Questions for the Designers

Discussing all things Ravenloft
User avatar
DeepShadow of FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2923
Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
Location: Heinfroth's Asylum

Post by DeepShadow of FoS »

cure wrote:There have been repeated hints, over the years, that Mordent's treatment in Gaz 3 was quite different than what was either intended or desired.

What would the intended or desired Mordent have looked like?
Okay, maybe it's just me, but...that's a lot more than a cutting-room-floor kind of question. That's closer to the split between authors than I'm comfortable going. I think any fan can look at the Mordent section of the Gaz and see that it was stylistically different: lots of fluff, very little crunch, lacking in Dread Possibilities, and the ones it had were garbled. The timeline was a total train wreck. CoE revisited was out of sync, IIRC, too.

If any of the authors have something constructive to offer about this, please speak up, but let's avoid another mudslinging match, especially against the people who aren't here.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
User avatar
Joël of the FoS
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 7108
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
Gender: Male
Location: St-Damien, Québec

Post by Joël of the FoS »

*lol* I see your point. The way I see it, cure's question is to ask what was planned as different about Mordent, not about the process of how it was written (or edited).

IIRC, John at first was very disapointed not to write this seminal domain, but again IIRC he liked what he saw in Mordent by Peter Woodworth.

Joël
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

Post by cure »

Joël of the FoS wrote:Yes, cure's question is to ask what was planned as different about Mordent, not about the process of how it was written and edited.
Given the title of the thread and looking back at the first post in it, is there a reason to apply the distinction?

True, people do choke and die on croissants, but that is good grounds neither for government to forbid the consumption of the delicacy nor for government to order potential consumers to chew well before being permitted to eat.

Please notice that my question was penned, self-evidently I think, with a maximum of neutrality to solicit useful answers from well-educated individuals, rather than being an advertisement to mercenaries to stick a sword in an author and twist it gleefully.

But the heart of the matter that, to my eye at least, makes any risks entirely worth running is that the question might, just might, yield valuable possibilities for, and valuable insight into, Mordent as we imagine it and as we address it in future material, especially as it is indeed a seminal domain all the more deserving of the care that comes with careful scrutiny and close attention.

(PS No designer's feelings were intentionally hurt, or deliberately spared, in the penning of this post.)
The cure for what ails you
User avatar
DeepShadow of FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2923
Joined: Mon Dec 22, 2003 1:43 pm
Location: Heinfroth's Asylum

Post by DeepShadow of FoS »

cure wrote:
Joël of the FoS wrote:Yes, cure's question is to ask what was planned as different about Mordent, not about the process of how it was written and edited.
Given the title of the thread and looking back at the first post in it, is there a reason to apply the distinction?
Given that the latter type of question has precipitated the violation of legal contracts, forswearing forum activity, and the annulment of professional relationships and friendships, then yes, I think a distinction may be in order.

I'm sorry if you took that as a personal attack, cure; it wasn't about you. Really, as I said in the previous post, it's about me. I've been hurt personally and professionally by some of these discussions when they get nasty. They are part of the reason I withheld my involvement as an author for so long, and for my long absences from the forum. I'm sorry if that's made me a little paranoid.

My apologies to everyone; please proceed to answer cure's question. I don't want to derail the thread any further with my own personal stomach aches.
The Avariel has borrowed wings,
The Puppeteer must cut the strings
The Orphan Queen must take the throne
The Queen of Orphans calls them home
User avatar
cure
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 1684
Joined: Sun Mar 06, 2005 12:34 pm

Post by cure »

Opps, I managed to misread Joël's distinction. Everything is sorted out. Please move on. Nothing to see. Back to the designers . . . .
The cure for what ails you
User avatar
Mangrum
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 811
Joined: Mon Dec 15, 2003 1:29 am

Post by Mangrum »

cure wrote:There have been repeated hints, over the years, that Mordent's treatment in Gaz 3 was quite different than what was either intended or desired.

What would the intended or desired Mordent have looked like?
I think that's a story that keeps going around, but there isn't much to it. The reality is that I'd hoped to be assigned Mordent, but wasn't. The sidebar explaining the events of House on Gryphon Hill ended up a little muddled, but beyond that it's simply a matter of the difference in individuals' creative impulses.
User avatar
Mangrum
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 811
Joined: Mon Dec 15, 2003 1:29 am

Post by Mangrum »

Ryan Naylor wrote:From a couple of stylistic discussions we had, I suspect he thinks I'm a moron and would have died rather than let me touch Death Undaunted.
Really? I don't remember that. If so, sorry -- I was, shall we say, not in a good mood in those days. In general.

