Page 3 of 5

re

Posted: Fri Jun 05, 2009 5:24 pm
by Jack of Tears
Good point, though that is no reason we shouldn't consider the idea now. Is anyone currently doing this?

Posted: Fri Jun 05, 2009 6:16 pm
by DocBeard
Honestly, I think Tepest's 'good-intentions-gone-way-too-far' flavor of Inquisition is a heck of a lot more interesting than turning a religion into a bunch of jack booted thugs.

Or rather, there are jack booted thugs everywhere, but having them be the entirety of Elina's faithful seems a little one dimensional.

Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2009 6:17 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
DocBeard wrote:Honestly, I think Tepest's 'good-intentions-gone-way-too-far' flavor of Inquisition is a heck of a lot more interesting than turning a religion into a bunch of jack booted thugs.

Or rather, there are jack booted thugs everywhere, but having them be the entirety of Elina's faithful seems a little one dimensional.
Ah, yes. The Doubting Thomases who question if what they're told is really the truth. I actually plan to explore that in the Lost Journals (and the tragic consequences for that one case specifically). It would make Elena's curse all the more prosaic if there were people who remembered what Belenus really teaches and hold services true to the faith, things the average Nidalan would find familiar and alien all at once.

Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2009 7:36 pm
by Yaoi Huntress Earth
I remember that there was that rebel group lead by a man named Irvine in one of the Book of series. Maybe he might have a few.

Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2009 7:45 pm
by DocBeard
It would make Elena's curse all the more prosaic if there were people who remembered what Belenus really teaches and hold services true to the faith, things the average Nidalan would find familiar and alien all at once
Nice. I like that. It's way to easy to write off a religion as 'oppressive authorities who harsh our mellow!', y'know? It's as one-sided as having the establishment be always wise and all knowing.

Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2009 9:05 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
One thing that still baffles me is Banemaw, the (non-existent) dragon that keeps her in power. How can she knowingly propogate a lie that big and still call herself a paladin? Is that one of the things that gnaws constantly at her confidence in her own righteousness? And if not, why not?

Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2009 9:25 pm
by DocBeard
Maybe she's deluded herself into thinking Banemaw exists. Maybe she thinks that keeping the people afraid of a mythical demon means they won't think about real demons, and open themselves up to corruption through thought-heresy.

Personally, I think Elena deserves a massive dragon going by Banemaw to step out of the Mists and ruin her day.

Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2009 9:33 pm
by Nathan of the FoS
DocBeard wrote:Personally, I think Elena deserves a massive dragon going by Banemaw to step out of the Mists and ruin her day.
I dunno...she might be pretty pleased to have something real to fight against. It would also kinda ruin the "Banemaw" thing for PCs, because now, all of a sudden, there really is a Banemaw. So Elena suddenly becomes much less creepy.

If she were scared out of her skin by the idea that the evils she is inventing are now coming to reality, that might be effective. But I kinda prefer Banemaw to remain Elena's dirty little (big, scaly?) secret means of population control, rather than a real flesh-and-blood enemy for her to perform "heroics" against.

Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2009 9:54 pm
by ewancummins
DocBeard wrote:Maybe she's deluded herself into thinking Banemaw exists. Maybe she thinks that keeping the people afraid of a mythical demon means they won't think about real demons, and open themselves up to corruption through thought-heresy.

Personally, I think Elena deserves a massive dragon going by Banemaw to step out of the Mists and ruin her day.
If Banemaw didn't exist. we'd have to invent him.....

Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2009 5:54 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
DocBeard wrote:Maybe she's deluded herself into thinking Banemaw exists. Maybe she thinks that keeping the people afraid of a mythical demon means they won't think about real demons, and open themselves up to corruption through thought-heresy.

Personally, I think Elena deserves a massive dragon going by Banemaw to step out of the Mists and ruin her day.
While control-by-fear is a valid tactic for almost any religion, I doubt Elena has convinced herself Banemaw truly exists.

Maybe not a real dragon but a Mist-based one coming and confronting her, tearing into her with the truth: he is nothing more than a lie and so is Elena's entire life. Her rule is built on lies, she's fallen from grace and is no less evil than Ebonbane, and she's utterly corrupted her own faith in the name of power. Having seen self-delusion in action it's possible, even likely that Elena would re-imagine or block out the experience. In that case any "attack" by the dragon she goes off on her own to stop isn't so much a way of protecting the people, but preventing the truth from coming out and hiding the subsequent episodes of extreme self-loathing on her part.

The idea of a Mist Banemaw was originally posted by someone else, so I can't take credit for it. But the idea is stone solid.

Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2009 8:10 pm
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Yeah, I agree. Elena is deluded, yes, but she's not stupid, and she's not insane. She knows Banemaw is propaganda, but probably sees those lies as necessary for the purity of her people. Not very paladin-like, but lying is small change compared to her other non-paladin-like sins.

And I've seen a lot of "Banemaw becomes real" scenarios, but can't help but feel that any sort of "real" Banemaw detracts from the coolness of the "dragon that doesn't exist," which is a powerful idea, IMHO.

Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2009 9:11 pm
by Hell_Born
Sorry to divert the topic for a second, but I was just curious; has anyone ever run a campaign where Banemaw's nonexistence was used as part of an effort to "get at" Elena? For example, luring Elena somewhere public, then having a hidden magus craft an illusionary Banemaw, which first lies about its origin (for example, claiming to be the ghost of the "real" Banemaw, which Elena slew through dishonourable methods decades ago, or anything else that prevents Elena from claiming that Banemaw truly was the culprit for the destruction) and then announces to all of the watching people of Nidala the truth about the destruction that "Banemaw" was responsible for, in order to reveal what sort of monster Elena herself truly is in an effort to turn her people away from her?

And on a side note, what sort of Power Check would be neccesitated by using such a tactic?

Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2009 9:26 pm
by High Priest Mikhal
I guess we'll have to agree to disagree on this. I kind of like "Banemaw" at some point appearing, even if only as a figment of Elena's imagination and as an eternal reminder of how far she's fallen from grace. But that's just me.

I just realized. How does "Banemaw" terrorize the populace outside her protection? Is it just the common hazards of living on the frontier attributed to a faux wyrm? Or is Elena arranging for "attacks by Banemaw" to occur using her own forces?

Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2009 10:09 pm
by Yaoi Huntress Earth
Banemaw's "visits" could explain why she occassionally runs out in a frenzy of guilt. Maybe he's what triggers it.

Posted: Sun Jun 07, 2009 10:34 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
In her original description, Elena wipes out villages herself for "harboring evil" (i.e. strong emotions about her), then publicly blames the massacres on Banemaw as propoganda. I doubt if Elena would be able to reconcile killing people just to corroborate her dragon-attack stories, but she's never had trouble finding "evil" in a given community; if she's already got another motive to destroy the place, she may just "look harder" for the corruption she knows is there (because it's everywhere).

Of course, if Elena had kept on annihilating whole villages because she'd sensed some "evil" there, then Nidala would've been largely depopulated years ago. Now that she's trained up a generation of Inquisitors to aid in her internal crusade, she may be a bit less inclined to erase entire settlements in one fell swoop, contenting herself with torturing captive heretics, instead. Only if she finds some sort of organized heresy or resistance to her rule -- or if she honestly thinks she has -- would ol' Banemaw "come out of hibernation" and roast an entire town, nowadays.