So Toben the many started as the child of a goodly author of games? Interesting. What may have turned him to a thief and murderer that eventually became such a creature?Joël of the FoS wrote:alhoon, I believe Toben is Rucht's child.
Questions for the Designers
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
If you knew how little being a goodly author of games pays, it becomes obvious.
He turned to theft to support his family, which his father couldn't do. He probably turned to murder to teach his father a "lesson" about responsible parenting. And it was all downhill from there
Why does no one ever think of the impoverished families of game designers?
He turned to theft to support his family, which his father couldn't do. He probably turned to murder to teach his father a "lesson" about responsible parenting. And it was all downhill from there
Why does no one ever think of the impoverished families of game designers?
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
No really. That's a neat idea. Not sure if I'll use it for Toben or another undead creepy thing though.Ryan Naylor wrote:If you knew how little being a goodly author of games pays, it becomes obvious.
He turned to theft to support his family, which his father couldn't do. He probably turned to murder to teach his father a "lesson" about responsible parenting. And it was all downhill from there
Why does no one ever think of the impoverished families of game designers?
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
In my next twisted wish . . .Ryan Naylor wrote:If you knew how little being a goodly author of games pays, it becomes obvious.
He turned to theft to support his family, which his father couldn't do. He probably turned to murder to teach his father a "lesson" about responsible parenting. And it was all downhill from there
Why does no one ever think of the impoverished families of game designers?
The cure for what ails you
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7108
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
It would eventually be fun to know who wrote what. We have a good idea for most of the Gaz, but not for many of the other books.
Joël
Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7108
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
OK then.
Please bear in mind this was all about 7 years ago, so my memory may fail on some details. Plus, I'm really self-centred, so everything is filtered through that lens.
First, I should say that I was very lucky to work with Rucht on VRGttWD. When we were talking about the basic ideas, we clicked really well and found we had very similar ideas about what we were going to do, which I think is reflected in the positive reviews the book got on release. He was particularly good natured about me demanding access to everything he'd written so I could edit it for tone and content.
The authors of most of the multi-author books written under Arthaus (in my experience at least) weren't really encouraged to interact with each other. The Kargatane did, obviously, because (a) we talked to each other (b) I wanted to steal any good ideas they might have had and (c) I thought it was a matter of professional courtesy, since we were all working on the same line.
Perhaps naively, we expected the developers to ensure that style, tone and characterisation were consistent between different authors. Then the Mordent Gazetteer came out and we all had a bit of a panic about it. So I was determined to make sure something like that didn't happen here.
And as I said, Rucht was very good about it.
I think Rucht originally just intended it to be a guide to skeletons and zombies, but I was slightly more ambitious. VRGtGhosts was essentially a guide to all incorporeal undead, so I decided that the time had come for VRGt the corporeal dead*. I crunched numbers for days to make sure that, using the creation lab in the Appendix, you could use the salient abilities to make every corporeal undead in the Monster Manual and Denizens of Darkness except the devourer. Certainly all the Ravenloft-specific undead ever mentioned anywhere are in there somewhere.
* Except liches, ancient dead and vampires, obviously.
So I sketched out the plan for the book and we divided it fairly evenly between us. You can actually tell who wrote what, I think, based on who the narrator for the chapter is. I was familiar with the VRGs, so I wrote as Laurie and Gennifer. Rucht was only familiar with VRA, and thought that other characters were meant to actually narrate the books, so his chapters are all narrated by people other than the twins. This is particularly obvious in the chapter on Restless Dead, where Rucht wrote all the bits narrated by Ratik and I wrote everything else as Alanik Ray and the twins. Rucht wrote really intense dialogue for Ratik, so I of course mocked him about it in Alanik's commentary.
Anyway, I get ahead of myself.
I wrote the Introduction and Necrology, which is where I came up with the idea of the Craving which drove all of the walking dead and the idea that DMs needed to hammer home the idea that the walking dead were once people, both of which came to permeate the book.
Rucht wrote the Obedient Dead.
I wrote the Hungry Dead, which, along with Necrology, was my favourite chapter, and the whole reason I wanted to do the book. Essentially, I'd just seen Ravenous and wanted to make a joke about it - and that's why this book exists, because I wanted to make a silly pun about a film title.
As I already said, Rucht wrote his half of the Restless Dead, then I wrote my half around what he'd written.
I wrote Weaknesses.
Rucht wrote Necromancers, which I've always thought is something that the twins in character probably wouldn't have published, but the book probably needed it.
I wrote Hunting the Walking Dead, and a tiny fraction of the Appendix, but Rucht did the lion's share.
Then I demanded everything he'd written and edited it. Or possibly just wanted to, not because it was bad but because I'm a control freak.
And the only thing that people remember from the book, Toben the Many, was completely and utterly down to Rucht.
Anything else anyone's curious about?
EDITED because I'm wrong: Rucht wrote the Introduction. So sorry.
Please bear in mind this was all about 7 years ago, so my memory may fail on some details. Plus, I'm really self-centred, so everything is filtered through that lens.
First, I should say that I was very lucky to work with Rucht on VRGttWD. When we were talking about the basic ideas, we clicked really well and found we had very similar ideas about what we were going to do, which I think is reflected in the positive reviews the book got on release. He was particularly good natured about me demanding access to everything he'd written so I could edit it for tone and content.
The authors of most of the multi-author books written under Arthaus (in my experience at least) weren't really encouraged to interact with each other. The Kargatane did, obviously, because (a) we talked to each other (b) I wanted to steal any good ideas they might have had and (c) I thought it was a matter of professional courtesy, since we were all working on the same line.
Perhaps naively, we expected the developers to ensure that style, tone and characterisation were consistent between different authors. Then the Mordent Gazetteer came out and we all had a bit of a panic about it. So I was determined to make sure something like that didn't happen here.
And as I said, Rucht was very good about it.
I think Rucht originally just intended it to be a guide to skeletons and zombies, but I was slightly more ambitious. VRGtGhosts was essentially a guide to all incorporeal undead, so I decided that the time had come for VRGt the corporeal dead*. I crunched numbers for days to make sure that, using the creation lab in the Appendix, you could use the salient abilities to make every corporeal undead in the Monster Manual and Denizens of Darkness except the devourer. Certainly all the Ravenloft-specific undead ever mentioned anywhere are in there somewhere.
* Except liches, ancient dead and vampires, obviously.
So I sketched out the plan for the book and we divided it fairly evenly between us. You can actually tell who wrote what, I think, based on who the narrator for the chapter is. I was familiar with the VRGs, so I wrote as Laurie and Gennifer. Rucht was only familiar with VRA, and thought that other characters were meant to actually narrate the books, so his chapters are all narrated by people other than the twins. This is particularly obvious in the chapter on Restless Dead, where Rucht wrote all the bits narrated by Ratik and I wrote everything else as Alanik Ray and the twins. Rucht wrote really intense dialogue for Ratik, so I of course mocked him about it in Alanik's commentary.
Anyway, I get ahead of myself.
I wrote the Introduction and Necrology, which is where I came up with the idea of the Craving which drove all of the walking dead and the idea that DMs needed to hammer home the idea that the walking dead were once people, both of which came to permeate the book.
Rucht wrote the Obedient Dead.
I wrote the Hungry Dead, which, along with Necrology, was my favourite chapter, and the whole reason I wanted to do the book. Essentially, I'd just seen Ravenous and wanted to make a joke about it - and that's why this book exists, because I wanted to make a silly pun about a film title.
As I already said, Rucht wrote his half of the Restless Dead, then I wrote my half around what he'd written.
I wrote Weaknesses.
Rucht wrote Necromancers, which I've always thought is something that the twins in character probably wouldn't have published, but the book probably needed it.
I wrote Hunting the Walking Dead, and a tiny fraction of the Appendix, but Rucht did the lion's share.
Then I demanded everything he'd written and edited it. Or possibly just wanted to, not because it was bad but because I'm a control freak.
And the only thing that people remember from the book, Toben the Many, was completely and utterly down to Rucht.
Anything else anyone's curious about?
EDITED because I'm wrong: Rucht wrote the Introduction. So sorry.
Last edited by Ryan Naylor on Mon Dec 28, 2009 5:20 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
Oh, and, in the end I always thought that the mistake in the narration of the chapters actually came to represent the twins' progression as monster hunters really well:
In VRA, they rely almost entirely on their friends for information.
In VRGttWD, they've got their own experiences to draw on, but otherwise still need a lot of expert help.
Until, by later books, it's almost entirely their own work.
In VRA, they rely almost entirely on their friends for information.
