Page 2 of 3

Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 9:08 pm
by HuManBing
ewancummins wrote:
HuManBing wrote:
ewancummins wrote:Strahd- look at how his mommy dresses him, these days:
I think he's acquired the fey template. Apparently he's prancing around the background of the domain having all sorts of interesting "low level encounters" but I'm not inclined to pry further.
So, he's finally gotten over Tatyana, then? :wink:
Well you know what they say in Barovia... "Every man keeps one eye ahead for the devil, and the other eye over his shoulder for the Count."

Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 11:02 pm
by ewancummins
brilliantlight wrote:
Lucius wrote:Easan.
True enough, he was a decent guy until the warlord messed with him.
Wasn't that warlord actually Iuz?

Posted: Fri Aug 21, 2009 11:04 pm
by ewancummins
Tobias Blackburn wrote:
alhoon wrote:
nothri wrote:
Jaqueline Renier for some reason I've always empathized with. Yes, she's evil...but honestly? Compared to the Renier clan as a whole, she's remarkably well adjusted. We're talking about a family shapechanging, decadent creatures that have been entrenched within their domain for years. jaqueline has struck me as the first one to ever truly rise above the rat heap (so to speak) and show some real humanity....and of course its that spark of humanity the Dark Powers use against her.
Remember, she's trying to create a breed of rats that would spread her lycanthropy so she can in one fell strike she can turn most of Richemulot's human population to wererats under her personal influence. That is she's researching a biological weapon that would kill many of the victims in pain and turn others to monsters she can control. And then she will order those monsters to infect others.
Ah, but the reason... She is doing it because she is terrified of being alone. But this has placed her in a position where she actually prefers the company of backstabbers to being alone.

So of course she's planning to turn people into monsters. To her she's giving them a great gift. She's making sure they will follow her for power, but also so that she knows she isn't creating a nation of enemies. She is making sure that people will follow her and protect her. She will never be alone again.

But most importantly, by placing everyone in the same boat she will never again suffer the humiliating and painful rejection that she did that night she found true love.

I can't agree with the methods, they're horrible, but her underlying reasons are sympathetic.

She's among my favorite DLs. She's made a brief appearance [as a patron/ally of the party] in my Mists over the Musarde PBP.

Posted: Sat Aug 22, 2009 7:40 am
by HuManBing
Oddly, I find the DLs with "lost-love" style curses less compelling. Sadly, most DLs have "lost-love" style curses, whether it's Azalin's sorrow for his son, or Strahd/Ivana/d'Honaire/Renier/Thakok-An/Soth/Gabrielle for their respective dating histories. Gabrielle Aderre is particularly uninteresting for me - her curse has led to a quasi-soap-opera parade of lovers and drama which strikes me as being not so much tragic as faintly unnecessary and impractically complicated.

I'm largely unsympathetic to that because it's an affliction that is intensely personal, so there's not that much of interest to somebody else. Being in love is like experiencing a religious revelation, or writing some inspiring poetry: It sounds great to you, but everybody else is strangely unmoved by it. Plus, being in love is an ethically neutral endeavor. It benefits only that one person (and maybe the object of their attention). The rest of society doesn't care, and with good reason.

I like the DLs whose curses involve some sort of grand sacrifice for the greater good, but which are thwarted by fate. This applies in part to Azalin and Strahd, both of whom led armies and ruled countries - and if you look closely at his backstory, to Harkon Lukas as well (who is one of the few wolfweres organized enough to try to order a society). Mordenheim's sacrifices are scientific, not political, but still compelling to me. von Kharkov's situation is the Nietzschean suspension between beast and superman, which I find fairly interesting.

Drakov's curse is not particularly well-defined, but in my campaign (and fan fiction) I'm giving him a backstory where he is a semi-literate mercenary leader trying to do the right thing and ally with the people who have the war-torn nation's best interests at heart. Unfortunately, he's in above his head with intrigues and deceptions that he can't even understand, so he ends up furthering the goals of the wrong factions. In Ravenloft, he is one of the few other DLs who knows Azalin's true nature, and he fervently believes that Azalin must be overthrown for the good of all living men - and he's not afraid to unite the rest of the Core by force to topple him.

Of course, such a noble goal is outright impossible, given how cack-handedly Drakov deals with his other neighboring states. Instead of a military alliance against the common foe, Drakov has made himself into the uniting enemy for his neighbors. His curse is to see his own efforts dissolve in a wave of indifference, and his own nation despised and hated by everybody else in the Core.

Posted: Sat Aug 22, 2009 8:48 am
by Tobias Blackburn
HuManBing wrote:Oddly, I find the DLs with "lost-love" style curses less compelling. Sadly, most DLs have "lost-love" style curses, whether it's Azalin's sorrow for his son, or Strahd/Ivana/d'Honaire/Renier/Thakok-An/Soth/Gabrielle for their respective dating histories. Gabrielle Aderre is particularly uninteresting for me - her curse has led to a quasi-soap-opera parade of lovers and drama which strikes me as being not so much tragic as faintly unnecessary and impractically complicated.

I'm largely unsympathetic to that because it's an affliction that is intensely personal, so there's not that much of interest to somebody else. Being in love is like experiencing a religious revelation, or writing some inspiring poetry: It sounds great to you, but everybody else is strangely unmoved by it. Plus, being in love is an ethically neutral endeavor. It benefits only that one person (and maybe the object of their attention). The rest of society doesn't care, and with good reason.
I think that its somewhat of a disservice to lump all of these darklords together as having a curse of "lost love".

Strahd definitely has lost love, but it works well for him. After a life spent dedicated to duty and war he met the one woman who made him feel alive. He gave up his honor, his family, his humanity for her, and still he lost her. Now he relives that loss over and over again.

Azalin's curse isn't lost love. It is the inability to rectify what he sees as his greatest failure. He executed Irik because he had broken the laws he had set out, but at the same time he blamed himself for having failed to raise the boy rightly. He seeks to raise Irik not due to the love a father has for his son, but so that he can give the boy a second chance to do things correctly (and raise a proper king to rule over his people). If you insist of the love aspect though, he lost a family member over a disagreement and wants to put this right.

Soth 's main curse was the loss of his memory, of his story. He wanted Kit again, but it wasn't as tormenting to him as the loss of his story. Knowing who he was and what he had done was really all he had after all. He felt something for Kit, but he didn't spend his every moment hunting for her. At the same time, he didn't want her for love, he wanted her for a companion in his eternal torment. There is a difference between himself and Strahd.

Ivana was pushed to her darkness by seeing her love seduced by her mother. But she doesn't pine for him. Her curse is that she is eternally cut off from being able to love someone. Eternally young, eternally beautiful, eternally alone. Can you imagine never being able to be with the one you love without killing them?

Meanwhile Dominic isn't pining for anyone. He's a momma's boy who craves female attention. The problem is that anyone he would really want to give it to him he can't manipulate them with his powers and they become more repulsive and hideous to him the more they feel for him. That's not really lost love. And who wouldn't be horrified to find that they couldn't stand ANYONE that actually loved them.

Jackie Renier isn't really lost love either. She's terrified of being alone and she is capable of love, but her curse is to be shown as the monster she is whenever she is at her most vulnerable with someone she loves. That's an extremely painful and humiliating rejection, and even those who haven't gone through it wince at that type of moment.

Thakok-An I can't really say. Her devotion caused the death of her city and her Lord/God/Love. Her curse is likely to want to make things right, but also to be terrified of what will happen should he awaken.

Finally, Gabrielle doesn't have much to do with love. Her curse isn't that she pines for a lost love, its that she can't have a family. She lives in constant panic as she manipulates people that she starts to care about to her own ends, and at the same time knows that she is destroying that which she wants most.

Love isn't that simple. Even for those on the outside, who may not understand why you feel as strongly as you do, the strength of the feeling and what is denied to you is something that every human being can feel for.

Everyone can understand the pain of losing the one you care about most over and over again, or having lost someone due to a disagreement and wanted to make things right. Or of needing a companion of some sort to slake the loneliness. The need for human contact and attention are central to our beings and the loss of that is unthinkable for so many, and who hasn't feared that moment of rejection when you are naked and exposed in front of the one you care about most. Who hasn't feared the response of a loved one when you know you really screwed up, or seen a relationship about to fall apart because of your actions and feared the coming catastrophe.

