Page 2 of 4
Re: THis just... I just... good lord...
Posted: Wed Apr 03, 2013 4:32 pm
by Zilfer
HuManBing wrote:For what it's worth, real life legal systems rarely punish criminal intent; they only punish criminal acts. One of the main logistical concerns is the difficulty of proving what went on in a person's mind. In free societies there is also the philosophical outlook that a citizen deserves to enjoy freedom of thought, no matter how objectionable, inside the privacy of their own mind. (So I'm free to think about rape, murder, and jaywalking as long as I don't actually try it out for real.)
In your campaign, however, the Dark Powers may be omniscient and may be able to infallibly determine this information...
Kinda on that side as well... though that may be because I don't believe we can fully control our thought processes. I mean how many times have you thought of something objectionable and not done it? Pushing someone out a window? or even the REALLY weird ones that you would never admit to people not even on the internet? They just come way out of left field and your like.... "where the hell did that come from?" type thoughts. xD
Or am I the only one with those? *Crickets*
Anyways if the darkpowers read minds I think they dont' punish the thoughts but arrange events to give more chances for said thoughts to come to fruitation.
Re: THis just... I just... good lord...
Posted: Wed Apr 03, 2013 6:18 pm
by Ryan Naylor
I would say that murder is an illegal killing. However, I'm going to say that "illegal" in this sense includes natural law as well as judicial law.
To draw on Hobbes' concept of natural law (which comes from about the same period that the enlightenment domains in Ravenloft are set), there are two main principles:
The first Law of nature is that every man ought to endeavour peace, as far as he has hope of obtaining it; and when he cannot obtain it, that he may seek and use all helps and advantages of war.
The second Law of nature is that a man be willing, when others are so too, as far forth, as for peace, and defence of himself he shall think it necessary, to lay down this right to all things; and be contented with so much liberty against other men, as he would allow other men against himself.
...
The seventh Law is that in revenges, men look not at the greatness of the evil past, but the greatness of the good to follow.
So from natural law, you're entitled to defend yourself (and your families). You can even kill someone for previous wrong (in revenges), provided that great good will follow. Which means that PCs are still able to attack bandits and monsters and so on (which is an essential part of most games), but if no good will come of the killing (according to a reasonable, disinterested observer--as in most revenge killings), or the victim is innocent (judicial murder, the sorts of killing most darklords and monsters go in for), it's murder.
Sometimes, natural law and judicial law conflict. How much weight you give to one over the other is one of the things that separates chaotics from lawfuls.
That's my rule of thumb. There may be obvious exceptions and nuances.
Re: THis just... I just... good lord...
Posted: Wed Apr 03, 2013 7:03 pm
by Zilfer
As with any system there are flaws... xD
Re: THis just... I just... good lord...
Posted: Wed Apr 03, 2013 8:21 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Ryan Naylor wrote:Sometimes, natural law and judicial law conflict. How much weight you give to one over the other is one of the things that separates chaotics from lawfuls.
I would argue that natural law separates good from evil rather than law from chaos. Since natural law is focused on the greater good, it resonates more with the moral axis as opposed to the ethical axis. Paladins, for example, have a caveat in their code of conduct that says to respect
legitimate authority. If a judicial system is clearly evil, it's not legitimate and they don't risk losing their paladin status for opposing such. Look at how paladins fight devils as zealously as demons. Good is more important to them than law when the two clash, even if they are more likely to attempt change from within unless they find the rot goes too deep. Likewise a chaotic good society may make them uncomfortable, but they aren't bound by their code to oppose it on general principle. The same is true for chaotic good individuals; they're more likely to rebel against evil societies but they aren't going to go straight to armed insurrection. Civil disobedience, demonstrations, even Robin Hood-style antics are more appropriate to someone who is chaotic
good. If the system is unrepentantly, irredeemably evil, that's when it's time for armed opposition. If they find themselves in a lawful good society they can agree on the ends if not the methods, most likely finding a niche as well-intentioned rebels or harmless rabble rousers.
Both are still going to try and bring a greater good from the grim realities. That's stated as part of the seventh natural law. Ignoring natural law is more the providence of the morally neutral at best, evil at worst, IMO.
All that said, it would seem that some entities (read: darklords and others as corrupted by failed powers checks) fall into a sort of limbo. Having forged their own damnations they are already being punished in the most fitting manners possible. Yet when they visit evil and suffering on others it's hard not to see how plotting their deaths isn't a crime. Does one let them exist in the misery they made for themselves and continue to torment innocents? Or is their destruction a far more preferable path?
Re: THis just... I just... good lord...
Posted: Wed Apr 03, 2013 8:37 pm
by Ryan Naylor
Natural law in Hobbes' conception is explicitly *not* based on the greater good - it talks about great good, but not greater good, because Hobbes was critiquing the proto-utilitarian philosophies that were around at the time and before.
However, morality is obviously a very complex field which maps onto the alignment system in complex ways.
