Page 2 of 3

Re: Unofficial Domains

Posted: Sun Jun 12, 2011 11:53 am
by alhoon
An island the size of Barovia?!?
How many people live there?

Re: Unofficial Domains

Posted: Sun Jun 12, 2011 2:25 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
alhoon wrote:An island the size of Barovia?!?
How many people live there?
An excellent question. At least a few hundred, one of which is a Mordentish doctor, but the module makes reference to "Natives" which sound like native Americans in description: tan skinned, deer skins, silent in nature. There is no indication how many of these people there are, and no settlements are marked on the map, so they may be very few in number. All in all, I'd say this backs up Alhoon's surprise at the size of the place. Seems unnecessary.

Re: Ramsay and his island

Posted: Sun Jun 12, 2011 10:48 pm
by ewancummins
Strahdsbuddy wrote:Discovering more domains, these in Dungeon magazine: Eyrie (more of a pocket, really) and the Island of Dr. Ramsay.

Ramsay's island has a nice map, which is of paramount interest to me. I have to say if anyone has Dungeon #76, and has read the adventure, why is the island so bag? Similar to my Whal argument, why does Ramsay need a domain the size of Barovia? While I understand why individual DMs change scale, I presume the scale in Dungeon magazine, by comparison, would be more or less canon.

Ramsay's island is 4 times the size of Markovia, and would constitute a major discovery in the Sea of Sorrows, rather than just being glanced over like Dominia. In fact, Dominia's size makes more sense for the scope of the Ramsay adventure, imo. Maybe a little bigger, but not enormous.

Well, you could shrink his island. I think it might be more fun to keep it large, though. Let it's discovery be a big deal. Run the adventure. Afterward, if the heroes survive, they can explore the island and make contact with the natives.

Map request

Posted: Tue Jun 14, 2011 2:21 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
Hey Ewan, I think that is a fine idea, I'm just not sure it was the intent when the adventure was thought up, which rattles my faith in the integrity of Dungeon adventures. (pause for amused chuckle).

I was going to start mapping these unofficial domains as part of the larger project, so I figured I would give the authors a chance to send me their maps int he beginning. Not only would it save me the time, it would help their creation get into the project just the way they drew it up. In lieu of the authors, I'll take any one else's map as well. If you made a map of a domain, PM me so I can include it. It doesn't even have to be a domain, I'm anxious for city maps also. All original works will be credited, of course.

Re: Unofficial Domains

Posted: Fri Jun 17, 2011 4:27 pm
by Protector
You have forgotten Rookhausen in your list of domains. While those of involved have been trying to track down the source material for years, the official chat setting is still semi-canonical. The domain was actually more than just the city and immediate countryside. There were a few smal villages in the domain as well.

Re: Unofficial Domains

Posted: Sat Jun 18, 2011 11:32 am
by Strahdsbuddy
Protector wrote:You have forgotten Rookhausen in your list of domains. While those of involved have been trying to track down the source material for years, the official chat setting is still semi-canonical. The domain was actually more than just the city and immediate countryside. There were a few smal villages in the domain as well.
You bring up a good point. I certainly left it out mostly because it is almost NEVER mentioned, although I have heard the name. When was this chat session running? Who was involved? What details can you provide?

Re: Unofficial Domains

Posted: Sat Jun 18, 2011 11:53 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Note that Rookhausen did get a "shout out" in the FoS's Nocturnal Sea Gaz.

Re: Map request

Posted: Sat Jun 18, 2011 2:58 pm
by alhoon
Strahdsbuddy wrote: If you made a map of a domain, PM me so I can include it. It doesn't even have to be a domain, I'm anxious for city maps also. All original works will be credited, of course.
I have a map of a domain and parts of settlement in the last QtR. I was about to make more domain maps of personal domains. I'll submit one to the next QtR if Joel ever gets over "no, there's no theme! ! !" thing and gives me a theme so I could make a domain based on the theme.

Re: Unofficial Domains

Posted: Sat Jun 18, 2011 3:46 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
:::::If the domain is already out, I will happily utilize any map. PM or email me.:::::

EDIT

I'm sorry, Alhoon, I misread your post. I remember the maps and having just re-read the article, I'd love to utilize it in a map. Of course the style of the article makes the location intentionally vague; are you interested in revealing the mapped realm to us?

Re: Unofficial Domains

Posted: Thu Jun 23, 2011 8:23 pm
by Wiccy of the Fraternity
I think that after Arlington Farm (a thousand plagues on those who forget that domain!) people should be glad I scrapped all the other finished articles I had plans for other domains, some of them were downright evil! They made Arlington Farm tame in comparison. The one with the spectral hanging tree (I kid you not) still sends shivers down my spine when I remember it.

But yes, remember Arlington Farm, best fan domain ever written. Or at least the most requested for further information on how to run a adventure in it :P

Re: Unofficial Domains

Posted: Fri Jun 24, 2011 6:34 am
by The Wolfman
Strahdsbuddy wrote:As an American, I often wonder if we have a difficult time thinking something the size of Delaware is big enough for a domain; we constantly have to make it the size of California. Or, as has been mentioned before, in the technological age we live in, our world seems much smaller. 100 miles is nothing to us, but would be a darn big deal to a Ravenloft resident.
I agree; however, the populations are usually too small to even support a Delaware-sized domain. The rural (everyone not living in a named city or town) population of each domain should be multiplied by ten or even more just to provide enough farmers and herders to feed everyone. For most of history, the vast majority of people did not live in farms.

Re: Unofficial Domains

Posted: Fri Jun 24, 2011 6:51 am
by Strahdsbuddy
That oversight has been amended, my dear Wiccy. My apologies!

Funny story, though. SInce my wife watches every cheesy horror movie that could possibly be released on cable (the TV rarely moves off SciFi or Chiller when she has the clicker) I saw a movie with her where the "heroes" were trapped in a cornfield and the scarecrows came alive, and they would drag dead people back to a farmhouse where they would sew their own scarecrow costumes and join the animated ranks. The whole time I thought to myself "These writers play Ravenloft, I KNOW it!" I say that about a lot of things, though, if only more people would admit to it.

Re: Unofficial Domains

Posted: Fri Jun 24, 2011 7:38 am
by ewancummins
The Wolfman wrote:I agree; however, the populations are usually too small to even support a Delaware-sized domain. The rural (everyone not living in a named city or town) population of each domain should be multiplied by ten or even more just to provide enough farmers and herders to feed everyone. For most of history, the vast majority of people did not live in farms.

I think you mean 'did not live in cities.'

Re: Unofficial Domains

Posted: Fri Jun 24, 2011 7:40 am
by The Wolfman
ewancummins wrote:
The Wolfman wrote:I agree; however, the populations are usually too small to even support a Delaware-sized domain. The rural (everyone not living in a named city or town) population of each domain should be multiplied by ten or even more just to provide enough farmers and herders to feed everyone. For most of history, the vast majority of people did not live in farms.

I think you mean 'did not live in cities.'

Yeah. It's early.

Re: Ramsay and his island

Posted: Mon Jun 27, 2011 3:45 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Strahdsbuddy wrote:Ramsay's island has a nice map, which is of paramount interest to me. I have to say if anyone has Dungeon #76, and has read the adventure, why is the island so bag? Similar to my Whal argument, why does Ramsay need a domain the size of Barovia?
Well, I just skimmed it. I don't see any reason for it. We're talking an island the size of Oahu, approximately, with 1 guy living on it. Weird.