The sin of lust, and its punishment

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Ail
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3429
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 7:33 am
Location: Egham, UK

Post by Ail »

On the other hand, if I'm permitted to go on, the religious restriction on sex is quite normal and understandable when you look at religion as a kind of normative law which has little confidence in the people it is trying to regulate.

Why? Hmmm, this might be controversial, but sex is too good. It is a temptation, something that with lack of discipline can detract from productive work, let's say. Its being a temptation also means it is potentially corruptive of morals, like wine and other addictive substances. Also, due to its potential consequences (pregnancy) it may be deregulatory of the familial structure of the community.

In communities where this is important, sex has to be heavily regulated. As has alcohol, gaming and all other substances / behaviours that can lead to a compulsive, lazy (for lack of a better term), irresponsible behaviour for good citizens (I'm thinking mostly of a society 2000 years ago, but it can also apply today. Some of this does remind me of the XVII / XVIII (?) century puritans). Where you do not trust the morals and self-discipline of your people you have to regulate in an absolute manner. You can not afford to let people discern the exceptions, where somethign is good and where that same thing is bad. So you forbid almost everywhere, and that's it.

Let me come back now to the Schools of Mysteries of antiquity, just to try to make this point a bit clearer. These schools are, in a way, the predecessors of a big organization like the Catholic church, and I find the Church as we know it is a School of Mysteries, but much more complex.

Such a school has a Mystery (one, to simplify), which is unsuitable to teach everyone. Why is it unsuitable? Because it is too complex to be correctly understood. Such a secret is too complex to properly understand, it may be something like 'how to behave properly in respect to God' or something, or 'when to throw the seed to the earth'. This secret might have an easy general answer, but of limited applicability. However, it should work as a good rule of thumb. This is what you'll teach in your exoteric doctrine (that which can be freel published). But that is all the public will ever know. To your initiates, those who study more and gradually pass the ranks to the ultimate secret, you can begin teaching your esoteric doctrine (that which is reserved for the insiders. Note the difference between 'exo' and 'eso'). In this, you will teach the exceptions, the variants and the subtleties of the basic rule, probably teaching many situations in which the correct answer is the opposite of what is taught to all. But this can only be grasped after a long study, and after all the intricacies are understood. Thus it is reserved for the initiates.

Of course, people who only know the basics and take it as gospel may become zealots who think an initiate is acting wrong when they see him following one of the subtler teachings they don't know of. I see many of these things in Catholic church. We are taught the basic exoteric doctrine without knowing the rationale behind it, because it is the consequence of century upon century of logical deduction and implication. If a tenet would be reversed now, like for example 'priests can marry' or 'homosexuality is not wrong' that might suddenly invalidate another tenet that was what implied the former in the first place. That, in its turn, would invalidate an earlier tenet which might eventually reach up the tree to one of the basic dogmas of the church. And if that is the case, then of course the tenet can not be removed. That is why the Church changes so slowly, in my view.

All of this now comes back to the beginning. Why is sex almost always wrong? Because now, you don't have to teach to your flock all of the subtle situations in which it might be right, all the implications of doing it this or that way, of not doing it at all, of breaking this or that norm (but not an essential tenet, just a simplification that was made for the exoteric doctrine because that would be the fail-safe default).

I even believe that there might be situations in which the hierarchy agrees that sex is good, the woman is not evil and all so forth, and that it can and is discussed among the initiates, but that it can never be taught to the public unless in an individual basis, which falls to the advice one priest may give to a few of his parishioners in particular situations.

It's like learning the piano, really. One day my teacher may say: 'you should always play this note like this', but then as I evolve begin saying 'now, instead, use your hand in this manner, you'll get a better sound' or in another say ' for this composer, taht won't work, you have to use this technique instead'.

So, forgive me for the length, I hope this is not too much of a tangent, and I hope to have made myself understood.
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
User avatar
High Priest Mikhal
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1642
Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
Gender: Male
Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.

