Transposition by Angel?
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Re: Transposition by Angel?
I use Transposition everywhere personally. Too cool to leave it half-way.
Why wouldn't a fiend want to transpose with a person somewhere else after all? It's tainting a mortal and corrupting him and influencing the world etc.
Why wouldn't a fiend want to transpose with a person somewhere else after all? It's tainting a mortal and corrupting him and influencing the world etc.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
Re: Transposition by Angel?
I am thrilled with the amount of conversation this has sparked!
The more I think about this whole topic, the more I want to push it harder. We have evidence of one angel in Ravenloft, Isolde. I am of the opinion that if one is there, there are more. Not a huge number, but certainly more than one. Transposition onto an Innocent I think would be an amazing thing to have to play through and develop. A new way for horror to enter the game.
I've never viewed Angels as "perfect beings" in DnD, and certainly not in Ravenloft. I picture them as beings of unwavering duty. That unwavering duty makes them a force for horror just like anything else. Supernatural has done amazing things with using Angels as villains for horror, as has the Prophecy movies. There is a LOT of to mine for Angels in the Mists that is basically untouched.
The more I think about it, the more I really want to actually write about it. Perhaps a lost Van Richten's Guide, one he was unwilling to publish because the information he learned made him feel hopeless. I don't know, there is a LOT to be done here, with "willing" possession by Angels to ... Ghost Rider styled Angels of Vengenance ... to the Supernatural Angels who are trying to destroy the world to allow the whole thing to start over. There is something here, and I plan on writing more and more about it.
The more I think about this whole topic, the more I want to push it harder. We have evidence of one angel in Ravenloft, Isolde. I am of the opinion that if one is there, there are more. Not a huge number, but certainly more than one. Transposition onto an Innocent I think would be an amazing thing to have to play through and develop. A new way for horror to enter the game.
I've never viewed Angels as "perfect beings" in DnD, and certainly not in Ravenloft. I picture them as beings of unwavering duty. That unwavering duty makes them a force for horror just like anything else. Supernatural has done amazing things with using Angels as villains for horror, as has the Prophecy movies. There is a LOT of to mine for Angels in the Mists that is basically untouched.
The more I think about it, the more I really want to actually write about it. Perhaps a lost Van Richten's Guide, one he was unwilling to publish because the information he learned made him feel hopeless. I don't know, there is a LOT to be done here, with "willing" possession by Angels to ... Ghost Rider styled Angels of Vengenance ... to the Supernatural Angels who are trying to destroy the world to allow the whole thing to start over. There is something here, and I plan on writing more and more about it.
Re: Transposition by Angel?
I love the hell out of the Prophecy films, particularly the first one. Not just because of the idea of angels as villains, but also for the awesomely mind blowing idea of what do you even do when the devil takes your side in an argument?
Imagine a situation where you've managed to set the PCs in opposition to the goals of a celestial (whatever they are). Perhaps a celestial that is far outside their power to defeat. But suddenly they've got an unlikely ally...and probably wish they didn't. (Crowley from Supernatural is another example of how this can work well.)
A couple other good sources for horror angel ideas could be found in The Spectre (DC comics), Neil Gaiman's novel Neverwhere (Islington), or Gaiman's comic Murder Mysteries, who weren't so much fallen as driven insane. Because I can imagine that, if it's even remotely possible for an outsider to go mad, madness might easily be a celestial's response to being trapped in Ravenloft.
I liked Murder Mysteries a lot. It takes the ideas of "angels unawares" and applies it to the crazy beggar. Of course, once you realize what you're really talking to, it can be absolutely terrifying...especially when you realize the "crazy" part isn't an act.
While I've so far refused to watch Constantine (I'm too big a Hellblazer fan, and can't stand Keanu Reeves...), I've considered doing so anyway, because I walked in on the end of it once, and Tilda Swinton's Gabriel seemed intriguingly deranged.
Imagine a situation where you've managed to set the PCs in opposition to the goals of a celestial (whatever they are). Perhaps a celestial that is far outside their power to defeat. But suddenly they've got an unlikely ally...and probably wish they didn't. (Crowley from Supernatural is another example of how this can work well.)
