Page 3 of 3

Posted: Tue Nov 13, 2007 2:02 pm
by DocBeard
I think, ultimately, Undying Soul is as much of a tool as any other "hax" Darklord Power. It's ultimately up to the Dungeon Master to decide how to use it, and to have the self-discipline to use it well.

If the campaign is about defeating a Darklord than, presumably, it should be possible to do so. Maybe there's a particular way to trap Lucas's spirit...or, you simply present the Dark Powers with a more interesting successor.

One thing that really interested me in 3E's Ravenloft is the subtle implication that, slowly but surely, the people of Ravenloft were starting to matter. Take Sithicus; the Black Rose was essentially set up to fall because his reaction to being a Darklord was, eventually, to sit in his castle and passivly wait the days out. But when ol'buckethead went home, his Domain didn't vanish into smoke and mist, like earlier Ravenloft products implied would probably happen; instead of giving a potential Darklord a new Domain, the Dark Powers matched the prisoner up with the prison, inadvertently giving the elves of Sithicus a little cultural revolution.

Rather than sit passivly and wait for the world to end, the Sithican elves as of their Gazetter have come to accept that they're in Ravenloft for the duration. It's their home now, for better or for worse, and while it's been a progression of inches, life in Sithicus has improved because of this. Eventually, Sithicus might become a vybrant Elven kingdom...or, at least, not the most emo place in the Core. So, to go back to the old metaphore, if the Darklord is the heart of the Domain, then the Domain itself is a body; it can evolve, change, become healthier or sickier, and even survive a heart transplant.

How this ties into Eternal Soul is that while most Darklords have the benefit of near-immortality, they're still in risk of being vulnerable just by not being an interesting story for the Dark Powers to follow anymore. I feel this puts the fate of the Darklords even more firmly in a given DM's hand; if a Darklord is worth keeping around as a recurring villain, a DM is probably going to find a way to bring him, her or it back no matter how throughly the PCs set the poor guy on fire. If the Darklord ultimately doesn't add to the campaign, then chances are the jerk'll fall to the wayside and be passed up for more useful villains, no matter how tragic and convulted the Darklord's backstory is.

It also shows how the Dark Powers keep their Darklords on the leash, so to speak; they encourage plotting, scheming, and other acts of villainy through rewards like new powers, new groups of people to rule, siezing underused land from a neighboring Domain, or whatever else one can think of, but can also encourage a Darklord seeking redemption by providing hints on how to get to a point of emotional decency, tantalizing glances of the things each Darklord /really/ wants, or just a good night's sleep. What the Dark Powers really don't want is apathy, because what's the point of having your own little prison world if no one ever leaves their little secret lairs and actually does anything?

Anyway, to make a long, convulted story short(Too late!), Ravenloft has enough of a metatextual element to it, at least from a setting perspective, that you can really just say, 'He survives because it's cooler that way.'. It's how the Dark Powers roll. But what really interests me about the setting as it has evolved over the years, is how it almost seems to be striving to /become/ a world.

What was once a collection of little islands in the mist centered around being a personal hell to an individual villain have developed into clusters, continents, and oceans, the drab peasentry who used to serve only as feeding stock and ways for the Darklords to express their depravity have become a number of vibrant, living cultures that produce heroes and villains capable of challanging the outsider powers that are what the Demiplane was origionally supposed to be about, to the point of actually improving the world-the Darklords can experience the turnabout of being influenced by their own domains and the people they were supposed to be haunting! Heroic action doesn't just help in the short term, in Ravenloft; you could argue that the actions of Van Richten, his contemparies and their heirs may have attracted the attention of the Dark Powers in the same way the actions of the Darklords attract them, resulting in a world that is more capable of producing heroic figures like these.

I dunno, I think I've gotten off the point here a bit, but it all ties back into the seemingly simple answer: Ravenloft doesn't have to be consistant, because the makeup of the world itself is designed to be a breeding ground for stories, adding a certain depth to the old "It depends on your campaign" answer that usually seems like such a cop out.

Posted: Wed Nov 14, 2007 1:01 am
by Sylaire
That's a great point on the development of Ravenloft as a genuine (fictional) world in which people actually (fictionally) live as opposed to being plot artifacts. The Ravenloft locals originally existed, after all, to serve as victims, to serve as examples of What Could Happen in other respects ("You see how that guy just grew tentacles on his neck? That's why you shouldn't be casting the despicably evil and corrupt feign death spell in this alternate world!"), and to serve as ways in which the players could blow Powers Checks. Only to the slightest extent was the original Black Box Ravenloft a "campaign setting"--at the very least, there was no serious conception of why a character should want to walk across a domain border within the course of an adventure, experiencing different cultures and settings (and, to be fair, it would kind of blow the mood if one decided to switch back and forth between Mordent and Valachan while those domains only existed as sketchy concepts...).