Its all part of the human experience, and its something we often forget. Its easy to look at all these darklords and wave a hand and say "lost love", but what hurts them and torments them is different for each and everyone of them, and each suffers in a way that strikes at one of the most important emotions humanity has.
Drakov's curse is not particularly well-defined, but in my campaign (and fan fiction) I'm giving him a backstory where he is a semi-literate mercenary leader trying to do the right thing and ally with the people who have the war-torn nation's best interests at heart. Unfortunately, he's in above his head with intrigues and deceptions that he can't even understand, so he ends up furthering the goals of the wrong factions. In Ravenloft, he is one of the few other DLs who knows Azalin's true nature, and he fervently believes that Azalin must be overthrown for the good of all living men - and he's not afraid to unite the rest of the Core by force to topple him.

Of course, such a noble goal is outright impossible, given how cack-handedly Drakov deals with his other neighboring states. Instead of a military alliance against the common foe, Drakov has made himself into the uniting enemy for his neighbors. His curse is to see his own efforts dissolve in a wave of indifference, and his own nation despised and hated by everybody else in the Core.
Drakov's curse is actually pretty well defined. He wants to rule a great nation and be seen as a great, powerful and feared leader. But he can never achieve that goal. He can never succeed in crushing his neighbours and so suffers humiliating military defeats. The neighbouring leaders look at him and see nothing but a bully, brute, and lowly soldier who happened to get to the top of the ladder by luck and sheer brutality. Everything he does is looked down on. He can only inspire fear and scorn, never the respect he believes he deserves.

He could have that respect by using the wealth of Falknovia to good use and create a worthwhile country, but instead he squanders it on wasteful carnage he can never win, blatently ignoring the supernatural aspects of the domains, willingly crippling his forces by rejecting things like magic.

Not every darklord has to be a tragic figure. I'm perfectly fine with Drakov being the lone unthinking brute in the bunch. As written up his curse suits him just fine.

Posted: Sat Aug 22, 2009 9:13 am
by brilliantlight
Tobias Blackburn wrote:
Drakov's curse is not particularly well-defined, but in my campaign (and fan fiction) I'm giving him a backstory where he is a semi-literate mercenary leader trying to do the right thing and ally with the people who have the war-torn nation's best interests at heart. Unfortunately, he's in above his head with intrigues and deceptions that he can't even understand, so he ends up furthering the goals of the wrong factions. In Ravenloft, he is one of the few other DLs who knows Azalin's true nature, and he fervently believes that Azalin must be overthrown for the good of all living men - and he's not afraid to unite the rest of the Core by force to topple him.

Of course, such a noble goal is outright impossible, given how cack-handedly Drakov deals with his other neighboring states. Instead of a military alliance against the common foe, Drakov has made himself into the uniting enemy for his neighbors. His curse is to see his own efforts dissolve in a wave of indifference, and his own nation despised and hated by everybody else in the Core.
Drakov's curse is actually pretty well defined. He wants to rule a great nation and be seen as a great, powerful and feared leader. But he can never achieve that goal. He can never succeed in crushing his neighbours and so suffers humiliating military defeats. The neighbouring leaders look at him and see nothing but a bully, brute, and lowly soldier who happened to get to the top of the ladder by luck and sheer brutality. Everything he does is looked down on. He can only inspire fear and scorn, never the respect he believes he deserves.

He could have that respect by using the wealth of Falknovia to good use and create a worthwhile country, but instead he squanders it on wasteful carnage he can never win, blatently ignoring the supernatural aspects of the domains, willingly crippling his forces by rejecting things like magic.

Not every darklord has to be a tragic figure. I'm perfectly fine with Drakov being the lone unthinking brute in the bunch. As written up his curse suits him just fine.
I agree with you here, why change Drakov so much? Drakov is fine for representing the kind of blood thirsty tyrant that history is full of.

