately, this same attribute of classical fiction makes it very tough to create a villain who can be held solely responsible for his own damnation. The very thing that makes Aischos's backstory feel so "classical" also undermines his viability as a darklord, and that's far more the fault of the tragedies being emulated than the fault of the writer.

No time wasting involved and no apology needed. I'm intrigued, actually, and will try to read it when I have time. (Just because I haven't loved a fan-made domain yet doesn't mean I'm not looking to change that.)DocBeard wrote:Obviously I misremembered. Apologies for wasting your time.


I'll keep watching over may shoulder though. Even when I'm powerless, seeing my name spelled wrong usually takes me close to a murdering rage...Checco wrote:Gentileshi with a single 'l'
But don't worry, Amedeo is powerless and wouldn't smite you anyway
I've seen the reactions to previous comments from the judges, and I know for a fact that the writers are aware of that. They tend to appreciate criticism, especially when it helps them build better domains (Igor, in particular, mentioned that once), as long as it doesn't go personal (And your comments do not).Gonzoron wrote:I'm sorry if this seems harsh. Just going for honest and constructive criticism..
Ooops!! Sorry. It's done. Won't happen again...Igor the Henchman wrote:WolfKook, I have a favor to beg: could you please put some spaces between paragraphs like MadStepDad did on his board? It makes all the difference between comfortable reading and wanting to tear one's eyes out.
You're not, and you raise a good point. Even though it's too late for the contestants to edit their entries (That would be unfair for those whose darklords have already been posted), there's no reason preventing them from polishing their write-ups for the final release, after the 10 best domains have been selected (And that would be at the end of this round).ManOfEvil wrote:I guess I'm kind of overstepping my bounds here, but even if it's too late for the entrants to edit their entries, there's no reason these domains can't be all they can be after the contest, Right?



I expected this question, though it has sense.whalejudge wrote:This one confuses me. What's the Call? Why'd she get into drinking blood? If they're under the control of someone else, why do they deserve their sentence?

OK, read that now. Seems to me that most published Darklords did it themselves, maybe with a little temptation from someone--and if there was the temptation from someone else, the DL took things farther than might be expected. The "Call", and influence of the ancestors, seems to me to be the sort of thing that requires even more than without it.Checco wrote:I expected this question, though it has sense.whalejudge wrote:This one confuses me. What's the Call? Why'd she get into drinking blood? If they're under the control of someone else, why do they deserve their sentence?
Everything about 'The Call' and Oriebo's background can be found in the last round's entry (I'll later edit and post a link).
Since this round was about the Dls, when we realized we were using the 1200 words to 'rewrite' the domain just with more details, we thought that it was better to focus on the DLs and ignore everything about the domain itself, as we described it before.
This round was a 'now or never' opportunity to detail the Dls, so we chose to do so fully, and we still think it was the right choice.
Regarding why they deserve their punishment, maybe it's better to precise that being influenced by one's ancestor doesn't mean you lose your free will; Amedeo managed to resist the Call as long as he, basically, wished.
EDIT: Here is the link to last round's Oriebo entry: http://www.fraternityofshadows.com/foru ... 4&start=15

What happens when the two DLs meet each other was precisely decided, it was not included so far because it's less important than other aspects we wanted to describe.Manofevil wrote:I'll say that I liked this one. (though I'm afraid I liked the other one better.) The only thing I would see added would be what happens when the two DarkLords come into contact. Do they try to attack one another? Are they overcome with grief? Maybe they can't even see each other? What?
Well, as much as I can say the 'Noble-making-nasty-things' is rather common in literature, as well as in several Dl of the core whose domains are not early medieval, there is not a big way to avoid them to do so, especially if you choose to create a DL which is not a children of the night, but you have to work upon an Aristocrat.Igor the Henchman wrote: one of my favorites. Guendalina seems cut out like your average evil-aligned noble who does vaguely-defined "evil stuff" to pass the time - a fairly old hat villain stereotype already explored in Ivana Boritsi, Ivan, Gabrielle and Jacky R. Amedeo's impotence places him somewhere between Haki Shinpi and Sir Torrence Bleysmith on the "what am I supposed to do with him?" scale. No minions, no combat ability, no outgoing schemes. There's just no obvious adventure hooks jumping out at me.
Which is a bit of a shame - Oriebo is one of the more interesting domains. I love the latent vampirism aspect of its nobility and the constant paranoia of the Bloodhounds.