Page 3 of 3

Posted: Tue Nov 20, 2007 10:59 pm
by Sylaire
gonzoron wrote: In brief: Adam's curse is not to be accepted, hence even his own land doesn't accept him, by reflecting his creator rather than him. His sin was one of jealousy (of Victor's love for Elise, and of Elise's love for Eva) and his curse is to forever be jealous of Victor's influence on Lamordia.
One unusual thing about Adam which stands out among all the other notable darklords is that in all the years of Ravenloft products, we never did get the story of what Adam actually did to get to be a darklord. We've gotten reams of text on Victor, what his motivations were, the acts he committed, the curse of the gods he received in the form of Adam's evil soul, the suffering he endures to this day, and the way in which he remains an evil individual who never learns from his mistakes and keeps charting the same course to rack and ruin.

Conversely, Adam's sins are withheld from us. We know that he did something bad on the night of Eva's death and Elise's maiming, but we never get the truth. In Mordenheim, Adam gets to tell his side of the tale, but that's no doubt as propaganda-filled as I, Strahd. After all, if that was the truth, fragging Elise would be darklord of Lamordia (after all, out of her jealousy and unreasoning fear, she violently attacked Adam and herself was the cause of Eva's death--which essentially makes her a religious-fanatic*, racist** child-killer***). So that story is clearly Not The Truth. But Mordenheim was out of the room, Eva is dead, Elise is incapable of talk (and as seen in Katrina's story, insane), and Adam isn't telling the truth. We're asked to condemn him, and more so, to condemn him as being a more appropriate iconic villain than Victor Mordenheim without knowing why.

*As in, "That monster is an unholy creation of unsanctified science! It is a trespass against God's will!"

**Flesh golems in particular--or perhaps just the leading edge of a hatred and rejection of all constructs? Think Dr. Pulaski on early second-season Star Trek: TNG.

***Accidentally, but hey, as I'm sure you've figured out I'm deliberately spinning this in the worst way possible for her. I'm sure Adam would. :D

That said, I will reiterate that I happen to think Lamordia is a beautiful piece of work thematically and in game terms, it features one of the few Undying Soul effects that I genuinely like and approve of as being wholly positive, and the whole Adam-Mordenheim story a very nice and Ravenloft-appropriate twist on the Frankenstein mythos, painted in much darker shades than in Shelley or most of the various movies (the truth is, it happens to be one of my favorite domains, up there with Mordent and Souragne, and I like it even more after reading Mr. Mangrum's work in Gazetter II--putting it bluntly, I wouldn't be wasting as much time, thought, and typing on this thread if it was about Farelle, or for that matter Barovia).

Posted: Wed Nov 21, 2007 1:00 am
by Nathan of the FoS
So, here's my attempt to square this particular circle:

Over his career as a scientist on his home world, Mordenheim became obsessed with creating life; one of the things he believed most fervently was that "life" was purely a process of biomechanics, and that either there was no such thing as the soul, or that it contributed nothing essential or even interesting to the function of the organism. The gods of his world, seeing his hubris, resolved to show him the truth of the matter, and reached out to add one "contribution" of their own to Mordenheim's magnum opus: they endowed Adam with a soul--Mordenheim's.

From that moment, Adam was the creature with the mind of a child, built from corpses--but he was a construct with the soul of a man. Mordenheim, the human genius, was the soulless one. Of course, neither understood what had happened; Mordenheim was delighted to have succeeded beyond all expectation in his creating "life", and Adam was eager to learn from his "father". But as Adam learned about the world around him, the soul in him hungered for the place it had had in human society, and especially for the love and companionship of Elise. Adam's desire to take Mordenheim's place grew stronger, and his confusion and anger at being rejected by Elise, and later Eva, grew stronger as he grew in understanding. The soul of Adam/Mordenheim would not be thwarted in its desires by gods or by fate; Adam resolved to kidnap Eva and take his freedom, achieving the human dignity he wanted on his own terms. But he was found out by Elise in the attempt; he struck her down, and inadventantly killed Eva as he tried to complete his escape. Adam and Mordenheim were drawn into the Mists together; the domain that formed around them was patterned after Mordenheim's mind, to function as a prison for the soul now found in Adam.

Because he is a construct, Mordenheim is passionless and essentially without imagination; his attempts to revive Elise are the unreasoning obsession of a highly trained automaton. He cannot give them up, because he can literally conceive of no other reason for his own existence. Similarly, he can never create another "success" as great as Adam, because he has no second soul to impart to his creation. Adam, on the other hand, is the one with passions, desires, and dreams; his hunger to achieve humanity is the ultimate cruel joke, because if he were not already possessed of a human soul he could never desire it as deeply as he does. Without Mordenheim's intellect, Adam can only observe Mordenheim's experimentation with jealousy and incomplete comprehension--feelings which spur him to sabotage Mordenheim's experiments whenever he can, and to imitate them as far as he is able.

