Page 2 of 3
Re: Is Ravenloft really that bad a place to live?
Posted: Fri Nov 25, 2011 1:10 am
by Guardian of Twilight
ewancummins wrote:Guardian of Twilight wrote:Also, I'd like to add how friendly these boards are as compared to Candlekeep. Over there if you say one opinion different than others, they attack you over and over again. Thank you all for always keeping it friendly here for any idea or view.

IME, there just aren't many 'hardcore canon purists' in Ravenloft fandom. Indeed, how could there be, when the official published material is rather sketchily drawn, and fairly often inconsistent? The fans have done tubs of development on their own.
I never looked at it quite that way before, but you're right. Thanks, ewan.

Re: Is Ravenloft really that bad a place to live?
Posted: Fri Nov 25, 2011 2:00 am
by ewancummins
Guardian of Twilight wrote:I never looked at it quite that way before, but you're right. Thanks, ewan.

You're welcome.

Re: Is Ravenloft really that bad a place to live?
Posted: Fri Nov 25, 2011 10:51 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
Considering how the setting was designed in the first place -- spun off from a couple of 1E adventures whose B plots were literally determined by the luck of the draw in fortune-telling scenes; designed from day one to allow DMs to import heroes from anywhere in the game-multiverse, rather than imposing any solid boundaries on players' character choices -- I think that a willingness to accept alternative scenarios as valid ones is a form of "purism". Insisting that everyone remain in lock-step with one version of canon, and exclude anything original because they "don't fit", is what would be inconsistent with the setting's history and campaign function.
Re: Is Ravenloft really that bad a place to live?
Posted: Fri Nov 25, 2011 11:36 am
by brilliantlight
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:Considering how the setting was designed in the first place -- spun off from a couple of 1E adventures whose B plots were literally determined by the luck of the draw in fortune-telling scenes; designed from day one to allow DMs to import heroes from anywhere in the game-multiverse, rather than imposing any solid boundaries on players' character choices -- I think that a willingness to accept alternative scenarios as valid ones is a form of "purism". Insisting that everyone remain in lock-step with one version of canon, and exclude anything original because they "don't fit", is what would be inconsistent with the setting's history and campaign function.
You have a point, particularly the way the Dark Powers like messing with time.
Re: Is Ravenloft really that bad a place to live?
Posted: Fri Nov 25, 2011 3:06 pm
by ewancummins
IMO, the really rabid canon purism is against the spirit of the game. I don't mean fans who just like to stick closely to published materials. I mean the minority who habitually flame other fans for 'heresy.' D&D is a creative, imaginative hobby. Settings, be they published or homebrew, are what you ( the DM and the players) make of them.
Re: Is Ravenloft really that bad a place to live?
Posted: Sat Nov 26, 2011 1:09 am
by HuManBing
The funniest flamers are the ones (on the old WOTC boards) who flame you for suggesting non-canon ideas, and then put some bright happy line in their signature saying "Flame ideas, not people" or "There's no WRONG way to play the game".
This makes me want to wet my pants, wipe it on the windows, and run naked through the hallowed halls of Congress with my arms in the air hooting and gibbering like a madman.
Re: Is Ravenloft really that bad a place to live?
Posted: Sat Nov 26, 2011 2:42 pm
by Manofevil
HuManBing wrote:
This makes me want to wet my pants, wipe it on the windows, and run naked through the hallowed halls of Congress with my arms in the air hooting and gibbering like a madman.
So join the republican party.
Re: Is Ravenloft really that bad a place to live?
Posted: Sat Nov 26, 2011 11:36 pm
by alhoon
ewancummins wrote:IMO, the really rabid canon purism is against the spirit of the game. I don't mean fans who just like to stick closely to published materials. I mean the minority who habitually flame other fans for 'heresy.' D&D is a creative, imaginative hobby. Settings, be they published or homebrew, are what you ( the DM and the players) make of them.
That.
Re: Is Ravenloft really that bad a place to live?
Posted: Sun Nov 27, 2011 12:12 am
by ewancummins
Manofevil wrote:HuManBing wrote:
This makes me want to wet my pants, wipe it on the windows, and run naked through the hallowed halls of Congress with my arms in the air hooting and gibbering like a madman.
So join the republican party.
Let's keep the real world politics out of this, please.

