Page 2 of 2
Re: A fond look back at the Black Box
Posted: Thu Sep 23, 2010 10:09 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Loethadai the Lurker wrote:Hmmm... I never thought of it this way, but I think your right! Granted, I've never really had too many rules arguments with my players, but that makes sense. Well now you've done it!! Now I'm going to have to go, and buy all of the 3e books now.
Like I said, I'm not trying to sway you, just give another perspective. But if you
do want to give it a chance, remember you don't really have to buy anything to learn the rules. It's all in the SRD.
woodsdarkman wrote:I am so glad my post about the Black Box started a good debate on 2E vs 3E. LOL!
yeah, sorry about the the thread-jacking!

Black Box for-evar!
As for Ivan or Ivana I thought that you should be able to kill them easily, they are humans. Now Ivana having high hit points could be explained by her being an Emourding. Ivan is a weasel and a coward. What protects him is his ability to blackmail people in protecting him. There is no logical way he should be up their with Azalin. I don't care how it is explained. If a throw of a rock kills him then so be it. The hard part is getting near him to be able to throw the rock.
Hp aren't everything. Even in their SotDR writeups (where their hp are higher than Az), neither of the Twins holds a candle to Az in terms of "difficulty to kill". Their Gaz IV writeups dropped their hp a bit (now lower than Az, though not by much), but beefed them up with some flashier abilities. Still... Azalin could wipe the floor with either of them.
In any case, you could just as easily stat up either of them as much more fragile, if that's to your liking. Personally, I like them to be a little more threatening than 0-level humans.
Re: A fond look back at the Black Box
Posted: Thu Sep 23, 2010 1:15 pm
by woodsdarkman
I did not mean Ivan should have 5 hit points. I just thought he was a bully, and they should be easy to take down once their protectors have fallen. I see him trying snivel and beg his way out of danger.
Re: A fond look back at the Black Box
Posted: Thu Sep 23, 2010 1:26 pm
by Loethadai the Lurker
I am so glad my post about the Black Box started a good debate on 2E vs 3E. LOL!
*winces a bit* Yeah, apologies WoodsDarkman. I think this was my fault. I have a tendency to speak my mind when something comes to it, and should have considered the original point of this thread before delving into the whole 2E vs. 3E thing. Sorry, it just kind of developed into that.

Re: A fond look back at the Black Box
Posted: Thu Sep 23, 2010 2:10 pm
by woodsdarkman
Dont be sorry. I enjoy a good debate. It kinda fits the topic anyways. I mean the Black Box came along I think in a down time for 2E and Ravenloft being such a great idea and setting could have possibly been the reason 2E stayed strong for so long. Or I should say been one of the reasons. Besides next week I am going to post a fond look back at Feat of Goblyns and I can't wait to see what off topic debate comes out of that.
Re: A fond look back at the Black Box
Posted: Thu Sep 23, 2010 2:16 pm
by Loethadai the Lurker
a fond look back at Feast of Goblyns
You know, I just went through all my Ravenloft Modules, and believe it or not, I don't have this one!

Figures!! I seem to remember wanting to procure this, but like several other pieces, I never got around to it. Doh!

I may have it somewhere in my basement, and as a special tribute, I will at the very least borrow it from a friend or something, and give it a good read so that I can actually discuss it with you, and actually know what I'm talking about. LOL!
Re: A fond look back at the Black Box
Posted: Thu Sep 23, 2010 2:21 pm
by woodsdarkman
My sympathy friend. It was the first Ravenloft module. Though it is different from what Ravenloft evolved into it was a damn good module. Thick and full of information on Kartakas and boy was their fighting aplenty. It was truly a bang for your buck module and it's legacy still lives on today with what took place in that adventure in many ways.