Page 3 of 3

Posted: Wed Jun 11, 2008 9:51 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
The kingdom itself would have to be larger than even the "Greater Barovia" i had proposed, wouldn't it? Probably extending northwest of Dorvinia. When Falkovnia entered Ravenloft Strahd could have hoped in vain that it was more of his homeworld revealing itself. The DP love to mess with him like that. I could see the appearance of Nova Vaasa causing the same type of apprehension in Strahd; could his enemies the Tergs have been brought in to torment him as well? Even Strahd is allowed to feel relief sometimes....

Rotipher brings up great points about Strahd's title of "Count." The coping mechanism while morning his parents makes perfect sense, but after the land was pulled into the Mists, Strahd would not have deemed this little sliver of land worthy of being called a kingdom, not with the little villages of Levkarest and Vallaki and Barovia, and the useless northern wilderness that came along with him.

Posted: Sun Jun 15, 2008 10:29 am
by Lord Cyclohexane
I keep meaning to reply and keep not getting around to it... So here's a rushed followup from me.

- First, thank you to Mr. Naylor for your kind words! On Upheavals, I just figured that since Science deals with observing and creating hypotheses regarding phenomena that repeat over and over again, and since the creation of odd landmasses is one of those, Science in Ravenloft should definitely have something to cover it.

Although, as you mentioned quite well, 99+% of the people will have no idea that there's even anything worth observing, much less care about the mechanisms behind it.

- To Strahdsbuddy, regarding larger landmasses: I'm so-so on this idea. When it comes to a Greater Mordent, I'm fine with that, as Godefroy is such a lame darklord and so I could see him losing land ala Darkon being split up between multiple darklords in Azalin's abscence and my own proposed theory (for a submission contest) of Nova Vaasa breaking up due to Malkin's lack of power. I could definitely see Mordent originally being larger and then falling apart. Do be careful with the map, however; Mordent and Arkandale *barely* share a border, and Richemulot did *not* spawn from Mordent (Claude Renier went south from Falkovnia, where he arrived via a portal from an outlander world) and so even though the Renier family similarity is there, Richemulot is *not* a Greater Mordent territory.

Anyway, one thing I might propose is to print out a copy of Jester's Old Core map and then cut out the individual domains. Then put them back together again according to the Timeline and see what interesting things you find! Also, you might try cutting out your Greater Mordent and Greater Barovia to see how those things are.

But anyway, my one big problem is with the Greater Barovia, which I just plain don't like. Personally, while I find it okay to have land taken from lame duck Godefroy, the idea of Strahd losing land and not noticing is rather distasteful to me. Not to mention, the idea of the Petrovna family having land holdings also sounds blah and especially with the Markovs, who aren't even a noble house. (Petrovnas are mentioned in the crypt below Castle Ravenloft, in case you weren't aware).

You could potentially make this palatable to me, however, if you could line it up with the Timeline on "Strahd meets a number of adventurers, kills them, goes into hibernation for a while" entry (or however it goes). Perhaps, after getting his ass kicked in the adventure "House of Strahd," Strahd has to go into hibernation for a few decades and it's during those that Borca, Dorvinia, Markovia, and G'Henna split off.

I'll go more into this later.

- On the Gondegal age problem thingy, Roti, I'm afraid I'll have to admit that I didn't know about this controversy. As such, I'm afraid I'll have to pass on that... Sounds reasonable, though, especially when you consider that Falkovnia could have existed as an Island prior to Drakov arriving and Drakov could have just deposed the previous darklord (as Gabrielle did against what's-his-face in Invidia, although Invidia was already cool enough to be a Core domain at that point, whereas Falkovnia might have been too lame under the previous Darklord to deserve Core status).

I'll come back to other things later, sorry.

But mostly, the Greater Domain idea is okay, as we have precedence for domains falling into smaller pieces ala Azalin's death and seeing Darkon break up into six smaller domains (or, I propose that it *would* have, had Azalin not come back to reunify it).

Posted: Mon Jun 16, 2008 7:18 am
by Strahdsbuddy
I started this thread with a few quick explanations on the hows and whys of these two greater domains. THey were quick hits, so let me reitterate.