Re: Is Ravenloft really that bad a place to live?
Posted: Tue Dec 20, 2011 6:57 am
by Kraken(rpgworld)
Europe the Middle Ages was a very bad place to live.
Many people suffered from hunger and disease.
1. hunger
-lack of melioration
Due to the lack of melioration during the
Middle Ages is too wet or dry summers completely kill crop
-absence of pesticides
Due to the lack of pesticides pests eat 10 to 90% yield.
Especially scary was locusts - in bad years swarm of locusts ate all the plants in the entire areas.
-lack of fertilizers
In the Middle Ages knew only from fertilizer lime (the exact amount of fertilizer did not know about it because piled proverb "Lime enriches the father and son ruins") and manure (by medieval legends were born pests of manure worms, because in many countries of the Middle Ages manure fertilizer was banned under penalty of death)
2. Diseases
-puerperal fever,
the most terrible disease of the Middle Ages, from 10 to 70% of pregnant women died shortly after birth from blood poisoning.
-red pox
infectiousness of influenza exceeded, the death rate of 20-30%, in the Middle Ages, people grow old and grey and nd not sick with smallpox was considered a rare lucky
-plague
had a terrible mortality, but by the total number of victims of inferior puerperal fever and pox.
-three military diseases (dysentery, gangrene, typhus)
occurred from unsanitary conditions, accompanied by wars. The Second World War was the first war in human history, where the actions of the troops have killed more people than from associated diseases.
-parasitic worms, lice, fleas, caries
Well it was all and considered normal
Re: Is Ravenloft really that bad a place to live?
Posted: Tue Dec 20, 2011 7:15 am
by Blot
If I ever try to conjure Ravenloft up as an image in my head, I never get Vampires, or Ghosts or other gribbly beasts... I always think of the vistas and horizons. Ravenloft to me is about landscape and natural beauty tinged with a heavy pervading sadness. It's standing in the early evening seeing the last touches of sunlight glimmer from a too still lake. It's pausing in the shadow of a mountain with the moon just cresting the spire of a castle tower jutting out into the night. It's the vibrant redness of Mt. Makab as stormclouds gather around it.
Ravenloft is a place of tremendous beauty.
Yeah... I think I'd like to live there.
Re: Is Ravenloft really that bad a place to live?
Posted: Tue Dec 20, 2011 7:26 am
by Kraken(rpgworld)
Oh, almost forgot to delirium tremens - in the Middle Ages it was very dangerous.
Grim example: The story of "The Great Pan" Arthur Machen taken from an Irish legend. It saved a peasant fairy, fallen into the web. She asked him what he wants as a reward. He wished to see the world of fairies. She said that she can fulfill his desire, but he bitterly regret this.
He began to insist, and she gave him this gift.
He started everywhere seem satire and Greek statues. In the evening he killed his wife and children and then hanged himself.
Modern scholars have suggested that the basis of this legend is raving of sick delirium tremens.

Re: Is Ravenloft really that bad a place to live?
Posted: Tue Dec 20, 2011 8:06 am
by Kraken(rpgworld)
Many of the monsters from the medieval legends are much stronger that in DND game.
For example the vampires of Slavic legends are not afraid of the sun.
In Stoker's "Dracula" Count calmly walks around London during the daylight, and that afternoon met Mina.
The first vampire not tolerate the sun was from the movie Nosferatu Murnau.
Also attributed to the possibility of vampires come out of the coffin nailsboarded without opening it. They also have the ability to enter or exit from the grave without disturbing the ground above it.
Otherwise, the vampire is very easy to find - on the ground dug grave.
Re: Is Ravenloft really that bad a place to live?
Posted: Tue Dec 20, 2011 8:33 am
by Blot
Nice research Kraken! For me though, Ravenloft shouldn't be too 'real' (I don't like to make sweeping generalisations... but I'm struggling to think of any RPG which I would strive for 100% historical authenticity!). In a good Ravenloft experience, I'm looking for a heightened sense of 'realism'. It should be more stylised. For my tastes, the rules and historical accuracies should submit to the narrative and characters, the experience of the players and the themes and ideology of the setting.
A thought occurs to me; If you wouldn't want to live there, why would you want to experience an adventure there?
Re: Is Ravenloft really that bad a place to live?
Posted: Tue Dec 20, 2011 3:49 pm
by Arikail
Blot wrote:If I ever try to conjure Ravenloft up as an image in my head, I never get Vampires, or Ghosts or other gribbly beasts... I always think of the vistas and horizons. Ravenloft to me is about landscape and natural beauty tinged with a heavy pervading sadness. It's standing in the early evening seeing the last touches of sunlight glimmer from a too still lake. It's pausing in the shadow of a mountain with the moon just cresting the spire of a castle tower jutting out into the night. It's the vibrant redness of Mt. Makab as stormclouds gather around it.
Ravenloft is a place of tremendous beauty.
Yeah... I think I'd like to live there.
/\ /\ This /\ /\
This is what pops into my head when I think of Ravenloft, and what I am hoping to get across to my players when I get my game up and running in a few months. Ravenloft is a dashingly beautiful setting to look upon and, I would imagine, to live in, provided you don't go poking where you're not supposed to. Not all the domains are like that, but the Core certainly strikes me in that regards almost everywhere.