In VRGttWD, they've got their own experiences to draw on, but otherwise still need a lot of expert help.
Until, by later books, it's almost entirely their own work.
The following are a pair of Dread Possibilities that didn't survive the cutting room floor that Ryan was kind enough to share with me a few years bacK:
"Dread Possibility: The Keeper of Secrets
The Keeper of Secrets is a strange entity native to the Plane of Shadow. It entered Ravenloft seven years ago, when Loht opened the Obsidian Gate, and has taken a lair near the Barovian-Nova Vaasan border overlooking the Shadow Rift.
The Keeper is a NE aberration that captures the secrets brought to it on the wind. It occassionally passes on some of this information in exchange for a secret of greater rarity.
Blindspot (Ex): The Keeper is unable to be seen by any magical divination, including scrying and fortune telling. This has protected it from Count Strahd and his Vistani minions.
Creature of Darkness (Ex): The Keeper is composed of shadowstuff. When in complete darkness, it is solid—visitors can hear its clicking footsteps and feel the occasional brush of a feathery antennae or slimy tendril. In any kind of light, however, it is invisible and incorporeal, although its whispery voice can still be heard. In direct sunlight, the Keeper takes 1d4 points of damage per round.
Maddening Whispers (Su): The Keeper’s lair is filled with the quiet susurrus of its trapped secrets, all of which are desperate to be told. The constant, quiet whispering can drive visitors mad; they must make a Madness save (DC 14) for every ten minutes spent in the Keeper’s lair.
Secrets (Ex): The Keeper has captured many secrets in its lair and sometimes shares them, but if it particularly prizes a secret, it will lie to ensure that it is the only creature that possesses that knowledge. It also takes pleasure in revealing secrets that humiliate or cause harm.
To determine the chance the Keeper knows a particular piece of information, the DM must decide how widely known the secret is, and then roll to see if the Keeper lies. If it doesn’t, the DM must roll again to determine if the Keeper knows the information. If the petitioner exchanges a secret of greater rarity for the knowledge, reduce the % Lie by 10. The content of the secret is unimportant compared to the rarity; the Keeper prizes a unique magical spell as much as knowing who stole a peasant’s goose. Because the secrets are brought to the Keeper on the wind, the information must have once been spoken aloud for the Keeper to know it.
[PRODUCTION—PLEASE ALIGN THE FOLLOWING INTO A TABLE]
Rarity % Lie % Known
Common 10 45
Uncommon 20 60
Rare 30 70
Very Rare 40 80
Unique 50 95
[END TABLE]
True Seeing (Su): The Keeper of Secrets has permanent true seeing. If dispelled, it can recast the spell as a free action.
Dread Possibility: Fractures
The Shadow Rift is an imperfection in the planar fabric of the Demiplane of Dread, caused by Gwydion’s attempt to escape the Obsidian Gate during the Grand Conjunction. In trying to pull himself free, the sorcerer-fiend uprooted the entire domain and dragged it with him, shattering the Dark Power’s carefully organized handiwork. Like a piece of glass smashed with a hammer, the Rift is a gaping hole in the Core, and Fractures radiate like cracks into the more complete domains around it. All these pathways exist outside, or perhaps between, time and space and allow the fey to enter other domains. Most lead to the Rift’s neighbors, but they can potentially open into any domain. Traversing any of the Fractures is a disturbing experience of bizarre, half-remembered impossibilities. The Fracture leading from Mordent to the Darkenheights, for example, is lined with invisible people who demand passers by surrender their equipment, their clothes and finally their bodies before they can ‘go down’. Those who do emerge as incorporeal spirits; those who don’t never emerge.
Transient Fractures: Several Fractures only intersect the material world on particular occasions, such as a solstice or equinox. Because of the temporal fugue, these Fractures only open once every 26 years for those inside the Shadow Rift. Others vary in their destination depending on arcane but clearly defined conditions. The Fracture at the bottom of Loch Lenore, for example, opens into Saragoss when the Seelie Court is in power but into Lake Amenta in Nidala when the Unseelie Court is. Another only opens when its opening on the surface is in shadow.
Keyed Fractures: Keyed Fractures only open if a particular action is performed or condition fulfilled by the person trying to pass through. Examples include walking 13 times anticlockwise around a particular barrow mound, or a Fracture that only opens if an Innocent touches the inside of a cleft tree.