A couple other good sources for horror angel ideas could be found in The Spectre (DC comics), Neil Gaiman's novel Neverwhere (Islington), or Gaiman's comic Murder Mysteries, who weren't so much fallen as driven insane. Because I can imagine that, if it's even remotely possible for an outsider to go mad, madness might easily be a celestial's response to being trapped in Ravenloft.
I liked Murder Mysteries a lot. It takes the ideas of "angels unawares" and applies it to the crazy beggar. Of course, once you realize what you're really talking to, it can be absolutely terrifying...especially when you realize the "crazy" part isn't an act.
While I've so far refused to watch Constantine (I'm too big a Hellblazer fan, and can't stand Keanu Reeves...), I've considered doing so anyway, because I walked in on the end of it once, and Tilda Swinton's Gabriel seemed intriguingly deranged.
Deranged Comics Fan
Strife-monger
Daughter of a Troll
Strife-monger
Daughter of a Troll
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Re: Transposition by Angel?
Well, whatever you like guys.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
Re: Transposition by Angel?
Oh man, a transpositioning angel. There is a story there.
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
Re: Transposition by Angel?
Heck, that might work nicely in the Crowdsourcing domain of Giddim. Someone write it up and add it!
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
Re: Transposition by Angel?
Your game, do what you like, etc etc, but these sorts of angels are not really in theme for gothic horror.
When you get right down to it, do you see any good in the world of Ravenloft? Is it a world of unrelenting horror where all good will inevitably fail and all hope is meaningless, or is it a spiritual battleground between good and evil where the choice actually means something?
When you get right down to it, do you see any good in the world of Ravenloft? Is it a world of unrelenting horror where all good will inevitably fail and all hope is meaningless, or is it a spiritual battleground between good and evil where the choice actually means something?
- Gonzoron of the FoS
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 7694
- Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: New Jersey
- Contact:
Re: Transposition by Angel?
I'm not sure how that choice precludes Angels that act in this way. The choice between good and evil can still be meaningful (perhaps moreso) if creatures other than humans can make the choice. The crux of the matter is, are angels an embodiment of absolute good, and unable to conceive of doing things that aren't good? (as alhoon sees them) Or are they as fallible as man in seeing what's good and what's not? Angels themselves don't often show up in gothic literature, so there's not a lot of precedent to go on. And the Ravenloft precedent, Isolde, shows that such a powerful force for Good (capital G) can't remain in Ravenloft and have solely good (small g) effects. While Isolde herself seems relatively* morally unscathed, not everyone who is changed by the Twisting is thrilled about it. (*Although, is the creation of the Abominations a "Good" punishment for their crimes? Isolde herself can be on shaky moral ground at times.)Ryan Naylor wrote:When you get right down to it, do you see any good in the world of Ravenloft? Is it a world of unrelenting horror where all good will inevitably fail and all hope is meaningless, or is it a spiritual battleground between good and evil where the choice actually means something?
I wouldn't say that good will inevitably fail. I will say that good will inevitably be tested.
ETA: Oh, and another good example of a "Good" extraplanar being (sort of) used as an antagonist: Angel: the Series
VIEW CONTENT:
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Re: Transposition by Angel?
Personally I prefer that each and every time an angel is tested, he/she/it passes the test. Sometimes without making the right choice, but the good choice.
Ryan: I actually didn't know there WAS a place for angels in gothic horror. IIRC they were seen as punishers more than good-doers. You did something bad? If an angel dropped by he/she/it would say "Bad boy. Get this curse". And turn you to a vampire.
Ryan: I actually didn't know there WAS a place for angels in gothic horror. IIRC they were seen as punishers more than good-doers. You did something bad? If an angel dropped by he/she/it would say "Bad boy. Get this curse". And turn you to a vampire.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
- Jester of the FoS
- Jester of the Dark Comedy

- Posts: 4536
- Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
- Location: A Canadian from Canadia
Re: Transposition by Angel?
I can see it working in a few ways.
First, there's the devout, chaste, holy figure who becomes "possessed" by an angel, becoming it's vessel in the mortal world. This might overlap with the 4e invoker or PF oracle, being another justification for those classes: a partially transposed angelic being.
