DeepShadow of FoS wrote:
That's where we all come in! We're all apologists for the setting here, fixing stuff like that. Have you seen the FoS writeup on Monette? I think you may like it
I may, and I am not saying that things can't be fixed in any setting, where there might be problems, but my point with the thread was rather discussing (in a humorous tone, I might add; I have no intention of making this an infantile discussion of "why Ravenloft sucks." I love Ravenloft, warts and all. I generally just choose to excise the warts and concentrate on the things I like) what doesn't work for individual DMs in the setting as written.
Malken...
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:
Yes, several of us have tried to remedy that one, too.
Again, I'm sure you have, and if I see anything I like, I may even co-opt your fine work into my campaigns, but again my remarks were aimed at the setting as officially represented, not as fixed by this fine community. I should have been more clear on that in my opening post.
Harkon Lukas..
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:...I agree, but that's hardly a reason to throw out an entire domain because the DL's species name rubs you wrong. Make him a werewolf since birth. Problem solved.
No, the problem for me isn't solved, because as you probably noted my list of darklords that didn't do it for me was not followed by long dissertations on why they didn't work, just one line that may have rubbed you and others the wrong way. That was just me being facetious.
Yes, I have a problem with wolfweres, which could be solved by replacing them all with werewolves, but that isn't the sole reason for me to dislike Kartakass. Kartakass for me is domain that doesn't really add up as a realm. I feel that it got short shrift from the creators, and that it was defined along the lines of "The Land Where People Sing A Lot And Drink Meekulbrau." I must admit that I am also biased against Kartakass because of its presentation in Feast of Goblyns.
Hazlik...
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:I'm starting to see a trend here...
Which is what? That these are my personal, idiosyncratic, maybe even slightly irrational reasons for not favouring something? If so, you are absolutely correct. I never claimed that these were anything but my own personal feelings about the setting. This isn't some universal truth I am trying to proselytize.
Jaqueline Renier
Not a big fan of wererats.
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:and here again...
Yeah, well, what can I say? I don't consider wererats very scary. If others can make them work, more power to them. Again, these are my personal views in relation to my own campaigns, not something people should have rammed down their throats.
Malus Sceleri...
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:Okay, you lost me. Pollution yes, but where do you get capitalist from? I think the message is a lot more subtle than you think. Matter of fact, I think it's mostly in your head.
Where do I get capitalist? Let's start with Sceleris himself:
"The lord of Nosos is Malus Sceleri, a lumber and mining baron. Actually he was a lumber baron only he killed all the trees by deforesting the region and polluting it with the smoke from his refineries. Now he focuses on trade and his profitable coal mines...
... His only skill lies in his genius, his shrewdness, and his bargaining power."
That sounds to me not like a wealthy landed noble, but like an entrepreneur of the wild excesses of laissez-faire capitalism in the mid-to-late 19th century.
Moving on to the land itself...
"The law in Nosos is only that dictated by the whims of the wealthy. The general state of the land is nearly anarchy... The only real law in Nosos is the Golden Rule: He who has the gold makes the rules."
Again, this sounds like a classic set-up of a anarcho-capitalist society.
This may indeed be all in my head, as you say, but I don't find this particularly subtle or "not at all related to capitalism." As I read it, Nosos is an unsubtle indictement of the rampant excesses of big business run amok. While I can agree that this is a bad thing, I found a bit too preachy in my game. But as you say, maybe it wasn't the intent to make Nosos capitalist and anarchistic, and I am just imagining it.
Elena Faith-hold...
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:Okay, so this basically the same problem as Harkon: you got hung up on the name. Take a few more steps in. Have you tried reading the framing fiction for the BoShadows?
Yeah, okay, so I am hung up on a name, but as with Harkon Lukas, I just spat out a not-so-serious one-liner about a domain I didn't care for. If I have to go into more detail, Elena just didn't tickle my creative bone, regardless of the inane name of her domain. I don't find Elena's background all that interesting, though I would be hard pressed to say why, other than I find the concept of the fallen paladin overused and trite. It's one of those taste things again, which I have also said earlier in the thread. I believe I am entitled not to like certain aspects of Ravenloft.
Lemot Sediam Juste
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:Okay, this one is not part of your trend, at least. If you've had trouble with Juste in the past, no problem. As for me, the first real-life horror checks I ever gave my players happened in Scaena. You spend two years hunting down a vampire, you get sooo close...and then the director calls cut and tell you you need to reread the script. Vampiress pops out her fangs and pulls out a sack lunch to wait for you to get your lines right.

See, that would have made me disappointed as a player. It's fine that you could make it work with your group, but far too many times have I played with DMs, who've pulled the "it's just a dream/illusion"-routine, and it gets old really fast.
In roleplaying, we are already playing in an unreal world. I don't want add yet another layer of unreality to that. I don't want to play a roleplaying game where I am pretending to be a character who is also pretending. I know that you could argue that the character thought it was all real, so he wasn't pretending, but it doesn't make a difference to me as the player. Another problem I have with the "it's just a dream," is that nothing the players do is of any consequence. Everything is up to DM whim, which I personally find makes for bad gaming.
Again,
de gustibus non est disputandum. It's a matter of taste. If it works for others, great, but it doesn't work for me.
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:Ahah! There's the root of your trend! You believe that a reworked domain is not worth the effort, because it can't ever measure up to a good one from scratch.
Well, are entitled to your belief, but you may not find a lot of support for that view around here. You see, almost all of us here are apologists for the setting. That's what we do, we enjoy doing it, and I daresay many of us do it quite well. We find ways to take those broken pieces and remake them into something great. I for one believe that the things we come up with are better than anything constructed from scratch, because the preexistent material challenges us to work within a structural framework.
I did not come here to find support for any agenda, or to make trouble. I merely pulled over a thread from Wizards discussing which darklords didn't work for individual players. As always with such things, answers will vary according to taste, and I am interested in hearing what others have to say, not just blare out what I don't like.
In case you should have missed it from my posts, I'll reiterate that I really like Ravenloft. I just like it better, when I've tweaked it completely to my own taste, and that includes ignoring domains, darklords and concepts that don't work for my campaigns.
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:Drakov/Falkovnia has several inspirational factors, Hitler and Vlad Tepes being only two of them. Of course, when I want to evoke horror and dread in my players, I play to the things they know. I'm running a game right now set in Falkovnia, and I can guarantee you that my players catch on faster when I relate things to the Nazis than to Wallachia.
You use what works for yourself and your group, and I can understand that. In my group, however, a reference to a Führer and disguised National Socialism in our Gothic Horror/Fantasy campaigns would be seen as jarring and intrusive, especially since all other trappings of Drakov's domain refer to a medieval, pseudo-Slavic/Balkan realm: the names Vlad Drakov, Stangengrad, etc., and the impalements and so forth.
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:He's still got that image, even as the Kingfuhrer. The problem is, many players couldn't relate to it. It's been combined with things they can relate to.
Yes, yes, sure, he's still an impaler. I just prefer that he is not referred to as a Führer in my own campaigns, as it would be jarring for me and my players.
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:Nobody's denying that Vlad Drakov is derived from Vlad Tepes/Dracula. However, this does not equate to Falkovnia being derived from Wallachia. In fact, if you read Drakov's original Black Box backstory, it hardly resembles Vlad Tepes at all. Vlad Drakov was a mercenary captain from Taladas in Krynn, with no claim to any right to rule by blood. This is very different from Vlad Tepes. Falkovnia has as much or more to take from Taladas/Krynn as it does from Wallachia.
Sure, sure, Vlad Drakov isn't a calque of Vlad III, that's not what I'm saying. All I asked was if Vlad Drakov wasn't closer to the historical Dracula, whereas Strahd was more the fictional Dracula.
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:And there it is again: you're making an argument based on a false assumption, that domains partly inspired or derived from one part Europe should resemble that part in other ways, too. It doesn't follow. Apart from "Vlad the Impaler" ruling it, Falkovnia NEVER resembled Wallachia, ever. It's more like a gestalt of having a Krynn-esque land converted to a fascist, racist government and then getting Vlad the Impaler to run it all for you.
I'm not making an argument for anything. It was only a semi-serious remark with a Simpsons quote thrown in ("should, nay, must"). It wasn't an indictement of Ravenloft not having an Ottoman Empire; why should they? It was merely me thinking out loud that it would be cool to have an Central Asian-flavoured empire knocking on the gates of the Slavic-flavoured domains in Ravenloft. You know, for my own campaign. It wasn't a call for "this must be changed in canon Ravenloft!" And I even added a little "or not" to my idea, as I wasn't even sure if it would fly.
DeepShadow of FoS wrote:If you prefer unified dedication to a single inspirational source, rather than a gestalt of many, I would recommend you play MotRD: Medieval. There was an awesome Dragon article on the different ages of Masque. Outside of Masque, gestalts are what most people are looking for.
Yes, and as you'll see in my reply to your esteemed colleague Gonzoron I said as much myself: that if I really wanted to create a campaign about Slavic principalities resisting the might of the Ottoman Empire, it would be easier for me to do just that: create a campaign taking place in late medieval Eastern Europe. So I am well aware of that option.
I guess that's it. I hope I've explained what I'm about. I'm not here to trash anything. This thread was merely intended as random musings from people about what concepts in Ravenloft they didn't use.
Cheers.