Page 2 of 5

Re: Any new word from WotC?

Posted: Sun Oct 30, 2011 6:49 am
by Le Noir Faineant
I really don't follow the D&D scene too closely apart from, well, this board, and my own :) ,
but it seems to me as if WotC had a few structural changes over the last few years as well.

Hopefully, with brand management more stable, there will be more of a, well,
understandable concept in their D&D release policy.

Stuff like the RL announcements are PR-disasters, simply.



I for my part would have been less than thrilled by what was announced and then taken back,
but as I said, my games are well-balanced, anyway. I would just like more nebs learning about RL!
It's such a great setting! :)

Re: Any new word from WotC?

Posted: Sun Oct 30, 2011 9:55 am
by HuManBing
Jester of the FoS wrote:WotC has been pretty bad the ast few years with the double talk and marketing terms and hype and spin. Everything just HAS to be spun juuuuust right. They hate admitting minds were changed or that mistakes were made.
This is an interesting change! I recall early in the announcement of 4E, they posted several articles hyping its changes from 3E, and they trash-talked the older edition. They had choice bits like "I'm sorry, but if your game is actually relying on skill rolls like Rope Use, then you're doing it wrong" or something similar.

Besides being immensely arrogant in the line of we-know-how-you-should-be-playing-your-game-better-than-you-do, it was also very disingenuous to bash your own company's product in such a disparaging way. I guess they were hoping that the whole logical argument of "get excited about 4E because it's so much better than 3E, which sucked!" would override the obvious logical corollary of "if by your own assertion 3E sucked, and you made the damn thing, then why should 4E (which you are also making) be any different?"

From what I'm hearing from you, it seems like they've become more cagey about their hype, even if it's not necessarily any more consistent.

Re: Any new word from WotC?

Posted: Sun Oct 30, 2011 10:47 am
by Jester of the FoS
HuManBing wrote:
Jester of the FoS wrote:WotC has been pretty bad the ast few years with the double talk and marketing terms and hype and spin. Everything just HAS to be spun juuuuust right. They hate admitting minds were changed or that mistakes were made.
This is an interesting change! I recall early in the announcement of 4E, they posted several articles hyping its changes from 3E, and they trash-talked the older edition. They had choice bits like "I'm sorry, but if your game is actually relying on skill rolls like Rope Use, then you're doing it wrong" or something similar.

Besides being immensely arrogant in the line of we-know-how-you-should-be-playing-your-game-better-than-you-do, it was also very disingenuous to bash your own company's product in such a disparaging way. I guess they were hoping that the whole logical argument of "get excited about 4E because it's so much better than 3E, which sucked!" would override the obvious logical corollary of "if by your own assertion 3E sucked, and you made the damn thing, then why should 4E (which you are also making) be any different?"

From what I'm hearing from you, it seems like they've become more cagey about their hype, even if it's not necessarily any more consistent.
The difference being, they wanted to sell 4e, so they bashed the hell out of 3e and promoted 4e in the best light. Now they're trying very hard not to admit the flaws or problems with 4e or their current philosophies & practices.

Re: Any new word from WotC?

Posted: Sun Oct 30, 2011 3:01 pm
by Bluebomber4evr
They did the exact same thing with the transition from 2nd edition to 3rd. Nothing new there. The idea being that D&D fans are notoriously intransient and reluctant to change editions, so if they can make the old edition seem bad it will supposedly make the new edition seem good by comparison.

I agree with Jester's assessment. They realized they had a stinker but didn't want to admit it. Seriously, everything that we had heard (what little of it there was) was that it was basically trying to pander to Twilight fans. That's why I said it seems more like a mercy killing. :wink:

Re: Any new word from WotC?

Posted: Sun Oct 30, 2011 10:19 pm
by HuManBing
Bluebomber4evr wrote:it was basically trying to pander to Twilight fans. That's why I said it seems more like a mercy killing. :wink:

Good point, Twilight would make sense in terms of contemporary fads.

Re: Any new word from WotC?

Posted: Tue Nov 01, 2011 7:50 am
by Jester of the FoS
Bluebomber4evr wrote:They did the exact same thing with the transition from 2nd edition to 3rd. Nothing new there. The idea being that D&D fans are notoriously intransient and reluctant to change editions, so if they can make the old edition seem bad it will supposedly make the new edition seem good by comparison.
The difference being 2e had some very real problems and odd mechanics. There was a lack of uniformity and even which dice you would roll for a given task was seemingly random. It was easy to create the need for 3e, while much hard to create the need for 4e. So they really went after 3e hard, lambasting its various flaws and commenting on how you could play the game "wrong".