Post by High Priest Mikhal »

DocBeard wrote:Your scholarship regarding the medieval Catholic Church is lacking, Mikhail.
Not my scholarship, DocBeard. I'm just stating what historians and sociologists have put forth. And yes, I've simplified gender relations to make it easier for folks to understand. Who wants to read a post that goes on for twenty paragraphs? But I still feel that the Church has some issues regarding women since it's fact that the Vatican did state that the automated laundry machine (my bad; wrong decive in the first post) was "the greatest invention for women in the Twentieth Century." What about birth control? I'd say that was more important since it gave women the ultimate power: the power of choice.

As for "the mean ol' Christians made everything stink," I find that statement insulting. Still, I apologize if my post offended anyone. My post was based on the statements of scholars and sociologists, coupled with my own research. I'm only human and anything I say is only as valid as what I've learned from my sources.

And Ail does have a point; truly primordial religions were based around a matriarchal "Earth Mother" figure before being driven away by more patriarchal "Sky Father" beliefs according to archaeologists and anthropologists. But I don't know enough to comment any more than that.

And there's only one "i" in my name, okay? Everyone please remember that.

All that said, I now wash my hands of this discussion.
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
User avatar
High Priest Mikhal
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1642
Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
Gender: Male
Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.

Post by High Priest Mikhal »

I know I said I was washing my hands of this thread, but I feel I owe this: DocBeard's right, I'm in the wrong. I'm remembering my "facts" all wrong after I double checked a few sources.

55 hours per, six hours of sleep a night even on weekends, this having to move stuff is taking a toll. I didn't care if it interfered with work, but when it interferes with Ravenloft I'll bite the bullet and take some medical leave as well as see a doctor. And no, I'm not joking about any of this. :cry:
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Post by ewancummins »

Oh, my! Well, I certainly hope that you get to feeling better, High Priest. Eat a good meal and get some sleep.






Thoughts on the OP’s ideas/suggestions:


I would suggest removing/obscuring any allusions to real world faiths, or to certain highly politicized interpretations of such faiths.

The Antifemmists seem like an implausible organization. 'We just really hate women' seems to me to be a shallow motivation- like the Captain Planet villains that 'just hate the environment.' Now, as part of a larger ethos and agenda, this could really be cool. I love Jack's tie-in with Nova Vaasa- that's a perfect place for a cult of killers- they will have many potential victims among the teeming masses of the urban poor. These guys need a better name and a more complex background, I think.

Have you read From Hell?

The lich-priest is intriguing, but he doesn't seem like a such good fit for Ezra's church, and his name reeks of unfortunate implications. Saint Augustine and Martin Luther- really? Don't shoot yourself in the foot like that. A priest who seeks lichdom to escape the temptations of the flesh is a great idea- so don't ruin it by trying to work in a feminist critique of Christianity. I would suggest renaming him and using some other god/church.


The Bodiless Children are pretty gross, and might evoke giggles or disgusted moans more than dread. It also assumes that masturbation is viewed as sinful, which is a pretty big assumption. It might fit very well in Jack's campaign- but I would not be able to use it.

The Chastiser is cool, but why not simply use an incubus, or some similar sort of fiend?

On a tangent, why is it we see so many fallen angels and so few ‘redeemed’ fiends? Really, in the context of the D&D multiverse, don’t good fiends make as much sense as evil celestials?
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
Ryan Naylor
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1285
Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm

Post by Ryan Naylor »

Apparently, evil is a lot more tempting than good.

I don't understand it either. Off the top of my head, Falls-From-Grace is the only good fiend I can think of in the D&D multiverse.
User avatar
Ail
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 3429
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 7:33 am
Location: Egham, UK

Post by Ail »

I read the original post. I agree with Ewan in most things, but I also wanted to caution in a way.

The whole feel of the post was a tad too violent for me, and I skipped a few things. I know this is Ravenloft, it's meant to mess with players' heads, but I'm always reminded of a few key-rules for RPG in general that I've gathered through the years. And one of them is 'never rape a girl's PC, just because she's a girl and your male characters would do it'. That is living up to selfish fantasies that the other player most surely will not appreciate. I'd take the same approach as a DM.

Some of the original ideas, namely the Castiser and perhaps the Anti-Femmists, fall a bit in this place. They open the possibility to abuse of women just because they're women. Also, I'm always leery of an author speaking through his/her characters. Even though a book should have a counterpoint for each opinion put forward, sometimes a given opinion is clearly favoured comparatively to others.

