Page 2 of 3
Re: Baron Metus
Posted: Sun Oct 20, 2013 12:34 pm
by alhoon
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote: But 14 was probably not considered a child in the time period Ravenloft is based on anyway.
It wasn't written in that period though, so according to the sensibilities of the people that read and used this material as those that will, a 14th year old consort is actually making the vampire a paidophiliac.
In the traditional sense, a century ago 17th years old girl in many rural parts of my country that wasn't married was getting odd looks and consolation of the kind "Don't worry, someone will come for you" etc.
Wait, sorry, did I say 100 years ago? In the village where some cousins of friend reside, half the girls were married at 16-17. My friend that attended the technical university was considered "risk-taking" by the rural cousins, and we had this discussion with them. They were saying "education is good and nice but... she's 22 years old and she's not even ENGAGED!"
Re: Baron Metus
Posted: Sun Oct 20, 2013 9:20 pm
by Band2
We do not need to speculate on an age of consent or anything similar. In the same book, van Richten refers to Erasmus as a child.
As for sex, van Richten makes no mention of vampire sex when discussing Brides/ Grooms. So, yes Baron Metus may not have molested Erasmus. But what he is saying in the quote in my original post is that vampires make Brides/ Grooms based on what they are attracted to. By following that up with the fact that Erasmus was Baron Metus’s Groom, would imply that Metus is attracted to 14 year old boys. Whether he was only molesting children before becoming a vampire or continues as a vampire is a different story.
Re: Baron Metus
Posted: Mon Oct 21, 2013 6:52 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Band2 wrote:We do not need to speculate on an age of consent or anything similar. In the same book, van Richten refers to Erasmus as a child.
Not without a bit of bias, though. I'm 37 and my parents still consider me a kid.
Look, I think we can all agree that what Metus did to Erasmus is messed up and wrong at any age, whether it was sexual or not. We can interpret it however we like best for our game, and with the sensibilities of our players and selves in mind. Even if you consider him practically an adult, and desexualize the relationship to an eternal bromance, the fact remains that he purchased Erasmus from kidnappers, and turned him into a vampire against his will. Not the best way to start any relationship. If you consider it sexual or if you consider Erasmus a child, it gets even ickier, and if you consider both of those to be true, that's about as icky as it gets.
The writers left enough wiggle room that you can use the interpretation you "like" most. (Personally, I lean towards "even ickier" option A)
Re: Baron Metus
Posted: Mon Oct 21, 2013 8:55 am
by HuManBing
Separate question, conveniently unrelated to any pederasty, pedophilia, or pedestals (of the broken variety).
Metus was apparently a baron. In Darkon! Does that imply that he was one of the lawmaking landowners who report directly to Azalin?
If so, then Van Richten's vengeance takes on a fairly heroic scope. Not only did he hunt down the ravening vampire that corrupted his son, but he did so fully understanding that he risked earning the everlasting enmity of his king...
Re: Baron Metus
Posted: Mon Oct 21, 2013 10:26 am
by Satyrwyld
DA, let me open by saying I'm not offended or angry at you personally. I have truck with a casual stance toward sexual violence, which is pervasive in many corners of gamer culture, but I do not hold you personally responsible for that. My aim here is purely to provide options and points for consideration, and if I'm coming across aggressively, I apologize. (It also has the misfortune of being related to the transition of vampires from bloodsucking corpse to sexualized object, which has been a matter of academic study on my part- I was a research assistant for several published papers on the topic, and we all know what happens when the Geek Trivia Dam bursts...). As to your concern...
Dark Angel wrote:If the part you are talking about was the serving girl anecdote...
No real issue with the serving girl angle. The part that raised my eyebrow was:
Dark Angel wrote:Yes, that angle can (and if your group can take it well enough, should) be used.
I posit that is can be equally chilling to have a vampire who runs a charity clinic and (when not actively seeking revenge on his own murderer) seems to be a rather decent sort, perform what we all agree are horrible acts (kidnapping, vampirization, etc) because he just wants a friend... honestly, as I was rereading it recently it was, at times, almost coming across as a deconstruction of the Twilight vampires. He's lonely, and because of what he is he cannot remedy this lack in a normal healthy manner; he tries to fill the void through violence and force.
Part of what gets me bristling about the "should" though... how do you know your group can handle it? Worst case scenario, can you be 100% sure that no one in your group has a history you'll be dredging up with it? It's not the sort of thing many people talk about. This is not to say it cannot be a powerful storytelling device, but it's an extremely vulnerable subject compared to most other RPG/horror topics. Real-world victims of brutal murder do not get the chance to do much role playing after, and few real people need to contend with PTSD following an orc raid or zombie outbreak. Even those on the sidelines, well, you usually know when your friend's mother was killed by a mugger in front of his eyes, and can avoid scenarios that resemble the traumatic event. However, between the lingering psychological effects, and the bizarre stigma of blame sexual assault victims often receive, it's very hard to know who's going to be triggered by having it pop up in the game... with the added complication that they probably won't tell you it's bothering them, either, since they don't want to be a wet blanket, or worse, have you seeing them as someone "weak" enough to be molested or raped.