Posted: Sun Aug 23, 2009 1:48 am
by HuManBing
[edits]

If you don't like my changes, don't use them. But I thought there was a need.

I was not alone, either - somewhere on this board are threads detailing several posters' proposed changes to DLs and their backstories, including a large section on Drakov. It inspired me to research and write a fan fiction exploring Drakov's backstory on Krynn, which is still being written (fitfully) two years after starting.



If you find the old threads (I don't have the URLs, sadly) you'll see counterarguments and rebuttals and the whole discussion presenting both viewpoints. I don't think I have the eloquence or patience to do it justice here.

Posted: Sun Aug 23, 2009 8:22 am
by Tobias Blackburn
HuManBing wrote:[edits]

If you don't like my changes, don't use them. But I thought there was a need.

I was not alone, either - somewhere on this board are threads detailing several posters' proposed changes to DLs and their backstories, including a large section on Drakov. It inspired me to research and write a fan fiction exploring Drakov's backstory on Krynn, which is still being written (fitfully) two years after starting.



If you find the old threads (I don't have the URLs, sadly) you'll see counterarguments and rebuttals and the whole discussion presenting both viewpoints. I don't think I have the eloquence or patience to do it justice here.
I didn't mean this as an attack on you, HuManBing. I haven't been part of any of those discussions (well, maybe I have, but I haven't been here for over two years), so I don't know what the arguments were. I also haven't read your fan fiction since coming back but am attempting to work my way through that forum at the moment and will likely get to it soon.

What you said was that you felt his curse was not particularly well defined and that is what I was disagreeing with. It is clearly spelled out in the first two paragraphs of his current sketch in Gazetteer II. It's clearly spelled out in Domains of Dread as well.

That you don't like the character's background or current sketch and change it to something more to your liking so perfectly fine. Everyone makes changes to the way the world works. But again, that isn't the issue you brought up. We are discussing which Dark Lords you didn't find sympathetic and you said you didn't sympathize with Drakov because his curse wasn't well defined. Personally I don't sympathize with Drakov in the slightest, but I can see the need for a couple of guys like him in Ravenloft. The guys everyone can feel good about hating purely on principle and smash without worrying about silly things like empathy to their situation or pathos. But you will have to notice that I did not attack the changes you made, just questioned whether they were necessary based on how well defined his curse was.

I can understand why you might want to change him so drastically. Not a problem, its your game and you can change the setting anyway you want for the story you want to tell. Again though, I wasn't attacking you or your work. I never once commented on the ideas you presented themselves. Now that I know where I can read more about them I will do so with an open mind and reserve judgment until after I have finished and digested it a while. If you feel open to comments I'll make some then, either in the appropriate discussion thread or though private message, whichever you prefer.

I'm sorry if you took my comments any other way, by they were not meant to attack you or the quality of the works or changes you had made. I was simply discussing the premise you had used for justifying your changes and the general tone of them changes themselves within that justification.

Posted: Sun Aug 23, 2009 9:37 am
by HuManBing
Sorry, after two years' mucking around with the backstory, I do tend to get defensive when people ask questions like "why would you want to..." or "what's the need for...". It's rather like an inventor who's spent his life perfecting the best design for an oil lamp when he hears about these fun little inventions called "Batteries".
:shock:

:evil:
It all boils down to personal taste, for sure. But I guess I'm trying to show that the sincerity of my desire to rewrite Drakov's backstory is very genuine.

You, however, are free to draw whatever inferences you want about the sanity of my obsessive endeavor... and I have no defenses for that. :)

Posted: Sun Aug 23, 2009 10:03 am
by Tobias Blackburn
HuManBing wrote:Sorry, after two years' mucking around with the backstory, I do tend to get defensive when people ask questions like "why would you want to..." or "what's the need for...". It's rather like an inventor who's spent his life perfecting the best design for an oil lamp when he hears about these fun little inventions called "Batteries".
:shock:

:evil:
It all boils down to personal taste, for sure. But I guess I'm trying to show that the sincerity of my desire to rewrite Drakov's backstory is very genuine.

