Page 2 of 4

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Thu Oct 10, 2013 9:43 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Dion of the Fraternity wrote:Image
I'll hold off for now. So far we're having a civil and reasonable discussion.

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Thu Oct 10, 2013 10:22 am
by alhoon
Mortavius wrote: Ardonk Szeria, the leader of the Gundarakite rebels in Barovia. He's actually filled all three of those criteria above.
Yes, he's a good example. Making him a bit more firebrandish and you're OK.

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Thu Oct 10, 2013 12:43 pm
by Tobias Blackburn
I get using a terrorist-type NPC in the game. It can make for some interesting stories and puts the players in a position of having to decide how to handle a situation when the side with the valid concerns are being just as reprehensible as the oppressing force.

But what does a direct analog to Bin Ladin or any specific terrorist or real world group add to the game other than shock value or pushing players' buttons? I've usually found that it removes immersion to be overly heavy handed with real world issues. It generally works best if you figure out what themes or specific parts of an event or person you think would make a good story/interesting character and work something new out of those.

So what is it you're looking for? War criminal who thinks he's a holy warrior? A mastermind who leads followers against his enemies but sees them as utterly disposable? What is it about this one historical figure that you feel would make a good basis for a new darklord? Or does it just tread into wish-fulfillment where you'd like to imagine the guy eternally suffering for his crimes?

Because the last one doesn't really make for a great game unless everyone wants to do just that, in which case why not just spend the session having their characters just beating up whatever historical figure they want?

I think that it's easier to just use Diamabel that try to shoe-horn in a very specific translation for a single historical figure. He was a religious fanatic who led a holy war against those that didn't follow his god or his creed. His crimes made him a darklord and he's denied the reward/transformation/closeness with his god that he expected. His daytime form is the reward he expected and desires but his nighttime form mocks it.

We don't know just how Diamabel carried out his early victories or the nature of most of his foes. Maybe he was just doing hit and run on other tribes. Maybe he was performing suicide attacks on foreign presences in his land. In the end it isn't all that important because the how he did it isn't as important as the what he did and why he did it. The how also has little to do with his current situation.

You can make parallels between Drakov and Hitler, but Drakov isn't just Ravenloft Hitler.
Same with Gwydion having similarities with Cthulhu but not simply being Ravenloft Cthulhu. It's easier to create a darklord and their punishment when you are working from a theme and a few inspirations rather than a single guy.

Edit: Minor spelling and grammar cleaning.

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Thu Oct 10, 2013 1:29 pm
by Dark Angel
I agree with Tobias. Strahd is not a carbon copy of Dracula as are many other darklord who bear some similarity. Diamabel makes for a good starting point if you wanted to attach a similar themed bad guy onto his (usually unfamiliar) template. Use these things to flesh out the darklords we have instead of creating new ones. Adding depth to the current ones makes them all the more potent and viable in a roleplaying setting. Having a hint of this guy and that guy from more familiar settings and characters helps us form ideas in our heads and assists the players in conceptualizing what they are dealing with.

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Thu Oct 10, 2013 1:50 pm
by Zilfer
Indeed, though a lot of people read things into other's when they aren't supposed to be directly related. I mean unless you specifically state it's modeled after Bin Ladin I doubt anyone's going to notice and if they do I'm sure there have been plenty like him. Just like i'm sure Hitler isn't the first just one of the most well known. xD

I'm curious if there's any parrallels with Stalin or his predesesor? If i remember right some people have attributed Stalin with killing his own people, kind of like Drakov kills daily for his evening meal? Though I wonder if he really enjoys it or just does it because he can.

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Thu Oct 10, 2013 2:36 pm
by MichaelTumey
While I agree that using fairly recent historical people as a darklord is a bad idea, creating a ficticious Darklord based on inspiration by real people is workable.

However, Osama Bin Ladin is not really darklord material. Sadaam Hussein, and/or his sons Uday and Kusay, on the other hand are far more likely darklord candidates if you ask me (though I still wouldn't use them directly, only as inspiration for darklords.) As torturers, commissioners of bio/chemical weapons, plus Hussein's actions are based on greed and power-hunger, whereas Osama's platform is more political tied to faith (which doesn't seem as dark as the Hussein activities.)

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Thu Oct 10, 2013 2:37 pm
by Dark Angel
Zilfer wrote:Indeed, though a lot of people read things into other's when they aren't supposed to be directly related. I mean unless you specifically state it's modeled after Bin Ladin I doubt anyone's going to notice and if they do I'm sure there have been plenty like him. Just like i'm sure Hitler isn't the first just one of the most well known. xD

I'm curious if there's any parrallels with Stalin or his predesesor? If i remember right some people have attributed Stalin with killing his own people, kind of like Drakov kills daily for his evening meal? Though I wonder if he really enjoys it or just does it because he can.
I have always seen Aderre as a better Hitler than Drakov. Stalinist types seems more up Drakov's alley with the totalitarianism and lack of a genocidal component. Invidia's war on the Vistani (even to the point of crossing borders to end the plague) falls under Hitler's insane vision more so.

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Thu Oct 10, 2013 3:00 pm
by MichaelTumey
Dark Angel wrote:Stalinist types seems more up Drakov's alley with the totalitarianism and lack of a genocidal component. Invidia's war on the Vistani (even to the point of crossing borders to end the plague) falls under Hitler's insane vision more so.
Are you saying that Stalin types involve a lack of a genocidal component? Because, in my estimation far more people died under Stalin's rule, than everyone killed by Hitler's orders. Stalin definitely had a genocidal component in his rule of law.

