alhoon wrote:As Roots of Evil: The Gods then had other problems to contend with, like the years of trouble in FR etc.
Also to be sincere it seems kinda weird that the DPowers, that don't hold sway over anything more powerful than Demigods (Which IMO brings them on par with lesser powers) would be able to bring a change to the whole multiverse.
It seems we have a divergence of viewpoints on the participation and motives of gods. This is likely to be a discussion that relies heavily on subjective interpretation, so I'll just state my viewpoint neutrally - with the caveat that it does not pretend to any level of objective truth for the DnD canon.
For me, the DnD gods were largely drummed up on the fly, to fulfill the needs of whatever storyline was being explored at that moment. I have seen multiple instances of what I consider to be significant internal inconsistencies in deities and power levels (with Ravenloft and Planescape being fairly common contexts).
DnD's canon for their deities, and their respective levels of powers, are wildly inconsistent. Vecna was trapped in Ravenloft, but was able to penetrate into Sigil in the adventure
Die Vecna Die!, something which even Greater Gods are not supposed to be able to do. (Wizards.com had a forum thread trying to explain relative deities' power levels. This pretty much degenerated into "Lady of Pain outranks all the others by far, except for Vecna which we can't really explain".)
Because of this, my philosophy in gaming with the DnD settings is to consider the Dark Powers and the canon gods primarily as plot devices for the GM. The pantheon is supposed to serve the storytelling - not the other way round. Ravenloft's writers, much to their credit, was completely upfront about this, telling the GM effectively "we have no recommended guidelines - do with these what you will". (Authors of other settings have been less flexible, but that's no reason for the GM to follow their example.)
In my opinion, if a GM starts letting "rules of DnD godhood" dictate their campaign, they've basically limited their freedom of choice, based largely on an inconsistent and internally contradictory set of guidelines. If you've got a good fun idea for a campaign, I'd say you should feel free to ignore a few of TSR's or WOTC's half-baked cosmological vagaries if they get in the way.
That's my final comment on the issue - I'm wary of religion-based discussions both in gaming and in real life, and if my explanations don't work for you, then feel free to disregard my adventure suggestions. (As a personal matter, I'd would rather you judge my adventure concepts on their own merits, rather than how well it fits in with a separate agenda I consider irrelevant... but my desire to avoid a religious discussion and possible hurt feelings about WOTC's cod mythology outweighs any authorial pride I might have in my work.)