Angels might also want to intervene in affairs in Ravenloft. But, being unwilling to be trapped, transposition might be a loophole, allowing themselves to imprint themselves on a mortal and confer an fraction of their essence and power (and will) while remaining outside of the demiplane proper.
Given angels cannot be resurrected and vanish upon death, this might be a way to repeatedly intervene despite the likely chance of failure and death. In this case, the angel is less pure good and more of a dick using mortals as meat puppets for a vendetta against evil.
There's a fun character there. Again, it might work well in Giddim as a contrast with the demon, but a slowly falling angel who is justifying more and more horrible things in their crusade.
Returning to the "no afterlife for angels" hook, you can imagine a trapped angel using this as a means to cheat death. After all, as a being of pure good in a land of darkness, it can do so much more than any one human or commoner. Its life has more value and can make up for the loss of one innocent being.
You can imagine Isolde or a similar figure using this as a way to continue to track the Gentleman Caller.
First, there's the devout, chaste, holy figure who becomes "possessed" by an angel, becoming it's vessel in the mortal world. This might overlap with the 4e invoker or PF oracle, being another justification for those classes: a partially transposed angelic being.
Angels might also want to intervene in affairs in Ravenloft. But, being unwilling to be trapped, transposition might be a loophole, allowing themselves to imprint themselves on a mortal and confer an fraction of their essence and power (and will) while remaining outside of the demiplane proper.
Given angels cannot be resurrected and vanish upon death, this might be a way to repeatedly intervene despite the likely chance of failure and death. In this case, the angel is less pure good and more of a dick using mortals as meat puppets for a vendetta against evil.
There's a fun character there. Again, it might work well in Giddim as a contrast with the demon, but a slowly falling angel who is justifying more and more horrible things in their crusade.
Returning to the "no afterlife for angels" hook, you can imagine a trapped angel using this as a means to cheat death. After all, as a being of pure good in a land of darkness, it can do so much more than any one human or commoner. Its life has more value and can make up for the loss of one innocent being.
You can imagine Isolde or a similar figure using this as a way to continue to track the Gentleman Caller.
Re: Transposition by Angel?
Another possible angle to look at it from... Celestials are often the servants of good deities. Good deities who have probably lost a lot of faithful mortal servants to Ravenloft. Deities that really can't do very much to influence workings within the Land of Mists itself due to...whatever it is that's going on between them and the Dark Powers.
Having an agent in there working on your behalf, even one you can no longer directly control, could be of a lot of benefit. And, of course, the celestial being cut off from that control could make a huge amount of difference in itself.
Having an agent in there working on your behalf, even one you can no longer directly control, could be of a lot of benefit. And, of course, the celestial being cut off from that control could make a huge amount of difference in itself.
Deranged Comics Fan
Strife-monger
Daughter of a Troll
Strife-monger
Daughter of a Troll
- High Priest Mikhal
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1642
- Joined: Sat Oct 20, 2007 5:48 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: It's dark and I hear laughing.
Re: Transposition by Angel?
I would think that's a violation of the Unspoken Pact. Even the eladrin (AFB, and I can't remember her name) who leads Carnival had to go to her superiors and sacrifice a lot of her power to even enter Ravenloft. I'm pretty sure the Dark Powers would trap other celestials in a similar way. Of course, if that's what you want then go ahead.Hazgarn wrote:Another possible angle to look at it from... Celestials are often the servants of good deities. Good deities who have probably lost a lot of faithful mortal servants to Ravenloft. Deities that really can't do very much to influence workings within the Land of Mists itself due to...whatever it is that's going on between them and the Dark Powers.
Having an agent in there working on your behalf, even one you can no longer directly control, could be of a lot of benefit. And, of course, the celestial being cut off from that control could make a huge amount of difference in itself.
One thing I'm not seeing mentioned is the aspect of Good Outsiders' reality wrinkles: they disrupt reality itself. No natural healing can occur within its radius, and native materials start to turn hideous in appearance before dissolving into the Mists completely. The RDMG says they can take a free action to supress it--but don't say what "it" stands for. Their whole reality wrinkle? Just the disruption? I'm thinking the former. Plus let's not forget that a celestial's reality disruption is an air-raid siren compared to the disruption paladins create. The darklord is going to know where they are instantly and probably react with due force.
