Page 3 of 3

Posted: Thu Aug 21, 2008 9:52 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:Yeah, IIRC this sounds a LOT like Elena's justification for summoning evil creatures in another thread. Might be funny to take note of how the PC justifies his actions, and use her as a dark mirror.
Yeah, funny, huh? I almost laughed out loud when he mentioned the same tactic we'd just been talking about here for Elena. Only the collateral destruction of the undead made it iffy to me. Since that's not actually possible, I agree with Jester. Straight Black Magic check. (It must be necromancy, not conjuration, in at least one of the books we found it in, or he wouldn't have chosen it as his bonus necromancy spell.)

Re: Calculate the Powers checks

Posted: Tue Sep 27, 2011 9:56 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Okay, time to resurrect another thread: IMC a PC just killed an innocent woman, who was also pregnant. The victim was nearly mad with pain and healing was not feasible. The PC was told that the woman wished for death, but all the PC heard was, "make it stop." The PC was told that the child was going to be an unholy monster, but this was probably a lie.

How much does ignorance play a role in a check? If the PC thought she was saving the world from a monster, does that figure in? How about if she's unwittingly making a hag bargain, what then?

Re: Calculate the Powers checks

Posted: Wed Sep 28, 2011 10:56 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
I dunno... That's a tough one. I'm not sure what the "right" response was, but from your other post it seems she didn't make any effort to validate the claims of the voice. Seems to me that killing someone because "the voice in my head told me her unborn baby was a demon god" is prime powers check material. But what if the voice was right? In this case it wasn't, but if there was some proof that the baby was evil, would this merit a powers check? Putting an innocent out of her misery and killing an evil "parasite" sounds like a good thing.

In this case, though, if Neerajah didn't do her due diligence to substantiate the claim, she's just as guilty as a tepestani mob who go all "burn the witch" on an innocent Redhead.

Also, if the voice started out by promising a solution to her problem before leading her there, she should have been doubly cautious. Perhaps she let her personal needs blind her to suspicion of the voice.

Re: Calculate the Powers checks

Posted: Wed Sep 28, 2011 12:15 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:I dunno... That's a tough one. I'm not sure what the "right" response was, but from your other post it seems she didn't make any effort to validate the claims of the voice.
Few, but not many. She confirmed using a Heal check that the woman could not be moved without harming her further, that the baby was feeding off the mother, and that the damage could not be restored using a CSW potion or other HP restoratives. She also heard the woman crying and saying "make it stop."
Seems to me that killing someone because "the voice in my head told me her unborn baby was a demon god" is prime powers check material. But what if the voice was right? In this case it wasn't, but if there was some proof that the baby was evil, would this merit a powers check? Putting an innocent out of her misery and killing an evil "parasite" sounds like a good thing.
Apart from the fact that the baby was feeding off the mother, there was no evidence that the baby itself was "evil." There was considerably evidence that the baby was a vampyr, but Neerajah has already met at least one non-evil vampyr.
In this case, though, if Neerajah didn't do her due diligence to substantiate the claim, she's just as guilty as a tepestani mob who go all "burn the witch" on an innocent Redhead.
Good point.
Also, if the voice started out by promising a solution to her problem before leading her there, she should have been doubly cautious. Perhaps she let her personal needs blind her to suspicion of the voice.
Yeah, that's how I felt, too. The voice said it wanted to "take the measure of her character" and it praised her for the courage to do what had to be done. I thought that was a dead giveaway, but the player was OK with that explanation.

Re: Calculate the Powers checks

Posted: Wed Sep 28, 2011 12:40 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:the baby was feeding off the mother
Isn't that rather normal for the unborn? :)
and that the damage could not be restored using a CSW potion or other HP restoratives.
Then, without being able to move the woman, options are obviously limited. One might have been, "go for help" but I'm not sure what kind of healers might be available to go fetch. Another might be anathesia (chemical or the spell), abfalduz or other pain-killing drugs, or hypnosis. I would mitigate the check depending on how hard the PC looked for another solution. But from what I've seen, it seems like this PC tends to go for the most straightforward solution and not worry about other possibilities.
She also heard the woman crying and saying "make it stop."
any attempt to ask the woman, "Make what stop?"?

Re: Calculate the Powers checks

Posted: Wed Sep 28, 2011 8:24 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Nope, no further investigation, not even asking questions re: make it stop.

So, using the Unified Theory, this is an Abomination (6) for cold-blooded murder of an innocent, +1 for failed powers check in another category (black magic from Voice of Wrath) so that's an AoUD right there! Now, what about the murder of the unborn child? Should she get a separate check with the penalty for the previous failure?

