Page 3 of 3
Posted: Sat Jan 06, 2007 8:59 pm
by Bluebomber4evr
Ivana_Boritsi wrote:Bluebomber4evr wrote: WW also gave us one of the worst, most inconsistent Ravenloft books ever:
Champions of Darkness. I don't need to say too much more about that.

(not to say TSR didn't give us a few stinkers, they did, but nothing so blatantly out of key with the setting as CoD)
How soon some forget...
Remember that TSR gave us
Thoughts of Darkness, one of the most infamous modules ever published. When people ask about Top Ten Worst D&D Adventures, that module consistently makes the list. Just about every time. That's pretty bad, folks.
Oh, I agree that
Thoughts of Darkness is a poorly-written adventure. It was also an
early one, and didn't blatantly contradict earlier Ravenloft material the way CoD does.
Now that I think about it, I guess TSR's editing was just as bad as WW's though....just look at the mess that Nova Vaasa was.

So I retract that comment about the editing. XD
Posted: Sat Jan 06, 2007 10:30 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
See, my question would be, how could we honestly tell which was/is better? Perhaps all the problems under TSR were the results of upper management problems, to the point that the RL team were wizards on a shoestring budget. OTOH, how many of the problems on the WotC end were fallout from the TSR/WotC takeover?
How would we know? I really don't know a single satisfactory way to draw a conclusion.
Posted: Sat Jan 06, 2007 10:34 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Bluebomber4evr wrote:Oh, I agree that
Thoughts of Darkness is a poorly-written adventure. It was also an
early one, and didn't blatantly contradict earlier Ravenloft material the way CoD does.

True, they saved all that up for the Grim Harvest adventures.

Posted: Sat Jan 06, 2007 10:35 pm
by LadySoth
DeepShadow wrote:
How would we know? I really don't know a single satisfactory way to draw a conclusion.
The point of this thread was to get people talking and hear various opinions. I don't think anyone on here has anything to prove. This is purely an exercise in speculation. Nothing more, nothing less.
Why all the accusatory questions?

Posted: Sun Jan 07, 2007 12:11 am
by HuManBing
Thoughts of Darkness did have an awesome Ice Storm trap in it, though. It is also the second adventure ever to feature The Apparatus (even if it did register fairly high on the "WTF is that doing here!" scale).
Posted: Tue Jan 09, 2007 8:59 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
LadySoth wrote:The point of this thread was to get people talking and hear various opinions. I don't think anyone on here has anything to prove. This is purely an exercise in speculation. Nothing more, nothing less.
Why all the accusatory questions?

I'm sincerely sorry if my questions were taken as accusatory. I guess I didn't understand the point of the thread; an exercise in speculation seems pointless to me, but as many of you seem to enjoy it, perhaps I should just stay away.
After talking with my wife, I've come to realize how I must be unlike most people: I don't form opinions without gathering data, and here, it would seem most of the relevant data is unavailable.
The questions in my last post were not merely hypothetical:
can anyone suggest a fair way to compare the two? I'm actually very interested in an comparison, if we could make it fair. Would we use sales? Budget comparisons? Staffing choices? Should I make that the topic of a different thread?
Posted: Tue Jan 09, 2007 9:08 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
HuManBing wrote:Don't forget WotC was also the one who was responsible for the contract breakdown with White Wolf, leading to WW cancelling their work for RL.
I hate sounding like a broken record, but can I have a source on this?
I'll be frank and admit that I actually have something of a stake in this particular issue: I was writing for MotJH when this all went down, and everyone I asked says it was Arhaus' decision, not WotC's. I would like to know anything about how that went down, because it may affect some of my business decisions for the future.