You, however, are free to draw whatever inferences you want about the sanity of my obsessive endeavor... and I have no defenses for that. :)
Not a problem. I know what it's like to work hard on something and have someone make a comment that seems to dismiss the entire work. As I said, that wasn't my intention.

All the Dark Lords have room for change, and I completely understand why you would want to flesh him into an actual character rather than just a gruff, unthinking sadistic monster. I don't usually use Falknovia that much other than a "it could be worse" example, so I have never had much problem leaving him as a straight forward, unsympathetic brutal tyrant. At the same time he has never struck me as very tragic character, let alone one that fits the gothic sensibility of Azalin, Strahd, Godefry or most of the others, so I would probably do the same thing as you have done if I wanted to make him a feature of the campaign.

I'm actually in the middle of fleshing out the Phantom Lover for a campaign that is about the get off the ground, trying to turn him into an evil yet sympathetic character. Of course, I'm working on a single guy from a pocket domain in a small 2e supplement, while you've put major effort into rewriting an important and heavily used and referenced characters in the core. Obviously your changes are going to be more controversial than mine.

I'll give you a few comments after I've had time to go through your material. I'm interested to see what you did. :wink:

Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 11:00 am
by brilliantlight
I, myself have no problem using Drakov as is. There have been a number of leaders in history that were as evil as Drakov is. To round him out I gave him a couple virtues that don't conflict with the canon character. One is a sense of honor when he makes an agreement he sticks to it. Unless you break the agreement with Drakov you can count on it being honored. Along with that he is not a hypocrite by any means. He doesn't condemn people for being violent lunatics but sticks them in the army. He doesn't care if you get drunk or hop from bed to bed to bed. He doesn't expect people to not do what he does himself on a personal level.

Posted: Mon Aug 31, 2009 10:24 pm
by HuManBing
I like that portrayal, and actually to me, the most poignant alignment in the DnD system is Lawful Evil.

These are the people who have committed whatever acts that have destroyed their inner moral workings... but they still have enough ethical integrity left to respect their word and the legal order around them.

Azalin is LE. Drakov (as written) is NE, but I've personally preferred a more LE cast to his character. And Strahd is CE in the rules but in most fiction portrayals he's closer to LE too.

It's easy to fear and respect a LE villain, in a way that's harder to do for a NE or CE one.

Posted: Tue Sep 01, 2009 7:27 am
by ewancummins
brilliantlight wrote:I, myself have no problem using Drakov as is. There have been a number of leaders in history that were as evil as Drakov is. To round him out I gave him a couple virtues that don't conflict with the canon character. One is a sense of honor when he makes an agreement he sticks to it. Unless you break the agreement with Drakov you can count on it being honored. Along with that he is not a hypocrite by any means. He doesn't condemn people for being violent lunatics but sticks them in the army. He doesn't care if you get drunk or hop from bed to bed to bed. He doesn't expect people to not do what he does himself on a personal level.

I like that. He's an honest monster.

Posted: Tue Sep 01, 2009 7:07 pm
by brilliantlight
Thanks, I always prefered LE villians myself. They tend to be more sophisticated and more successful. For me LE is clearly the most dangerous alignment. Orginized evil is much more dangerous than a bunch of raving loons . Random violence is far less dangerous to society than orginized evil. A bunch of thugs are far less dangerous than the SS or Stalin's NKVD.

Posted: Fri Sep 04, 2009 10:18 am
by HuManBing
For organizations, yes, Lawful Evil is the most dangerous way to go. Also, if you're interested in giving your villain some redeeming qualities so that the audience will have some points of sympathy for them, the "lawful" part could allow them to see him as an honorable duty-bound person, even if they can never agree with his brutality.

But if you're talking about lone wolf operatives, then Neutral Evil may be better, in my opinion. Absent any legal ethical framework, these villains are purely dangerous. Anton Chigurh from No Country For Old Men strikes me as Neutral Evil. He kills people almost on a whim (or at least, if there is a rhyme or reason to his actions, they're known only to himself) and he is very very good at what he does.

The Heath Ledger Joker from The Dark Knight struck me as a good portrayal of Chaotic Evil. But even then, there were sequences where he described his organization's methods, and I found those sequences hard to square away with a random chaotic persona.