That's changed, and I think most of all it's changed on account of the attitudes of the players and DMs. People didn't want to take a "weekend in hell"; when they visited, they wanted to stay. The problem with that is that the rough edges on the setting had to be polished.

After all, the initial concept of Ravenloft is not that it is a game-world per se, but a collection of individual mini-worlds. Essentially, the DM could pick his/her favorite kind of horror story and ship the players off to it, without having to worry about fouling up continuity in their home-world (or without having to ship the players cross-continent to get there).
DocBeard wrote: How this ties into Eternal Soul is that while most Darklords have the benefit of near-immortality, they're still in risk of being vulnerable just by not being an interesting story for the Dark Powers to follow anymore. I feel this puts the fate of the Darklords even more firmly in a given DM's hand; if a Darklord is worth keeping around as a recurring villain, a DM is probably going to find a way to bring him, her or it back no matter how throughly the PCs set the poor guy on fire. If the Darklord ultimately doesn't add to the campaign, then chances are the jerk'll fall to the wayside and be passed up for more useful villains, no matter how tragic and convulted the Darklord's backstory is.
Now that I agree with. Campaign utility uber alles. Because here's the real key to it all:

It's not the darklord's story that you're telling. It's the PC's story, and the darklord is a supporting cast member in it.

*snip the last half-hour's worth of writing, darn it; these things really are becoming essays*

This is why I feel Undying Soul--the artificial, not-Adam-and-Mordenheim kind of Undying Soul--ultimately has no place. If a villain needs to be saved, then villains will be saved. Most DMs have done that more than once, and not just in Ravenloft campaigns. Heck, whole reams of pulp novels, movie series, and comic books have devoted their existences to unnaturally saving the lives of quality villains. Heck, Conan Doyle pulled the Obscure Death Rule on his hero. :D Likewise, if it's time for Strahd to die, well, just maybe the players got to the right coffin at the right time. DeepShadow actually went so far as to out-and-out change Godefroy's Undying Soul, and from having read that thread I think it worked beautifully.

What's not needed is the equivalent of a munchkin rule built right into the statistics of the darklord. All that does is to create a situation where the DM will either (1) ignore the Undying Soul's existence if it doesn't fit their campaign story, (2) change the Undying Soul's existence to something that fits with their campaign and the character's storyline or (3) obey the letter of the statistics by deliberately introducing a way for the characters to fulfill the impossible condition. Those aren't the reactions one wants to elicit from the readers/users of a gaming product (and remember, when push comes to shove, Ravenloft supplements are that: gaming products, designed to stimulate the imagination and enjoyment of their purchasers. The finest supplements, IMHO, are those that are used as-is or nearly so by the greatest percentage of readers--and on the other end of the spectrum, we have Ship of Horrors.).
It also shows how the Dark Powers keep their Darklords on the leash, so to speak; they encourage plotting, scheming, and other acts of villainy through rewards like new powers, new groups of people to rule, siezing underused land from a neighboring Domain, or whatever else one can think of, but can also encourage a Darklord seeking redemption by providing hints on how to get to a point of emotional decency, tantalizing glances of the things each Darklord /really/ wants, or just a good night's sleep.
I've always wondered what would happen if Strahd woke up one night and understood at last that Tatyana just didn't love him and never would even if the Dark Powers didn't keep screwing with his courtship attempts. :idea:
What was once a collection of little islands in the mist centered around being a personal hell to an individual villain have developed into clusters, continents, and oceans, the drab peasentry who used to serve only as feeding stock and ways for the Darklords to express their depravity have become a number of vibrant, living cultures that produce heroes and villains capable of challanging the outsider powers that are what the Demiplane was origionally supposed to be about, to the point of actually improving the world-the Darklords can experience the turnabout of being influenced by their own domains and the people they were supposed to be haunting! Heroic action doesn't just help in the short term, in Ravenloft; you could argue that the actions of Van Richten, his contemparies and their heirs may have attracted the attention of the Dark Powers in the same way the actions of the Darklords attract them, resulting in a world that is more capable of producing heroic figures like these.
That was largely the snipped part from above, discussing how Ravenloft's sometimes mind-numbing drumbeat of despair was really more appropriate to Lovecraftian horror rather than Gothic horror. I find it interesting that you perceive ongoing, positive change reflected in the world in its latter-day products.

Personally, I think it has more to do with the transition from "weekend in hell" to "campaign setting"--horror is only horrifying in contrast with some baseline level of normalcy, and once PCs stopped comparing Ravenloft to, say, Krynn or Faerun, then Ravenloft itself had to develop the ability to possess hope and decency within itself.

Posted: Wed Nov 14, 2007 10:53 am
by Jester of the FoS
I think alot of them were added to make otherwise easily killed darklords more of a challenge. They'd just keep coming back.
It also allows you to bring the lord into the game and have the party thump them without changing 'canon', which alot of DMs are loath to do.