Page 3 of 4
Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 1:22 am
by alhoon
A G Thing wrote: No phylactery is fine and perhaps it is a supreame achievement for a lich.
As a DM employing liches so often that at the start of each campaign I'm asked "Which lich are we going to fight this time?" I have to tell you that no, Phylactery is the supreme achievement for a lich. It's not a weakness it's the power to come back again.
A lich with a phylactery is a lich that takes twice as much effort to be destroyed.
Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 1:50 am
by Lord Soth
I think he meant to say that making a phylactery was a supreme achievement for a Lich.
"Ah ha! Not only have I conquered death by achieving Lichdom, but now I've made myself a nice little phylactery, to boot. Chew on that, suckers!"
Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 9:39 am
by Charney
About the chill touch, it's not just an attack for the lich, it's a defining part of what's a lich: it's the chill of the grave, of one of the most powerful undead ever. It comes with the cold aura that surrounds it. It's saying that the mere touch of a lich can suck life itself from the living. So it's also "fluff" as some might say it.
Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 12:43 pm
by HuManBing
Technically speaking liches do not use Chill Touch, which is a L1 spell. They have Lich Touch, which is somewhat different. (And variously listed in noncanonical 2E stuff as L5 or L6 wizard spell.)
Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 2:30 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
It's conceivable that there might be a list of powers which NPC vampires get to choose among, in addition to the standardized abilities included in their base templates. Perhaps that's where a vampire could acquire the ability to change into animals (at-will power) or to summon them (per-encounter), for instance.
If that's the case, it would effectively give every vampire in D&D a slate of "salient abilities", VRG-style. Not that I'm saying that's likely, but it's an interesting thought.
Likewise, a traditional "lich touch" ability might be something that a lich can select as an at-will power, much as it chooses powers appropriate to its character class.
Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 2:46 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
If the vampire lord template is to be added to a preexisting vampire or spawn, the lord would automatically have the more basic vampire weaknesses.
Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 3:34 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
That's true. OTOH, the template appears to assign some pretty standard undead traits -- immunity to disease & poison, etc -- which wouldn't be needed if "vampire lord" were intended to stack on top of another undead template.
I suspect WotC will deliberately shy away from "nested" templates, i.e. those that have to be layered onto other templates. A major overall aim of 4E monster-design seems to be lightening a DM's workload, and stacking multiple templates would run counter to that goal.
Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 4:30 pm
by Mangrum
Rotipher of the FoS wrote:I suspect WotC will deliberately shy away from "nested" templates, i.e. those that have to be layered onto other templates. A major overall aim of 4E monster-design seems to be lightening a DM's workload, and stacking multiple templates would run counter to that goal.
If I'm reading the DMG excerpt correctly, it appears that the maximum number of templates you can apply to a given creature is two.
Posted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 11:56 pm
by A G Thing
alhoon & Lord Soth
Yes Lord Soth is correct I was refering that perhaps a lich needs to build it's phylactery as an achievement of sorts that they can then come back and that perhaps not all liches figure such out before a group of adventurers come plowing through their lairs. More that the most fit liches are the ones to figure it out, and the lesser liches must scrape by on the perilous chance they may be destroyed before they can reach such lofty heights.
Charney
I know that liches are supposed to be the uber masters of the undead but I am simply saying that perhaps they don't all have this power. Like I said give them whatever you desire and as for named liches drawn from canon just give them the power because they have either developed it as a salient ability or all liches in your games may have it.
HuManBing
Ah yes that is true but I have just gotten used to refering to it as such. I don't mean to spread disinformation but it is just how I am used to saying it.
Rotipher of the FoS & DeepShadow
Yeah I think that they are trying to nerf multiple templates, because I noticed the undead traits, but then again I could be wrong because we have yet to see the official versions of base vampires or the final product of such which could be much different then we remembered.
Mangrum
Really? Limiting it to 2 templates max? I don't see the point of setting such a limit as the DM could just ignore it and that just seems like a little bit of a useless regulation... Still perhaps it is for the players but I guess I will just have to wait and see if that is true...
