Does anyone play (or have played) 3.5 e6?

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

Troile wrote:The thing with levels in d&d is that your power increases exponentially. So after a certain point (the top end of which is 6th level) you suddenly start getting a lot of power with each level.
I'd argue that "exponential" is the wrong word.
It certainly builds and you gain more power on a regular basis that just adds up to being crazy powerful.
But as I've said before the biggest jump is 1st level to 2nd level. You have twice the hitpoints, BAB, spells, etc. It's a big leap. From sixth to 7th you gain one 7th the hp, BAB, etc.

Certain spell levels are more impressive. 3rd is a large jump, as are 5th. But other factors keep pace. But you're not doubling your power anymore.
Troile
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 280
Joined: Tue May 11, 2004 9:22 am
Location: Canada

Post by Troile »

But as I've said before the biggest jump is 1st level to 2nd level. You have twice the hitpoints, BAB, spells, etc. It's a big leap. From sixth to 7th you gain one 7th the hp, BAB, etc.

Certain spell levels are more impressive. 3rd is a large jump, as are 5th. But other factors keep pace. But you're not doubling your power anymore.

That isn't true at all.

Your power isn't doubled from 1st to 2nd level. A 1st level Barbarian with a greatsword and 16 strength won't be doubling his chance to hit, damage or hit points from 1st to 2nd level. Not even close.

BAB +1 to +2 does not mean he has double the chance to hit that he had before. Once he gets pounce, leap attack, power attack, haste and a lot of other buffs working for him he'll be doing a lot of damage.

He starts off pretty decent. 2d6+7+3 for power attack is 17 damage a hit and +5 to hit. Then at 2nd level that goes up a bit and so on...but each level brings him more elements to stack on and start multiplying his damage output until it gets ridiculous.

That goes for every other class, especially the spell casters.

It looks like a linear progression but it isn't. Spells get exponentially stronger.

You also have WBL. The magic items the characters will have and how they synergize has a huge effect on their power level. My games tend to stay under control because I control the magic items. By RAW though characters are supposed to have a certain wealth and cities of different sizes are supposed to have a plethora of magic items available. Of course Ravenloft is a bit different but we're talking about standard rules. If you take a look at the WBL table it is exponential with level.

Then you have feats too which work much better the more you have.

And then you put it all together. The more you mix in the more ridiculous the power level gets. At low levels you don't have as many variables and you don't have as many things mixing together.
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

At this point I have to say "prove it".
Fine me three fourth level spells that are twice as powerful as a third. Or a fifth that's twice as powerful as a fourth.
artemis wands
Conspirator
Conspirator
Posts: 22
Joined: Tue Oct 09, 2007 2:22 am
Location: Los Angeles, CA

Post by artemis wands »

Hey, when did this become a spitting contest? :lol:

If you don't like the system, no one's saying you have to. If you do like the system, no one's saying you shouldn't. It's all about tastes.

Anyway, my E6 Strahd is in the works, and it looks like he'll be about CR12 at most. I'm making use of the Incantation rules and some of the new feats in the E6 doc.

Will be posted soon.

And seriously, the debate is interesting. I like that things stay civil around here.
Troile
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 280
Joined: Tue May 11, 2004 9:22 am
Location: Canada

Post by Troile »

Jester of the FoS wrote:At this point I have to say "prove it".
Fine me three fourth level spells that are twice as powerful as a third. Or a fifth that's twice as powerful as a fourth.
Sure, but first I want to point something out.

Most of the bonuses you get are linear.

Some of them, usually your main stat features are closer to a geometric progression.

Few like WBL and possibly spells are exponential.

When you add them all together it results in an overall exponential increase in power.

This is a common occurrence in games like these and strategy games where you build kingdoms and armies and such.

Lets look at 3rd level vs 4th level wizard spells.

Twice as powerful? There are 4th level spells that are more than twice as powerful as 3rd level ones.

To start off with something simple lets go with Summon Monster IV. You get 1d3 monsters from the third list, averaging 2.

So twice as powerful.

Animate Dead. There isn't really one to judge it against. Animate Dead is incredibly powerful though. You can get an army of Zombie Ogres with it. I would say that is easily twice as powerful as 3rd level spells.

Evard's Black Tentacles. Everything in a 40ft diameter circle has to make a grapple check. If they're medium they make it against +15.