Guarded Fractures: Many are protected by strange and fearsome guardians. This can be a good excuse to use creatures that may not otherwise fit into a Ravenloft campaign. As a rule, they should have a CR of at least 12. For example, one Fracture is watched by the Hound, an immensely strong half-dog, half-giant, who must be fought for the journey to be completed. Another leads from a goblin lair in the Mountains of Misery and is guarded by a balor (with no reality wrinkle)."
Are there any other lost Dread Possibilities out there that might be saved, perhaps in an unofficial web extra by the FoS?
"Dread Possibility: The Keeper of Secrets
The Keeper of Secrets is a strange entity native to the Plane of Shadow. It entered Ravenloft seven years ago, when Loht opened the Obsidian Gate, and has taken a lair near the Barovian-Nova Vaasan border overlooking the Shadow Rift.
The Keeper is a NE aberration that captures the secrets brought to it on the wind. It occassionally passes on some of this information in exchange for a secret of greater rarity.
Blindspot (Ex): The Keeper is unable to be seen by any magical divination, including scrying and fortune telling. This has protected it from Count Strahd and his Vistani minions.
Creature of Darkness (Ex): The Keeper is composed of shadowstuff. When in complete darkness, it is solid—visitors can hear its clicking footsteps and feel the occasional brush of a feathery antennae or slimy tendril. In any kind of light, however, it is invisible and incorporeal, although its whispery voice can still be heard. In direct sunlight, the Keeper takes 1d4 points of damage per round.
Maddening Whispers (Su): The Keeper’s lair is filled with the quiet susurrus of its trapped secrets, all of which are desperate to be told. The constant, quiet whispering can drive visitors mad; they must make a Madness save (DC 14) for every ten minutes spent in the Keeper’s lair.
Secrets (Ex): The Keeper has captured many secrets in its lair and sometimes shares them, but if it particularly prizes a secret, it will lie to ensure that it is the only creature that possesses that knowledge. It also takes pleasure in revealing secrets that humiliate or cause harm.
To determine the chance the Keeper knows a particular piece of information, the DM must decide how widely known the secret is, and then roll to see if the Keeper lies. If it doesn’t, the DM must roll again to determine if the Keeper knows the information. If the petitioner exchanges a secret of greater rarity for the knowledge, reduce the % Lie by 10. The content of the secret is unimportant compared to the rarity; the Keeper prizes a unique magical spell as much as knowing who stole a peasant’s goose. Because the secrets are brought to the Keeper on the wind, the information must have once been spoken aloud for the Keeper to know it.
[PRODUCTION—PLEASE ALIGN THE FOLLOWING INTO A TABLE]
Rarity % Lie % Known
Common 10 45
Uncommon 20 60
Rare 30 70
Very Rare 40 80
Unique 50 95
[END TABLE]
True Seeing (Su): The Keeper of Secrets has permanent true seeing. If dispelled, it can recast the spell as a free action.
Dread Possibility: Fractures
The Shadow Rift is an imperfection in the planar fabric of the Demiplane of Dread, caused by Gwydion’s attempt to escape the Obsidian Gate during the Grand Conjunction. In trying to pull himself free, the sorcerer-fiend uprooted the entire domain and dragged it with him, shattering the Dark Power’s carefully organized handiwork. Like a piece of glass smashed with a hammer, the Rift is a gaping hole in the Core, and Fractures radiate like cracks into the more complete domains around it. All these pathways exist outside, or perhaps between, time and space and allow the fey to enter other domains. Most lead to the Rift’s neighbors, but they can potentially open into any domain. Traversing any of the Fractures is a disturbing experience of bizarre, half-remembered impossibilities. The Fracture leading from Mordent to the Darkenheights, for example, is lined with invisible people who demand passers by surrender their equipment, their clothes and finally their bodies before they can ‘go down’. Those who do emerge as incorporeal spirits; those who don’t never emerge.
Transient Fractures: Several Fractures only intersect the material world on particular occasions, such as a solstice or equinox. Because of the temporal fugue, these Fractures only open once every 26 years for those inside the Shadow Rift. Others vary in their destination depending on arcane but clearly defined conditions. The Fracture at the bottom of Loch Lenore, for example, opens into Saragoss when the Seelie Court is in power but into Lake Amenta in Nidala when the Unseelie Court is. Another only opens when its opening on the surface is in shadow.
Keyed Fractures: Keyed Fractures only open if a particular action is performed or condition fulfilled by the person trying to pass through. Examples include walking 13 times anticlockwise around a particular barrow mound, or a Fracture that only opens if an Innocent touches the inside of a cleft tree.
Guarded Fractures: Many are protected by strange and fearsome guardians. This can be a good excuse to use creatures that may not otherwise fit into a Ravenloft campaign. As a rule, they should have a CR of at least 12. For example, one Fracture is watched by the Hound, an immensely strong half-dog, half-giant, who must be fought for the journey to be completed. Another leads from a goblin lair in the Mountains of Misery and is guarded by a balor (with no reality wrinkle)."
Are there any other lost Dread Possibilities out there that might be saved, perhaps in an unofficial web extra by the FoS?
The cure for what ails you
I think by now just about everything has come to light. That the Kargatane ever had a hand in, regarding the published line, that is. I'm not sure that any of us know anything about the planned Masque of the Jade Dragon, for example.cure wrote:Are there any other lost Dread Possibilities out there that might be saved, perhaps in an unofficial web extra by the FoS?
- DeepShadow of FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 2923
- Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
- Location: Heinfroth's Asylum
Yeah, I'm not sure how much about Jade Horror I can talk about, though, because of how it was sealed up. Very frustrating. I was originally involved with Rucht on the Monsters appendix, and later took the character creation chapter from Steve Miller after he lost everything. About all I can tell you is that we were working under the title, "Masque of the Jade Horror."
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
- Joël of the FoS
- Moderator

- Posts: 7108
- Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: St-Damien, Québec
Thanks Ryan, Cure, John, DS, for the input!
Too bad we can’t have more info on MotJD…
Ever had a project to blend the bogeymen into an adventure?
For the cool spells part in VRA, where there spell ideas that you rejected for the final?
---

---
To all:
We have a good idea in the author notes about who wrote what for most of the books (except CoD and HoL, but it’s OK we don’t). What of the RL DMG?
Where there hidden jokes / puns that nobody ever found (or mentioned?)
Where there cool links or hidden mentions of things that nobody ever found (or mentioned?)
Joël
Too bad we can’t have more info on MotJD…
For your part in DT&DL, what did you change from the design of bogeymen from the original BoS article? What concept / corrections / whatever you changed when you rewrote this for DT&DL?Ryan Naylor wrote:Anything else anyone's curious about?
Ever had a project to blend the bogeymen into an adventure?
For the cool spells part in VRA, where there spell ideas that you rejected for the final?
---
If I may, there are darklords cut out of SotDR that are still on my Xmas wish listMangrum wrote: I think by now just about everything has come to light. That the Kargatane ever had a hand in, regarding the published line, that is.
---
To all:
We have a good idea in the author notes about who wrote what for most of the books (except CoD and HoL, but it’s OK we don’t). What of the RL DMG?
Where there hidden jokes / puns that nobody ever found (or mentioned?)
Where there cool links or hidden mentions of things that nobody ever found (or mentioned?)
Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
As for hidden jokes and pun and shout outs, I don't remember which ones have or haven't been found, and I'd probably have to re-read everything again to remind myself of what I put in there anyway. So unless there're more specific questions, I don't think I can answer that one.
Although I am surprised by how blatant a shout out there was to the Mines of Moria in that Dread Possibility. In fact, that whole dread possibility is really composed of shout outs to various legends (mostly Celtic).
I'm still a bit annoyed that they were all cut from the published product.
On bogeymen:
I made them a little more powerful compared to the versions from the BoS, and I obviously replaced the plagiarised ones with ones I couldn't be sued for using.
I thought a lot more about the concept and the concept of stories, and generally made everything a lot more recursive than it had been (Monsters made by stories in a story within a story being told as a weapon by a storytelling monster hunter named after the Brothers Grimm in a book about stories!) I think I took the design brief for DT&DL to heart the most of all the authors, although hopefully it wasn't as ridiculous as that summary makes it sound.
Other than that, I think things were expanded rather than changed, but I'm not really sure any more.
Obviously all the stuff outside of the bogeyman descriptions, which wasn't in the BoS article, was greatly expanded or created anew. And physically painful to write, I might add. That chapter was by far the hardest to finish of all the work I did. Which makes it particularly gratifying that it was so well received. I remember being very pleased that I'd made the front cover.