These two constructions may indeed promote a bit of that agenda by the DM, I don't know, but I wouldn't be comfortable with that. The Chastiser seems too extreme and a bit implausible to me. I don't like his punishments. Also, would he be ever-vigilant and punish every single act of illicit sex in the world, or would he work like the Dark Powers, who punish someone here, someone there, more according to the horror niches the RL authors wanted to fulfill than to any internal consistency?

Another thing I dislike is the many references in the text to real world concepts / figures: God, Eve, Onan. These do not exist in Ravenloft, period. So please, work these out of the text.

That said, I like Augustinus. That theme would also go very well with a buddhist-kind of monk, and that is the first idea that springs to my mind from the whole idea of 'cast off your body to avoid physical temptation / needs'.
Zumba d'Oxossi (A Stitch in Souragne)
Brother Eustace (The Devil's Dreams)
Robert de Moureaux (A New Barovia)
User avatar
DeepShadow of FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2923
Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
Location: Heinfroth's Asylum

Post by DeepShadow of FoS »

DeepShadow of FoS wrote:What's with the women as source of lust? I don't get it.
Okay, perhaps I should expand on this. My point was not that I was unfamiliar with this concept in our world. The problem is I haven't seen any reason to believe there is a RL parallel.

Consider the Antifeminists. Lust-centered misogyny IRL is usually a matter of male projection: a man who is uncomfortable with lustful thoughts blames them on women trying to seduce him. This is inconsistent with the actions and motives of the antifeminists: they would be raping women, not obliterating them. So if they have no psychological foundation, the burden of their hatred rests exclusively on an ideological foundation. Where is it? What church, society, or other belief system in RL has such a pretext for hating women?
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
User avatar
DeepShadow of FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2923
Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
Location: Heinfroth's Asylum

Post by DeepShadow of FoS »

HuManBing wrote:Dead Man's Seed sounds like a trope inversion of the dhampir (where the sperm donor already is technically undead but the fetus lives on, in utero, with some weird alterations).
Yeah, but really the dhampir is just a kind of mystical heritability issue. DMS isn't a direct inversion, but a lateral shift, where the woman neuttralizes her own life-giving power by inseminating herself with death.
You could shape interesting rituals around this to allow female characters to do as Lady Macbeth does and "unsex" themselves to become a neuter immortal - functionally fulfilling much the same plot mechanic as lichdom.
I see hagdom as a potential female counterpart to lichdom in this way. Still, I'm not sure that hags created from Dead Man's Seed would ever have offspring, even after they mature.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
User avatar
Jack the Reaper
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 340
Joined: Mon Jul 06, 2009 7:28 am

Post by Jack the Reaper »

My, you are *heavy*! I thought this forum is about Ravenloft, not about research of christianity and sexuality in history and theology.

Now to the relevant replies:

The lich priest really doesn't fit too much to the Ezran church, I admit. In my campaign I have a monotheistic church more similar to the Christian church, so that's why I described him that way. The references to biblical concepts were done for the readers' sake (the DMs), to better portray the characters. They are not supposed to be used in the game itself. As to the lich's name, sincerely, I had no intention to refer to any real life figure. I just picked the first christian-like name that came to my mind. I am not christian myself, and I know very little on the original Augustinus and Luther, so any resemblance to them is only coincidential.

The Chastiser must be an angel and not a demon, because he should evoke feelings of remorse and shame in his victims. If you get a divine punishment from an angel, you feel tainted and unclean. If you are abused by a demon, you'll feel like a good guy being wronged for nothing.

Lust and masturbating are considered sinful in many soceities, not only christian, ans are still treated as such in modern literature and media. That's why I mentioned the slasher films in the beginning. So there is much logic to assume that in RL there would be similar concepts.

The antifemmeists hatred is derived from twisted psychological urges. They hate the power that women have to incite desire in them, and they manifest their desires in homicidal manner. I don't want to start a real life psychological thread here, though.

