Thanks for the response, Jack. I'd really like to go into this further.
Jack the Reaper wrote:As to their psychology, I don't have a grade in psychology (though I deed took some lessons in it), but from looking at the world and seeing the hatred groups and cults that exist, I can't see why a similar group against women is implausible.
It wasn't their existence that I found implausible, but their methods. IRL there are groups of men that hate women for instilling lust in them, and how do they act on it? They throw acid on women who reject them, to scar them for life. They rape them or stone them, and then say the women were asking for it because of how they dressed. This is projection; the men blame the evil in themselves on the women. The men are performing deeds that they admit are lustful--such as rape--but they insist they can't help themselves, because the women made them lustful.
What you are describing is men who profess the same hatred, but they kill women and obliterate the remains, presumably without satisfying any of the lustful thoughts the women have supposedly aroused in them. Either they aren't aroused by women, or they are exercising an unusual level of discipline. If the former, then this begs the question, what are they complaining about? If the latter, then the question becomes, why are they resisting, when resistance undermines their arguments? Either suggests an ideological foundation that is redirecting the psychological one.
Why do some people hate Jews, or blacks? Simply enough, because there is some part in the human psyche that hates and fears the different. Its not that ideology creates the hatred, but vice versa - it starts from irrational hatred, and the ideology comes after that, trying to rationalize it.
What you are describing here is not hate, but blame. Blame is keyed to fixate on the different or the unusual. The Nazis were able to galvanize everyone against the Jews by blaming the Jews for selling out Germany after WWI. Most organized hate groups use blame as a touchstone for recruiting, for this very reason.
Also, what you are describing about the psychology preceding the ideology is true, but only for the people who
create the ideoology. Once created, the ideology can spread to people who have no prior psychological foundation, who often become truer believers than the originals. This is how your antifemmeists are behaving: as absolute true believers, ideological fanatics who have surpassed the hypocritical roots of their founders.
Sure, Nazis and rascists have written full volumes in attempt to prove and justify their thories, but the source of all is psychological hatred toward the different. And women are different enough from men to evoke such feelings.
If that were true, then we should have examples of people who hate just by looking at the opposite sex. I don't know where you got your ideas about hatred of the different, but they seem to be grossly overgeneralized.
Still, I think you've got something here we can work with. Let's assemble the ingredients:
We need a specific crisis that can be blamed on all of womankind.
We need a charismatic ideologue with an axe to grind against women.
It needs to spread to people who can become true fanatics.
The first one is going to be the hardest. There are mythical examples of such a thing happening, but they are always used to justify patriarchy--Adam's Fall, Pandora, etc. What we need is something more current, and something that can serve as justification for murder of half of humanity.
Here's my suggestion: the antifemmists started as overzealousness in fighting hags. The founder was a renowned and successful hag-hunter who was led to believe, by a combination of research, coincidence and self-justification, that ALL women turn into hags eventually. I can imagine him engaged to a young woman in his early adventuring career, when he discovers the diary of a hag, and with it the horrible truth about how hags mature. Like a dopp-hunter, he starts eyeing every woman he meets with suspicion, and imagines suspicious behavior on the part of his fiancee. It might all have been self-delusion, but we can throw in some red herrings to stir him up: maybe his fiancee was really marrying him for ulterior motives, or maybe she was hiding spellcasting talents, or whatnot.
The coup de grace came when one of his hag foes exacted a terrible revenge on him for the slaying of her sisters. She killed his aging mother and took her place, gaslighting him and convincing him that she had just recently changed. Based on this and other mounting evidence, the hunter concluded that Van Richten and other scholars were fooling themselves, or (in the case of women and those they had bewitched) hiding the truth: all women were hags. He began killing old women who he believed were on the verge of changing, and this merited some powers checks. The effects of these checks allowed him to spread his delusions to other men he trusted. Under his influence, even some of the most objective scholars would aquire irrefutable evidence that he was correct.
So that's how it started. Seems like it would serve well as an origin, IMO. This also makes it easier to justify eradicating women when they perpetuate the species: they kill most women after their kids have grown, before they can change. Of course, if they find a particularly bewitching or seductive young woman, they'll assume she is a precocious hag developing early.
By the way, if you want to get into the psychological roots of evil, I highly recommend "Evil: Inside Human Violence and Cruelty" by Baumeister. It's got a strong background in hard science, but it's readable by the layperson. Matter of fact, I recommend it for any RL DM's.