Greater Barovia splitting up MUST have happened during one of Strahd's hibernations! I picture Strahd conducting search after exasperating search for Tatyana for the better part of 3 centuries. Around the beginning of the 700s he took a nap (The one Van Richten thought he was still in the middle of during the prologue of I,Strahd.) While he would have dutifully collected the taxes, he may have forgotten about the western realms of his domain because Tatyana wasn't showing up there. The worthlesss wilderness to the north certainly held no interest for him, he probably hadn't set foot in the woods that would become Markovia since the night he got his revenge on Leo Dilisnya, and surely not further north into what would become GHenna. I even picture Borca as the launching-off point for Strahd's re-conquest of the von Zarovich homeland; hence those lands may not have tecnichally ever owed him fealty, even after they went with him into the Mists.

These factors combine to make outlying Barovia less and less Strahd's. Fran Markov would have been chased away from his village after his crimes were discovered, and into the creepy North Svalich Woods is a natural stop, cause even someone as insane as Markov wouldn't head for the Mists! After the mob lost him legends crept up in Barovia's northern thorps about the shadowy man in the wild that perverted nature wherever he found it. In no way was i trying to assert that the forest that would one day become Markovia was in any way the "ancestral land" of some sort of noble Markovs. It is just where he ended up.

Same deal with Yagno Petrovna. I don't view the once-mighty Petrovnas lording over a barren wasteland miles away from the seat of power. As Markovia was hewn from the "North Svalich", the land that would become GHenna was already a barren wasteland known to the Barovians but shunned. Or it was an extension of the forest that was blasted barren by the DP when it became its own domain.

BOrca/Dorvinia is trickier because of the families involved. The Boritsi had been loyal servents of Barov von Zarovich and the time it took them to rebuild their mercantile empire with such limited commercial resources (and markets) around them show their resolve. But the Dilisnya were known enemies of the state. Stripped of their holdings after their failed coup attempt, they went underground. It was a bold move for Camile to announce herself as the spouse of the powerful merchant-lord. The Dilisnya took Strahd's lack of a reaction as an "all clear" signal and went on a romp, reestablishing themselves as an open power. BY the time Strahd awoke from his hibernation, Ivan had already been granted his own domain; Strahd burned at this latest prank of the DP; the Barovians viewed it i as a secession, but that is nowhere close tot he truth.

Thoughts on Greater Mordent and the Reniers later. I love this thread!

Posted: Tue Jun 17, 2008 5:45 pm
by Baduin9
Some remarks on Nova Vaasa - they may prove useful for any changes:

Malkin is simply hilariously unsuited to "his" domain. He is an archetypal city villain, and Nova Vaasa is a land of fields and steppes, half Ukraine, half Hungary. Both Nova Vaasa and Malkin are interesting - but they don't fit together. The Gazetter put a lot of effort into binding them together, and I must say it was very well done; but the task was impossible, and success was only partial.

So, I have a simple suggestion, based actually on the history of Ukraine: divide Nova Vaasa into two domains: a port city, ruled by Malkin, and Nova Vaasa proper, ruled by some other Darklord. They can form one state - since Malkin is not a political ruler.

What is the historic connection? Ukraine traditionally exported grain, which was farmed in the interior (originally ruled by Scythians) and exported by Greek cities of the coast. There were many such dual food exporting lands - ancient Egypt and Alexandria, XVI century Poland and Danzig, etc.

As for the darklord of Nova Vaasa, the history of Hungary and Ukraine offers a lot of candidates. Some examples:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zalmoxis

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ermanaric
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jonakr%27s_sons
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atilla
http://www.mainlesson.com/display.php?a ... 36b1c2d85c
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bohdan_Khmelnytsky
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ivan_Mazepa
http://www.encyclopediaofukraine.com/pa ... paIvan.htm
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_XII_of_Sweden