As to the claims about the level of violence, that depends on the pesonal DM campaign. I don't think my ideas are more violent than what can be found in Falkovnia, Nova Vaasa or Invidia (just read Bakholis background in the gazetteer, for example). You don't have to get to the gory details when describing the antifemmists activities, or to "rape the PC girl", but I think that as a plot device they can be very useful.
User avatar
Nerit
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 637
Joined: Sat Aug 15, 2009 12:22 am
Location: The Eternal Autumn
Contact:

Post by Nerit »

Jack the Reaper wrote:My, you are *heavy*! I thought this forum is about Ravenloft, not about research of christianity and sexuality in history and theology.
You will never be able to de-politicize fiction because it originates from a politicized (even if unconscious) standpoint. No, I am not calling you a misogynist, I am saying we all have subconscious thoughts and reactions to a subject, which, no matter what we say, is highlighted by our beliefs and upbringing.
Yes, psychological blah blah blah.

Point is, roleplay is one of the most intimate of fictions, because we are pretending to be people in that world. It is your prerogative to have a more staunch monotheist religion over Ezra in your game. It is also your prerogative to have violent cults against women in your game. However, you simply cannot expect people to have no reaction to an especially charged subject [in our world]. Ravenloft is horror, and it is violent, but that doesn't mean the players and DMs don't think it's no big deal that everyone is getting murdered and raped :shock:. Dark RP is definitely an aesthetic, but not one that should be light-hearted for the most part. It is an exploration of our shadow selves.
Petroselinum, salvia, ros marinus, et thymus.
Nuray Solak
User avatar
DeepShadow of FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2923
Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
Location: Heinfroth's Asylum

Post by DeepShadow of FoS »

Jack the Reaper wrote:My, you are *heavy*! I thought this forum is about Ravenloft, not about research of christianity and sexuality in history and theology.
We've been talking about Ravenloft. Specifically, we've been talking about your contribution, and how well it meshes with our own views of Ravenloft. Some of us aren't seeing a fit here, but that's not a criticism, just a difference of preferences.
The lich priest really doesn't fit too much to the Ezran church, I admit. In my campaign I have a monotheistic church more similar to the Christian church, so that's why I described him that way. The references to biblical concepts were done for the readers' sake (the DMs), to better portray the characters.
That would make sense as a way to better portray the characters, if the characters are being portrayed as coming from a Judeo-Christian worldview. Hence we asked the question, is there a worldview in RL that fills this role? If there is, I don't see it. Note the careful wordage: there may be such a worldview that I don't see. This would include a worldview you choose to impose in your own games.
Lust and masturbating are considered sinful in many soceities, not only christian, ans are still treated as such in modern literature and media.
No argument. The question is whether any of those societies are in Ravenloft.
That's why I mentioned the slasher films in the beginning. So there is much logic to assume that in RL there would be similar concepts.
Well there's another area where we differ: I for one don't see most slasher-movie tropes as fitting well in RL, and I know I'm not the only one.
The antifemmeists hatred is derived from twisted psychological urges. They hate the power that women have to incite desire in them, and they manifest their desires in homicidal manner. I don't want to start a real life psychological thread here, though.
That's fine if you don't want to start such a thread, but that's what I'd need to fit them in my game: realistic psychological foundation. I've a Masters degree in psych, so I can't help filtering things I read through this, and I find this group psychologically unbelievable.

This may sound like a criticism, but it's not. We all shape RL--or any other setting, for that matter--based on our own ability to suspend disbelief. My need for psychological realism is no different from Agamenmnon's knowledge of European languages or Roti's knowlege of biology. Gozoron's villain in his game was limited by Ron's inability to believe in a limitless power source, hence he invented a gem-fueled power source. Even outside of gaming, people lose satisfaction in things their knowledge interferes with. I know an audiophile who can't enjoy music on anything other than ribbon speakers, and a mechanic who couldn't stand to listen to a story after it mentioned spark plugs in a diesel engine. Mark Twain wrote about his loss of satisfaction in riverboating after he learned to read the meaning of every ripple and bend.

