Mortavius wrote:I can point to things that WotC does that inspire loyalty from me, for example, the efforts of the DDI team. I personally think that the character builder is the best electronic thing to be released for D&D ever. And the basic version, while only giving levels 1-3, is free. AND they've even updated that basic version with all the stuff from the PHB2 (and presumably will do so again when PHB3 comes out).
The character builder is nice now, but it inspires more memories of the DM Tools from 3.0 and the character generator that came with the PHB.
If it came out with it when it was promised (June 2008) I'd probably feel better, rather than have the tools leak out over years.
And there are still many flaws with the character builder. It works great for the base stuff, but doesn't handle add-ons very well and seems very hastily updated. Look at familiars or paladins post
Divine Power.
The Monster Builder has been out for three months now with none of the updates promised. Their development must be glacial slow.
I also don't feel the cost is worth it. I'll pay $7 for a print magazine knowing the store and distributor and printer are all raising the cost and knowing the publisher probably makes a buck-a-copy. The digital magazines seem pricier.
I also have concerns about the lack of revision/complaint resolution. There is precious little errata done between publication and compilation. And I've seen a good dozen people complain about being unable to professionally print the magazines because they lack a statement in the file saying they can be printed.
I also call BS on their statement Dragon content is a rigorously playtested and proofed as book-published content.
Mortavius wrote:I can talk about how I get articles three times a week (sometimes more) that I can use. Do I have to pay for them? Yes. But now I don't have to go down to my local store and buy a magazine only once a month. As well, all the stuff from those magazines that is pertinent to players is integrated into the aformentioned character builder, meaning the player doesn't have to look through 20 million books while making their character.
It's alright, but I feel a good 1/4 of the magazine is what used to be Web Enhancements. And I greatly miss Dragon Mirth.
I'm curious to see how the magazines will handle the latest change, with the content being divided into DM content (in Dungeon) and PC content (in Dragon). It's worth noting the latest issue has a wealth of new player content for three classes AND an brand new class and it still has a page-count smaller than average issues of Dungeon.
Mortavius wrote:I feel D&D is completely playable with the base three books. All the base classes and roles are covered. Do the extra books add more? Yes. But they damn well better! Otherwise, how would they ever release new stuff?
Saying that the 4E books has only the bare bones material is another opinion. Saying it leaves out iconic races and classes? Depends on your point of view. Someone who has played since 1E probably wouldn't say that. Looking that far back, what's iconic to D&D? Fighters, Clerics, Thieves, and Magic-Users. All in the 4E book. So it doesn't have Druids or Barbarians. Well, Druids were only added to the core line-up in Advanced 2E. And Barbarians had to wait till 3E (though they were in 1E, so that was more of a step-back on 2E's part.) Considering the overhaul that Barbarians got in 4E, it makes sense to put them with the other Primal classes, IMO.
[/quote]
There's a decent amount of content, but really only two variants of each class. It's very, very easy to have mechanically identical characters. The system is solid but inflexible with customization compared to 3e.
And iconic goes beyond just OD&D. The classes and races that have caught the player's eyes over thirty years and shown-up again and again. I would argue tieflings are iconic now, even before 4e.
Its sixteen months after launch now and we're just about to see summoning druids and are still five months away from psionics.
It is inarguable that they are withholding content and releasing it at a slower rate. They're spacing out releases to extend the line so they don't end-up having to force out
Magic of Incarnum or
Dragon Magic or
Tome of Magic or
Book of 9 Swords two or three years after the line's launch. And having a big book each and every month just so their profit it spread out over all four quarters.
The question is over if this is good or bad for the game.
Mortavius wrote:And saying that the world is barely described...Jester I challenge you to find me a PHB from 2E or 3E that DID describe the world in any more detail than 4E does.
The "world" I meant was the greater world, the planar landscape and other realms.
The DMG contains almost unusably limited information on the planes, compared to the massive sections in the 3.5 DMG (or even the preview books).
Even the Manual of the Planes was small and sparse. Instead of the comprehensive book we've been used to since 1e it was sparse and terse to leave room for four or five new planar books once a year. I still have difficulty imaging the Shadowfell and expect the actual book to greatly change how it is seen.