Page 2 of 2

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Fri Jan 13, 2012 11:09 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
alhoon wrote:I always thought S was a generalist wizard. All schools. Sure, she may have a few more necromantic spells in the repertoire and perhaps even skill focus, but I doupt she has given up 2 schools. I believe the Apmortens may have a couple of true specialist necromancers in their midsts throughout the years but more or less, I think they too, are generalists.
Again, I was not arguing that S was a specialist. I was talking about her ghoulish mindset. If the ApMortens share than mindset, then I would imagine that would set people's teeth on edge a little in Forfarmax.

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Sun Jan 15, 2012 2:49 pm
by alhoon
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:
alhoon wrote:I always thought S was a generalist wizard. All schools. Sure, she may have a few more necromantic spells in the repertoire and perhaps even skill focus, but I doupt she has given up 2 schools. I believe the Apmortens may have a couple of true specialist necromancers in their midsts throughout the years but more or less, I think they too, are generalists.
Again, I was not arguing that S was a specialist. I was talking about her ghoulish mindset. If the ApMortens share than mindset, then I would imagine that would set people's teeth on edge a little in Forfarmax.

Oh, I get it now.
I agree that to the pitchfork mob, an excuse like "necromancer? me!? Nonsense! I use all forms of arcane magic, but I just prefer to have undead doing my menial tasks and I'm really good in necromantic spells, which take up half my spell book" would sound kinda empty.

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Mon Jan 16, 2012 10:34 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:
alhoon wrote:Again, I was not arguing that S was a specialist. I was talking about her ghoulish mindset. If the ApMortens share than mindset, then I would imagine that would set people's teeth on edge a little in Forfarmax.
Just because S likes them doesn't mean they're necessarily evil- or necromantically-inclined. For all we know, she might've liked them because they had no problem treating a wizardess with the same respect as a wizard.

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Mon Jan 16, 2012 10:38 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
nothri wrote:Honestly, why the Gaz felt the need to shoehorn it into Hazlan when Barovia is a perfectly good realm to use is beyond me.
Probably it's because Barovia was already quite well developed in other products, and was the starting point for an awful lot of peoples' Ravenloft campaigns. Plunking a new village onto Strahd's turf would've begged the question of why nobody'd ever mentioned the place before, whereas Hazlan was a virtual blank slate for the 3E writers to fill in as they wished.

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Mon Jan 16, 2012 12:35 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
IIRC that village is actually from CotN:Ghosts and was drawn into the Mists well after the rest of Forlorn (from the same home world though). It might have been placed in Hazlan to avoid the question of why Castles Forlorn, which details the whole domain in a way not otherwise seen until the Gazetteers, doesn't mention it (and not in Barovia for the reasons Roti cites).

I could just be confabulating that, but that's what I remember.

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Sun Jan 22, 2012 10:37 pm
by Mortavius
Just commenting on the whole Necromancy thing...

I doubt the "pitchfork mob" would really know the details about magic schools. They know Necromancy if they see the wizard animating a dead person, or calling up a spirit. Otherwise, they would just think of it as magic in general.

If the ApMortens were Necromancers, they would probably be smart enough not to animate the dead to defend the town; they probably relied on other spells, and kept their Necromantic studies for behind closed doors. Protectors or not, even the people of the town would only put up with so much from their defenders.

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Mon Jan 23, 2012 2:53 am
by alhoon
Yeah, but Hazlik would kill them anyways.

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Mon Jan 23, 2012 10:17 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
All the more reason why, IMO, they shouldn't be necromancers. If only because there's more potential for stories in a diverse assortment of generalists and specialists, and Ravenloft's already got necromancers by the bucketload. Merely being wizards at all, and newcomers to the town, should be enough to justify the other locals' distaste.

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Wed Jan 25, 2012 5:05 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:All the more reason why, IMO, they shouldn't be necromancers. If only because there's more potential for stories in a diverse assortment of generalists and specialists, and Ravenloft's already got necromancers by the bucketload. Merely being wizards at all, and newcomers to the town, should be enough to justify the other locals' distaste.
I would agree. IMC I've got them as generalist wizards. I do make them slightly morbid and mercenary, however, as a tribute to Lucy's legacy and because I like to read more into S's approval than is probably there. Matter of fact, I'd expect my vision of them would fit well within the FoS, which would forbid necromancy altogether.

Holy crap, I think I've got a narrator idea for the SoS Gaz....

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Wed Jan 25, 2012 5:12 pm
by alhoon
Necromancy looking still makes the FoS suspicious of them. They don't prohibit Necromancers, they prohibit necromancy alltogether.

Re: Gaz I / Forlorn problems

Posted: Thu Jan 26, 2012 7:31 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
alhoon wrote:Necromancy looking still makes the FoS suspicious of them. They don't prohibit Necromancers, they prohibit necromancy alltogether.
Exactly as I said: they prohibit necromancy, not just morbid and mercenary thinking.