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Thu Oct 10, 2013 3:09 pm
by Zilfer
I believe what he is saying actually is that he see's Drakov more of a Stalin type figure minus the genocidal part of Stalin. :wink:

Go ahead and correct me if I'm wrong but that's how I read his sentance. :D

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Thu Oct 10, 2013 3:14 pm
by Tobias Blackburn
MichaelTumey wrote:While I agree that using fairly recent historical people as a darklord is a bad idea, creating a ficticious Darklord based on inspiration by real people is workable.

However, Osama Bin Ladin is not really darklord material. Sadaam Hussein, and/or his sons Uday and Kusay, on the other hand are far more likely darklord candidates if you ask me (though I still wouldn't use them directly, only as inspiration for darklords.) As torturers, commissioners of bio/chemical weapons, plus Hussein's actions are based on greed and power-hunger, whereas Osama's platform is more political tied to faith (which doesn't seem as dark as the Hussein activities.)
I agree that you can use them for inspiration. I guess my point is that you should boil them down into the "interesting" parts, if that makes sense. The inspiration should be loose and not so obvious that it jumps out at anyone who is aware of them.

For example, you could probably draw comparisons between Sadaam and his sons to Drakov and his sons. It fits in pretty well and doesn't require a lot (any?) stretching to fit in.

I think it's hard to bring up any sort of tyrant/dictator with a list of atrocities to their name without bringing up Drakov. And that's actually a good thing. Drakov is meant to be that brutal dictator, but he isn't meant to be a specific dictator. You can see Hitler, Sadaam, even Vlad the Impaler, but you can also see shades of Kim Jong Il and others too.

Which makes Drakov more frightening, in my opinion. It reminds us he doesn't represent a single deranged individual who is dead and will never be seen again, but a type of person who comes up again and again throughout our history, even in the modern day.

That's why I think historical figures are better used as inspiration for a theme or flaw that can be used to good effect rather than as a more direct source of events or background. But I'm probably just splitting hairs.

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Thu Oct 10, 2013 3:17 pm
by Tobias Blackburn
Zilfer wrote:I believe what he is saying actually is that he see's Drakov more of a Stalin type figure minus the genocidal part of Stalin. :wink:

Go ahead and correct me if I'm wrong but that's how I read his sentance. :D
That's true. Drakov is sadistic and treats demi-humans like animals, but he isn't trying to cleanse demi-humans from the earth.

The Aderres are outright trying to cleanse the demiplane of the Vistani "taint".

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Thu Oct 10, 2013 3:37 pm
by MichaelTumey
Zilfer wrote:I believe what he is saying actually is that he see's Drakov more of a Stalin type figure minus the genocidal part of Stalin. :wink:

Go ahead and correct me if I'm wrong but that's how I read his sentance. :D
Ah, gotcha.

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Thu Oct 10, 2013 4:47 pm
by Dark Angel
Man, I left to go grocery shopping at the wrong time...

Yeah, Stalin and Hitler killed any in their way (or might be in their way or called someone a name, etc...) and Stalin was in power way longer. The USSR did wrack up the highest body count in WWII and a number of attacking Russians died from bullet holes in the backs of their heads. Stalin would cull and condemn any who threatened his authority, but any Jew (or Jew ally or Jew ancestor a generation or two back) would be marked as a threat to the state and hauled off or killed. That was the primary basis for the assault on the Soviets and Aderre has that kind of sick passion against the Vistani (who are also treated like criminals and scapegoats all over the Core).

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Thu Oct 10, 2013 4:58 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
It was the Dune reference that made me think of this, and it's something I try to stress every time I hear it: jihad DOES NOT mean "holy war." It means "struggle on behalf of the faith." The Crusaders ("crusade," there's a word closer to "holy war") brought it back and twisted its meaning. Jihad by the sword (what terrorists believe they're doing, but many Muslims feel violates the Five Pillars of Islam and is just plain murder) is the lowest form; better to use the hands, the heart, and the tongue to spread a message.

This subject just touches a nerve in me. Especially since my own grandmother (whom lives with me so I can take care of her) believes Islam and the Qu'ran are evil. More than the Nazis. It's sad that she can't open her mind enough to accept that maybe, just maybe, she's wrong. It's sadder that so many others I know maintain the same attitude, many of them educated. And living in Utah, I know more than I care to about religious extremism gone political (Tea Party, anyone?) and blindly believing what religious leaders say. Is it any wonder I'm an apostate of the LDS Church?

Re: osma bin ladin in ravenloft?

Posted: Thu Oct 10, 2013 6:50 pm
by Zilfer
Yeah I meant no offense if that's where your coming from Mikhail. I just meant that the word was used in Dune and it was....

From my point of view which might be different than you, and I completely understand all Muslims/Islamic's are not what is painted over TV. Also not to nitpick words but....

'A struggle on behalf of faith.' could be called a war. For example some Christians or Catholics believe that we FIGHT a war against hell/sin/satin every day. That doesn't mean they are getting up and clobbering each other or killing each other but they are fighting a war. So in the context they are right that it kinda does mean.... holy war.....

If you have the definition that holy is connected to faith. When taking it in the context of the defined word..... here is straight off google.

"dedicated or consecrated to God or a religious purpose; sacred."

So technically any thing someone considers a "war" and "dedicated" to a god or religious purpose. It could be considered a "holy war".

in which case those individuals who believe they 'fight' evil every day and try to save people from their other beliefs (which I will say again I do not like these people!), could be said to be waging a holy war.


Now as a disclaimer I will say I know that Jihad doesn't always mean the way people try to paint it. Also will probably drop this subject as it's not entirely in line with the topic. :D Bottom line is Dune is a good book!


On topic I agree that general idea of a person is fine, and if you do specific examples tailor it to look differently. Even some of the most familiar things can be made almost unrecognizable with a little bit of thought. :D