The closest 3rd level spell I could find is Stinking Cloud. Fortitude negates and you get nauseated. So you can flee and don't take damage or anything. The Fortitude save will be much easier to make than the grapple check.

Polymorph. It's ridiculous.

As we can see from Summon Monster, the spells are designed to be twice as powerful as the level before. Some of them end up being not as powerful and some of them end up being more than twice as powerful. The spells can't all follow this pattern though. New concepts are introduced and they tend to open up a can of worms and let the wizard gain even more control.
Troile
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 280
Joined: Tue May 11, 2004 9:22 am
Location: Canada

Post by Troile »

Those those interested I have completed my capstone and prestige feats.

These will allow the character to maintain the flavour of advancing in their class or pursuing a prestige class with the feats gained after level 6.

They will be fine up to +10 feats. I might make feats for +10 and +15 but I'm not sure how much power that would add to the game and it will be harder to balance. It would let you keep advancing until +20 feats though which is probably ideal.

http://www.xphox.net/daveoftherave/othe ... 0Feats.rtf

Ravenloft PrCs will come next I think.
User avatar
Sorti
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 255
Joined: Sat Nov 26, 2005 9:56 am
Location: Ethereal Border

Post by Sorti »

Hey Troile, I like your feats a lot! (and also the whole e6 idea, btw).

Have a cookie: *cookie*
Coltiviamo per tutti un rancore
che ha l'odore del sangue rappreso
ciò che allora chiamammo dolore
è soltanto un discorso sospeso
User avatar
Archedius
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 568
Joined: Mon Aug 21, 2006 8:11 pm

Post by Archedius »

e6 looks like something I'll try
Troile
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 280
Joined: Tue May 11, 2004 9:22 am
Location: Canada

Post by Troile »

Sorti wrote:Hey Troile, I like your feats a lot! (and also the whole e6 idea, btw).

Have a cookie: *cookie*
Thanks.
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

Attempting not to derail the thread further, but I'll just point out that the WBL table only goes up geometrically because the magic item costs go up geometrically. (bonuses are priced based on bonus squared, and spells are priced based on caster level * spell level). The bonus stacking rules and magic item slot rules serve to cut down (but not eliminate) the "buy lots of little stuff instead of a few big ones" strategy. Also, spells are very hard to categorize, but clearly the damage ones are mostly linear based on caster level (fireball and the like.) And summoning two of the same monsters is not exactly double the power, see the CR tables for a matched pair. Also, a 4th level spell should be not 4/3, but 7/5 of the power of a 3rd level spell, since you you get them at level 7 and level 5, respectively.

What really gets exponential is your *options* and how you can combine them, not the power of each individual option.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
User avatar
Jester of the FoS
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Jester of the Dark Comedy
Posts: 4536
Joined: Wed Dec 03, 2003 12:19 am
Location: A Canadian from Canadia

Post by Jester of the FoS »

artemis wands wrote:Hey, when did this become a spitting contest? :lol:

If you don't like the system, no one's saying you have to. If you do like the system, no one's saying you shouldn't. It's all about tastes.
He asked what we thought, so I told him.
Other than that it's a friendly academic debate, in which I will crush him.

(Totally, completely j/k :wink: )
Troile wrote:
Jester of the FoS wrote:At this point I have to say "prove it".
Fine me three fourth level spells that are twice as powerful as a third. Or a fifth that's twice as powerful as a fourth.
Sure, but first I want to point something out.

Most of the bonuses you get are linear.

Some of them, usually your main stat features are closer to a geometric progression.

Few like WBL and possibly spells are exponential.

When you add them all together it results in an overall exponential increase in power.
Of course, 3/10ths of the classes don't have spells (fighter, barbarian, rogue).
And 3/10th don't have strong spellcasting and mostly cast other classes spells at a delayed level (ranger, paladin, rogue).
Troile wrote:Twice as powerful? There are 4th level spells that are more than twice as powerful as 3rd level ones.

To start off with something simple lets go with Summon Monster IV. You get 1d3 monsters from the third list, averaging 2.

So twice as powerful.


Oooo, good choice.
However, it still assumes two CR3-4 creatures are as as powerful as one CR 4-6 and multiple low-level creatures are a formidable threat at high levels.

The best of use multiple summoned creatures are as make-shift meat shields and road blocks to break-up monsters. They're just not going to reliably hit or deal damage except to a large number of underlings.
Troile wrote:Animate Dead. There isn't really one to judge it against. Animate Dead is incredibly powerful though. You can get an army of Zombie Ogres with it. I would say that is easily twice as powerful as 3rd level spells.


