Page 3 of 3

Posted: Fri Sep 04, 2009 11:21 am
by DocBeard
The Heath Ledger Joker from The Dark Knight struck me as a good portrayal of Chaotic Evil. But even then, there were sequences where he described his organization's methods, and I found those sequences hard to square away with a random chaotic persona.
That's because Joker's a man: He can understand organization and planning, and quite clearly has an ultimate goal he's working towards. The goal, however, is something that the average criminal cannot understand-see the scene where he sets the money on fire. Joker realizes that this will reinforce his control over the petty thugs the gang leaders have been treating as employees instead of animals, but he doesn't have to say this out loud-in fact, doing so would damage the persona that's keeping his followers afraid and in awe.

Chaotic Evil isn't just setting things on fire for the fun of it, just like Lawful Evil doesn't have to be a bureaucrat who wants a better gig. That's why I've found that the neutral alignments are ultimately inhibitive; their 'betweener' status restricts the big four alignment axises, and you end up spending a lot of time thinking, "Is he Lawful Good or Neutral Good or Lawful Neutral or Lawful Evil?" when you could just say, "The guy's Lawful Evil, but ultimately not very good at it.".

Posted: Sat Nov 07, 2009 9:32 pm
by MDSnowman
I always had a soft spot for Darklords who spent their entire lives either as victims or under the care of previous darklords. Can you seriously tell me Ivana would have Darklord material if she hadn't been raised the way she was and then been utterly crushed by her mother's manipulations?

I always felt bad for Adam as well, because I always felt like Victor was the one who really deserved Lordship. He was the one that tossed natural law out the window, he's the one who ignored reason and created Adam, he's the one who adopted a little girl to socialize his creature, and he ignored the sane arguments of his wife. Now he spends his days performing inhuman experiments.

Meanwhile Adam was created, may have gotten a little too rough with a child, and flipped out on Elise. He's no innocent, but his actions until that point weren't a series of narrow minded decisions that any sane person would have stopped long before it got to that point.