You are right in saying I was thinking about LG and CG; I was. I would argue that there are certain brands of LN and CN that also follow the same idea though - LN people who think community is important enough that they're prepared to tolerate a bit of evil for the greater good, and so CN people with personal freedom (the anarchist who wants to tear down a corrupt society for the greater good, and is prepared to blow up innocents to make it happen). In Planescape, that's fundamentally the ethos of the planes of Arcadia and Ysgard.
I also didn't say that LG weight judicial law exclusively. If you're LG, judicial law has to be based on natural law. If it's not, it's not legitimate law. But the important thing is that they recognise the importance of judicial law, whereas CG people don't recognise it *as much* (again, not "at all").
LE people might accept judicial law with or without natural law, whereas CE people don't recognise either. Some brands of CN and LN might do the same. OR the evil alignments might recognise these laws, but apply it to everyone but themselves.
As I said, it's a complex terrain. And these discussions have a tendency to degenerate quickly.
EDIT for your second point: Darklords are being punished for specific crimes. Strahd - the murder of Sergei, the murder of his wedding guests, his war crimes, his deal with Inajira, etc. Everything that he's done since then that has been cruel or vicious or blasphemous or involving black magic has not been. Basically, they just keep racking up evil and promoting suffering for those around them (that's one of the main arguments for the Dark Powers-as-evil camp). In which case, it is not immoral to plot their deaths.
Of course, if you think that Fate has them in hand, and you priorities the second law over the seventh, you may be content to let them stew. Again, it's complex, and there is room for individual weightings and decision making.
Re: THis just... I just... good lord...
Posted: Thu Apr 04, 2013 5:58 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
Good points, my friend. I especially don't want to see this thread degenerate into yet another list of rants and flames. There's enough of that on the
Non Sequitur page daily to fill a demagogue's book of speeches for life. I fear we're close to derailing this thread, too.
Getting back to the OP, the core question is worth exploring deeper. Why is it "less evil" (read: lower powers check) to do bad things to evil people? Is it a way of using metagaming to tempt players (who shouldn't be metagaming)? Or do the Dark Powers really care less about the black-hearted? If the latter, why?
Re: THis just... I just... good lord...
Posted: Thu Apr 04, 2013 7:52 pm
by Joël of the FoS
Don't worry about this thread, we keep an eye on all "muscular discussion" threads. But I have to say this site rarely needs moderation, or is invaded by trolls. Keep the good spirit alive.
Interesting discussion too.
Re: THis just... I just... good lord...
Posted: Thu Apr 04, 2013 9:48 pm
by alhoon
As for the "planning to murder the irredimably evil"... it's after all, a D&D game. In the vast majority of D&D games you kill bad people. You don't arrest them, you bring a sword on them. While you fight your way to the big bad ? (? stands for a living person or monster) you also kill minions that may not be that evil or not at all.
Yes, my PCs can plan to kill the evil warlord/cleric/lycanthrope/doppleganger/red Widow. They don't roll a PC for casting disintigrade on him/her/it in a fight. They wouldn't even roll a PC if they casted or killed the villan before the fight started if they did it "fair".
Yet, if they killed him/her/it with poison, or in his/her/its sleep or after he/she/it has surrendered etc, I would require a PC.
That's me though.
Re: THis just... I just... good lord...
Posted: Fri Apr 05, 2013 6:21 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
alhoon wrote:As for the "planning to murder the irredimably evil"... it's after all, a D&D game. In the vast majority of D&D games you kill bad people.
This. And in Ravenloft, where a good portion of the authority figures and structures are evil, good won't get far if it can't fib to the town guard or cover for a hunted innocent now and then. That's the ultimate behind the scenes purpose of the chart: enforce a stronger moral code than standard D&D while letting the heroes do what heroes do in this kind of story.
Re: THis just... I just... good lord...
Posted: Fri Apr 05, 2013 7:10 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
OK, so I hit the books.
Near as I can figure, the infamous chart doesn't even exist in the Black Box. Am I missing it? If someone can point me to a page number, that would be great. But the Black Box section on PCs simply seems to say "pick a number between 1 and 5%, or if really evil, 10%"
It seems the chart isn't codified until the Oaths of Evil booklet in the Forbidden Lore boxed set. This chart is later rolled into the Red Box, Domains of Dread, R3E, etc. And in that booklet, it EXPLICITLY says that the evil act is cross-referenced with the
victim's alignment, for crimes and acts of violence. (For Unholy Acts, it's cross-referenced with the alignment of the faith being violated, which is kinda the same thing. The faith is the victim here.) Further, in the same chapter it says that the chart is for PCs only, and that for NPCs the DM should just decide whether the DPs notice a given act or not.
So, I'm not sure where they are even seeing the chart if they are just "reviewing" the Black Box. Someone must be looking at or remembering the chart from a different edition of the setting material. Yes, we all have our opinions on the matter, and we can debate them and have fun, whatever works for you, etc. But if the question is: what was the intent of the original authors? Then the answer is clear. We are right. They are wrong.

It is as you said in your OP, the victim's alignment that can reduce or increase the severity of the Power Check, not the perpetrator's. So "frank" is condemning the system based on misinformation. Will it change his opinion to tell him? Probably not, but have fun if you try.