As far as I remember, Arthaus wasn't interested in publishing adventures, so there was never, ever going to be a bogeyman adventure. I believe RL always sold well as novels, and sold moderately as sourcebooks, but no one ever made any money from adventures.
Personally, I never thought about doing it as a fan project, because having worked up Shadow of the Knife from John's outline showed me what a nightmarish experience writing an adventure could be. One of the reasons Death Undaunted never appeared (although it is only one of quite a few) was because I couldn't face writing it up. I have no idea what John thinks of this idea or my write up of his adventure. From a couple of stylistic discussions we had, I suspect he thinks I'm a moron and would have died rather than let me touch Death Undaunted.
Anyway.
I think all the spells I seriously thought about made it into VRA. I'm a bit retentive like that, and because it was my first professional project and I was 18 or something, I was too excited to leave anything out. The only major idea that didn't go in was my desperate attempt to salvage something from Death of a Darklord. I devised what was essentially a Wild Magic table for Ravenloft to represent the warped magic the heroine of that book cast, and said it was a byproduct of the Grand Conjunction. I thought the Taint (as it was called) was a relatively innocuous thing to add, but the others didn't and gently suggested I get rid of it.
Finally, in terms of projects that never saw the light of day, the very last book that was discussed before the line folded (at least with me) was Lands of Nightmare. It was going to be a Gazetteer for 13 Pocket Domains, narrated by Dr. Ilhousen for his new born child as a monster hunter's guide and memoir should anything happen to him. Dr. Ilhousen essentially went around describing the lands he saw in people's dreams. But that never got beyond the bare concept stage; I don't think the developers even picked out authors to do it.
Although I am surprised by how blatant a shout out there was to the Mines of Moria in that Dread Possibility. In fact, that whole dread possibility is really composed of shout outs to various legends (mostly Celtic).
I'm still a bit annoyed that they were all cut from the published product.
On bogeymen:
I made them a little more powerful compared to the versions from the BoS, and I obviously replaced the plagiarised ones with ones I couldn't be sued for using.
I thought a lot more about the concept and the concept of stories, and generally made everything a lot more recursive than it had been (Monsters made by stories in a story within a story being told as a weapon by a storytelling monster hunter named after the Brothers Grimm in a book about stories!) I think I took the design brief for DT&DL to heart the most of all the authors, although hopefully it wasn't as ridiculous as that summary makes it sound.
Other than that, I think things were expanded rather than changed, but I'm not really sure any more.
Obviously all the stuff outside of the bogeyman descriptions, which wasn't in the BoS article, was greatly expanded or created anew. And physically painful to write, I might add. That chapter was by far the hardest to finish of all the work I did. Which makes it particularly gratifying that it was so well received. I remember being very pleased that I'd made the front cover.
As far as I remember, Arthaus wasn't interested in publishing adventures, so there was never, ever going to be a bogeyman adventure. I believe RL always sold well as novels, and sold moderately as sourcebooks, but no one ever made any money from adventures.
Personally, I never thought about doing it as a fan project, because having worked up Shadow of the Knife from John's outline showed me what a nightmarish experience writing an adventure could be. One of the reasons Death Undaunted never appeared (although it is only one of quite a few) was because I couldn't face writing it up. I have no idea what John thinks of this idea or my write up of his adventure. From a couple of stylistic discussions we had, I suspect he thinks I'm a moron and would have died rather than let me touch Death Undaunted.
Anyway.
I think all the spells I seriously thought about made it into VRA. I'm a bit retentive like that, and because it was my first professional project and I was 18 or something, I was too excited to leave anything out. The only major idea that didn't go in was my desperate attempt to salvage something from Death of a Darklord. I devised what was essentially a Wild Magic table for Ravenloft to represent the warped magic the heroine of that book cast, and said it was a byproduct of the Grand Conjunction. I thought the Taint (as it was called) was a relatively innocuous thing to add, but the others didn't and gently suggested I get rid of it.
Finally, in terms of projects that never saw the light of day, the very last book that was discussed before the line folded (at least with me) was Lands of Nightmare. It was going to be a Gazetteer for 13 Pocket Domains, narrated by Dr. Ilhousen for his new born child as a monster hunter's guide and memoir should anything happen to him. Dr. Ilhousen essentially went around describing the lands he saw in people's dreams. But that never got beyond the bare concept stage; I don't think the developers even picked out authors to do it.