http://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/wo ... y/ch03.htm
"Dózsa suffered defeat before Szegedin and moved to Czanad which he captured, having defeated an army of the nobility under Batory Istvan and Bishop Esakye, and having perpetrated bloody repressions on the prisoners, among them the Bishop and the royal Chancellor Teleky, for the atrocities committed on the Rakos. In Czanad be proclaimed a republic, abolition of the nobility, general equality and sovereignty of the people, and then moved toward Temesvar, to which place Batory had rushed with his army. But during the siege of this fortress which lasted for two months and while he was being reinforced by a new army under Anton Hosza, his two army columns in Upper Hungary suffered defeat in several battles at the hand of the nobility, and Johann Zapolya, with his Transylvanian army, moved against him. The peasants were attacked by Zapolya and dispersed. Dózsa was captured, roasted on a red hot throne, and his flesh eaten by his own people, whose lives were granted to them only under this condition. The dispersed peasants, reassembled by Lawrence and Hosza, were defeated again, and whoever fell into the hands of the enemies were either impaled or hanged. The peasants' corpses hung in thousands along the roads or at the entrances of burned-down villages. According to reports, about 60,000 either fell in battle, or were massacred. The nobility took care that at the next session of the Diet, the enslavement of the peasants should again be recognised as the law of the land."

Posted: Sun Jun 22, 2008 6:11 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
To LordC: Good suggestion on the cutting out of the old Core map. Noticed a lot of things that were probably already discussed 10 years ago, but of course, i wasnt paying close enough attention then. Cutting out the 7 domains of "Greater Mordent" as one works out fine, if you count the blank land on the southwest corner that would become Valachan as a domain. That is all moot if you consider the land all coming in at the same time. The 7 future domains of Mordent, Dementlieu, Richemulot, Arkendale, Verbrek, Invidia, and the blank-future-Valachan all coing in togehter doesn't seem to shake things up that much. THe southern forest would have been full of werewolves, hence the 3 domains that spring from it (Invidia's DL was originally a werewolf). The Timothy pack was from Mordentshire, in fact, one of their ancestors was a servant of Strahd during I-10.

Similarly, a Renier built the House on Grpyhon Hill. Call it a coincidence, but what is the point of having a coinceidence in a setting like this? I realize i am not telling most people anything new, but these clues all help to prove my points. Legacy of the Blood discusses the Renier clan splitting in two BEFORE the conjunction that brought half of them into Ravenloft (Ironically, the GOOD half; what are the DPs real motivations?). THey snagged the rest of the Reniers, Claude's pack, after Falkovnia was formed. After a quick war with Drakov, they retired to a realm custom made for them. THe land was already there, complete with abandoned cities and extensive sewers.

Save for Valachan, which didn't occupy the land til after the Great Upheaval, the domains are connected by a common language. THe difference between a lot of strange mist and a huge forest of strange trees isn't really all that different in the grand scheme. They are creepy and intimidating, and the people who go in don't usually come back. THese two chunks of land (Gr Barovia and Gr Mordent) would only border each other near the very sparsely inhabited western border of future Borca, and the only thing on the other side of the border is an uninhabited forest all the way to Mordentshire, which wasnt exactly a metropolis even then. So not only was it a long hike, there was no reward for the trip. Plus, you might get eaten by a werewolf....

Posted: Sun Jun 22, 2008 6:37 pm
by Strahdsbuddy
to Baduin: Great observations about Nova Vaasa. I was going to wait til after i had read Gaz 5 before i replied, but i didn't want to let the thread go cold.

Nova Vaasa definitely has feeling of one of the "greater domains" i've been talking about, particularly because of the nature of the Darklord. Aside from the Hiregaards, the Five Familes aren't exactly known for their good deeds. Any of them could begin to chip off pieces of the domain, with Malken ignoring it for the most part. Not to mention the Paka or other groups operating in the domain. Not that every evil creature needs its own domain, but Baduin points out just what i have been talking about.

THe post-GC map has some interesting anomolies. Jester's map has a few descrepancies with the whole Core map on gryphonhill.com. I don't have access to my poster maps right now, or i'd compare them further. Nova Vaasa obviously doubled in size, inheriting what used to be the Nightmare lands, and all of the cities seemed to roll downhill toward their new seacoast. Nova Vaasa also seems to have booted Hazlan to the south, inheriting all of its lands and Hazlan was created all over again with entirely new land!

According to Jester's map, barovia even snagged a little of Hazlan's land, a little lump west of Bergovitsa. (not on Gomez's map) What did Hazlik do to tick off the DP and get totally rearranged!?!?