Anyway, I've gone back and reread it a couple of times, and I think it's fine. Now that I've picked up some basic proficiency in layout design, I sometimes even ponder going back and making the newspaper handouts actually look authentic.
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

Ryan Naylor wrote: And the only thing that people remember from the book, Toben the Many, was completely and utterly down to Rucht.
You're quite wrong there Ryan.
I use hungry dead extensively and the part of the CR calculating.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
Gonzoron of the FoS
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 7694
Joined: Tue Dec 02, 2003 8:02 pm
Gender: Male
Location: New Jersey
Contact:

Post by Gonzoron of the FoS »

cure wrote:The Fracture at the bottom of Loch Lenore, for example, opens into Saragoss when the Seelie Court is in power but into Lake Amenta in Nidala when the Unseelie Court is.
Ah.... finally someone did something with the hints about the bottom of Lake Amenta! :) Nice! And possibly relevant and useful in my campaign, too!
"We're realistic heroes. We're not here to save the world, just nudge the world into a better place."
User avatar
Joël of the FoS
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 7108
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2003 1:24 pm
Gender: Male
Location: St-Damien, Québec

Post by Joël of the FoS »

alhoon wrote:
Ryan Naylor wrote: And the only thing that people remember from the book, Toben the Many, was completely and utterly down to Rucht.
You're quite wrong there Ryan.
I use hungry dead extensively and the part of the CR calculating.
I always use the book when planning lower hd undead. An ordinary skeleton or zombie or ghoul is near non existent IMC.

It's fun to see 6-7th level guys fearing zombies :)
"A full set of (game) rules is so massively complicated that the only time they were all bound together in a single volume, they underwent gravitational collapse and became a black hole" (Adams)
User avatar
alhoon
Invisible Menace
Invisible Menace
Posts: 9089
Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 6:46 pm
Location: Chania or Athens // Greece

Post by alhoon »

Joël of the FoS wrote: I always use the book when planning lower hd undead.

It's fun to see 6-7th level guys fearing zombies :)
1. :? Well "lower" HD is a denomination, right?
How you deal with the low attack roll of undead? I usually give to Obedients a salient ability that gives a +2 to +4 to hit rolls and to hungry dead abilities that penetrate armor (at least to a degree) with their teeth etc.
On the same track of thought, since Jaquiline Renier's bite ignores hardness on items, shouldn't she also ignore at least some of the AC bonus given by armor or natural armor?

2. Agreed. The traditional zombies and skeletons from the MM aren't fun. They're so lowly and boring than people I know are asking why there are necromancers spending spells and resources to animate these traditional creeps that can't threaten anyone with AC 20.
"You truly see what a person is made of, when you begin to slice into them" - Semirhage
"I am not mad, no matter what you're implying." - Litalia
My DMGuild work!
User avatar
DocBeard
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 2165
Joined: Mon Nov 05, 2007 5:35 pm

Post by DocBeard »

The reality is that I'd hoped to be assigned Mordent, but wasn't.
Ah!

Well, if you don't mind me asking, what would your Mordent have looked like? Would you have kept the "ghost of a nation" feel, or was there some other direction?
User avatar
Strahdsbuddy
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 605
Joined: Fri Apr 25, 2008 4:02 am
Gender: Male
Location: A Finger Lake

Post by Strahdsbuddy »

DocBeard wrote:
The reality is that I'd hoped to be assigned Mordent, but wasn't.
Ah!

Well, if you don't mind me asking, what would your Mordent have looked like? Would you have kept the "ghost of a nation" feel, or was there some other direction?
I second this request! The Mordent section was THICK, but there can't ever be too much information on this domain.
Get the Core Genesis Project V4 https://fraternityofshadows.com/Mausole ... ect_v4.pdf

Ravenloft Cartographic Society on Facebook
https://www.facebook.com/groups/1327810691065274
User avatar
Mangrum
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 811
Joined: Mon Dec 15, 2003 1:29 am

Post by Mangrum »

I've been asked that before, and the answer is "Dunno, was assigned Borca instead, so I focused my energies on that."
User avatar
Mangrum
Evil Genius
Evil Genius
Posts: 811
Joined: Mon Dec 15, 2003 1:29 am

Post by Mangrum »

Joël of the FoS wrote:For the cool spells part in VRA, where there spell ideas that you rejected for the final?
I believe that everything cut from VRA (which was very little) was included in the web enhancement we released at the time.
Joël of the FoS wrote:If I may, there are darklords cut out of SotDR that are still on my Xmas wish list :)
I suppose that's true. Let's see here...

Anhktepot: Stat blocks for him as a mummy (LE male human rank 5 ancient dead clr14 of Ra, CR 20) and as a mortal (LE male human Ari 1, CR 1/2). No major revisions to his backstory that I can spot at a glance.

Arijani: Stat block (CE male rakshasa clr6 of Kali/sor5, CR 20); no significant revisions to his depiction.

