Page 3 of 3

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2009 9:07 am
by Gonzoron of the FoS
Ail wrote:I think the first step is too drastic already, both in the reward and in the punishment. +7AC is very very strong,
Yeah, as you noted this is 2e. That's not +7AC, it's 7AC (the 3e equivalent would be +3AC, but I don't recall how armor stacking worked back then, so I don't know if precludes other armor or not.)

I do agree that the spike attack sounds a little broken, but it is only once a day. Maybe that's OK for 2e purposes. What does the 2e version of an actual manticore get? My Monstrous Manual is in storage, I think.

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2009 10:21 am
by Ail
Actually, I had missed the thorns attack was only once a day. As it is then, it sounds like a daily power in 4E and is not too much.

But I still say I'd like some more subtlety in the terror track. However, that is just my personal taste :P

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2009 12:21 pm
by Deewun
Ail wrote: I got the impression, reading your terror track, that there is not much subtlety here.
It's true, I wasn't going as subtle as it could normally be. I actually did that purposefully, though. Consider that the character already looks kind of like a deformed cat-man. Here, here's a great pic to put you in the right mindset. If I'm too subtle here, he won't really know what is going on in a character sense. I also really was shooting for having a powerful, combat-monster character having to decide where the line is for him between being great in combat and being disadvantages out of it. This doesn't work on some players, as they have a strong opinion to one side or the other, but the player of Gaston actually built the character to have this fight as an internal struggle for him to deal with from the beginning (back when I though I may turn him into a Broken One and then use the Book of S_____ rules to keep him playable).
Ail wrote:Also, why abbreviated? Wasn't a terror track something with Darklord as the 6th step in RL3E? I know it was 13 steps in Domains of Dread, but they cut it short already.
I think the ten step second edition path is too long, and the five step 3.x path is too short. Combine and average.
Ail wrote: I'm going to stop here. I just noticed you may really be using 2nd Edition and I don't remember the rules anymore :-/ I do remember you had Rate of Fire and therefore you could shoot many projectiles in a round, which makes that thing of the 1d6 thorns in one round viable.

But I would still swap it with the third and perhaps even the fourth steps.
Again, I'm tempting him with a powerful ability early to keep him going. As subtle as a brick, but all the better as each disadvantage he thinks he can cheat the dark powers. "Shave thrice a day, I can do that, I already shave every day anyway, this isn't so bad"; "Clip crazy spikes off my forearms so they don't rip my shirts and don't look weird? That's not so bad, I still get to shoot them out, and it just takes a few extra minutes a morning, not even as long as the wizard"; "Paws ... um ... I can wear gloves to hide them and just take them off when I want to attack with them? Easy peasy"; then it's too late, you cannot hide everything else.
Gonzoron of the FoS wrote:Yeah, as you noted this is 2e. That's not +7AC, it's 7AC (the 3e equivalent would be +3AC, but I don't recall how armor stacking worked back then, so I don't know if precludes other armor or not.)

I do agree that the spike attack sounds a little broken, but it is only once a day. Maybe that's OK for 2e purposes. What does the 2e version of an actual manticore get? My Monstrous Manual is in storage, I think.
That is the actual manticore attack, word for word, except once a day. It's powerful, yes, but I've seen more powerful, considering some people can cast spells as a supernatural ability once a day at this point.

Oh, and the 7AC is a non-stacking thing in 2nd edition. So he could use his natural 7AC, or wear armor, and if the armor was better, it would override, not stack.
Ail wrote: But I still say I'd like some more subtlety in the terror track. However, that is just my personal taste :P
I'm with you, and can respect that. I like the temptation to be strong, and the punishments to be subtle, though I have been known to be more subtle about things before. My Elf fighter's Path of the Brag is pretty subtle in an of itself, IMO. Course, getting a Lawful Neutral character to attempt and fail a powers check is a pretty dubious procedure that is probably not going to happen that often.

Thanks for all this feedback guys! I know I'm the strange one around who still uses 2nd edition instead of moving on up to 3rd, which makes feedback a little ... difficult to gauge, but I greatly appreciate it.

Posted: Wed Nov 04, 2009 8:24 pm
by Rotipher of the FoS
Ail wrote: I think the first step is too drastic already, both in the reward and in the punishment. +7AC is very very strong, adding that you do not immediately preclude the PC from using an armor.
It's actually the equivalent of a +3 to AC, as 2AD&D armor classes start at 10 and count down. I don't think natural armor stacked with worn armor in 2E, either, so if the PC is wearing protection anyway he may not actually gain a benefit from this.


I'm a little concerned that the benefits are all brute-force combat perks, aside from the wings at the end. Perhaps something a little more subtle, like feline night vision or an intimidating grin (note: manticores of myth had three sets of teeth, sometimes depicted as being of solid steel) would diversify the Terror Track into less of a straight-up tank.

Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2009 2:52 am
by jules
maybe he could turn into a sentiant sea-lion?