Well, not a according to Kuhn, who did a sociology of science, for lack of a better description. New theories are accepted when the old guard dies. Take Einstein . . . . please. He understood quantum theory but dismissed it with the phrase: "God doesn't play dice with the universe." Ignore the God part of the phrase. The point is rather that quantum offended Einstein's sensibilities because the indeterminism at its heart undermined the possibility of a thoroughgoing scientific determination of all existence. Science appeals to "values" such as simplicity, elegance, and mathematical determinacy, with no clear criteria for balancing between them, or especially clear grounds for upholding them. Hence, there is lots of room for disagreement, agendas, even bigotry of a sort. Throw God or Gods into the mix, and things get really fun: deitism, best of all possible worlds, intelligent design, etc.Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:A true scientist would never want to remain ignorant of anything, even if it would be convenient to do so. If something supposedly supernatural were explained as a scientific truth, a true scientist would accept it and integrate it into his or her worldview. That's the scientific method at its purest, no?
In other terms, even if we can agree on what appears to be, we may not, as Rotipher suggested, agree on what should be. The floating of the distinction between first and secondary qualities, was an attempt to delegitimise a vast range of everyday phenomena so as to better get after the 'Truth' behind them.
So magic then is an illusion, not an illusion without bite, but a thoroughgoing barbarism of the 'Truth', which is standing right behind it for anyone with the good sense to look. Wizards sacrifice virgins to make it 'work' when 'reasonable' men would instead be crossing wires to produce properly predictable and perfectly controlled effects. Of course when 'reasonable' men fail in this, they get very embarassed and very angry, and consequently would be all to happy to take out their frustration on any available wizards.