Posted: Wed Nov 21, 2007 1:25 am
by DocBeard
I don't understand the confusion re: Mangrum's comments on Adam. If I'm not mistaken, the "original comments" are on the first page of this very thread. (Searching for posts containing the word "Adam" by poster "Mangrum" doesn't turn up much else, unless he commented elsewhere before that.).

....see, and here I assumed it was something like, "Okay, it's not coming out, can you please tell us what the master plan with S and Azlain was?" that had been asked/answered a gillion times.

'll show me to start reading at page two.

Posted: Wed Nov 21, 2007 5:12 am
by The Giamarga
Nathan of the FoS wrote:So, here's my attempt to square this particular circle:

Over his career as a scientist on his home world, Mordenheim became obsessed with creating life; one of the things he believed most fervently was that "life" was purely a process of biomechanics, and that either there was no such thing as the soul, or that it contributed nothing essential or even interesting to the function of the organism. The gods of his world, seeing his hubris, resolved to show him the truth of the matter, and reached out to add one "contribution" of their own to Mordenheim's magnum opus: they endowed Adam with a soul--Mordenheim's.

From that moment, Adam was the creature with the mind of a child, built from corpses--but he was a construct with the soul of a man. Mordenheim, the human genius, was the soulless one. Of course, neither understood what had happened; Mordenheim was delighted to have succeeded beyond all expectation in his creating "life", and Adam was eager to learn from his "father". But as Adam learned about the world around him, the soul in him hungered for the place it had had in human society, and especially for the love and companionship of Elise. Adam's desire to take Mordenheim's place grew stronger, and his confusion and anger at being rejected by Elise, and later Eva, grew stronger as he grew in understanding. The soul of Adam/Mordenheim would not be thwarted in its desires by gods or by fate; Adam resolved to kidnap Eva and take his freedom, achieving the human dignity he wanted on his own terms. But he was found out by Elise in the attempt; he struck her down, and inadventantly killed Eva as he tried to complete his escape. Adam and Mordenheim were drawn into the Mists together; the domain that formed around them was patterned after Mordenheim's mind, to function as a prison for the soul now found in Adam.

Because he is a construct, Mordenheim is passionless and essentially without imagination; his attempts to revive Elise are the unreasoning obsession of a highly trained automaton. He cannot give them up, because he can literally conceive of no other reason for his own existence. Similarly, he can never create another "success" as great as Adam, because he has no second soul to impart to his creation. Adam, on the other hand, is the one with passions, desires, and dreams; his hunger to achieve humanity is the ultimate cruel joke, because if he were not already possessed of a human soul he could never desire it as deeply as he does. Without Mordenheim's intellect, Adam can only observe Mordenheim's experimentation with jealousy and incomplete comprehension--feelings which spur him to sabotage Mordenheim's experiments whenever he can, and to imitate them as far as he is able.
A most interesting twist. This would make a great dread possibility. It explains the connection the two share quite handily. I wouldn't go so far as make Mordenheim have the construct type because of the mechanical consequences. The Soulless feat should suffice for this. (And it also adds another magic immunity to the Exp5/Sci10 Mordenheim!) Consider this borrowed.

Posted: Wed Nov 21, 2007 11:18 am
by DocBeard
A most interesting twist. This would make a great dread possibility. It explains the connection the two share quite handily. I wouldn't go so far as make Mordenheim have the construct type because of the mechanical consequences. The Soulless feat should suffice for this. (And it also adds another magic immunity to the Exp5/Sci10 Mordenheim!) Consider this borrowed.
Agreed. Nice twist.

Posted: Wed Nov 21, 2007 11:24 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
I think that's a brilliant idea, Nathan. At long last, an explanation that works! :D

Come to think of it, if you go with Nathan's soul-exchange explanation, one could even omit divine intervention from the equation, altogether. It always seemed awfully cruel for the gods to have given Adam a soul that would make him a danger to people other than Mordenheim; it's not the sort of pettiness you'd expect dieties who are distanced from mortals to engage in. Interventionists like the Greek or Egyptian pantheons, yes, but not gods who sit back and allow faith to grow of its own accord.

Perhaps Victor's closed-minded insistence that there were no such thing as "souls" became so potent that it weakened his spiritual bond to his own soul, and it lodged itself in Adam of its own volition, to escape the mind that had spurned it? So Mordenheim rejects his own soul, and it seeks solace in Adam, only to keep on getting rejected by him and everyone around it....

Posted: Wed Nov 21, 2007 12:51 pm
by Sylaire
Damn, I'm in jaw-dropping awe, Nathan (and Rotipher, for the footnote). :shock: That's just incredible.

Posted: Wed Nov 21, 2007 3:20 pm
by JinnTolser
Yeah, I'm definitely going to have to jump on the "this is a great idea" bandwagon as well. It's the perfect tweak to the story of Adam and Mordenheim.