"Money is the root of all evil...I think I need more money."
- alhoon
- Invisible Menace

- Posts: 9089
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
- Location: Chania or Athens // Greece
Re: Transposition by Angel?
On the above, it depends on how you view good. As far as good is generally accepted or in the game as far as Book of Exalted Deeds go, the above being is not good.Jester of the FoS wrote: Returning to the "no afterlife for angels" hook, you can imagine a trapped angel using this as a means to cheat death. After all, as a being of pure good in a land of darkness, it can do so much more than any one human or commoner. Its life has more value and can make up for the loss of one innocent being.
The "My life is more valuable" isn't an exemplar's of goodness view on life. The "little evil for the greater good" is not the exemplar's of goodness view either.
I.e. the angel above is also a dick with a vendetta against evil.
As I mentioned, in my campaign the only way I can see it work is with the chaste and good guy/girl that agrees in every step of the way, getting a promised place in heaven for an angel to get in. If that guy/girl finds out he's too attached with Ravenloft, the angel departs his body and finds someone else.
Their powers don't work there though. Sure, a powerful creature like Strahd wouldn't need his extra powers to beat a CR6 angel. But Ivan wouldn't be able to do anything personally AND he would lose his immunity to poison. So he would send henchmen.High Priest Mikhal wrote:. Plus let's not forget that a celestial's reality disruption is an air-raid siren compared to the disruption paladins create. The darklord is going to know where they are instantly and probably react with due force.
BTW I didn't know that the Angels could suppress their Reality Wrinkles.
PS. Considering that a deity's aura is 2000' per Divine Rank, I've changed the radius of the reality wrinkle to 200'/CR. Another reason I did that was campaign-oriented: I wanted my Ravenloft to be able to accomodate more than 10 outsiders at the same time, without the Darklords being confined into a tiny portion of their domain.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
-
Ryan Naylor
- Evil Genius

- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Thu Jun 24, 2004 10:55 pm
Re: Transposition by Angel?
What I was trying to get at in my last post:
Gothic horror and modern horror are very different things and coming from very different places. Gothic horror is founded in the late 18th to 19th centuries, which means as a genre it carries a lot of cultural preconceptions from that era: the existence of a just, benevolent and personal God is unquestioned, humans occupying a privileged space in creation, and so on. So even though evil exists, and is a powerful force in the world, so does good and innocence; sins may leave a taint, but ultimately they are repaid, evil is vanquished or self-destructs and the forces of good triumph (although they are often left scarred by the experience).
This was succeeded in the 1920s by cosmic horror, which took the discoveries of human evolution (that we’re not anything different from animals), psychology (we’re controlled by the bestial urges of our ids; what is innocence if even tiny children are sexually aware?), physics (the universe is frighteningly large and old and uncaring), recent history (the atrocities of World War I) and philosophy (particularly existentialism). Cosmic horror repainted human nature in terms of our powerlessness in a cold and uncaring universe that will casually destroy us. Human concerns, including good and evil, are fundamentally irrelevant human constructs that barely constrain our own base natures. And then this eventually led to modern horror, which I’m sure everyone is familiar with (but particularly, while we’re all still very clear that evil exists, we’re not so sure that good exists, and neither may exist in a personal form).
The point of difference (or at least, the point of difference relevant here) between gothic horror and its successors is the place good and evil and justice have in the narrative; it is utterly central to gothic horror, and marginalised or even irrelevant in later subgenres of horror.
So we have quotes like “the Gothic novel is a primitive detective story in which God or Fate is the detective.” At its most basic, gothic horror is about the contest between good and evil. Although the forces of evil may appear to be vastly more powerful and influential than good, good is just as powerful but a lot more subtle. They have courage, purity, the redemptive power of love, and (probably most importantly) the force of divine justice on their side. Gothic horror is primarily about heroism, and doing what is right in the face of seemingly insurmountable odds, with no financial rewards and often without recognition, because it is the right thing to do. The wages of sin may be immense temporal power, but it is a spiritually bankrupt existence.