Crocodile:: Stat block (CE male giant crocodile, CR 12); backstory basically unchanged, plus a "No Man's Land" sidebar on the supernatural effects of the Wildlands, which was much later squeezed into a sentence or two in his entry in the RLDMG.

Diamabel: Stat block (CE male unique monstrous humanoid or undead, CR 19), no significant revisions to his backstory.

Easan the Mad: Stat block (CE male fiendish wood elf Wiz13, CR 16), backstory basically as given in Domains of Dread with the required filing off of the Greyhawk serial numbers.

Ebonbane: Stat blocks for Ebonbane itself (CE unique outsider, CR 17) and its animated sword (Small construct, CR 12). Backstory updated to the status quo presented in the RLDMG. I have a feeling these stats may have been posted once upon a time, along with the sidebar on the amorphous Phantasmal Forest.

Elena Faith-hold: Stat block for Elena (LE female human ex-Pal3/ Blk8, CR "11+") -- which I assume means it hadn't quite been hammered down -- and her fiendish war horse mount. Backstory basically as we've come to know it.

Maligno: Stat block (CE dread carrionette, CR 7), status quo basically unchanged from DoD.

Frantisek Markov: Stat block (LE male unique shapechanger Exp7, CR 10), backstory still as presented in Neither Man Nor Beast.

Prince Ladislav Mircea: Stat block (CE male human mature vrykolaka vampire Ari3/ Exp6, CR8); a boiled-down version of his backstory was presented in RLDMG. Big thing to know about him is that he drains "humours" rather than just blood, with differing effects. There's also a sidebar on vampiric thralls that I'm sure saw print somewhere early on. Gaz II, mayhaps.

Anton Misroi: Stat block (LE male zombie lord Ari2/ Sor6, CR 20), backstory basically as presented in DoD.

Yagno Petrovna: Stat block (LE male human clr12 of Zakhata, CR 14); the events of Circle of Darkness are mentioned, but he's basically unchanged.

Sodo: Sodo was included in Shadow of the Knife.

Gregor Zolnik: Stat block (CE male human werewolf Rgr9, CR 14), backstory unchanged.

I suppose I could post the stat blocks, but here's the thing: we were all brand new to 3E at the time, and it shows. We continually revised these stats as we revisited darklords in the Gazetteers, and nearly a decade later (particularly now that I've picked Pathfinder for my poison & I've moved toward a more revisionist mindset) I'd want to essentially just remake them all from scratch anyway.
Joël of the FoS wrote:We have a good idea in the author notes about who wrote what for most of the books (except CoD and HoL, but it’s OK we don’t). What of the RL DMG?
I loathe going back and re-reading my old "Here's what I wrote" posts in general, but I can offer a little assistance. Truth be told, for the most part I don't know who wrote what. I wrote the intro (knowing it was highly likely to be my final word on any subject therein).

Chapter I, "Crossover Campaigns": I believe I wrote this section, but it's really just a simple reworking of DoD material.

"Creating Atmosphere": I (very) slightly expanded on an unused "Thirteen Tips for Tension" section Andrew Cermak had written for SotDR, and the developers then slightly expanded on that (by adding all the "in-play" dialogue); unfortunately in the end Cermak received no author's credit.

With "Portraying NPCs" and "Sinister Scores," I have no idea, save that it was non-Kargatane.

"Dramatic Techniques": The "Pacing" section is my primary singular contribution to the chapter. A non-Kargatane wrote "Cut Scenes"; I have no idea who it was.

Chapter Two: I believe that Andrew Wyatt wrote the "Sinkholes of Evil" section.

I wrote the "Expanding the Mists" section, working, as with all the authors, exclusively from 3E material. It's basically just a clear presentation of the underlying framework we'd been working with all along. You'll note that the solution for incorporating all of the prestige classes added to the 3.5 DMG is "you can't." That was the developers' contribution to a section otherwise devoted entirely to "Here's how to add non-Ravenloft material."

I wrote the NPCs section as well, basically as some last-minute filler, I dimly recall. (The whole book was coming up short, somehow, and this was my counter-suggestion to including full entries for 2 or 3 darklords.)

"Twisting Thoughts: Psionics in Ravenloft." Andrew Wyatt, I believe? But note, sadly -- and Wyatt had no control over this -- that this section of a presumably 3.5 book is entirely about a 3.0-exclusive rule system.

Chapters Three (Structuring the Campaign) & Four (Parting the Mists): I have no idea. Entirely non-Kargatane, I believe.

Chapter Five (Magic Items in Ravenloft): With the exception of a small handful of magic items the Kargatane tossed on the pile from our archives, this was entirely non-Kargatane, ergo, I have no idea who wrote what. Note that, because the chapter had no section on non-cursed artifacts, the non-cursed major artifact we offered up (the updated scroll of return) was included, verbatim, as a standard magic item. Sigh.
Post Reply