Page 2 of 2

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Fri Jan 04, 2013 7:02 pm
by HuManBing
Man, I have to dig further into that game system. I played an introductory adventure of that, but my character specifically backed away from possible occult weirdness, so I didn't get to try out the horror/madness mechanics.

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Fri Jan 04, 2013 7:09 pm
by alhoon
Jester of the FoS wrote: And here's the strength of 5th Edition: the focus on modularity and drop-in design. Why settle for just one version of madness?
I hear a lot about modularity but so far, I only see "modularity". Yes, they promised. I doupt they will deliver. I'm not optimistic that their vision of modularity is what we would call real modularity.
Modularity would be to have the choice of spell points or spells or at-will/encounter/daily spells in the same book as options for the game. Or Different combat systems. That kind of stuff.
"Modularity" is having a nice set of maneuvers and choosing which to use to make your own fighter. Still good, but not as good as multitude of core mechanics.
Jester of the FoS wrote: There can be one for games that need periodic madness with a single save sending you into insanity. And there could be a variant where you track Sanity with insanity being a regular threat. People can decide how much of a role they want madness to play a part in their game.
Yeap, that works. And I still wouldn't call that modularity. ;)
The point is... what would we want for Ravenloft? Personally I would go with sanity track.
Leliel wrote: You know what I liked? Unknown Armies.

There are many different kinds of stressor, and most people do not react to them the same way. One person might come out of the Far Realm perfectly fine, if a little shaken, but human cruelty might send him to tears.

UA realized that, and realized that system works very well with its brand of humanistic horror.
Can you elaborate more?

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Sat Jan 05, 2013 1:31 pm
by Jester of the FoS
alhoon wrote:I hear a lot about modularity but so far, I only see "modularity". Yes, they promised. I doubt they will deliver. I'm not optimistic that their vision of modularity is what we would call real modularity.
Modularity would be to have the choice of spell points or spells or at-will/encounter/daily spells in the same book as options for the game. Or Different combat systems. That kind of stuff.
"Modularity" is having a nice set of maneuvers and choosing which to use to make your own fighter. Still good, but not as good as multitude of core mechanics.
We already saw their spell point system, and they want to tweak the sorcerer so it's not just a wizard with spell points, as they plan on allowing wizards to take that system as well.
But right now they're playing with Vancian memorization, and adding optional systems would complicate things. You don't want to add the customization options until the baseline is set.

But you can already see some of the modularity in the healing rules. That's just the first example, hopefully of many.

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Sat Jan 05, 2013 1:44 pm
by alhoon
Jester of the FoS wrote: But you can already see some of the modularity in the healing rules. That's just the first example, hopefully of many.
Should I bump again the 4E thread with our expectations for the final product? :wink: Our anticipation with "Wooo, with the 1/5th of the game we've seen so far, it seems nice" while we've actually seen 3/4th of the game and haven't realized it yet?
Nope, never again. I judge by what I see, not what I hope I will see. (PS IMO their spell point system was good but kinda weird)

The healing variants is an example of "modularity". As I said, since 4E and the "ehh... what you saw was actually most of the game" I judge by what I see, not by what I hope to see.

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Sat Jan 05, 2013 2:28 pm
by HuManBing
alhoon wrote:
Leliel wrote: You know what I liked? Unknown Armies.

There are many different kinds of stressor, and most people do not react to them the same way. One person might come out of the Far Realm perfectly fine, if a little shaken, but human cruelty might send him to tears.

UA realized that, and realized that system works very well with its brand of humanistic horror.
Can you elaborate more?
Here are my notes from an Unknown Armies game I played about 3 years back. I did not read the rule book - this was our GM's summary of the game mechanics for players' benefit.

"MADNESS:
The GM chooses a stress meter, and a rank of the check.
If hardened notches are equal or greater than rank, no roll.
If less than, make a Mind check. Success gives you a hard notch, and you can act as you wish. Failure gives you a failed notch, and you must either flee, freeze, or fight."

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Sun Jan 06, 2013 1:32 am
by Leliel
HuManBing wrote: "MADNESS:
The GM chooses a stress meter, and a rank of the check.
If hardened notches are equal or greater than rank, no roll.
If less than, make a Mind check. Success gives you a hard notch, and you can act as you wish. Failure gives you a failed notch, and you must either flee, freeze, or fight."
That.

Basically, there are five varieties of stress: Violence, Unnatural, Isolation, Helplessness, and Self, with Self being actions that you, yourself, do that are mentally troubling.

Fail a check, get a failed notch and progress that further to an actual mental illness. Succeed a check, and you get a hardened notch and it doesn't bother you as much.

Thing is, "what doesn't bother you as much" tends to include things like torturing people and such, so max out the hardened meters in two categories and you become emotionally dead (the game uses "sociopath", but that seems like it better refers to someone who's maxed out their Self hardening). Everyone's psyche is a little different, so they have better resistance to some things and worse to others, represented by hardened and failed notches in character creation.

Here's the thing though-notches are pretty easy to lose, you just need a therapist (which is to say, someone who knows you well). This fits in with the theme of the game that humans are responsible for their own fates-everything supernatural in UA is a human magus, a former human, a creation (however unintentional) of humans, or the ghost of a human. Well, that and the Comte St Germain, who's really more of a gestalt being formed of the best and worst traits of humanity.

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Sun Jan 06, 2013 6:53 am
by alhoon
Seems solid and it uses a kind of sanity meter.
For the horror fans here (I usually use Ravenloft as fantasy with a theme) the accumulating fear and horror of the heroes that may lead to a breakdown is good thing. For the rest of us... a more simplified version that works like mental "hp" or something.

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Sun Jan 06, 2013 9:21 am
by Jester of the FoS
alhoon wrote:
Jester of the FoS wrote: But you can already see some of the modularity in the healing rules. That's just the first example, hopefully of many.
Should I bump again the 4E thread with our expectations for the final product? :wink: Our anticipation with "Wooo, with the 1/5th of the game we've seen so far, it seems nice" while we've actually seen 3/4th of the game and haven't realized it yet?
Nope, never again. I judge by what I see, not what I hope I will see. (PS IMO their spell point system was good but kinda weird)

The healing variants is an example of "modularity". As I said, since 4E and the "ehh... what you saw was actually most of the game" I judge by what I see, not by what I hope to see.
Fair enough. But given modularity and swappable rules systems is one of their key goals and major selling, I will be very disappointed if we don't get it.

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Sun Jan 06, 2013 11:45 am
by alhoon
Jester of the FoS wrote: But given modularity and swappable rules systems is one of their key goals and major selling, I will be very disappointed if we don't get it.
That's the key here. :wink: For a great deal of us, the previous edition was one a big disappointment (and I say that as one of the few that enjoyed 4th edition). So I keep my hopes low. It's better to be pleasantly suprised, than hop from foot to foot in anticipation and get a product that actually fails to deliver the promises.

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Sun Jan 06, 2013 2:44 pm
by HuManBing
:shock:

Alhoon, when did you get that custom title?

How am I going to keep track of your movements now, you invisible fiend???

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Sun Jan 06, 2013 10:35 pm
by alhoon
Weeeeeell... I got it like 3 years ago or so, in the Fraternity play by post game.

Re: Ravenloft monsters/variations for 5th edition.

Posted: Mon Jan 07, 2013 12:52 am
by Zilfer
Your an Evil Genius.... I'm sure you'll think of something.... :Strahd: