After reading all the postings on this topic, I find I have a few things to say.
First, thanks to everyone who understands that both Nicky & I DO support Ravenloft. When we were asked by White Wolf/Arthaus execs to become developers for the line several years ago, we jumped at the chance. It is one of our favorite settings, and our favorite FANTASY setting by a longshot. We care very deeply about what books are published and have fought for some books that otherwise might not have been published. Sometimes we won and sometimes we didn't. But we have always had the input from the fans in mind -- except that we also include those fans we meet that DON'T post on the Internet.
We fought very hard to publish adventures for Ravenloft, since they were for us the biggest asset of the original series. I have always collected modules whenever I could, even if just to read them. Finally, Andrew Bates enjoyed the Dark Tales proposal which came from, I believe, an idea proposed by Ryan Naylor. We saw it as a perfect way to give people adventures without simply publishing a module that would only be used once. We turned it into a handbook on storytelling, a book of fiction, and a collection of modifiable adventures. And we're glad people seemed to like it for the most part.
Second, any claims we have made that certain kinds of books don't sell have not originated with us but have come from higher ups in Arthaus/White Wolf. The information comes from people who have access to sales figures -- something we don't have at the developer level. We don't make up this info. We pass it on when people want to know why we make certain decisions.
Third, ALL our decisions are approved or disapproved at two levels. First, our immediate bosses at Arthaus/White Wolf have to give the okay for us to do each particular book. Second, the material has to be approved at Wizards before it's published. Our usual practice is to send the Arthaus Manager a list of potential books, along with a brief blurb telling what the book is about and why we think it's a good sell. Then we get a reply that tells us what books we CAN publish and what books we need to rethink, put on the back burner or just forget.
We are the DEVELOPERS of the line, not the Managers. We create or solicit outlines for the product, assign authors, try to make sure the text comes in on time, develop the material (which involves putting it all together, adding transitional text when necessary, catching as many mistakes as we can, and sending it to an editor for copy editing and statistics checking before sending it to the Arthaus production staff for layout and production. When it comes back, it's sent to Wizards for their approval. Only then does it go to printing and distribution.
Fourth, to those who think we only do this for the money, I have to say you are sorely misled about what kind of money freelance writers and developers make! We get paid in cents per word and make less per word than the writers we hire. As freelancers, we are paid as "work for hire," which means we get no benefits and the only "perks" we get are complimentary copies of the books we publish. Both Nicky & I have day jobs to pay the bills. We work as freelancers because we love to write and we love roleplaying games.
Fifth, though many if not most of you miss the Kargatane and their involvement in Ravenloft, we parted ways with them a couple of years ago for reasons I choose not to go into here, except to say that we are not the vile incompetent villains some people think we are. It was not our decision to split with them as a group, and one of their number still writes for us (see Dark Tales and Disturbing Legends).
Sixth, of course we take credit for jobs well done -- because we played a part in it. We do not, and never have, taken all the credit. We know that the authors and artists do the bulk of the work and we have never (to my knowledge) failed to mention that fact. But we do acknowledge our part in a job well done.
And not only do we take the blame for books that drew criticism, we usually have gotten pretty well slammed by the posters for what they consider our mistakes. We don't have to "take" the blame, it's pretty much dumped on us anyway!
Seventh, and finally, we don't play Ravenloft so much as we run it. We've run it at conventions and we've run it at our gaming club. We don't have a lot of time for gaming, however, since we have day jobs, our freelancing (which is another full time job) and a household to run. We've finally talked one of our friends into running MotRD for us at some future time, but that hasn't materialized yet. Do we play other games than Ravenloft? Yes, because our friends who run those games have other interests besides the Dread Realms. Would we play Ravenloft if someone asked us to? Darn straight we would!
Sorry for such a long post, but I feel some issues had to be addressed.
If you criticize us, please please make your statements true. Don't say we don't love the game. We do. Don't say we're incompetent. We aren't. Don't call us evil. We aren't. Don't say we don't care about the fans. We do.
Thanks,
Jackie Cassada
Ravenloft co-developer (along with Nicky Rea)