I'm really just arguing that it's not necessarily the best, much less only, way to portray the incident, and if you're going to go that route, to be very sensitive to your players' reactions.
Unrelated technical note: Given Erasmus' age, it wouldn't actually be pedophilia, it would be ephebophilia.
Re: Baron Metus
Posted: Mon Oct 21, 2013 3:30 pm
by Mangrum
Feel a need for a quick reminder that the "historical period" Ravenloft is based on is "Universal/Hammer Studios Backlot." It's an artificial world, within the context of a fictional fantasy universe, anchored in a genre noted for its apathy toward anything more than the trappings of history, written at the turn of the 21st century for a PG-13 audience of that era.
Re: Baron Metus
Posted: Mon Oct 21, 2013 4:11 pm
by Dark Angel
Satyrwyld wrote:Part of what gets me bristling about the "should" though... how do you know your group can handle it? Worst case scenario, can you be 100% sure that no one in your group has a history you'll be dredging up with it? It's not the sort of thing many people talk about. This is not to say it cannot be a powerful storytelling device, but it's an extremely vulnerable subject compared to most other RPG/horror topics. Real-world victims of brutal murder do not get the chance to do much role playing after, and few real people need to contend with PTSD following an orc raid or zombie outbreak.
Sorry about the confusion and understanding and you make valid points and raise noteworthy issues. I am lucky to be apart of a group that has been together for over twenty years and we hang out socially on a less frequent basis than we game. We always catch up with each other and often break game to relate a funny/relevant story. So I know with some confidence what gets my players blood up, what lines to not cross and what things to avoid entirely. While I am not perfect in this craft, I am doing what I can to become a better story teller. If we had other players (especially newer ones), I would alter and approach such topics with a high level of care and concern.
Re: Baron Metus
Posted: Mon Oct 21, 2013 10:06 pm
by Zettaijin
HuManBing wrote:Separate question, conveniently unrelated to any pederasty, pedophilia, or pedestals (of the broken variety).
Metus was apparently a baron. In Darkon! Does that imply that he was one of the lawmaking landowners who report directly to Azalin?
If so, then Van Richten's vengeance takes on a fairly heroic scope. Not only did he hunt down the ravening vampire that corrupted his son, but he did so fully understanding that he risked earning the everlasting enmity of his king...
Broken pedestals, you say? Is there something you'd like to share?
As for him being a Baron, who's to say it isn't just for show? I mean, maybe he just likes the way it sounds. You know, vampire dudes do that sort of stuff all the time and Azalin probably knows he can't stop them.
Enquiring about Metus' title is like asking about Vladimir Ludzig's sunglasses and leather jacket. When it comes to vampires, you just have to nod a smile sometimes without worrying too much about those sort of things.
Re: Baron Metus
Posted: Mon Oct 21, 2013 10:43 pm
by Ryan Naylor
Now that you've mentioned that, I quite like it. It certainly makes sense that Azalin would install undead as barons here and there to ensure control.
However, I think the text of VRGtV makes it sound less likely. Perhaps he was once the Baron but has been deposed or abdicated, and still uses the title?
Re: Baron Metus
Posted: Tue Oct 22, 2013 12:06 am
by Satyrwyld
Or, since Azalin's patronage sent some of the events in motion to begin with, it's possible he considered Van Richten more interesting / a potentially greater asset than a vampire who was drawing attention to himself / growing sentimental / fixated on companionship (no one can accuse Azalin of being attached to other people, after all). This would depend on your interpretation of Metus' character, of course.
Re: Baron Metus
Posted: Tue Oct 22, 2013 6:13 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
I don't think Azalin would care one whit if one of his Barons got offed. I would imagine it happens fairly often. He's got plenty more vampires. If Metus couldn't protect himself against a lone herbalist/physician who's never lifted a stake before, he wouldn't be fit to hold his position.
Re: Baron Metus
Posted: Tue Oct 22, 2013 7:17 am
by HuManBing
Zettaijin wrote:HuManBing wrote:Separate question, conveniently unrelated to any pederasty, pedophilia, or pedestals (of the broken variety).
Broken pedestals, you say? Is there something you'd like to share?
Oh, apparently it's only a
TVTropes phrase. I thought it might have been broader but apparently not.
As for him being a Baron, who's to say it isn't just for show? I mean, maybe he just likes the way it sounds. You know, vampire dudes do that sort of stuff all the time and Azalin probably knows he can't stop them.
Why do you think he can't stop them? Even before the Requiem, Azalin's canonical powers are that he can control undead anywhere in Darkon. And pretending to be a baron when you're not, is similar to impersonating a police officer in the modern world - you're assuming the wrongful mantle of authority, and those who wear it rightfully have very strong reasons to put you straight.