Stories require the suspension of disbelief, and that varies with a person's background knowledge.
As to the claims about the level of violence, that depends on the pesonal DM campaign. I don't think my ideas are more violent than what can be found in Falkovnia, Nova Vaasa or Invidia (just read Bakholis background in the gazetteer, for example). You don't have to get to the gory details when describing the antifemmists activities, or to "rape the PC girl", but I think that as a plot device they can be very useful.
See, now this is where I have no problem. In my current campaign, I make sure people know when they join that I will be dealing with adult issues. At least three of the PC's have been raped--one by Vlad Drakov, one by his son. At the end of this story arc, I expect one of them will be pregnant with the child of her monstrous captor.

If these were the only issues, I'd think that your ideas would fit just fine. I have other issues, however, that you seem reluctant to discuss. I'll be poking around in your ideas, finding bits I can use for my own campaign, and I'd love your help.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Post by ewancummins »

DeepShadow makes several very good points.

All these things probably fit is very in Jack's version of Ravenloft. We all have our own take on the settings. No two DM's are going to have identical views, even if they are both 'canonistas.'

My own version of the setting has numerous small, and a few not-so-small, divergences from canon, as well as elaborations that are not found in any published material. I've posted notes in a background thread for my ongoing Ravenloft PbP game, here in Cafe de Nuit. My players can reference this to get things straight, and I welcome comments and questions from other Ravenloft fans.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
User avatar
Manofevil
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1729
Joined: Sat Dec 20, 2003 11:12 pm
Location: Why should I say? No one ever visits!

Post by Manofevil »

DeepShadow of FoS wrote:See, now this is where I have no problem. In my current campaign, I make sure people know when they join that I will be dealing with adult issues. At least three of the PC's have been raped--one by Vlad Drakov, one by his son. At the end of this story arc, I expect one of them will be pregnant with the child of her monstrous captor.
See, this is what I meant before about something that targets men instead of women. There are probably more women in RavenLoft who have been raped than who haven't. I imagine that violence against women is far more widespread in RavenLoft than it is even IRL. I remember hearing about a gang of women IRL who had been rape victims who began stalking the streets and attacking men. They would tear off their pants and sodomise them with foreign objects often, while telling them to 'lay back and enjoy it'. Then there's also the rapists who get castrated. Many a woman in mideval times was expected to cook and as such spent a great deal of time with knives in hand. Of course, being a male dominated society, punishments for women would probably be more terrible for women than men. Women would probably get burned at the stake where men would just be hung. After all, a fair and even handed ruler is a rarity in RavenLoft. Also IRL, there is supposedly a widespread underground railroad in the United States to help battered wives escape abusive husbands. That could easily be adapted to RavenLoft.
Do us a favor Luv, Stick yer 'ead in a bucket a kick it!

So, gentlemen, that's how it is. Until Grissome.... resurfaces, I'm the acting president, and I say starting with this... anniversary festival, we run this city into the ground! :D
User avatar
DocBeard
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2165
Joined: Mon Nov 05, 2007 5:35 pm

Post by DocBeard »

Mikhal, I'm sorry you are not feeling well. I just helped my aunt move out and into a new house very quickly, so I know what a hassle the whole process can be. While I can take a tense tone when speaking, I never meant to cause you discomfort or contribute to you losing sleep. I sincerely hope you feel better soon.

Jack, who'd call themselves 'the anti feminists'? Feminism hasn't even developed in Ravenloft. Call it the "Cabal of Values", guss up the oppression with a side of 'protecting family values' and 'enforcing traditional attitudes for the sake of community morality' and for a real lark have one of the leaders be a woman, like what happened a heck of a lot in the real world.
User avatar
ewancummins
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 28523
Joined: Tue Oct 25, 2005 1:35 pm

Post by ewancummins »

Manofevil wrote: There are probably more women in RavenLoft who have been raped than who haven't. I imagine that violence against women is far more widespread in RavenLoft than it is even IRL.
:shock: :shock: :shock:

Wow, this is so very different from my own take on Ravenloft that it really drives home my point: each DM's campign setting is unique, and sometimes the differences are radical.
Delight is to him- a far, far upward, and inward delight- who against the proud gods and commodores of this earth, ever stands forth his own inexorable self.

-from Moby Dick (Hermann Melville)
Post Reply