The reason I’m writing all this is because the power of good and the centrality of that struggle between good and evil sometimes seems to me to be forgotten. As I said earlier, people seem very clear that evil exists, but not good: there are no happy endings, there’s no value in opposing evil, good is either weak, nonexistent or hypocritical, and there often seem to me to an adversarial relationship between GMs and players. This is where the reputation of Ravenloft as a PC meatgrinder comes from; you send your players there to struggle and die in horrific circumstances while the GM laughs manically, piling up more and more diabolus ex machina to torment them. The very existence of the
emoticon irritates me for this reason.
This is the thematic difference between Ravenloft and Warhammer; similar real-world historical timeframes for the setting, similar ideas about the corrosive and influential nature of evil, but diametrically opposed on the idea of good or hope.
At this point, I’ll go back to what I said earlier: it’s your game, and if that’s how you want to play it, that’s fine. All power to you. But I don’t think it’s in theme for the genre, and I don’t think it’s served Ravenloft well when it has cropped up.
Back to the angels:
VRGtFiends/Demons (and all the source material since then) casts fiends as pure, unadulterated, uncompromising, unsalvageable evil. Fine. But that means that, to be true to the genre, celestials are just as pure and unadulterated good (probably albeit more subtle – think of Isolde’s enforced illusion of humanity). Remember, these forces are either more or less evenly matched, or good has the (long term) upper hand. That means that angels in a gothic horror world are pure, unswerving servants of good. According to the game, as exemplars and outsiders, they are literally good made flesh. I understand that makes them hard to deal with, particularly in an adventure game, but that’s what they are. Unlike mortals (even darklords) whose natures are formed from a comingling of both sides (which is why paladins make mistakes and darklords have redeeming features), outsiders are pure. Remember that in certain Abrahamic traditions, outsiders don’t have freedom of choice in the way that mortals do.
I don’t actually have problems with angelic transposition, provided it’s done for the right reasons. Paladins and good monks are both essentially on the same path, after all. From the point of view of the mortal being transposed, your reward for a good life is that you get transported off to heaven – and unlike most, you get a clear indication that’s what’s happening, and you get to do it while still alive. And just like it says in Isolde’s description in Carnival, it’s an unparalleled opportunity for the angel to do some good. I do think that as a being of pure good, the angel needs to make sure that the mortal is willing, aware of what the decision means, and in charge of their own fates at every step of the way. It’s not an invasion of the mind, body and soul (like a fiendish transposition is), but a partnership. Perhaps more like being mounted by a good loah. (This is setting aside the question about whether they know which plane they’re answering the mail from, which fiends are explicitly said not to be able to do—and incidentally then, transposition must exist elsewhere, or fiends wouldn’t fall for it).
My issue is with the implicit idea that an angel needs to be fallen to be interesting, or to fit into Ravenloft:
Compare the number of fallen angels in D&D with the number of fallen/risen fiends. It’s overdone. I think it’s lazy storytelling, and based probably on the assumption that good is boring. There are plenty of opportunities for a being of perfect good to function effectively in a game (especially if they’re under orders to keep it subtle), even as an antagonist. Watching a loved one transpose might be terrifying for those around them, especially if they don’t understand what’s going on. Mental illness. A loved one who sounds like they’re going to commit suicide (“I’ll be in heaven soon”). For the person themselves: fear of leaving everything the know, doubt, whether they’re doing the right thing by abandoning their loved ones... And then there’s the question of deliberate malice by darklords and fiends who can sense the angel coming and want to make it difficult for those around them by creating fear around them. Then there’s the idea that mortals just can’t see the full picture, and might get on the wrong side that way (particularly the way a lot of PCs behave). That’s everything from a very tight psychological horror game to a very sweeping Salem witch hunt game depending on how you want to play it. Have a look at Jacob’s Ladder: the angels are terrifying even though all they want to do is help him, because he doesn’t understand and can’t see the whole picture; his organic nature is pulling him down.
I think that’s probably enough for now. Just to reiterate so you don’t think I’m flaming you: this is how I see things. You may see things differently, and that’s perfectly valid.