Re: Any new word from WotC?

Posted: Fri Dec 16, 2011 7:39 pm
by Catman Jim
Long time WotC staffer Rich Baker was let go this week. AFAIK, his only direct Ravenloft contribution was the adventure "Dark of the Moon" in 1993. His blog can be found here:
http://community.wizards.com/wotc_richb ... e_of_plans

Re: Any new word from WotC?

Posted: Fri Dec 16, 2011 7:53 pm
by Le Noir Faineant
Strange enough. He was one of the backbones of 3e, and is probably one of the best writers out there, generally.

He wrote "Forge of Fury", which is likely one of my favorite adventures of all time.

Re: Any new word from WotC?

Posted: Fri Dec 16, 2011 8:29 pm
by brilliantlight
Jester of the FoS wrote:
HuManBing wrote:
Jester of the FoS wrote:WotC has been pretty bad the ast few years with the double talk and marketing terms and hype and spin. Everything just HAS to be spun juuuuust right. They hate admitting minds were changed or that mistakes were made.
This is an interesting change! I recall early in the announcement of 4E, they posted several articles hyping its changes from 3E, and they trash-talked the older edition. They had choice bits like "I'm sorry, but if your game is actually relying on skill rolls like Rope Use, then you're doing it wrong" or something similar.

Besides being immensely arrogant in the line of we-know-how-you-should-be-playing-your-game-better-than-you-do, it was also very disingenuous to bash your own company's product in such a disparaging way. I guess they were hoping that the whole logical argument of "get excited about 4E because it's so much better than 3E, which sucked!" would override the obvious logical corollary of "if by your own assertion 3E sucked, and you made the damn thing, then why should 4E (which you are also making) be any different?"

From what I'm hearing from you, it seems like they've become more cagey about their hype, even if it's not necessarily any more consistent.
The difference being, they wanted to sell 4e, so they bashed the hell out of 3e and promoted 4e in the best light. Now they're trying very hard not to admit the flaws or problems with 4e or their current philosophies & practices.
Too bad for them lots of people HATE 4e. Look at the computer games based on D&D all of them I know of use 3e.

Re: Any new word from WotC?

Posted: Fri Dec 16, 2011 8:31 pm
by Jester of the FoS
They also let go of Steve Winter had been around since 1e and the TSR days. And was directly responsible for my publication in Dragon. That saddened e greatly.

Re: Any new word from WotC?

Posted: Sat Dec 17, 2011 5:06 am
by Blot
I prefer 2ed to 3... I picked up all of the 3ed stuff for RL, along with all of the Core stuff, but could never really click with it.


I love me some THAC0...

Re: Any new word from WotC?

Posted: Sat Dec 17, 2011 5:26 am
by Le Noir Faineant
I wonder where Wizbro is heading these days; because, frankly, the upcoming releases,
there's nothing there I would want to buy or even recommend.

Paizo is the way to go; or, simply, other systems, that have aged better than D&D has since the turn of the millenium.

So, for example, I moved on to Dragonwarriors. Easier and not as setting-heavy as D&D, but the mood's alright, and the books are cheap.

Re: Any new word from WotC?

Posted: Sat Dec 17, 2011 9:50 am
by brilliantlight
Blot wrote:I prefer 2ed to 3... I picked up all of the 3ed stuff for RL, along with all of the Core stuff, but could never really click with it.


I love me some THAC0...
To each his own, 2nd ed has things going for it. I prefer 3rd ed and think that is where it peaked but 2nd ed is by no means bad. I have major problems with 4th ed but glancing over it even that has one or two things that are good ideas. I am thinking mainly of how it handles minions and artifacts but the bad far outweighs the good.

Re: Any new word from WotC?

Posted: Sat Dec 17, 2011 11:14 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
MODERATOR NOTE: Let's not get involved in an edition-war, please. No one has crossed the line yet, but this is a pre-emptive warning.

Re: Any new word from WotC?

Posted: Sat Dec 17, 2011 11:57 am
by Blot
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:MODERATOR NOTE: Let's not get involved in an edition-war, please. No one has crossed the line yet, but this is a pre-emptive warning.
Oh definately not! No hatred at all for 3rd or 3.5. Not really looked at 4th yet, so don't really feel I can comment... but by jove 2nd ed was beautiful...

Might be fueled mostly by nostalgia...