Re: Calculate the Powers checks

Posted: Wed Sep 28, 2011 11:21 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
I dunno, under the circumstances much of what the voice was telling her was plausible--that it would be a mercy to kill the woman is at least credible, and that the child is a "monster" is not easy to contradict.

On the other hand, hearing a voice in your head offer to get you out of something highly dangerous and unpleasant if you'll kill a pregnant woman should at least raise questions, and it seems it didn't.

I would not give two checks; I think "one check per action" is a good rule of thumb. I think cold-blooded murder is right, but I have a hard time describing the victims as "innocents" for purposes of the check. I'd probably go with strangers/neutral, for a -2. Add in the previous failed check for black magic, +1. Also add +1 for cross-classing with Black Magic, voluntarily performing a service to an evil being. Total is 6, Abomination.

YMMV, of course. In fact, I think it already has. ;)

Re: Calculate the Powers checks

Posted: Thu Sep 29, 2011 8:53 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Nathan of the FoS wrote:I would not give two checks; I think "one check per action" is a good rule of thumb.
Okay, that sounds good. I didn't like the idea of this PC busting through the stages of corruption so quickly.
I think cold-blooded murder is right, but I have a hard time describing the victims as "innocents" for purposes of the check. I'd probably go with strangers/neutral, for a -2.
Yeah, I never could tell when to use alignment and when to use relationship.
Add in the previous failed check for black magic, +1. Also add +1 for cross-classing with Black Magic, voluntarily performing a service to an evil being. Total is 6, Abomination.
Hmmmm...Okay, that sounds good!

Re: Calculate the Powers checks

Posted: Fri Oct 07, 2011 9:52 am
by DeepShadow of FoS
Anyone care to calculate the check for "Dead Man's Seed," as described here?

Re: Calculate the Powers checks

Posted: Fri Oct 07, 2011 10:17 am
by Nathan of the FoS
Wow.

Well, it's hard to fight the AoUD on that one. You're looking at cold-blooded murder (Violence 6) plus Black Magic (+1), plus Betrayal (+1) if the woman in question is seducing her target, and if you wanted to throw Blasphemy in there for another +1 I wouldn't stop you. Since the sacrificed man is necessarily a sex partner, it's hard not to go with the Intimate/Close Friend non-adjustment, even if he is not, in fact, someone the woman knows well.

One can imagine scenarios in which the Betrayal modifier doesn't apply, and in which one would count the male partner as Evil rather than Intimate (see the stepfather in DeepShadow's first example). In such a case I could see the check going as low as 4 (Violence 6 + Black Magic 1, -3 for evil subject). Certainly no lower.

If you count the base transgression as Black Magic, it ends up slightly different. You would have to throw in a +1 for Violence and, depending on circumstances and taste, the +1 for Betrayal and/or the +1 for Blasphemy, AND make no adjustment for the relationship between the woman and her partner. Off the top of my head I would rate it an Abomination (6) with the spell as an Atrocity (5) and +1 for the murder, with the potential Betrayal and Blasphemy add-ons.

Re: Calculate the Powers checks

Posted: Fri Oct 07, 2011 7:59 pm
by DeepShadow of FoS
Nathan of the FoS wrote:Wow.

Well, it's hard to fight the AoUD on that one.
I figured. I was going for the idea that this was a deliberately failed check. I've never seen formalized rules for those; I mean, can you just lie to your neighbor for a lousy 2% chance and deliberately fail as your pact with darkness? I don't think so.

Re: Calculate the Powers checks

Posted: Mon Nov 07, 2011 12:34 pm
by cure
In a FoS netbook, one of the in game FoS sets out to become a Darklord as part of the project of understanding the rules of the Land of Mists. That is to say that he actively seeks out power checks. The Dark Powers caught on appear to strip him of all the accumulated benefits, either making him immune to power checks or taking complete possession of him as their tool.

Re: Calculate the Powers checks

Posted: Wed Nov 09, 2011 9:00 pm
by Leliel
How about the Chairman from Paprika?

He deliberately uses a psychic device (think a more fanciful version of the Inception dream machine) to construct a virus-like entity that drives people who's psyche it enters mad while assimilating their dreamscape, with the goal of eventually entering the real world and remaking it in it's mad image.

He does partially because he hates the modern world, but mostly because he thinks he'll be able to walk again when it overrides reality. Also, he employs a rapist and gave him the protagonist to do as he may as a reward.