Spell idea - please comment.

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Isabella
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1859
Joined: Mon May 30, 2005 12:54 am

Post by Isabella »

Jester of the FoS wrote: Second I'm stumped on given the two best choices (dop & illithid) are aberrations.
Dopplegangers are monstrous humanoids. And unlike spells like Hold Person, nothing in the spell would indicate it wouldn't work on aberrations.
Third is likely Nat or a Renier.
Who's more likely to fail the save? Although in the case of Nathan Timothy, it'd be super easy to cast the the spell on him (provided the food you designated was your adventuring companions... :wink: )

I'm kind of curious where the spell's creator is on all of this chaos.
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."
User avatar
Rock of the Fraternity
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 6844
Joined: Wed Nov 21, 2007 1:16 pm

Post by Rock of the Fraternity »

I'm sitting back and watching all of these developments, hoping some of the opinions and suggestions will eventually help me to make the spell viable.
Welcome to my webcomic, Sarcantasy.
You can read it here:

Comicfury; Webtoon

Come drop by and leave a comment; you'll make my day.
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Spell thoughts:

Firstly, knowing all the stats, even only in relation to the caster, is slow and cumbersome as the DM has to borrow a character sheet and compare on a stat-by-stat basis.
Likewise going through every skill, or even ones just with ranks, can be a slow and cumbersome. To say nothing of going through a possibly massive list of feats and describing them one-at-a-time.

So let's simplify. What's the intent of the spell? To let a caster divine information from someone who ingests enchanted food and gain potentially useful information.
In many ways it'd be easier to treat this like a successful knowledge check on the subject and allow the caster to ask questions on abilities, defences or special attacks. But that's even more abusable.

So instead of every stat, it might identify the subjects' lowest or highest stat (caster's choice) in relation to the caster's. ie "He is stronger than you" means his highest stat is his strength which is also higher than the caster's. Or "he is slightly less witty than you" might mean her highest stat (int) is lower than the caster's.

Alternatively, the caster might get information on their most practiced skill (the one with the most ranks, not the one with the highest modifier). Again, this is only in relation to the caster's. If the subject has multiple skills with the same rank then all are provided.

An additional save might be made each round with the spell ending after a successful save. With each additional round the caster can gleam information on something else (their choice), such as their second highest stat or second highest skill. The spell continues until the duration expires, the caster dismisses the spell or the subject makes a successful save.

There could be additional options. With a spellcraft roll a caster might compare someone else with the subject instead of themselves, but this might require the second person to also eat the food. Or if multiple people eat the same food (say the spell was cast on a serving bowl) then information from both is provided but the spellcaster cannot tell from who the information is provided.
This could be an option where the caster can allow for multiple subjects, or focus on a the first person to ingest. I like the idea of the spell as more of a broad net and intelligence gathering rather than strict instigative, so I might provide a single target a bonus to the save.
Plus I like the paranoid-inspiring idea that the PCs know there's someone or something at the party that's a disguised monster but being unsure exactly who.
Plus it feeds well into this fun scene:

PC: I cast spell X on the inn's keg and order a round for the house, then scan for any odd skills.
DM: You detect someone with more talent than you in Control Shape.
PC: Can I tell who?
DM: Of the six people in the inn? All of them.

Additional information might also be gleamed, such as the creature's type (but not subtype), HD (again in relation to someone), etc. But each of these might provide the subject a bonus to their saving throw.

It could also be made a two-way street. The subject, if they can make a spellcraft check to spot the existing spell effect, or maybe nail their saving throw (say a nat 20) might be able to reverse the spell on the caster or even feed misinformation.

I would also rule that creatures who have had their type changed (ie from human to undead) can choose which type they're identified as.

This does everything the original spell could, with the exception of identifying feats which are troublesome and possibly lengthy. Feat trees might be an option to ID or significant feats (DM's discretion) but a full list is probably unworkable.

* * *
"Solutions"
Although not real puzzles, since there's probably multiple legal solutions.

The first was a straight ogre mage from the SRD. A nice little beastie for a couple unrelated reasons. The first, because they are a great example of how not to make a monster. There's a nice article on the WotC site on this and how they're fairly weak for their CR and don't do a good job at their "role".
However, they're fun for Big Bads as they have a nice high CR but you can throw them against lower level PCs for some decent XP. And they easily take class levels and are great examples of how to abuse the monsters-with-levels system as it can be argued that either martial or spell-casting classes only add 1/2 to the CR (fighter levels don't add 1-for-1 CR because they're ogre mages / sorcerer levels don't add 1-for-1 CR because they're ogre mages).

The second is a half-fiend medusa.
This was me manipulating the spell as half-fiends gain skill points as outsiders so putting the template on a monstrous humanoid jumps up their skills so it looks more rogue-ish. Although if I had to do it again I'd probably make it a doppelganger to by-pass the obvious question "how come nobody would notice a medusa at a party?".
User avatar
Isabella
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1859
Joined: Mon May 30, 2005 12:54 am

Post by Isabella »

I suggested this:
Isabella wrote: Here's what I'd suggest the spell tell the caster:
-The target's highest and lowest stat (but not the number) - in the case of a tie the target picks which stat you get.
-If the target has spell casting or spell like abilities
-A range for the target's Hit Die along the lines of detect undead or spells of that vein (Faint - 2HD or less, Moderate 3-8HD, Strong 9-20HD, Overwhelming 21 or higher)
But I guess no one liked it. :cry:

The Spell Compendium has two spells, Know Opponent (cler 3) and Know Vulnerability (wiz 4/cler 3), which gives you strengths and weaknesses from the target. But, Know Opponent only gives you one strength/weakness per two levels, and Know Vulnerability is also limited (not to mention it simply imitates a knowledge check). I'm not sure if I'd allow either of those spells, however, mostly because they're confusingly worded. What counts as a "strength" for a PC class doesn't seem to be fully explained.
"No, but evil is still being — Is having reason — Being reasonable! Mousie understands? Is always being reason. Is punishing world for not being... Like in head. Is always reason. World should be different, is reason."
Post Reply