It also costs money and requires lower level monsters to make. You can make said army of zombie ogres (where army = 9) if you can find that many ogres (CR3?) at level 7+. Each of which will likely have 1/2 the attack bonus of every monster you will fight at that level.
Troile wrote:Evard's Black Tentacles. Everything in a 40ft diameter circle has to make a grapple check. If they're medium they make it against +15.

The closest 3rd level spell I could find is Stinking Cloud. Fortitude negates and you get nauseated. So you can flee and don't take damage or anything. The Fortitude save will be much easier to make than the grapple check.
Compare it to entangle. Really, it's 1/4 of the size of entangle and almost as effective. Only entangle can also slow monster who make the save.
It's just amped up and uses grapple and deals damage (same damage as a fireball over many more rounds).
Troile wrote:Polymorph. It's ridiculous.


Yes, but it's also broken beyond words. They did remove it from the later game. It's arguably better than many 5th-level and 6th-level spells.
Troile
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 280
Joined: Tue May 11, 2004 9:22 am
Location: Canada

Post by Troile »

gonzoron wrote:Attempting not to derail the thread further, but I'll just point out that the WBL table only goes up geometrically because the magic item costs go up geometrically. (bonuses are priced based on bonus squared, and spells are priced based on caster level * spell level). The bonus stacking rules and magic item slot rules serve to cut down (but not eliminate) the "buy lots of little stuff instead of a few big ones" strategy.
Granted.
Also, spells are very hard to categorize, but clearly the damage ones are mostly linear based on caster level (fireball and the like.)
Damage spells are also not very good.
And summoning two of the same monsters is not exactly double the power, see the CR tables for a matched pair.
But now you're comparing it against the cost of the spell slot. I was asked to show that the spell is twice as powerful, not factor in the opportunity cost of it. If Summon Monster IV was a third level spell it would be at least twice as powerful as Summon Monster III.

Twice the number of monsters is twice the amount of power. CR is not linear though so you don't double the CR number.

That is exactly what I'm getting at. Also, the CR system is pretty messed up anyway.

What really gets exponential is your *options* and how you can combine them, not the power of each individual option.
Agreed.
Of course, 3/10ths of the classes don't have spells (fighter, barbarian, rogue).
And 3/10th don't have strong spellcasting and mostly cast other classes spells at a delayed level (ranger, paladin, rogue).
My first example was Barbarian and you ignored it and asked for spells. So now that I talk about spells you flip back to fighter types.

What do you want to talk about?
Oooo, good choice.
However, it still assumes two CR3-4 creatures are as as powerful as one CR 4-6 and multiple low-level creatures are a formidable threat at high levels.
Now you're factoring in the greater threat posed to higher level characters.

That isn't what this discussion is about. In fact, it is exactly my point. You can't simply throw more lower threat creatures at higher level characters because their power increases exponentially while adding on creatures is a linear progression.

Two CR 3 creatures are twice as powerful as 1 CR 3 creature. But 2 CR 3 creatures are not as powerful as a CR 5 creature which is my point.

The best of use multiple summoned creatures are as make-shift meat shields and road blocks to break-up monsters. They're just not going to reliably hit or deal damage except to a large number of underlings.
I'm not talking about how good the spell actually is. I'm making a comment about how the 4th level version is at least twice as good as the 3rd level version. Stay on the argument please.
It also costs money and requires lower level monsters to make. You can make said army of zombie ogres (where army = 9) if you can find that many ogres (CR3?) at level 7+. Each of which will likely have 1/2 the attack bonus of every monster you will fight at that level.
And what 3rd level spell will give you at least half as many minions?
Compare it to entangle. Really, it's 1/4 of the size of entangle and almost as effective. Only entangle can also slow monster who make the save.
It's just amped up and uses grapple and deals damage (same damage as a fireball over many more rounds).
Entangle is a Reflex save DC 11 + ability modifier, Evard's is a Grapple Check against a +15. There is a huge difference.

Entangle requires the right scenery.

"Entangled: Ensnared. Being entangled impedes movement but does not entirely prevent it unless teh bonds are anchored to an immobile object or tethered by an opposing force. An entangled creature moves at half speed, cannot run or charge, and takes a -2 penalty on attack rolls and a -4 penalty to its effective Dexterity score. An entangled character who attempts to cast a spell must make a Concentration check (DC 15 + the spell's level) or lose the spell."