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 2:17 am
by Mangrum
A G Thing wrote:Mangrum
Really? Limiting it to 2 templates max? I don't see the point of setting such a limit as the DM could just ignore it and that just seems like a little bit of a useless regulation... Still perhaps it is for the players but I guess I will just have to wait and see if that is true...
Well, just read the excerpt:
Multiple Templates: Each of these templates is intended for use by itself, making a monster into an elite opponent. However, you can turn a standard monster into a solo creature by adding two templates. Follow the process for adding each template, one at a time, but add just one template’s hit point bonus (your choice which). Then double the creature’s total hit points. Increase the monster’s saving throw bonus to +5.
You can also advance an elite monster to a solo one by adding a template, then doubling its hit points and adjusting its saving throw as above.
This method is quick and easy, but it carries some risks. For example, the adjusted monster’s hit points might be lower than those of a typical solo monster of its level and role. Once you’ve finished the process, be sure to “reality check” the monster by comparing its statistics and abilities to others of similar power.
Unless there's some catch to these rules that they've mysteriously chosen not to include, I read this as:
Adding one template: Standard monster becomes elite monster (which I believe means it's worth two standard monsters when creating encounters). Apply template changes as written.
Adding a second template: Elite monster becomes solo monster (which means it should be capable of taking on a party by itself). Add second template's changes, then modify hit points and saving throw bonuses as listed above.
Adding a third template: No such rules are provided. Intention seems to be two templates max. Which, frankly, doesn't surprise me once I think about it. The 3E era was all about customization, customization, customization. 4E, when it comes to monsters at least, is all about streamlining, streamlining, streamlining.
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 2:35 am
by alhoon
Well it seems that you could stack a template to a solo monster making it more powerful. Now, when it wipes out your party they'll be justified to moan and whine.
It seems that the templates add an x2 to monsters. I.e dracolich= 2 solo monsters.
Now that I think of it, it can be done. It just takes a higher level party.
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 7:43 am
by Rotipher of the FoS
FWIW, if you look back, what I'd said was that they'd probably eliminate templates that must be stacked. Stacking them can still be an option, if the DM wants to make the effort, but it most likely won't be mandatory to stack them, in order to build a particular monster (as with vampire strains from DoD).
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 10:55 am
by Jester of the FoS
Charney wrote:About the chill touch, it's not just an attack for the lich, it's a defining part of what's a lich: it's the chill of the grave, of one of the most powerful undead ever. It comes with the cold aura that surrounds it. It's saying that the mere touch of a lich can suck life itself from the living. So it's also "fluff" as some might say it.
And here I thought the defining part of the lich was being an undead spellcaster.
This is really how they approached monsters in 4e (as I gather from the many, many interviews and designing essays). They find they key element of the monster and try to work around them while adding interesting combat abilities and powers that will define them anew in their 2-5 rounds on screen.
Unlike 3e that just updated the monsters straight from the old sources without really comparing power levels or role or intent. So some monsters ended up being too powerful while others ended up being too weak. Many had useless abilities or lengthy lists of powers (such as demons and devils with their massive stack of spell-like abilities, or beholders with a half-dozen eyebeams that either did nothing in combat or outrighted killed a character).
So when creating a lich what is important? Undead and spellcasting. Done and done.
Then maybe some flavour abilities. They're unearthly cold and bring the chill of the grave. Done, they have a aura effect.
Looking at monsters thought, I'm not sure how salient powers can be handled. The easiest way would be to create some monster-only class abilities or powers that can be taken in-place of class abilities.
They were a nice idea at the time (customizing otherwise set monsters) but with the options available now their time might have passed.
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 11:24 am
by Charney
For that matter, a vampire, mummy even a ghoul spellcaster is an Undead spellcaster. Had phylactery and maybe that cold/death aura, now it sounds like a lich (which doesn't have any real life folklore equivalent)
Posted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 11:33 am
by Jester of the FoS
Vampires, mummies and ghouls originally couldn't cast any spells and were generic monsters. Liches were the only spell-casters. They're spell-casters who willingly enter into undeath though magic.
Every other undead can be spellcsters but liches are always spellcasters.