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:I don't think Azalin would care one whit if one of his Barons got offed.
I'm afraid I'll have to disagree with you there. At least in my campaign, if every baron is part of Azalin's power structure and he enforces Darkon through them, then anything powerful or brazen enough to outright kill a baron is likely to win his immediate attention. To continue the police analogy from above, it would be similar to some vigilante killing a few scumbags, to general police half-hearted disinterest, but then going out and killing a police officer in a bust gone wrong. Suddenly the entire police force is mobilizing against this perpetrator, who has picked a fight personal fight against the law enforcement.
It would be similar to saying "if a civilian has the gall to kill a KGB officer, the rest of the KGB would probably take notice, even though KGB officers fight among themselves and get routinely purged from
above all the time".
tIMC, The death of a baron might not be particularly unusual, especially if it was from infighting or Azalin's own displeasure. The death of a baron from a
quisling outsider civilian would be.
But as always, each campaign is different and YMMV.
Re: Baron Metus
Posted: Tue Oct 22, 2013 9:02 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
HuManBing wrote:I'm afraid I'll have to disagree with you there. At least in my campaign, if every baron is part of Azalin's power structure and he enforces Darkon through them, then anything powerful or brazen enough to outright kill a baron is likely to win his immediate attention.
See that to me sounds more like a Strahd response. "An attack on my vassal is attack on
my authority. An attack on my authority will not be tolerated! I AM THE LAND!"
I see Azalin as more pragmatic and calculating. He sees everything and everyone as either a resource or a liability. One of my underlings was killed? Oh well, he'll need replacing. (That's how Metus got the job in the first place, his vampire master was destroyed and Metus moved into his house. (see Bleak House) ) That's why even my underlings have underlings. Let them sort it out, I've got scheming to do.
It would be similar to saying "if a civilian has the gall to kill a KGB officer, the rest of the KGB would probably take notice, even though KGB officers fight among themselves and get routinely purged from above all the time".
But Azalin is smart enough to see that this wasn't a budding rebellion about to sweep through the ranks. He knows it was a singular act of personal vengeance, and is now done.
tIMC, The death of a baron might not be particularly unusual, especially if it was from infighting or Azalin's own displeasure. The death of a baron from a quisling outsider civilian would be.
The way I see it, Azalin does not suffer fools or incompetents. Metus failed at the single biggest qualification for remaining Baron: remaining alive. He got
pwned. By a
n00b, no less! "Typical vampire, he was so caught up in the idiocies of mortals: feeding, companionship, and all that rot, that he couldn't see the big picture and guard his immortality properly. Van Richten spared me the trouble of deposing Metus myself."
"Now, on the other hand, this wannabe vampire slayer is a potentially useful resource. Driven, smart, and above all, lucky. Surely some use can be found for him. He's already proven capable of leading my loaned zombie minions to further his revenge (see The Crucible of Van Richten). Perhaps he can be groomed into a more competent underling than Metus was. And if he likes killing vampires so much, I know just the one to point him towards...."
But as always, each campaign is different and YMMV.
QFT
Re: Baron Metus
Posted: Tue Oct 22, 2013 9:32 am
by alhoon
Band2 wrote: Whether he was only molesting children before becoming a vampire or continues as a vampire is a different story.
To be sincere, there are other forms of abuse and molestation that sexual abuse. I think it's clear that Baron Metus was attracted to the innocence of children and whether that was sexual attraction or not, I would consider turning someone to a curse monster as "child molestation" whether it was accompanied by sexual molestation or not.
Zettaijin wrote:
You know, vampire dudes do that sort of stuff all the time and Azalin probably knows he can't stop them.
I think he can actually if he cared.
As for why Azalin
didn't react to the destruction of one of his barons, I'll go middle ground. Azalin is lawful and wants his rule enforced
but he's also pragmatic and realized that Metus wasn't worth of his time. I believe his approach on the matter is similar to the bandit problem in the woods and the "a child carried by his parents will never learn to walk".
If VR killed someone important to Azalin's plans then yes he would retaliate. Or better, he would have made sure that those important to his plans aren't that vulnerable.
Re: Baron Metus
Posted: Tue Oct 22, 2013 12:52 pm
by Dark Angel
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:HuManBing wrote:I'm afraid I'll have to disagree with you there. At least in my campaign, if every baron is part of Azalin's power structure and he enforces Darkon through them, then anything powerful or brazen enough to outright kill a baron is likely to win his immediate attention.
See that to me sounds more like a Strahd response. "An attack on my vassal is attack on
my authority. An attack on my authority will not be tolerated! I AM THE LAND!"
Agreed to a point; while Strahd would be way more concerned and protective of his things (i.e. people, cities, etc) than Azalin, he cannot afford to lose too many top echelon minions. Azalin seems to have a higher level of built in redundancy where one or two members of his political/command structure can be moved over or another can be placed into that position. Both rely on support and networks and of enough personnel begin dying off, they might both have a problem (but Azalin would recover from it faster).