So you're saying being Grappled is similar to being Entangled?





I'm sorry if you can't see the power differences but I don't think there is really any other way for me to show you.

I've done exactly what you've asked and you came back and said that the monsters are more difficult at higher levels to make up for it. Yes, I agree. I'm not arguing that the game gets easier, and as a DM you can make it as hard as you want anyway.

The world doesn't make sense to me with 20 levels. The economies don't make sense.

If they make sense to you more power to you.

I won't be replying further because we're not getting anywhere.
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

I agree that the exponential vs. linear discussion isn't really going anywhere.

Just wanted to say that I especially like your prestige feats. They are nice way of giving players something to look forward to after they top out.
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
artemis wands
Conspirator
Conspirator
Posts: 22
Joined: Tue Oct 09, 2007 2:22 am
Location: Los Angeles, CA

Post by artemis wands »

As promised, here's my E6 take on Strahd. I'm pretty sure it all balances out to CR12, but feel free to check my math; I've been focusing on school far more than gaming lately.

Count Strahd Von Zarovich, Darklord of Barovia
Male Human Ancient Vampire Ftr 1/Nec 5: CR 12; Size M undead (6 ft. 1 in. tall); HD 6d10, hp 38, Init +9 (Dex, Improved Initiative) , Spd 50, AC 32 (touch 32, flat-footed 27); Atk +11 melee (1d6+8 and energy drain, slam) or +15 melee (1d10+12, +4 bastard sword),+8 ranged (1d8+7, +2 mighty composite longbow); SA Animate dead**, blood drain, children of the night, command undead, create spawn, domination, energy drain, spells, incantations; SQ undead, alternate form, cold and electricity resistance 20, darkvision , damage reduction 25/+2, dread familiar, fast healing 6, gaseous form, light sleep, master of the realm, spider climb, turn resistance +6, vampire weaknesses; SR , AL CE, SV Fort +3, Ref +6, Will+7 ; Str 26, Dex 20, Con --, Int 20, Wis 17, Cha 18

Skills & Feats: Climb +9, Concentration +4, Knowledge (arcana) +10, Knowledge (history) +7, Knowledge (nobility and royalty) +7, Knowledge (Ravenloft) +10, Handle Animal +8, Intimidate +8, Ride +8, Spellcraft +10; Alertness, Blindfight, Combat Casting, Combat Reflexes, Craft Wand, Craft Wondrous Item, Dodge, Expanded Caster Stamina (x2)*, Expanded Spell Knowledge (x2)*, Exotic Weapons Proficiency (bastard sword), Expertise , Extend Spell, Improved Initiative, Lightning Reflexes, Maximize Spell, Mobility, Power Attack, Quicken Spell, Scribe Scroll, Spell Focus (Necromancy), Weapon Focus (bastard sword), Specialization (bastard sword)

Languages: Balok*, Darkonese, Draconic, Luktar, Mordentish, Vaasi

Wizard Spells Per Day: 4/6/4/2

Spellbook: 0 – daze, detect magic, read magic, touch of fatigue; 1 – burning hands, cause fear, chill touch, darkness, hold portal, ray of enfeeblement, protection from good; 2 – darkness, ghoul touch, ground fog, scare, Strahd’s baneful attractor; 3 – augment undead, halt undead, vampiric touch

Signature Possessions: +4 bastard sword, +2 mighty composite longbow [Str 18], amulet of proof against detection and location, bracelets of armor +6, cloak of resistance +3, crystal ball, gloves of Dexterity +2, ring of minor elemental resistance (fire), ring of protection +4, rod of absorption, The Book of Names***, various other mystic tomes.

*Indicates a feat taken from the E6 rules.
** Thanks to his centuries of necromantic study, Strahd can use this salient ability to create Strahd skeletons and Strahd zombies (as per the relevant spells), as well as the normal type.
*** Strahd has used this cursed tome to become a master of necromantic Incantations.
User avatar
Scipion_Emilien
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 246
Joined: Thu Jun 23, 2005 6:54 pm

Post by Scipion_Emilien »

Seing your E6 i'll probably use it for my next ravenloft game. But just curious, why did you chose the lvl 6 and not lvl 5, 7 or 8??? What is specific to the lvl 6?
Post Reply