(I put reviewing in quotes because I just took a look through the link for the first time, and it seems like they are practically giving it the MST3K treatment, rather than a serious review.

Please don't start a board-war, folks, but anyone who wants to champion Ravenloft over there, good luck! For my part, I don't have the stamina for such things anymore, and will restrain myself with the help of xkcd:
http://xkcd.com/386/ )
Re: THis just... I just... good lord...
Posted: Fri Apr 05, 2013 10:23 am
by High Priest Mikhal
alhoon wrote:As for the "planning to murder the irredimably evil"... it's after all, a D&D game. In the vast majority of D&D games you kill bad people. You don't arrest them, you bring a sword on them. While you fight your way to the big bad ? (? stands for a living person or monster) you also kill minions that may not be that evil or not at all.
Yes, my PCs can plan to kill the evil warlord/cleric/lycanthrope/doppleganger/red Widow. They don't roll a PC for casting disintigrade on him/her/it in a fight. They wouldn't even roll a PC if they casted or killed the villan before the fight started if they did it "fair".
Yet, if they killed him/her/it with poison, or in his/her/its sleep or after he/she/it has surrendered etc, I would require a PC.
That's me though.
Okay, this I mostly have to agree with. There is a definite difference between a fight and going after a BBEG when they're helpless to resist. As for poison, it and sneak attacks are covered in the 3.5
RDMG as not being evil in and of themselves. Underhanded, yes. But not evil as a combat technique. The intentions behind their use determine whether they call for powers checks or not. Ivana Boritsi and Ivan Dilisnya are object examples of how it's not poison itself that is evil but the poisoner. Though even I'll admit some poisons, such as Necropolitan amaranth extract and others that draw on negative energy or evil supernatural forces, are inherently evil.
Re: THis just... I just... good lord...
Posted: Fri Apr 05, 2013 12:40 pm
by HuManBing
2e had an entry for the disintegration chamber which states that putting any sentient being - even a darklord - into it and turning it on will trigger a Powers Check.
Of course, like most rules dealing with the good/evil axis, I think this says more about the author than it does to illustrate any universal standard. Certainly each GM is likely to have different nuances and readings.
Re: THis just... I just... good lord...
Posted: Fri Apr 05, 2013 2:17 pm
by The Pickled Punk
My main view on Dark Powers checks is that they are a game mechanic that should only really apply to player characters. If the DM wants an NPC to have failed one or more DP checks, then the DM should assign the stage of corruption that the NPC has reached, determine what benefits and curses the Dark Power granted to the NPC and call it a night. The DM should never roll randomly for an NPC to determine if they have attracted the Dark Powers' attention.
With that caveat being said, even if a DM feels that NPCs should be subject to random rolls to determine how corrupt they are, the table in the Black Box is clearly meant to indicate who the victim is, not the perpetrator. The Dark Powers' view of morality takes into account the relationship of the sinner and those he or she sins against. A father who murders his daughter is worse in their eyes than an adventurer killing a Red Widow who is pleading for her life (especially when he's just stopped her from laying her eggs in another party member). There are certain activities that just fly under the radar of the Dark Powers, either not warranting a check or having a 1% chance of drawing their notice. Then there are acts of Ultimate Evil that show up like a flare on a dark night; a PC who murders another PC is a good example.
After a long while away from running Ravenloft I've managed to gather players for a new campaign. I finally feel confident I have enough system mastery with 4E to use those rules. One issue I haven't decided yet is to keep the percentile chances (using the Ravenloft Campaign Setting's chart) or to use a simpler, d20 based mechanic. Either way, my rule of thumb is going to be that only PCs are subject to the game mechanic. Playing 4E (as both player and DM) has made me realize that the NPCs need to be defined clearly and not be subject to the fickleness of random die rolls for non-combat events.
Re: THis just... I just... good lord...
Posted: Fri Apr 05, 2013 2:27 pm
by The Pickled Punk
HuManBing wrote:2e had an entry for the disintegration chamber which states that putting any sentient being - even a darklord - into it and turning it on will trigger a Powers Check.
The point of that is to illustrate that the PCs should be using a magic item called a "Disintegration Chamber" as a toy. They should be using it to get rid of garbage.
More to the point, the PCs should really be heroes. Someone who sneaks into Castle Ravenloft at dawn, hunts for Strahd's coffin and tries to stake him, braving traps and monsters, is a hero. Someone who grabs Dr. Victor Mordenheim out of his bed and tosses the mad scientist into his own Disintegration Chamber, is most likely not.
Re: THis just... I just... good lord...
Posted: Fri Apr 05, 2013 3:26 pm
by alhoon
What on earth is a disintigration chamber, that should only be used on garbage?
If it is a non magical big furnance then I would say I would agree that locking a sentient creature there and burn it alive is a painful way to end it's life, since to put it in there, you probably had it overpowered, so you could end it in a more humane way.
If it is a chamber that casts freaking disintigrate on something inside it, then I would say such things should not IMO exist in Ravenloft.