Gothic horror and modern horror are very different things and coming from very different places. Gothic horror is founded in the late 18th to 19th centuries, which means as a genre it carries a lot of cultural preconceptions from that era: the existence of a just, benevolent and personal God is unquestioned, humans occupying a privileged space in creation, and so on. So even though evil exists, and is a powerful force in the world, so does good and innocence; sins may leave a taint, but ultimately they are repaid, evil is vanquished or self-destructs and the forces of good triumph (although they are often left scarred by the experience).
This was succeeded in the 1920s by cosmic horror, which took the discoveries of human evolution (that we’re not anything different from animals), psychology (we’re controlled by the bestial urges of our ids; what is innocence if even tiny children are sexually aware?), physics (the universe is frighteningly large and old and uncaring), recent history (the atrocities of World War I) and philosophy (particularly existentialism). Cosmic horror repainted human nature in terms of our powerlessness in a cold and uncaring universe that will casually destroy us. Human concerns, including good and evil, are fundamentally irrelevant human constructs that barely constrain our own base natures. And then this eventually led to modern horror, which I’m sure everyone is familiar with (but particularly, while we’re all still very clear that evil exists, we’re not so sure that good exists, and neither may exist in a personal form).
The point of difference (or at least, the point of difference relevant here) between gothic horror and its successors is the place good and evil and justice have in the narrative; it is utterly central to gothic horror, and marginalised or even irrelevant in later subgenres of horror.
So we have quotes like “the Gothic novel is a primitive detective story in which God or Fate is the detective.” At its most basic, gothic horror is about the contest between good and evil. Although the forces of evil may appear to be vastly more powerful and influential than good, good is just as powerful but a lot more subtle. They have courage, purity, the redemptive power of love, and (probably most importantly) the force of divine justice on their side. Gothic horror is primarily about heroism, and doing what is right in the face of seemingly insurmountable odds, with no financial rewards and often without recognition, because it is the right thing to do. The wages of sin may be immense temporal power, but it is a spiritually bankrupt existence.
The reason I’m writing all this is because the power of good and the centrality of that struggle between good and evil sometimes seems to me to be forgotten. As I said earlier, people seem very clear that evil exists, but not good: there are no happy endings, there’s no value in opposing evil, good is either weak, nonexistent or hypocritical, and there often seem to me to an adversarial relationship between GMs and players. This is where the reputation of Ravenloft as a PC meatgrinder comes from; you send your players there to struggle and die in horrific circumstances while the GM laughs manically, piling up more and more diabolus ex machina to torment them. The very existence of the
This is the thematic difference between Ravenloft and Warhammer; similar real-world historical timeframes for the setting, similar ideas about the corrosive and influential nature of evil, but diametrically opposed on the idea of good or hope.
At this point, I’ll go back to what I said earlier: it’s your game, and if that’s how you want to play it, that’s fine. All power to you. But I don’t think it’s in theme for the genre, and I don’t think it’s served Ravenloft well when it has cropped up.
Back to the angels:
VRGtFiends/Demons (and all the source material since then) casts fiends as pure, unadulterated, uncompromising, unsalvageable evil. Fine. But that means that, to be true to the genre, celestials are just as pure and unadulterated good (probably albeit more subtle – think of Isolde’s enforced illusion of humanity). Remember, these forces are either more or less evenly matched, or good has the (long term) upper hand. That means that angels in a gothic horror world are pure, unswerving servants of good. According to the game, as exemplars and outsiders, they are literally good made flesh. I understand that makes them hard to deal with, particularly in an adventure game, but that’s what they are. Unlike mortals (even darklords) whose natures are formed from a comingling of both sides (which is why paladins make mistakes and darklords have redeeming features), outsiders are pure. Remember that in certain Abrahamic traditions, outsiders don’t have freedom of choice in the way that mortals do.
I don’t actually have problems with angelic transposition, provided it’s done for the right reasons. Paladins and good monks are both essentially on the same path, after all. From the point of view of the mortal being transposed, your reward for a good life is that you get transported off to heaven – and unlike most, you get a clear indication that’s what’s happening, and you get to do it while still alive. And just like it says in Isolde’s description in Carnival, it’s an unparalleled opportunity for the angel to do some good. I do think that as a being of pure good, the angel needs to make sure that the mortal is willing, aware of what the decision means, and in charge of their own fates at every step of the way. It’s not an invasion of the mind, body and soul (like a fiendish transposition is), but a partnership. Perhaps more like being mounted by a good loah. (This is setting aside the question about whether they know which plane they’re answering the mail from, which fiends are explicitly said not to be able to do—and incidentally then, transposition must exist elsewhere, or fiends wouldn’t fall for it).
My issue is with the implicit idea that an angel needs to be fallen to be interesting, or to fit into Ravenloft:
Again, we're getting into fallen angel territory, but that's Ravenloft for you...
Kind of like the way the angels in Supernatural required the consent of their vessels...even if they weren't necessarily 100% honest about the consequences... Now, that isn't to say that, regardless of how willing the participant is or their reasons for accepting, the process once begun won't be scarring and horrifying, with the mortal--and, conceivably, the celestial--coming out a little damaged by the experience on other end...
A new way for horror to enter the game... I've never viewed Angels as "perfect beings" in DnD, and certainly not in Ravenloft. I picture them as beings of unwavering duty.
In order: no, that’s not how I see it; even if there were consequences, wouldn’t a mortal sufficiently pure to transpose with an angel still take it on, so the angel wouldn’t have to lie by omission?, and again, not everything has to be tarnished (Prophecy and Supernatural are both closer to modern horror than gothic); that’s not how I see it, and isn’t consistent with who fiends are treated, and also I don’t think how outsiders are treated in the rest of the D&D multiverse necessarily applies here; and as Alhoon said, that’s not an angel, that’s being a dick. Also celestials have phylacteries; Isolde’s is her sword.you can imagine a trapped angel using this as a means to cheat death
Compare the number of fallen angels in D&D with the number of fallen/risen fiends. It’s overdone. I think it’s lazy storytelling, and based probably on the assumption that good is boring. There are plenty of opportunities for a being of perfect good to function effectively in a game (especially if they’re under orders to keep it subtle), even as an antagonist. Watching a loved one transpose might be terrifying for those around them, especially if they don’t understand what’s going on. Mental illness. A loved one who sounds like they’re going to commit suicide (“I’ll be in heaven soon”). For the person themselves: fear of leaving everything the know, doubt, whether they’re doing the right thing by abandoning their loved ones... And then there’s the question of deliberate malice by darklords and fiends who can sense the angel coming and want to make it difficult for those around them by creating fear around them. Then there’s the idea that mortals just can’t see the full picture, and might get on the wrong side that way (particularly the way a lot of PCs behave). That’s everything from a very tight psychological horror game to a very sweeping Salem witch hunt game depending on how you want to play it. Have a look at Jacob’s Ladder: the angels are terrifying even though all they want to do is help him, because he doesn’t understand and can’t see the whole picture; his organic nature is pulling him down.
I think that’s probably enough for now. Just to reiterate so you don’t think I’m flaming you: this is how I see things. You may see things differently, and that’s perfectly valid.
Re: Transposition by Angel?
I get that. And immediately would like to point to:Ryan Naylor wrote: But I don’t think it’s in theme for the genre, and I don’t think it’s served Ravenloft well when it has cropped up.
- Vechor, a place that is horrific Midsummer Night's Dream (not gothic)
- Pharazia, a place that is horrific Persian folklore (not gothic)
- Timor, a place that is based on the Alien franchise (not gothic)
- Bluetspur, a place that is literally all cthullu brain monsters all the time (not gothic)
- Darkon, a place that is literally evil Middle Earth (not gothic)
So on and so on and so on. Ravenloft is founded in gothic and evolved to pull its references/building blocks from elsewhere in horror. There is a lot to mine with Angels/the Host/law v. good. And I think discounting it is the surest way to miss out on GREAT ideas being added to Ravenloft as a whole, which keeps the setting growing in new and interesting ways.
Even better, it's your game and you can run it how you want. I LOVE the post you put up, because it gives details many people didn't know about the history. And quite clearly you think it is a bad idea to expand into this quite honestly new territory of unmined horror-ness for the setting. But I for one am THRILLED we are getting so much discussion from just the random thought that popped in my head, including your discussion!
I love this place. Long live Ravenloft. Excelsior.
